No matter what happens in future installments, Final Fantasy's legacy is secured. No other franchise in gaming history could possibly hope to accomplish as many feats as Final Fantasy in a 25 year long reign. Since its inception, the series has become renowned for a sense of innovation; always willing to experiment with gameplay, visuals and story in ways that capture the imagination and draw you into its various worlds. Perhaps the most intriguing aspect of Final Fantasy's immense success is the division it inspires within its own fanbase; everybody has their own favourite game; their own favourite character; their own favourite villain... It doesn't matter how many times people try and classify one aspect of one game as "the best"; others will always be willing to step up and fight the corner of their favourites. This all stems from the high standard of game we expect from a Final Fantasy release and its these high standards that have perhaps led to a slight diminish within the series. Final Fantasy XIV's failed launch was seen by many as the first major blunder within the franchise, though others pinpoint the beginning of the series' demise as far back as Final Fantasy VIII. All of that is irrelevant though. Even if Square Enix release a dozen failed MMOs, the quality and standard of the Final Fantasy games leading up to it will not be diminished. Still, within these games, there are elements that are slightly off-putting to us as players. With a wide variety of characters and story arcs, you'd expect to be more interested in certain characters ahead of others; that's simply human nature. Interestingly though, some characters seem to be placed within the series simply to annoy us. Why else would you introduce "heroic" characters with wildly inflated egos and aggravating personalities? This article seeks to highlight ten characters who challenged us with their appearances throughout the series; characters who annoyed us, upset us or offended us with their pointless ways. Whether it was an annoying personality or habit or an infuriating sidequest which wasted our time, these ten characters should be ashamed for their crimes against us - the players. Of course, as already stated, this isn't a definitive list. Everybody's opinions will be different here so please feel free to disagree and add your thoughts to the comments below; I'd wager that there's at least one character on this list that everybody can agree on though.
10. Umaro (Final Fantasy VI)
Interestingly, Final Fantasy VI was created with no main protagonist in mind; it's characters form more of an ensemble than any other Final Fantasy game. As such, there's a range of creative characters with many optional choices that can be missed entirely (especially when in the World of Ruin where rediscovering certain characters is optional). Of course, when you're introducing a wide range of characters, not all of them are going to be hits. Umaro is a remarkably strange choice for a playable character, even by Final Fantasy standards. He's a berserker yeti who doesn't take any commands from the player; he simply uses physical attacks and generally does whatever he wants. Not exactly the sort of party member you want around when the going gets tough. Even stranger is the way you recruit him into the party. In the World of Ruin, Umaro is encountered in a mine and after a battle, if Mog is in your party, the Moogle will command Umaro to join you; apparently Mog knows how to control him. It's a bizarre partnership to say the least; so bizarre in fact that when held up against the more mature storylines in Final Fantasy VI, it kind of falls apart. There's various ways to get the most out of Umaro in battle but with little story and character, when all is said and done, one question really remains about Umaro - why?
9. Edward (Final Fantasy IV)
Is it possible to have a playable character who was placed in a game just for one line? Edward's first appearance in Final Fantasy IV sees him being insultingly referred to as a "spoony bard" by Tellah. It's an example of the silliness of the series as well as some terrifically poor translation throughout the years, but it's somehow incredibly apt; there is something rather spoony about Edward, after all. At least part of Tellah's exclamation is right anyway; Edward is a bard. He's also a prince but his love for music far outweighs his love for politics. His story features an early tragedy when the love of his life, Anna, is killed by Golbez (who also steals Edward's airship for good measure) and it doesn't get much better from that point. He spends a lot of time moping about his lost love and the rest of the time acting cowardly and very un-princely. He also ends up bedridden for most of the game (although he does help the party out greatly from the comfort of his bed), further making him look weak and useless. In battle, his stats are pretty poor (they skyrocket after Level 70 but in the original SNES version, you simply aren't going to get him that high) and his abilities, mainly Sing, are fairly useless. He also uses Hide when his health is low, saving him from death while simultaneously making him unusuable. Edward might not be much of a fighter (or a character in general) but we'll forever remember him as the Spoony one.
