10 EXACT Moments Video Games Lost The Plot

The best/worst "Wait... what?" moments from gaming history.

By James Metcalfe /

Unlike in film or TV where a story can be wrapped up and called time on whenever the creators deem fit, the world of gaming can be far more... elongated. If a game sells well, it's almost a non-negotiable fact that there are going to be an arsenal of follow-ups made over the next couple of years.

Advertisement

Not only is the turnaround time on new titles significantly shorter, but video game companies are now expected to keep churning out new entries into their series with the same level of creativity in their stories, gameplay, and mechanics from their very first project.

And this quest for constant creativity can sometimes push a developer too far, and into that 'Wait... what did they just do?' territory. The ramifications of these moments can end up losing entire fanbases, stunt the momentum of well-performing series, or just derail a franchise entirely.

So, whether it be creative visions gone too far, shocking plot twists that failed to hit the mark, or simply the bizarre decision to give a cartoon hedgehog a submachine gun, these are the exact moments when video games completely lost the plot.

10. Lara's "Death" - Tomb Raider: Chronicles

Is there a lazier writing trope in the world than a supposed "death" of a flagship protagonist? 1999's Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation concluded with the supposed death of Lara Croft, left hanging from a rock as the Great Pyramid of Giza crumbles around her.

Advertisement

Despite this supposed death, Eidos Interactive wanted to plow on with the series, prompting developers Core Design into writing a storyline that revolves around some of Lara's friends toasting to her memory with tales from her past. With six entries released in just five years, the Tomb Raider series had been growing stale for a while.

However, Chronicles is really where Eidos and co. really lost their way.

The number of new gameplay features introduced in Chronicles can be counted on one hand, and with no new developments to the lore of either Lara or the series on the whole, the game felt pumped out as a way of cashing in on the Tomb Raider name yet again.

Hardcore fans of the series remember The Last Revelation as being where the "true" Lara Croft series died, with Chronicles and other games following it being a mixed bag of convoluted reboots and remakes designed to keep the revenue ticking over.

Angel Of Darkness might be a more obvious point of no return, but the issues go right back to here.

9. Planets In The Sky - Resistance 2

Resistance: Fall of Man was released in 2006 as a launch title for the PS3, and remains one of the most underrated titles in recent gaming history. The shooter's gripping storyline and impressive controls and visuals helped make the series look like a genuine competitor to the likes of Call of Duty at the time, however, developers Insomniac just had to go and lose the plot with Fall of Man's sequel, Resistance 2.

Advertisement

'Bigger' is not always 'better', and Resistance 2 is undoubtedly a game that throws away a lot of what gave the series so much promise, tossing aside the gritty settings and storylines in favour of a more blockbuster science-fiction look.

The game's single-player campaign illustrates this unexplainable departure from the first game's formula the best, with protagonist Nathan Hale being killed off whilst looking up at a whole host of planet-looking objects in Earth's atmosphere. Hale was not the most charismatic protagonist the world of gaming has ever thrown up, but seeing him removed completely fractured the series and left fans wondering what the point was in sticking with the franchise.

And whilst there were naturally science-fiction elements in Fall of Man with the Chimera and their various weaponry, the decision to start filling the screen with even more outlandish sights, culminating in the game's final scene, helped the Resistance series lose all of its early promise.

8. All-Out Action - Resident Evil 5

From its first entry in 1996, all the way to the release of Resident Evil 4 in 2005, Capcom's Resident Evil series was known as the world's most successful survival horror series. And whilst RE 4 marked a significant departure from the earlier titles in the series with the introduction of a dynamic camera system, it was the opening level of its successor, Resident Evil 5, that fans began to realise the series was free-falling into something completely different.

Advertisement

The opening level of RE 5 takes place in Kijuju, a fictional part of Africa, and the game immediately puts its new direction front and centre, with the two-player cooperative system, motion-captured cutscenes and added emphasis on action baring little resemblance to the games that came before it.

And whilst RE 4 was certainly more action-based than most other titles in the series, it still held the same strong focus on story and atmosphere over anything else, something that RE 5 can't boast about possessing.

