Complexity and complication are like the hilt and blade of a Hattori Hanz sword; one grants control, a sense of empowerment, and in some cases, great power. The other will cut your hands off if you're not careful. In gaming, complexity and complication get confused. Far Cry 3 is complex. Borderlands is complicated. Mass Effect 2 is complex, Final Fantasy XIII is complicated. The difference is in how game developers point the sword. If they bury the systems of a game under needless menus, or crush the narrative under poorly acted subplots and flights of fancy, the player ends up with the sharp end. If a developer is careful to deliver as much cool stuff as possible while focusing on intuitive design, the player can wields it instead. When it comes to overcomplicated gaming franchises, the sins are many and varied. A game like Assassin's Creed is needlessly complex in multiple ways - its dual narrative and complicated stealth mechanics are elements you work against, instead of with. Meanwhile a franchise like Metal Gear Solid can become so entwined in plot developments and overlong cut-scenes and a ridiculous egg metaphor, that jumping into the franchise as a new player and figuring out what's going on is nigh impossible. These complications can put off folks who may be genuinely interested in the subject matter of a given game, but confusing mechanics, overwrought back stories or needlessly clunky menu and inventory systems can make those folks think twice before plopping down their hard earned money for a title or its sequel. Thus, this list of ten gaming franchises that are mostly worthwhile but take a bit too long to fully understand, and could stand to shed a few founds pounds of baby fat if they want to stay trim into their old age.
10. Battlefield
Warfare on a massive scale sounds awesome. Well, in a video game anyway - in real life it's not so great. Actually, it's not so great in video game form either, as Battlefield's much-touted 64 person-strong multiplayer experience is equal parts confusing, disappointing, and needlessly complicated. While the single player campaigns are generally pretty good, once you hop into the meat and potatoes of any of the recent Battlefield games i.e. the multiplayer; prepare for a veritable assault of noise, colour, obtuse icons, and long, boring, walks back to wherever it was you died, so you can get killed again. When Battlefield first debuted its quality was contagious - being able to use helicopters, planes, naval cannons and other artillery added an awesome dynamic to what was previously an infantry focused genre. But as time went on and Call of Duty came out, Battlefield increased the scale and complexity of their games to the point where if you're only a casual fan of first person shooters you'll be so wildly intimidated by all the green boxes, orange triangles, beeps, buzzes, radio chirps and grenade fire you'll get PTSD just from the class and spawn point selection screen. For a specific kind of person the Battlefield franchise offers a ton of depth, nuance, and worthwhile adventure. For the rest of the world - folks who want to shoot and drive and fly and capture a control point just as bad, but don't have military experience, an NRA card or countless hours to spend acclimating themselves to the harsh realities of Battlefield's....battlefield, they'll have to be content playing arm-chair general as they watch people far better than them do the amazing things they'll never get too.
9. NBA 2k
While it's good that the dribble moves have moved to the right stick in recent entries, the control scheme for NBA 2K is still mind-meltingly complicated. There are modifiers, button combinations, roll-outs and spin moves to perform, all of which seem to require the dexterity of a classically-trained octopus pianist. This isnt necessarily a bad thing as you can play and have success without knowing the controls in and out on easy difficulties, but once you get into situations involving the low and high-posts, as well as real opponents, things become a crap-shoot as to what moves and buttons do what and where... and you'll panic. Simply put, NBA 2k is intimidating. If you're a new player entering into the 2K fold, prepare for a daunting and frustrating journey as you'll make your big men shoot threes, point guards attempt dunks, and offensive three second violations become your best friend. Unlike Madden Football or MLB: The Show, NBA basketball is a fast-paced game where you rarely get a second to think, adjust or take a breath and a wrong button press results in the other team getting the ball and easy points. As a result playing the NBA 2k series is an investment. You'll start like the fat kid in gym class who gets passed the ball and chucks up a wing and a prayer just to get rid of the thing, and by the time you've invested a few hours, you're comfortable enough to hold, dribble and move, but unless you're willing to study the controls and dig deep into tutorials and Youtube videos to experiment on your own, you'll find many of your shots blocked, jukes duped, passes intercepted and far too many things happening you don't want too - remaining unsure why. NBA 2k is one of the best series' going on consoles, and making it less complicated - while maintaining its complexity - is one of the few things Visual Concepts could do to drastically improve an already excellent - but needlessly obtuse - franchise.
