For some, video games differ from books and movies chiefly because the consumers primary concern is not a well-crafted story; its gameplay. In fact, strong gameplay can cover a multitude of sins: even if the story, graphics, or soundtrack dont do anything for you, the well-crafted mechanics might reel you in. However, sometimes a title occupies a special place in ones heart for aspects other than how fun it is, and this is especially the case if its full of emotionally intense moments. Maybe an unexpected tragedy occurs and leaves a void in your heart, or maybe the entire experience is intense and keeps you on your toes. Whatever the reason is, emotionally loaded games tend to linger longer in the memory. And of course it isn't enough for those games to be relentlessly grim: there has to be balance, and the most artful achievements in emotional games come thanks to the wider range of emotions that make the tragedy stand out even more. The greatest examples set the bar high in creating narratives or mechanics that tug at the gamer's heartstrings, and future developers really need to learn from their example. That way, instead of demanding gameplay over storytelling, players can expect higher quality of both aspects. That's the dream.
Advertisement
10. Shadow Of The Colossus
At the time of its release, Shadow of the Colossus was unlike any other PS2 game because it only featured boss fights; it doesn't send endless waves of minions at you to waste your time. Because Wander spends half of his time searching for the colossi in a barren wasteland, he (and the gamer) endures excessive alone time with only his trusty stallion as his companion, and in order enhance that feeling of isolation, there's not even any background music until one of the titanic beasts appears. Once the players engage in battle, however, Shadow of the Colossus blares epic music in order to pump up their adrenaline; however, the music immediately conveys somberness once a colossus is defeated. Keep in mind that the colossi rarely pick fights with Wander, and fans often feel guilty upon murdering the first colossus, and even the black tendrils that emerge from the fallen giants and attack Wander afterwards fail to enforce the idea the homicide is justified. And then its back to the grind; Wander grows increasingly lonely as he explores the wasteland, and his isolation reaches its climax once he loses his equine companion just before the final battle. Considering that the horse also doubles as the players' only friend, it's understandable if they shed a tear during this moment.
9. Depression Quest
Unlike the other entries on this list, Zoe Quinns Depression Quest is not a traditional video game. Despite this, she accomplishes her goal of creating a text adventure that puts the player in the shoes of someone who suffers from depression. Depression Quest is like a choose your own adventure, providing you options for how you want to deal with your symptoms. The protagonist, on whom players can project their own lives (such as what they want their passion project, their soul crushing job, and significant other to be) is trusted with making those decisions in order to get by. It's easy to say that you should listen to your therapist and open up to your friends and family, and by doing so you'll receive a more positive ending. If, however, you choose the harder path, where you dont seek help and keep your troubles to yourself, things begin to fall apart. By going down this path, you eventually lose all but one choice - the one that allows you to continue to wallow in your depression - for each scenario, and you eventually lose your job and loved one in the process. Nothing about this game is fun in the traditional sense, and that's kind of the point.
8. Silent Hill 2
The best games of the survival horror genre are capable of crippling you emotionally thanks to their ability to induce fear, but Silent Hill 2 raises the bar. While it is certainly terrifying, it also elicits feelings of guilt and sadness while you're running away from Pyramid Head. As discussed in 10 Times Silent Hill Was Absolutely Terrifying, the franchise has a penchant for building tension. At times, this tension leads to devastating jump scares; however, more often than not, absolutely nothing happens, and while this might sound like a relief, in actuality these uneventful scenes allow players to torment themselves via their own imaginations. Then the game will create a sense of confusion and loss that torments players beyond fright. For instance, Pyramid Head brutally murders potential love interest Maria, who reappears periodically only to be murdered again, and Rachel exposes James for his hypocrisy when he realizes he doesn't care enough about her to save her from suicide. Of course, most will remember the horrific twist at the end that reveals James is Marys true killer. The feelings of guilt that follow afterwards makes the game feel scarier when you realize that the town is actively trying to punish James, who is still a sympathetic character despite this, for his sins.
7. Mother 3
Nintendo is known for being more family friendly compared to its competitors, but its exclusives often hide some of the darkest moments in gamings history, and fans will often point to the Mother 3 as a prime example because it's simultaneously cute and horrifying. Creator Shigesato Itoi urged players to name all of the characters based on members of their own family and for a good reason. For instance, the scene in which Lucass mother dies wouldnt create as much of an impact had players given her a silly name as they're wont to do. Keep in mind that the mothers death takes place at the beginning of Mother 3, and the rest of the content has plenty of light-hearted moments. The franchise has always been known for its Saturday-morning cartoon vibe and quirky, hilarious dialogue, and this entry is no exception. But then it also uses this friendly aesthetic to thinly veil its darker moments. The most emotionally intense moment occurs when Lucas battles his brother, Claus, who is under mind-control. The mother eventually interrupts the battle to free Claus who then decides to end his life for the greater good.
