10 Fan Backlashes That SAVED Video Games

Without the infamous Craig debacle, Halo Infinite would've been released a hot mess.

By Jack Pooley /

One of the best things about the modern era of gaming is the more wide-open dialogue that players have with the people creating their games. If there's a problem, there's an easy way for fans to address it through social media.

Advertisement

And while this unfortunately often results in developers being harassed over menial, subjective "issues," it can also be a powerful way for gamers to ensure they're not taken advantage of by money-grubbing publishers or sub-par work.

A backlash is the last thing any publisher or developer wants, but sometimes they'll take a calculated risk, that invoking the ire of x number of players is worth the commercial gain of whatever they've done.

But sometimes the controversy is so overwhelming and sustained for such a long period that it actually forces the bigwigs to pivot and do something about it.

And in the long run, the result is a superior game which actually benefitted from an embarrassing period of ridicule, even though the publishers in particular might see things a little differently.

For players, though, these games were all substantially improved by putting the pressure on those in charge and refusing to let up...

10. The Art Style That "Looks Like Poop" - Bloodstained: Ritual Of The Night

The pre-release hype for Castlevania's spiritual successor, Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night, sure was something. Until the first gameplay footage was released, that is.

Advertisement

Fans immediately expressed disappointment with almost every aspect of the game's visual design, from its flat lighting to its low-fi character models, dull environments, and wonky animations, with many comparing its roughshod aesthetic to what would be expected from a pre-alpha version of a game.

Perhaps more succinctly, one offended fan simply said the art style "looks like poop."

But rather than dig their heels in and push ahead blindly, developers ArtPlay opted to go back and give the overall visual style a major upgrade, ensuring the entire aesthetic looked more polished and vibrant.

Hilariously, the publisher even debuted this nifty new look with a trailer which poked fun at the backlash while comparing the improved version with the bland, muddy original one.

That added hard work certainly paid off, as Bloodstained released to strong reviews and quickly became a best-seller on Steam.

9. Failing To Deliver On Its Promises - No Man's Sky

There's surely no better example of a game being rescued by vocal fan backlash than No Man's Sky.

Advertisement

The highly anticipated space exploration game launched in a shockingly barebones state in 2016, with many decrying both the repetitive nature of the gameplay and lack of features promised by Hello Games founder Sean Murray - namely a rich story and multiplayer component.

The backlash was tectonic, with many players demanding refunds and a small number of idiots even sending death threats to Murray.

It didn't help that Hello Games went quiet for the months following the game's release, though given the literal threats of harm made, it's tough to blame them.

But even with the player count falling off a cliff, Hello Games quietly got to work to fix the game and finally deliver the title they'd promised.

Over the years that followed, they released a number of substantial, free updates which added a more comprehensive story element, the promised multiplayer mode, a greater diversity of alien races, and even VR support.

More than six years on from its launch, No Man's Sky is still receiving updates, which is all the more impressive given that it contains no microtransactions whatsoever.

As much as Hello Games absolutely bungled their marketing rollout of the game, they more than made good on it in the long run.

8. No Tails - Sonic Adventure 2

Until Sega was deep into development on Sonic Adventure 2, Tails wasn't actually supposed to be included in the game in anything beyond a story capacity, with Sonic, Knuckles, and Eggman intended to be the three playable characters.

Advertisement

As a result, Tails naturally wasn't featured as part of the gameplay in its marketing, as caused a not insignificant reaction from the character's many devoted fans, who felt he absolutely should be playable.

And so while Sega were way too deep into development to plug Tails into the bulk of the game, they developed a small number of additional levels featuring him.

This effectively explains why all of Tails' levels feel disconnected from the core loop of the story and are also vehicle-based, because it would've just been too damn costly to do anything more.

And yet, Sonic Adventure 2 went on to receive rave reviews from critics and fans alike, ensuring nobody felt particularly deprived of their Miles Prower fix.

7. Loot Boxes - Star Wars Battlefront II

Star Wars Battlefront II had perhaps the single most vitriol-filled launch in recent gaming history, as after EA promised that the sequel would offer a more feature-rich platter of content than its initially barren predecessor, they ended up being dragged through the mud before the game had even launched.

Advertisement

In the pre-release period, journalists noted that the game was engineered to make players grind for up to 40 hours to unlock a single hero character, or spend real money on loot boxes to save all that time, as EA was clearly banking on.

The blowback was so catastrophic, including an EA customer support rep posting the most downvoted comment in Reddit history, that EA ended up disabling microtransactions the day before release, all while governments worldwide considered the legal and ethical quagmire of loot boxes.

Within four months of release, all remnants of the pay-to-win mechanics had been removed from the game, and progression was reworked to reward players for their actual performance.

Battlefront II was later given a soft relaunch with 2019's Celebration Edition, which included the base game and all the customisation content, while a tie-in with Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker was released as a free update to all players.

By this point, Battlefront II had been reworked from a flabbergasting cash grab into a genuinely enjoyable game worthy of the Star Wars license. All it took was millions of players getting very, very pissed off for a sustained period, apparently.

6. Cole's Redesign - Infamous 2

When Infamous 2 gameplay was first unveiled at E3 2010, many fans were taken aback by the changes made to protagonist Cole MacGrath's character model.

Advertisement

Not only was Cole's face totally remodelled to look like a different person, but he had a considerably thicker head of hair, "hipper" set of clothing, and even his voice actor had been changed, all of which rubbed fans totally the wrong way.

The outcry from fans was swift and strong, enough that while developer Sucker Punch kept new voice actor Eric Ladin, they backpedalled on many of the other design changes.