8. Madden Football
It seems Madden Football was playing catchup from the word go on the PS3 and Xbox 360. Considering its lacklustre debut and bevy of strange bugs, odd offensive line A.I. and the strange way in which cool features appear and then vanish (looking at you "Weapons" system and "Madden IQ"), it's tricky for casual players to wrap their hands about Madden Football's laces every year. American Football is complicated though, so Madden should have complexity. The ability to make pre-snap reads and adjustments is a cornerstone of the experience. But outside of the excellent hot-routes system, a lot of adjustments are difficult to parse without fore-knowledge of football tactics, and the game often does a poor job of explaining them - especially on defence. Even if you get the basics, double covering a receiver in Madden requires understanding terms like "Y receiver", "Flank", "Double X", and a ton of other terminology in the play-call menu, or contending with a complicated system of button presses pre-snap that feel a bit like entering a code into Mortal Kombat; hit this button to open up coverages, then another to adjust the depth, then flick the right stick down to adjust the line, and then the ball is snapped and who knows what's going to happen. Couple the gameplay obtusity with major gameplay modes like Ultimate Team and Franchise that do a poor job laying out what specifically you're supposed to do, and it's clear Madden is a complicated mess in many areas. The most recent Franchise mode featured a strange menu system that inundates you with more sub-menus than a sandwich shop. Managing your roster involved tabbing over (and waiting for the subsequent load), finding what you wanted to do, doing it, then clicking over to another menu to progress your player in that menu's submenu, and by the time you're done doing all the tweaks and simulating the pre-season, getting into an actual game feels almost like a chore. Worse, offline Madden Franchises don't save - requiring re-doing all your hard work and re-tweaks in an already-irksome mode if you forget to hit your save button before quitting. Beyond that, Madden doesn't 'feel' right because everything is so complicated and impersonal. It's bogged down by NFL rules that limit its ability to display personality, technological problems that make "Madden Football" and "American Football" very different things when it comes to strategy, and constantly changing features and game modes that drastically alter the way you approach the game year-to-year. Madden is a popular franchise and a good game, no doubt - but it's certainly not because of its approachability.
7. Magic: The Gathering
Magic: The Gathering deserves all the credit in the world for bringing the collectible card game to the masses. Many a kid in the 1990s bounded into their local collectibles shop to purchase packs of cards that represented spells, creatures, mana, and all manner of wonderful fantasy creations. It was a massive success, not only legitimising the Collectible Card Game (CCG), but was the cornerstone for the Pokemon cards and Yu-Gi-Oh cultural takeovers as well. Magic is so popular that there are now over 15,000 cards in circulation, and getting a handle on all them - with the various play formats and card synergies - is practically impossible for the new player. Getting acclimated to MtG requires an investment and dedication that ultimately rewards you with...more confusion, an empty wallet, and possibly a headache if you want to become competitive. While the player community is helpful, most of them have been playing for years and years and can rattle off card types, expansions, and particularly deadly strategies off the top of their head while you're still busy trying to thumb through your deck for that all-accessing land card. In today's day-and-age, Magic: The Gathering is more important than it is 'good' by current tastes. With games like Hearthstone, Scrolls and Shadow Era available on multiple platforms that cut down on the number of available cards, and do a lot of the math and mechanical upkeep for the player, there isn't really much of a reason to invest in Magic:The Gathering if you're looking for a CCG fix - unless you have a thing for the classics.
6. Mario
Never has a series of awesome games been doomed by their dumb and confusing naming conventions. For a company that targets primarily kids, Nintendo has done a particularly poor job of making their various Mario games easy to discern for the parents that buy those games for their kids. New Super Mario Bros. debuted on the Nintendo DS, then its sequel New Super Mario Brothers 2 came out on the DS, too followed by New Super Mario Brothers Wii, then New Super Mario Brothers U, a title that made it seem like it would it share shelf space with edutainment games like Mario Teaches Typing. There' also Super Mario 3D Land and Super Mario 3D World - two titles pretty much any non-gaming person could easily get confused, and the Mario Kart series which recently ran out of creative names and just started using numbers - with the recently released Mario Kart 8 technically being the 11th entry in the series if you count the arcade titles. The whole thing sits funny, like a couple of aspirin on an empty stomach. With so many major Mario games being released in different genres with easy to confuse names - it's easy to blow him off entirely, which really hurts. There are so many games on so many platforms with so many similar titles that it's easy to not only confuse yourself, but really easy to confuse anyone attempting to buy a specific game for a specific person as gift, and getting the wrong Mario game entirely.