8. Squall (Final Fantasy VIII)
Squall offers something of a dilemma; as the central character, he's imperative to Final Fantasy VIII's narrative yet his irritating personality and unsociable habits mean that it's hard to root for him. He's a character that divides opinion on an incredible scale; some view his personality traits as inhuman (and therefore, highly problematic) while there's also an argument that his cynical and cold ways make him an intriguing character - one that we want to see more of. Squall's stoic personality derives from an intense feeling of loneliness; a combination of his life as an orphan and a feeling of abandonment from the girl he looks up to as his older sister. When this storyline actually develops, it's an interesting look at our hero, giving us the chance to peel back his rigid exterior and see what lies beneath. Sadly, it comes very late in the game and for some, the damage may have permanently been done. You see, Squall doesn't seem to get on very well with people. His talents allow him a leadership role within the SeeD organisation (specifically leading Zell and Selphie on their first assignment to Timber) but his dismissive attitude makes you wonder why he's entrusted with this role. Even those who follow him mock him for his pouty ways; Quistis and Rinoa both preemptively copy him with his catchphrase "Whatever". He's really not the world's biggest bad-ass. Yes, Squall's development is central to Final Fantasy VIII and seeing him finally open up is a genuinely awesome moment. Still, you can see why so many felt that the journey to get there simply wasn't worth it. Not that Squall really cares what we think anyway.
7. Cait Sith (Final Fantasy VII)
You have to be especially abnormal to be the weirdest character in a game featuring a vampire, a man with a gun for an arm and a talking animal. Cait Sith is definitely abnormal though; he's a giant stuffed animal controlled by a robotic cat with a megaphone (who's actually being controlled by Reeve of Shinra - you know, the bad guys). Upon joining the party in the Gold Saucer, Cait Sith acts as a spy for Shinra. Cloud quickly suspects that the group has a spy within its midsts but doesn't seem to suspect the new guy at all. Later on, he steals a key item from the group (the key to the Temple Of The Ancients) and hands it to Shinra. When caught, he reveals his true colours but then announces he's holding Barret's daughter hostage, forcing the group to keep him around. It's fair to say that he's not a team player. Cait Sith's redemption arrives in the Temple Of The Ancients when he sacrifices himself to get the Black Materia. However, mere minutes later, an identical replacement shows up, making the entire sacrifice ordeal irrelevant. On top of all of this, in battle, his limit break is entirely random and has a chance to give you an immediate Game Over screen; Cait Sith might be the first character you've ever wanted to literally knock the stuffing out of.
6. Zell (Final Fantasy VIII)
Perhaps it's intentional that nearly every Final Fantasy game has a character that's been perfectly designed to annoy you on a constant basis; how else can you explain Zell's exasperating role in Final Fantasy VIII? Zell is a near-disastrous mix of arrogance, stupidity and speech in capital letters, meaning that when he's not annoying you by trying to fight everyone, he's saying or doing something that's bound to get your party into trouble. There's a great example of this during the party's early mission in Timber. The President of Galbadia (who the group have been tasked with kidnapping) is making a speech on television but before the group can put their plans into action, Seifer storms in and holds him hostage in front of the nation. When you arrive in the TV studio, Zell blurts out that Seifer is from Garden, despite Squall's desperate attempts to shut him up, directly leading to Galbadia taking military action against the three Gardens. Great job, Zell. Zell and Seifer's rivalry is actually a running plot thread through the early stages of Final Fantasy VIII and it's unbelievably silly. Seifer likes to call Zell a "chickenwuss" which, despite being one of the worst insults ever created, gets under Zell's skin for some reason and usually leads to him firing up in a big, melodramatic fashion. He does bring some good qualities to the table (particularly in battle where his limit break sees him performing wrestling moves on foes) but Zell's annoying qualities will undeniably have you facepalming like Squall on a constant basis.
