10 Failed PS2 Games That Became Cult Classics

Shadow of GOAT, more like.

By John Tibbetts /

Sony has been doing this gaming console thing for a while now, but the era that is universally agreed to have been their peak remains the PS2.

Advertisement

While the original Playstation had its charms and definitely cemented them as a serious player on the field, the PS2 proved that Sony were not only to be taken seriously by the distinguished competition, they were to be feared.

Immediately wiping out the Dreamcast by essentially being the superior version of it, the PS2 proved a kingmaker for the company through its then cutting-edge graphics, excellent first-party franchises, and truly insane library of third-party games.

But with such an expansive library, it's only natural that a lot of great games weren't truly appreciated until long after they left the shelves. Whether they were commercial bombs, critical flops, or both, these PS2 games were not shown the love they deserved until after they got thrashed.

10. Gungrave

Gungrave, the underrated follow-up to Yasuhiro Nightow's sci-fi masterpiece Trigun, got an anime and two video games to advertise it, and it just didn't work. From a story perspective there could be many reasons for this, but in terms of the game, really bad marketing had a lot to do with it.

Advertisement

Fortunately, hardcore otaku have since discovered Gungrave, with its satisfying arcadey gun combat, stylish evasion mechanics and memorable character design, making it very recommendable.

The gun combat is the real reason you buy this game - it would be a rather poor adaptation of a manga called GUNgrave otherwise. While it can get repetitive at times, as tends to be the case with arcade-like shooters such as this, the game isn't too long so it doesn't wear out its welcome, leaving the player more satisfied with the combat overall.

True, the super condensed story does cost the game the more emotional and philosophical writing that Nightow is known for, so this isn't the best version of the story. Besides that, though, Gungrave is an awesome game for what it is.

9. Extermination

Launch window titles are rarely remembered, with only Nintendo known for starting their new consoles off on extremely good notes. Even then, their batting average can be off sometimes.

Advertisement

One of the launch titles for the PS2 was Deep Space's Extermination, intended to be Resident Evil for the next generation of consoles. Mainly due to the fact that Deep Space was made up of a bunch of former Resident Evil devs.

The reason you don't remember this game alongside the other, better-received launch titles for the PS2 is that the game sold like absolute garbage.

It isn't hard to see why when playing, as while the deliberately slow gameplay of the PS1-era RE games has been appreciated in recent years, back then, folks wanted something more innovative to go with their new console.

Fortunately, Extermination has become better appreciated in the years since, mostly due to the fact that, shock of all shocks for a game made by the team that revolutionized survival-horror, Extermination is a VERY good Resident Evil clone.

It's short, sweet, often genuinely terrifying, and a John Carpenter's The Thing approach helps it stand out from the series it's copying so much from. It's definitely a better option to play than the game actually based on The Thing.

8. Mark Of Kri

If sports-related games are your bag, then Sony Computer Entertainment San Diego is a name that's firmly on your radar. But believe it or not, there was a time when San Diego made games OTHER than MLB The Show sequels.

Advertisement

Mark of Kri is the closest entry on this list to have broken into the mainstream. I mean, this is a wing of the company BEHIND the PS2, if they couldn't sell one of their own games at least *decently* well, what are we even doing here?

Mark Of Kri is essentially what happens if Genndy Tartakovsky's Primal was made in-house at Disney and literally nothing else was changed. Behind its cel-shaded cartoon aesthetic is brutal, grisly combat, epic fantasy worlds populated by people whose dialect wouldn't sound out of place at a seedy bar in Queens, and storytelling driven by the strength of its characters.

But the combat mechanics are the real draw. Unlike other 3D games at the time, which made use of Ocarina Of Time's reliable lock-on system, Mark of Kri mapped different enemies to different face buttons, so pressing X would attack the guy to your right, while pressing square would attack on your left, etc. Just a shame that, while it did get a sequel in Rise of the Kasai, the franchise failed to gain the mainstream impact other PS2 franchises did.

2002's loss can be your gain, as Mark Of Kri comes highly recommended.

7. Killer 7

Suda-51 is one of the most interesting and eclectic voices in the game industry, with all of his games containing a fun mix of offbeat Japanese and American pop culture. And the first time we westerners were made aware of his weirdness was in the cult classic Killer 7.

Advertisement

Describing Killer 7 is a testament to how insane it is, because your explanation will always contain at least one "oh but wait-" because there's ALWAYS something more to add. This game is legitimately insane. It starts on the note of "7 highly trained assassins all trapped in the same brain" and then keeps going until that note sounds positively sane and reasonable.

Frankly, this game was destined to be a cult classic, even if it did sell well, which it didn't. Its eccentric nature means that only a select kind of person would vibe with it enough to get into it.

With games like Lollipop Chainsaw and No More Heroes, Suda-51 would find more success, but Killer 7 is still remembered, because really, how can you forget something like this?

6. Shadow Of Rome

We as a society are irreparably fascinated with Ancient Rome, or at least our gory, mostly inaccurate version thereof. So it makes sense that there have been lots of games made centring around the bloody theatrics of the colosseum. And Shadow Of Rome...sure is one of those.