5. Dark Souls
Good news, if you have an Xbox 360 and Xbox live Gold, you're getting Dark Souls for free in June, and can try it for yourself. The bad news? Clear your schedule. The Dark Souls franchise takes great pride in its obtuse nature and ominous atmosphere, which makes first impressions prickly. The game does a decent enough job introducing you to the mechanics of combat and traversal, presents a wonderfully gothic world Tim Burton could only dream of, but never really gives the skinny on items, stats or the minutiae of the meta elements that tie it all together. Which is fine. An incredible subculture has sprung up around Dark Souls, and there's hundreds of online resources that can get you up to speed, regarding the best approach to tackling this qausi-impenetrable franchise. If you have a friend that's any of the games that's even better. A guide on your journey makes the perilous path far less fraught. But there's something endlessly irksome about having to consult literature or call a friend before you feel comfortable in your own shoes - especially in a game. Because of the Dark Souls' difficult nature, its easy to feel like you're constantly doing something wrong when you can't kill a certain character, or keep dying and needing to retrace your steps for the fifteenth time. Consulting the wiki to see what other people have done makes it easier to progress, but makes you want to play less, it's like reading a history book and constantly needing to flip back to the glossary - it takes out you out the experience. Which is a shame because the combat and contending with your environment leads to a satisfying gameplay loop that's intensely difficult but in a logical and fair way. You'll never say "The computer cheats" when playing Dark Souls. If the game was exclusively just combat and didn't throw dozens of stats and nebulously defined items at you it'd be far more approachable. Beating up a group of six bad guys with barely a sliver of health left is incredibly satisfying and doesn't need the tonnage of stats and weird items with unknown properties to make it good. The Dark Souls games are a marathon in the Mojave, made for the hardest of hardcore. If you're the kind of player who likes challenge in all its forms, fiddling with stat bonus, equipment, managing resources, and truly pouring yourself into a game that gives out as much as you put in, these games are near classics. But for players who are curious what the fuss is about, expect to be frustrated. While you can make your way through the game with no help at all, the omnipresent vibe that you're screwing it all up creates the not-good-kind of gameplay stress. If there was a Dark Souls: Mystic Quest, where the items were less obtuse, the stats more streamlined, and the gameplay just as brutal, 'regular' gamers would eat it up and not even chew - while hardcore gamers across the world foam at the mouth - no doubt taking to twitter to complain about the game losing its guillotine 'edge'.
4. Resident Evil
Putting aside the legendarily complicated control scheme for a second, for all the hammy acting and silly conspiracy theories at one point it was pretty easy to take Resident Evil (and more specifically its first sequel) seriously. The game oozed atmosphere and was to horror games what Terminator 2 was to action movies; trendsetting and bar-raising. But also like the Terminator, the 3rd entry in the series felt a little weak. Some of the spark was gone - it went from two discs to one, we no longer had Leon or Claire, and while good, the magic felt missing. From there the franchise began to fracture, with Code Veronica, Code Verionica X, Resident Evil 0, The Resident Evil remake on Gamecube, Game Boy editions... suddenly trying to keep track of the plight of the Umbrella Corporation and the folks attempting to unravel the conspiracy became a brain-mangling exercise. Eventually Resident Evil 4 released and was a wonderful breath of fresh air, defining the third person shooter in a way gamers hadn't seen before, delivering the atmosphere, terror, and unsettling adventures and scares we loved from the series. And then Resident Evil 5 was set in Africa and decided to deliver a control scheme that...was simply awful, then Resident Evil 6...happened, and it seemed the franchise simply lost whatever creative juices it had. Fast. See, Resident Evil was always good despite itself. The tank-like control scheme was always a pain in the rear, as was inventory management - the games were complicated, but we didn't care because the stuff surrounding those awkward controls was so entertaining. Once that entertainment factor dissipated into a awkward series of narrative events with no real drive behind them, we were left with just the tropes of a Resident Evil game without any of the flair, the complicated and off-putting nature of the franchise became the only thing we knew about it.