5. Vaan/Penelo (Final Fantasy XII)
When are your main characters not actually your main characters? When they're Vaan and Penelo. Final Fantasy XII's main story deals with Ashe's quest to accumulate power and regain control of her kingdom after it's overthrown by a betrayal. Vaan and Penelo accompany her on this journey, acting as viewpoints on the various events. This seems strange though, given that they're the first characters introduced in the game (aside from the tutorial section which features Vaan's soldier brother Reks). For the majority of the game, you'll be controlling Vaan, yet in a narrative sense, he's not really the main character. Perhaps Square felt that Ashe's tale was told better from a third person perspective but it also undermines Vaan's character somewhat. Vaan's main developments center around his desperate want to obtain an airship and become a sky pirate. Later on, he admits that this is driven by a desire to leave the memory of his brother behind. Penelo serves as his companion and that's legitimately pretty much it. Together, they learn about the world of Ivalice during their travels but beyond this, any story focused on them as characters is pretty much non-existent. Vaan and Penelo's problem isn't even really to do with them as characters; it's more their frustrating role within the story. They're given little opportunity to stand out and by the end of the game, they're only slightly better off than they were before. Plus, there's a section of the game where you're required to run around as Vaan and yell "Don't listen to Ondore's lies!" in the smuggest voice possible - yeah, these two definitely needed more work.
4. Quina (Final Fantasy IX)
After the semi-realistic worlds of Final Fantasy VII and VIII, Square's decision to return to its more bizarre fantasy worlds in Final Fantasy IX allowed them to bring their imaginative creations to the fore once again. How else do you explain the decision to create a humanoid lead character who has a tail for no reason? There's plenty of weird and wonderful characters in Final Fantasy IX but none come close to the bizarre appearance of Quina Quen. It's almost impossible to describe Quina in words, though the first thing to point out is that Quina is actually genderless (a pretty annoying character trait to write about, as it turns out). Quina speaks in broken English, forcing him/her into a Jar Jar Binks-esque role within the game; not the best role to be playing in anything, really. Quina's defining characteristic is a love for food which is pretty much the character's sole purpose within the game. S/he initially joins your party on his/her own quest to discover new foods and s/he regularly departs the group while chasing down foods, conveniently returning when its time for the group to move on. Annoyingly, this is pretty much Quina's role throughout the entire game. S/he'll pop up in several Active Time Events or when the group first enters an area and usually make a comment about cuisine before disappearing. It's repetitive to say the least. On a positive note, Quina can be quite useful in battle as s/he acts as the Blue Mage of the party in battle, learning enemy skills by eating them. Of course, the problem with any Blue Mage class is that in order to maximise their usefulness, you have to spend time tracking down every skill for them. If you're fully invested in Final Fantasy IX and looking for as much adventure as possible, that's fine. Others simply won't bother and Quina simply won't match up to other party members. If Quina had some actual story (and a gender), s/he might have been a decent character in Final Fantasy IX, despite his/her broken English and annoying habits. Sadly, s/he's relegated to simple comic relief and like Jar Jar Binks, half the time, it simply isn't funny enough.
3. Tidus (Final Fantasy X)
It's hard being stuck in your ways and then suddenly finding yourself completely out of your depth in a whole new world. Well, at least, that's what Tidus' story in Final Fantasy X tells us. The Star Player Of The Zanarkand Abes is transported to Spira when Sin destroys his home of Zanarkand and he finds himself lost in a world which is almost completely different. You really have to feel for the guy. ...Or not. Main characters have divided opinion in the Final Fantasy series before, but Tidus is easily the most conflict-causing protagonist of all. His naivety and ignorance means that he's a pretty good character to control as we, the player, learn about Spira ourselves, though this causes a lot of awkward situations that just make our hero look stupid. A key example is early in the game, when Wakka warns him against telling people he's from Zanarkand (in Spira, it's regarded as a holy place. Plus, it's been destroyed for a thousand years). Despite this, Tidus proceeds to tell everybody that'll listen that he's The Star Player Of The Zanarkand Abes, completely disregarding Wakka's wise warnings. While this never actually causes any conflict within the game (well, he does get branded a heathen by an old woman), it hardly paints Tidus as the sort of intelligent, heroic figure we want to be playing as. As a hero, Tidus develops late on in the game, especially due to his love story with Yuna becoming more central to the plot. Sadly, to get to that point, we have to endure his irritatingly cocky attitude, his inability to learn basic manners and a laugh scene in Luca which has lived in infamy for being one of the worst scenes in the entire series. Plus, he fits into the dumb blonde stereotype perfectly; time to buck up your ideas, Tidus.