Namely, Cole's original face and short-haired look were returned, albeit while retaining some of the new Cole's attire, effectively delivering a comprise between the two designs that most fans found acceptable.

Granted, neither Cole design is exactly spectacular, but when the fanbase has gotten attached to a character's look, why on Earth would you change it? It felt like a cynical executive decision rather than something that benefitted the game or its fans, and so they were right to walk most of it back.

5. Not Enough To Do - Sea Of Thieves

When Rare's action-adventure game Sea of Thieves released back in 2018, the initial response was relatively muted, with some enjoying the limited seafaring shenanigans on offer, while others found the package too lacking in features to sustain interest.

Advertisement

The adventuring was painfully rote and generic out of the gate, which in conjunction with the amount of griefers who flocked to the game made Sea of Thieves a routinely miserable experience.

But to their eternal credit, Rare listened to the vocal feedback from fans, and over the years that followed worked hard to deliver a number of updates which significantly expanded the experience.

The addition of narrative missions called Tall Tales added a much-needed degree of structure to the core gameplay loop, and the inclusion of a PvP Arena mode was also widely praised.

Rare has continued to roll out free updates, enough that Sea of Thieves today scarcely resembles the launch product, and just last year posted its highest concurrent users ever on Steam.

That's one hell of a turnaround for a game that could've so easily disintegrated into the watery abyss were it not adequately supported.

4. The Auction House - Diablo III

Though Diablo III was released to positive reviews, a month after release Blizzard opened the real money auction house, where players could buy and sell in-game items for actual money.

Advertisement

This effectively created a gross pay-to-win economy in which players willing to shell out real cash had a major advantage over those who didn't.

The fan backlash was huge, and in conjunction with the game's always-online DRM, caused a large swath of the community to turn against both Diablo III and Blizzard entirely.

After well over a year of dogged complaints, in which even the game's own director lamented the auction house's existence, Blizzard finally announced that both the gold and real money auction houses would be closing down, and that they finally did in March 2014.

This decision, combined with the rollout of a more balanced, less grind-centric loot system, caused many fans to turn around on Diablo III and finally deem it the game it should've been at launch. Better late than never, eh?

3. Microtransactions - Payday 2

When Payday 2 launched in the summer of 2013, developers Overkill Software promised that they wouldn't ever plug microtransaction nonsense into the game.

Advertisement

But with the release of 2015's Black Market update, Overkill reneged on their word and indeed added microtransactions by way of weapon-filled safes which could only be opened with drills that players could pay to acquire with real money.

The fanbase quickly and aggressively pushed back, and though game producer Almir Listo initially defended the decision as funding their ability to increase the size of the dev team, the community kicked up a huge stink and simply wouldn't let the issue go.

And in mid-2016, Overkill's parent company Starbreeze Studios acquired full rights to the Payday IP from publisher 505 Games, and then promptly announced that all microtransactions would be removed from the game in the next update, with all safes then being openable for free.

Though the history of gaming is filled with examples of publishers beating their customers into submission and forcing them to accept a bum deal, in this case the community's persistent anger - in conjunction with a fortuitous change in rights ownership - allowed the good guys to win.

2. Craig The Brute - Halo Infinite

While Halo Infinite is certainly a far-from-perfect game, it nevertheless launched in considerably sturdier shape than it would've had 343 Industries not endured a brutal - if necessary - round of ridicule.

Advertisement

Infinite was originally planned to release in November 2020, but that all changed after Microsoft dropped an infamous gameplay reveal that summer. Players and the press promptly expressed bewilderment at the game's lack of polish and generally underwhelming visuals for a "next gen" title.

Fans drew particular attention to an especially poorly rendered Brute, and a screenshot featuring the enemy quickly went viral, with Internet commentators coming to refer to him as "Craig."

After almost a month of ridicule over Craig and the game's generally lackluster presentation, 343 announced that Infinite was being delayed into an unspecified 2021 date, and was ultimately released in December 2021, over a year after its planned initial release.

But the Craig debacle was basically a blessing in disguise, because it made it emphatically clear to 343 and Microsoft that pushing this thing out in 2020 would've been a massive, brand-damaging mistake.

Shortly before the game's release, Character and Combat Director Steve Dyck admitted that the blowback and subsequent delay were ultimately a good thing for the game:

"The positive outcome of Craig was that he was one of the factors in gaining some more time to finish work and get Brutes to a place where the team is happy with them... This is one of the many positive examples of 343 working with and aligning with the Halo community around expectations."

343 also included a Craig Easter egg in the game's campaign, to prove they could laugh at themselves too.

1. Spin Distance For Gyms & Pokéstops - Pokémon Go

Pokémon Go is a phenomenally successful game, grossing more than $6 billion in revenue between 2016 and 2020 alone, though developers Niantic risked killing the cash cow during its most commercially fertile period.

Advertisement

At the onset of the pandemic in 2020, Niantic decided to expand the game's original interaction radius with gyms and Pokéstops from 40 meters to 80 meters, allowing players to keep playing without risking closeness with other people.

But even while the COVID-19 Delta variant was raging in July 2021, Niantic opted to revert back to the original 40-meter radius, as angered millions of fans worldwide, both for health concerns and because the 80-meter radius made the game more accessible for many disabled players.

Niantic originally refused to restore the 80-meter radius, but as the pressure intensified with the #HearUsNiantic Twitter campaign, the studio buckled within a few weeks and agreed to make 80 meters the permanent radius.

And like that, a game which threatened to encourage players to endanger themselves in the height of a global pandemic avoided a huge PR disaster by simply letting people play in the way they'd become accustomed to.

Given that 2020 was the most profitable year in the history of Pokémon Go, it would've been supremely stupid not to listen to fans on this one.

Advertisement