Advertisement

Not bad by any means, not at all. In fact, if you're a gorehound, this game is some of the bloodiest action on the PS2. But with God Of War acting as the competition, there simply is no comparison.

However, taken on its own, Shadow Of Rome is quite a lot of fun, which is probably why it has the cult that it does. Tearing an opponent apart in this game feels so damn satisfying, as the sound perfectly blends with the gore flying everywhere. And really, that's the only part this game absolutely needed to get right.

Didn't save it from its sales, though, as Capcom is more likely to return to Mega Man before giving this franchise another shot. But if you want some good gory action and don't feel like slicing it up as Kratos for some reason, you could definitely do a lot worse.

5. Shin Megami Tensei 3: Nocturne

Atlus has had a helluva time getting anyone in the west to give a damn about their games. Sure, they've gotten it pretty down pat nowadays, but the mid to late-2000s was ROUGH for them, barely reaching above cult status.

Advertisement

But while the Persona series was slowly picking up steam with the one-two punch of 3 and 4, the series that built Atlus - Shin Megami Tensei - has only very recently seen any success here in the west. The closest they got before this was the legendary cult classic JRPG SMT: Nocturne.

Nocturne's difficulty is notorious for making Dark Souls look like a game starring the Smurfs, as it has no patience, no mercy, and no regrets. The RNG is absolutely what keeps it from the mainstream, on top of some archaic dungeon design and an incredibly dense plot.

However, if none of that sounds like a problem for you, then you'll find Nocturne to be one of the most satisfying-to-master games ever made.

4. Psychonauts

Psychonauts is one of the best platformers the PS2 ever released, and that is actually a pretty hefty list. However, unlike its more successful counterparts like Jak & Daxter or Sly Cooper, Psychonauts sold like actual garbage.

Advertisement

Now, granted, we know why this is, and it has nothing to do with the game itself. Microsoft, Majesco, and the developer Double Fine really just fumbled the whole thing from top to bottom, bickering with each other constantly to the point where an entire console generation went by before the game was released.

Psychonauts got its butt whooped in sales for what was then a dying generation, but those who were in the know remember Psychonauts as being some of the most fun they've ever had on the PS2.

This comes from tight controls, fun characters, and dark humor. Everything about the game strikes this brilliant balance between being timeless, and yet as an aughties kid, your scribe can point to the exact year this game came out while blindfolded.

3. God Hand

Ever wanted to know what it feels like to lose your goddamn mind? Then play God Hand.

Advertisement

God Hand is madness piled upon madness which is then topped off by some of the most satisfying beat-em-up combat ever put to code. You will fight knock-off power ranger midgets, you will fight gorillas wearing luchador masks, you will fight burly purple dudes in military combat gear. And the game's response to the madness is just "okay next".

This is what cost God Hand anything resembling mainstream appeal. There is simply no port in the storm in this madcap adventure, no bastion of sanity to hold onto. The game is mad as a hatter and will not wait for you to catch up.

Fortunately, the game is fun as all hell to play, so there's no trouble continuing on despite that.

Sure, the movement controls have definitely shown their age, but when you get into the rhythm of it, there are few games as satisfying to play as God Hand. Just try to keep your brain from leaking out your ears when you fight a big fat demon Elvis.

2. Beyond Good & Evil

Still waiting on that sequel, Ubisoft.

Advertisement

Even though Ubisoft has been dragging its damn feet for coming on two decades when it comes to making a sequel, Beyond Good And Evil is exactly good enough to warrant that kind of a wait.

Mixing the style and gameplay of 5th-6th gen platformers with a sci-fi dystopian setting and a strong spiritualistic undercurrent, Beyond Good and Evil stood out from its contemporaries with strong visual direction, tight combat, and a deep and complex female lead. Beyond Good and Evil had everything needed to become a stone-cold classic in the hearts and memories of an entire generation.

Shame then, that it really struggled to sell.

A lot of this is on the head of Ubisoft, to be fair. They barely advertised the thing, and when they did, the ads kinda sucked. But those who bought it regardless made sure the whole internet knew what they missed, and are desperately waiting for Ubisoft to take a break from systemically abusing its staff to release the sequel promised over half a decade ago.

1. Okami

It was a genuine debate whether to put this or Beyond Good and Evil at the top, but Okami in the end feels like the bigger snub.

Advertisement

Okami is one of, if not the most visually breathtaking game ever released on the PS2. Considered to be Capcom's magnum opus for the 6th generation of consoles, Okami blends gorgeous visuals with a story rich with Japanese folklore and legend to create an unforgivable experience.

And, say it with me one more time, it sold like GARBAGE.

Again, a lot of this is the fault of the marketing, as when they advertised the remake, Okami HD, it actually sold pretty well. But the PS2 was characterized by a sinful glut of video games, from first to third-party, so being an artistic achievement simply wasn't enough to get attention. Marketing was half the battle, and Capcom, like so many on this list, simply refused to get with the program when it came to niche games like this.

And so, Okami bombed financially but became a cult classic for those in the know. And, more than any other entry on this list, you can absolutely see why.

Advertisement