Kijuju and most of the other locations in the game are legitimately well-designed and interesting settings - just not for a series like Resident Evil.

Ultimately, RE 5 is the point in which most fans of the series can say Capcom began to lose its way in terms of what they thought made the series so popular, with RE 6, without a doubt the lowest point in the franchise, continuing the trends set out in its predecessor, before RE 7 stripped everything back and returned the series to form.

7. Sam's Introduction - Unchartered 4

Throwing in never-before-seen family members midway through a successful franchise is always a frustrating thing for loyal fans to swallow. Players invest hundreds of hours immersing themselves with their game's main characters, so suddenly having a developer come along and introduce something so major out of the blue often feels a bit cheap.

Advertisement

That is certainly the case with Uncharted and Samuel Drake. Making his first appearance in Uncharted 4: A Thief's End, Sam is main protagonist Nathan's brother, introduced as a man presumed dead after a failed jail break, but who has returned in an attempt to lure his brother back out of retirement.

The thing about Sam's introduction is that it blatantly feels like Naughty Dog were desperate for something to build a story around, rather than it being a natural fit for the series. What makes things even worse is the fact that Sam is one of the franchise's most dislikable characters, constantly lying to Nathan throughout the game.

A Thief's End is undoubtedly a great game, filled with beautiful visuals and a stunning collection of environments, however Sam's out-of-the-blue introduction was perhaps the moment most fans gave up on expecting a consistent storyline arc in the series.

6. Raiden Over Solid Snake? - Metal Gear Solid 2

1998's Metal Gear Solid produced one of the most badass protagonists in the gaming world with Solid Snake, a super-soldier who infiltrates a nuclear power plant to neutralise the threat carried by a terrorist group known as FOXHOUND.

Advertisement

Growing to become one of the most recognisable figures from the early generations of consoles, Snake is shown throughout the game to be a veteran fighter, emotionally repressed but also remarkably intelligent and surprisingly moralistic, with his character design and depth being one of the biggest reasons behind the game's success.

The sequel, however, 2001's Metal Gear Solid: Sons of Liberty, made the controversial decision to transition the protagonist from Solid Snake to Raiden. The difference between the mystery and depth of Solid Snake and Raiden's strange mix of whining and arrogance really held the game's storyline back from packing the punch of its predecessor had.

Raiden would be given a fairly decent redemption in Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots and Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance, but neither of those titles are enough to save this from being one of the most controversial decisions in the series' history.

5. "Do You Guys Not Have Phones?" - Diablo Immortal

With over 20 million copies worth of sales stretching back to 1997, the Diablo series has established itself as one of the most important RPGs in the industry. It also houses an extremely passionate community, who spend their time and money into not only playing through the series, but also invest in the books, magazines and other bits of lore connected to the franchise's world.

Advertisement

In summary, Diablo has a well-established formula for what makes the series so special to so many fans around the world, and going out of your way to mess with it is going to end up making you look rather silly.

Rumours had been swirling around the Diablo community for a number of months that developers Blizzard were going to be unveiling a major announcement at Blizzcon 2018, which most assumed would be "Diablo 4 confirmed". Instead, the conference has become infamous for the announcement of Diablo Immortal, the franchise's first foray into the mobile world.

The announcement and subsequent reveal there were no plans in the work for anything on PC came as a bitter blow to both the audience in attendance, as well as those in Twitch chat watching the event live, and the developer's meme-worthy 'do you guys not have phones?' response left many fans wondering what direction their beloved franchise was going down.

4. ANOTHER 2D Mario Adventure? - New Super Mario Bros. U

2006's New Super Mario Bros for the Nintendo DS was the first 2D Mario title for fifteen years, and successfully put the series back on the map with its combination of faithfulness to the games of the past, as well as the improved control scheme taken from 3D titles, Super Mario 64 and Sunshine.