6. Final Fantasy X
The world of Final Fantasy X is a rather bleak place, but it can also be beautiful at times. If it were completely bleak, fans would have been too depressed to continue on; yet, Square Enixs writers, artists, and composer worked together to provide us a world thats worth protecting. The futuristic planet of Spira boasts a tropical flair thats tantalizing to the eyes, the soundtrack captures the curiosity of life, and the inhabitants are able to set aside their distances for an exciting game of Blitzball. However, with these beautiful moments come devastating tragedies. Families are torn asunder thanks to the many fruitless battles with Sin, and the ruined city of Zanarkand, as beautiful as it is, reminds Tidus of his loneliness. The ending is especially devastating, somehow providing both a heartfelt goodbye between lovers and a reparation of a dysfunctional father and son relationship. It's as if Final Fantasy X's goal was to make its fans simultaneously cry tears of happiness and sorrow.
5. To The Moon
While RPG Maker is often frowned-upon as an engine, some creators have used it to create ingenious games. Freebird Games, for instance, not only created a point-and-click adventure game with the engine but also a one that will completely captivate you. To The Moon demonstrates the power of music during its introduction. The somber piano piece immediately strikes a chord (no pun intended), and even the car crash at the beginning doesnt detract from its effectiveness. Considering that the game is one parts tragic, funny, and nostalgic, the soundtrack needs to emphasize each emotion, and it fluidly switches when appropriate. The soundtrack perfectly complements the excellently written story, which delves into the strange life of scientists who attempt to take a dying man to the moon - at least in his dreams. The result is a tale of heartbreak and nostalgia that might require a few pieces of tissue paper upon completion.
4. This War Of Mine
This War of Mine is one of the most interesting war games in some time due to the fact that its not about soldiers. Because it is essentially a resource manager, This War Of Mine doesnt have an overarching narrative, but you will be introduced to many characters throughout, each with their own strengths, weaknesses, and personalities. All of them, unfortunately, share in common their forced existence in a war-torn city. The characters' situation is bleak; they begin in a poorly fortified home with a lack of necessary supplies. While its a good idea to dedicate most of your time to survival, you might encounter instances in which you want to give your companions some entertainment - booze, radio (which doubles as a survival tool) and anything that makes life worth living. Eventually, however, everything goes to Hell. Either a group of bandits will raid your home and kill the characters youve come to known, or youll need to do the same in order to save your own party.
3. The Last Of Us
The Last of Us begins with a bang: the opening ten minutes in which Joel watches the city fall to ruin and his daughter loser her life is so gripping that players might feel like they're part of the introduction of a zombie movie. Afterwards, however, players have to live in the aftermath of the catastrophe. Joel has now gotten into the smuggling business, and hes tasked with protecting a young teenager named Ellie from both men and monsters - for some the line between them blurs. Seeing Joel and Ellies relationship develop as they work together and trade quips is charming, and as a result the stakes feel appropriately high whenever one of them is in danger. The Last of Us is just as intense to play as it is to watch, as Joel and Ellie are not trained enough to run-and-gun; rather, they have to carefully assess their environment and sneak pass or stealthily kill enemies in order to make it through with minimal damage. The combination of the dangerous post-apocalyptic setting and the limited capabilities of Joel and Ellie create a game that's suspenseful throughout and often complemented with tear-jerking moments.
2. The Walking Dead
While for some the zombie apocalypse can't arrive soon enough, in actuality it might be difficult due to the horrible choices everyone would have to make. Telltale Games The Walking Dead captures this intensity perfectly by creating an interactive experience based around the decisions youd have to make; shooting and stabbing are only minor parts of this tale. When Lee discovers and adopts Clementine, he is given a life to raise and protect, and part of that process includes deciding what to teach her in this unforgiving world. Sure, it might be easier to kill the big man who is turning into a zombie and trapped in the same room as you, but is that the kind of message - kill people before they have a chance to recover in order to prevent them from turning into walkers - Lee should send to an innocent little girl? Eventually, even if you try to remain neutral and protect Clementine, youll do some terrible things, and the villain of the game reminds you of your decisions during the final confrontation in season one. There may be some things you wish you could have done differently as Lee, but for now you have to trust Clementine to learn from your best examples in order to make the right choices in the second season.
1. Lisa
A fairly recent game, Lisa caught the attention of the press for billing itself as the painful RPG on Kickstarter and boasting similar graphics to Mother 3. Unlike the latter, however, Lisa wears its darkness firmly on its sleeves. From the very beginning, when Brad's father throws a beer bottle at him, creator Austin Jorgensen lets us know that this is going to be an emotionally draining game. Brad has had a terrible childhood which he tries to forget by taking the fictional drug Joy, and the players stumble across enigmatic dark imagery to give us just a glimmer of what haunts him. Lisa also presents players choices that are not pleasant, of course; the difference is that theres a clear answer: do whatever you can to make it to the last battle with as many limbs as possible, even if it means sacrificing the lives of your friends. Should you try to be a decent human being, you'll lose almost all of your limbs which permanently gimps Brads stats and makes the final battle that much tougher (hint: its often not worth saving your friends' lives). But Brad does terrible things in the game regardless of your choices, becoming the monster he fears to become and even hurting the little girl he's trying to save. By the time he reaches the final battle, everyone, including Brad, his nemesis, and his step daughter are all crying. And there's a very good chance you might be too. What are some games that you found to be emotionally intense? Let us know in the comments section!