2. Hope (Final Fantasy XIII)
It's fair to say that there are very few redeeming factors in Final Fantasy XIII's six main characters. Lightning, Sazh, Snow and Fang can best be described as alright and Vanille is one of the series' most divisive characters. Still, none have drawn as much hostility as Hope and for good reason. A lot of Hope's problems stem from bigger problems with Final Fantasy XIII's characters in general. We're given little motivation to care about their plight or themselves as characters and they develop very slowly due to a lack of interaction throughout the game. In fact, the group is split for the vast majority of the game, preventing us from seeing the various dynamics of the party at work. Perhaps worst of all though, this all serves to highlight Hope as the game's most irritating character. His mother's extremely unsurprising death early on in the game is clearly intended to attach us emotionally to the character, yet it falls flat as he proceeds to blame everybody but actual killers for her death, driving a wedge between himself and the group (especially Snow) for next to no reason. He constantly moans about the group's situation, rather than embracing it and you constantly get the feeling that he simply wants to curl up in a ball and give up; hardly the most heroic of actions. Thankfully, Hope is redeemed slightly with his appearances in XIII-2 and Lightning Returns (or FFXIII-3) where he's far more mature with his high intellect helping you throughout the two sequels. Sadly, in Final Fantasy XIII, there's little of that on show. Again, Final Fantasy XIII won't be remembered fondly for its characters but Hope's constant lack of hope (intentional irony?) will have you rolling your eyes every time he's on screen.
1. Yuffie (Final Fantasy VII)
Optional characters have it tough in the world of role-playing games. Due to their optional status, they very rarely get involved in major plot events and their own storylines may be significantly worse than others in the game. Yuffie may be an optional acquisition in Final Fantasy VII and that's perhaps for the best; if you knew the trouble she was going to cause you, in hindsight, you might have turned her away. Yuffie first appears as a random encounter on the world map in a forest region (the earliest possible location is just outside Junon Harbour). After battling her, you're transported to an open field where you have to pick the correct responses to her questions in order to get her to join you. If you so much as open a menu or try to save at the nearby save point, she will rob you and leave; apparently she has little worries about making a good first impression. If you have Yuffie in the party, she'll make a few humorous appearances throughout (such as when she gets a job at a Materia store part-time, only to rob them when leaving with the party) with little to offend. Yuffie comes to the fore when the party arrives in her home nation of Wutai. Here, she leaves the party temporarily, taking the group's Materia stash with her. This leads to one of the game's most frustrating segments; with no Materia (and therefore no magic), the fights in Wutai become much tougher and it's impossible to leave without finishing the storyline, which involves chasing Yuffie all over the place. Great. For the majority of the game, Yuffie is an inoffensive yet unimportant character. She appears in several scenes and has some funny lines but apart from that, she doesn't do a lot (she doesn't even appear in the game's closing FMV). Her storyline in Wutai is a chore though and while it's optional, you'll undoubtedly find yourself stumbling upon it during your search for the Temple Of The Ancients. Here, Yuffie's annoying qualities come to light and it's hard for her to regain our trust after putting us through such a grueling, testing time. Are you a major Cait Sith fan that disagrees with this list entirely? Which characters almost killed a Final Fantasy game for you? Leave your thoughts in the comments below.