3. Assassin's Creed
Assassin's Creed is one of the most polarizing games in recent history. It's beautifully rendered, with flowing animations and a painstaking attention to detail when creating the atmosphere and majesty of its various historical settings. The cut-scenes are wonderfully acted and filled with non-verbal nuance from raised eyebrows to tapping fingers and scowled brows. There are very few games as visually impressive as Assassin's Creed. But it gets into trouble when it comes to the actual game part. Assassin's Creed is a complicated game because it's asking you to accept quite a lot conflicting animation when it comes to interacting and immersing yourself in the game's narrative and mechanics. Let's start with the over-arching narrative. The story of Desmond Miles is a confusing one - featuring secret societies, ancient quasi-alien beings, a rag-tag group of super geniuses and futuristic non-existent technology that allows you to jump into the memories of your ancestors so you can have fun historical adventures...erm, we mean, gain important information that will decide the fate of the universe. With Assassin's Creed IV it seemed like that particular series of events would be pushed to the back-burner and allow new and old players to start fresh, but no. Instead, while Desmond is no longer featured in the game there's a first person, unnamed character who interacts with the previous modern-day Assassins from previous games. This makes Assassin's Creed a phenomenally complicated franchise to dive into if you want to care about the entirety of the plot, and makes the actual main part of the game - the whole action-adventure-stealth thing, feel like a chore to the characters in the present day narrative, especially since in-game the historical events have already happened and would be common knowledge to the people running the animus. Assassin's Creed ALSO suffers from enough gameplay complications to be sent directly to the city morgue. From stealth mechanics that don't feature a stealth button, to strange tailing missions that require you to stay inside a certain radius of your target while not being spotted, to the strange way your character is supposed to be a hero (but is constantly required to kill and maim and brutally murder quite a lot of dudes in the name of 'freedom') Assassin's Creed constantly feels like its at war with the player. The side-content also feels strange and disconnected and overly robust for what the games are trying to accomplish. AC: Brotherhood featured mini-game where you'd be training other Assassins and sending them on missions, part three featured building up your massively grand 'homestead' whilst also somehow being portrayed as an underdog Native American, and while the text-based goods trading caravan mini-game from Assassin's Creed III is so boring and bizarre that you'll just stare at the screen and get horrible flashbacks to Zork. Having all this side content creates a strange experience where you're not sure what to do, and what's worth doing, and generates some confusion about where exactly all the Assassins' resources are coming from - it ruins the game's internal logic and leads the player to having complicated thoughts about plot-holes, how the world you're inhabiting works, and it's why the game just doesn't sit 100 percent right with most gamers.
2. Metal Gear Solid
If you bought an Xbox 360 instead of a PS3, you lucked out in that you didn't need to see Metal Gear Solid temporarily jump the shark. Guys, lets face it, Metal Gear Solid 4 is a mess. It exists in a reality very few people can relate too, features a complicated and overlong plot about various AI systems that control the world, has a soda-pop drinking monkey and a supporting character with irritable bowel system. To call Metal Gear Solid 4 tonally uneven is like calling Yokozuna 'a little chunky'. Metal Gear Solid IV also had the problem of attempting to tie up all the loose ends from Metal Gear Solid 2 and 3, putting a supposed end-cap on the franchise and trying to leave fans satisfied. And in a way it did. For fans who followed the franchise from Metal Gear Solid's Alaskan base to Metal Gear Solid 2's big shell and Metal Gear Solid 3's Russian jungle (there are no jungles in Russia), Metal Gear Solid 4 was a conclusion that made a point to pay off all the loose threads the previous games left dangling, but at the expense of pacing, accessibility, and plot cohesion. Lets also remind ourselves that Metal Gear Solid was a franchise that started out as a decently grounded in reality sci-fi military espionage tale - sort of like a more serious take on the stuff in the James Bond flick Moonraker. Yes there were fantastical elements like psychics and keys you had to melt in order to fit into certain locks, but largely the first Metal Gear Solid was restrained enough to be somewhat believable and allow players to meditate on its themes. The franchise then went on to include a roller-skating bomber, Liquid-Ocelot (the result of Ocelot replacing his severed hand with Liquid Snake's) which in-turn allowed Liquid's spirit to posses him, an incredibly expensive conspiracy designed to recreate the events of Metal Gear Solid, a group of all-seeing 'Patriots' who controlled how the world worked...despite being dead for years, really gross, sexually-offensive boss battles that resulted in enemies springing from their mechanical bodies in their underwear and being shot multiple times until they died 'for real', and, oh yeah - a little girl trying really hard to make good eggs. Metal Gear Solid is the definition of overcomplicated. It is impenetrable and confusing and so tied up in its own continuity it never stops to catch people up in a way that isn't ham-handed, awkward, or an exposition dump. There's also the question of how seriously the game wants players to take it. In Peace Walker you gained the ability to literally balloon people out of the Cuba via the Fulton Recovery System - and its a huge part of the game. But when it would have come in handy in the most recent Ground Zeroes game it's no where to be found. Ultimately Metal Gear Solid is a series where you need to start at the beginning or find yourself confused and disinterested in a story that was once the shining example of cinematic storytelling, but is now it's an utter mess.