Advertisement

New Super Mario Bros. Wii was released in 2009 as the first home console 2D Mario side-scroller, but by the time it was released, it's safe to say most fans were beginning to feel the formula was growing slightly stale. However, 60 million sales seemed to be all the prompting Nintendo needed, releasing TWO play-it-safe follow-ups in 2012, the 3DS' New Super Mario Bros. 2 and Wii U's New Super Mario Bros. U.

And whilst New Super Mario Bros. U certainly didn't kill off the 2D Mario franchise, it is certainly still one of the most divisive games Nintendo have recently released. The game received DLC and a port to the Nintendo Switch, however, the game's divisiveness with the community led to the company changing tact and letting players design their own 2D side-scrollers with the release of games like Super Mario Maker.

3. An Airport Massacre - Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 is one of the world's most iconic video games from the seventh generation of consoles. The game was one of the first titles in the series where online multiplayer became the primary focus for its fans, with the game garnering quite the reputation for its addictive grind.

Advertisement

One of the reasons for this shift in focus is the huge amount of content available with the multiplayer modes, however another reason is just how controversial the main game's storyline proved to be.

The game comes with a warning that: "some players may find one of the missions disturbing or offensive. Would you like to have the option to skip this mission?", allowing players to leap right past the campaign scene, "No Russian".

No Russian sees the player, undercover as a Russian terrorist group member, asked to massacre a crowd of civilians, with them having to literally pull out their gun and manually firing at the people in front of them. The level drew some of the biggest backlash seen in the gaming space, is still a hot topic to fans now, and really saw Call of Duty's main storylines take a backseat to multiplayer in the editions that followed.

2. Shadow Gets A Gun? - Shadow The Hedgehog

If ever there was an example of a mega-successful video game franchise struggling to make the jump from 2D to 3D gaming, it's the Sonic the Hedgehog series.

Advertisement

Going from a series that was right up there with Super Mario, the demise of Sonic the Hedgehog series began with the likes of Sonic 3D Blast and Sonic R on the Sega Genesis and Saturn but hit rock-bottom with 2005's Shadow the Hedgehog.

The moody rival introduced in Sonic Adventure 2, Shadow the Hedgehog was designed to be a more mature, gritty entry to the series. Given that the series was built off of plenty of bright colours and a cute blue hedgehog, it was a strange departure for Sega to make, but quite how far they were willing to go in order to hammer these themes home shocked the entire gaming world.

Right from the opening cutscene, players can tell this was something where Sega had taken their creative brains too far, with Shadow slowly walking into the shot like a wannabe John Wick bizarrely cocking an MP5.

Shadow the Hedgehogs's use of literal submachine guns in a series primarily known for its family-friendly accessibility was one of the most controversial decisions Sega have ever made, and the game's poor reception would kickstart the lowest point in Sonic's history.

1. Desmond Kills Lucy - Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood

By the time Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood was released in 2010, the Ubisoft series was primed to reach its commercial peak. Assasin's Creed II had delivered a huge upgrade on the 2008 original game in the series with a massive open world, improved mechanics and, most importantly of all, developed two of the best storylines for Ezio and Desmond.

Advertisement

And whilst Brotherhood continued on a lot of the good work AC2 laid the foundations for, the storylines both inside and out of the Animus failed on the whole to really land the same level of impact its predecessor had. Whilst the majority of these storylines are more than fine, the whole series nosedived off the edge when it came to the main plot's finale.

When Desmond retrieves the Piece of Eden he and the Assassins have located thanks to Ezio, a vision of Juno appears and takes hold of his body. Players are then forced to stab Lucy, who had just spent the past three games being Desmond's closest ally and more-than-teased love interest, before the pair collapse and the credits roll.

Whilst it certainly blindsided the bulk of players at the time, the reasoning behind killing off such a popular character was lost on most of these same players. Whilst the stuff in the Animus was always what players were more interested in to begin with, this was the point in which most of them switched off entirely from the plots outside of it.

On top of that, the decision to kill off Lucy is really the point in which the Desmond Miles era of Assassin's Creed's storyline starts to become convoluted and messy, which would contribute hugely to Brotherhood's two follow-ups, Revelations and AC3, being two of the most mixed titles in the franchise.

Advertisement