1. Final Fantasy
It's probably a bad sign when the most culturally relevant element of your franchise is a movie that bombed. Yes, it's true, Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within seemed to predict Frakking (or the act of creating man-made earthquakes to release natural gas from the planet) and how it could possibly ruin our world. But beyond that, Final Fantasy seems to be in a bit of a lull, save for the recent Final Fantasy XIV trailer at least year's E3. See, Final Fantasy suffers from the quadruple crown of over-complication. Multiple games with confusing titles across several platforms? Check. Multiple games in the same universe across multiple platforms and media? Check. Occasional forays into strange mechanics and hard to relate characters? Check. Using the war chest of nostalgia the franchise has created to release cheap cash-ins that cost too much money? You bet your Chocobo. Because the Final Fantasy franchise has been around since the dawn of the NES, it's changed, grown and mutated. It's released great games, bad games, strange games, engaged in strange dalliances with pay-to-win iOS games, there's the brutally uninviting entirety of Final Fantasy XIII, two MMOs (one of which required a reboot after being so terrible), the fact the sequel to the much beloved "Final Fantasy Tactics" was a Gameboy Advance game with a bare-bones plot similar to The Neverending Story, and the less said about Ehrgeiz and Mystic Quest, the better. There's also the Crystal Chronicles series - the much touted return of the franchise to Nintendo consoles....which pretty much demanded you have a Game Boy Advance or two, a link cable (or two) and a Gamecube. The thing about Final Fantasy is that it's such a massive franchise with such massive appeal and money-making potential it's easy to exploit the brand and its fans for everything they're worth until no one cares. Being a Final Fantasy fan, let alone completest, is far more complicated than it should be. Take for example Final Fantasy VII - the most beloved of the Final Fantasy titles. Fans clamored for a sequel or remake to the game - frothing at the mouth for more Cloud, Barrett, and Tifa. And they got it. On cell phones. The first true 'sequel' to Final Fantasy VII was a mobile game before that was a 'thing'. The second? A shooter staring Vincent. The third? An action RPG game on the PSP, which 15 people on the entire planet owned. Beyond that there's been a DVD movie and more slash fiction than those Guns n' Roses rumours you keep hearing about. The above problems are less irksome with Final Fantasy X's and XIII's sequels, but the idea of releasing a sequel to a game that's wildly different in tone and style and appeal creates a situation where players are buying games based on the brand and not on whether or not the game being released is something they'd like to play. Thus when it comes to over-complication, extreme over-complication, Final Fantasy deserves all the finger-points of judgement it can get. Players don't want more Final Fantasy, they want good Final Fantasy. They want relatable characters and quality stories. Interesting battle mechanics and the whimsical distractions like Chocobo breeding and the smile-inducing Golden Saucer date sequence from Final Fantasy VII. Instead, it seems Square Enix isn't quite sure what it's doing with the franchise, other than milking it dry in ways that are confusing, complicated, and make very little sense. Though thankfully someone has had the presence of mind to never, ever, EVER copy the weapon system from Final Fantasy VIII, and that remains appreciated. Which games have buried themselves alive under a mountain of plot threads and contrivances? Let us know in the comments!