Originality versus Repetition is a debate that branches across all forms of media: is it better to watch a film which is original in its premise and ideas or a film that is a multiple sequel but that we'll watch it because 'we're used to it'? Should we listen to music that tries to be innovative and genre-breaking or should we listen to the usual cheesy music that fills up the charts because it is deemed popular? And of course, the same applies to games: is it more fun to play an original game like Ico or play the next Call of Duty or Resident Evil? The gaming industry (like the film industry) currently has a pretty bad case of sequelitus: try and think about some of the games you're interesting in buying between now and Christmas, and I'd bet that 90% of those games are sequels or re-launches. The question is, are sequels necessarily always a bad thing? The answer is fairly simple: not really. Sequels usually represent what was or what has been popular, so it is simply the easier option for a publisher to release an updated version of the previous game rather than potentially lose millions on a new idea. However, during this generation multiple sequels have attracted much-deserved criticism, because certain publishers have realised that they can rather lazily release a sequel without changing or adding much compared with the previous game. This hasn't always been the case though, as this article will hopefully point out. Personally, I've always enjoyed original games and quickly get bored of sequels that fail to innovate or repeat the process over a couple of games. For me, it is always a calculated risk to bring out a new non-sequel game as they can either fail miserably like Lair (even though it was a good ideas) or greatly influence the games industry like Heavy Rain. However, I do enjoy sequels - in fact, some of my favourite games are sequels and this list is meant to show how good some sequels can be. Of course, games can quickly innovate themselves with changes of technology whilst films and music are very much restricted to set formats and genres. Games therefore have an advantage as a form of media: characters such as Mario can survive for almost thirty years and whilst the type of gamplay has remained the same the way we play the game has changed substantially. Saying all of this; there are a fair amount of sequels that have become legendary and have greatly influenced the video game industry, perhaps more so than most original games. Here are ten such examples of sequels proving that originality isn't always necessary. There will also be some honorable mentions and some lessons to be learned along the way. One or two rules for this list: the franchises still have to be running today on current generation consoles but the sequels mentioned don't. Let's get to it...
10. Gran Turismo 3: A-Spec
The Gran Turismo series may have gone a little stale since the convoluted release of Gran Turismo 5, but it is a truly brilliant franchise that has managed to sell millions of copies of each game despite making minimum changes over the last fourteen years. Developers Polyphony Digital will probably have to alter certain aspects of the core basis of the franchise for the next entry in the series due to criticism of Gran Turismo 5 but they have shown the gaming world that you do not necessarily have to constantly re-brand the racing genre like Test Drive, Need For Speed and the Grid/TOCA series' have attempted to do. Polyphony have always gone for the approach that 'bigger and beautiful means better' and this was certainly the case with Gran Turismo 3. The game boasted ground-breaking graphics which came to typify the PS2 and rival consoles despite the fact that GT3 was released only a year into the PS2's lifespan. There was also a new physics engine which meant the series was truly worth of their self-proclaimed tag as 'The real Driving Simulator' . The game may have had less cars than its predecessor but these were minor criticisms as the game had an almost endless supply of content. The fact that the game is the second best-selling PS2 and received full-marks from most reviewers at the time is testament to how great this sequel truly was. What can be learned: Content and great graphics can make or break a sequel. Honourable Mention: Gran Turismo 4 As great as Gran Turismo 4 was, it perhaps didn't have the immediate effect of GT3. It was also the first example of people becoming rather tired of Gran Turismo's flaws and outdated games mechanics such as the lack of vehicle damage.
9. Final Fantasy VIII
I've never been the greatest fan of the Final Fantasy franchise which may account for VIII's fairly low entry on this list. In fact, I downright hated most RPGs until the PS3 release of Oblivion in 2007, even today I find J-RPGs extremely difficult to play. However, my own personal feelings towards the genre can not discount for the great sequel that Final Fantasy VIII is. For me, despite my feelings against the genre, it went against the grain. I never owned the game - in fact, I never even wished to own the game - but the two months or so that I played it certainly opened my eyes to new gaming genres. There was something special about Final Fantasy VIII, and most people who played the game would probably suggest the same. For me, it was the graphics: there comes a point, usually towards the end of a console's life that you realise that said console's capabilities have peaked, and in the case of the original Playstation this peak came with Final Fantasy VIII. Even if you played the game and didn't enjoy it, there is no denying that the graphics were absolutely stunning and were certainly a clue to the wonders we may see on the Playstation 2. I had played Final Fantasy VII and thought that the graphics weren't all that great and I wasn't a fan of the story or the game-play, but with VIII, I was majorly impressed with the graphics and I actually enjoyed the story; it is the first game I can remember playing, which took its time with the story and didn't rush to get the player engaged. In many ways I found Final Fantasy VIII to be like an epic film such as Lord of the Rings; in many ways it was with the game's four disks and fifty-hour length story. I can't even remember if I got off the first disk but that was rather unimportant. Finally, let's not forget that we are talking about the 8th main entry in a series of games that were already critically acclaimed, and the very fact that Squaresoft followed up Final Fantasy VII with this beast of a game surely means that it deserves a place on this list. What can be learned: If your previous game is excellent, make sure to make the most of the consoles capabilities to better it. Honourable Mention: Final FantasyVII I realise that this is going to split Final Fantasy fans down the middle. I understand that VII was an influential game but for me it didn't utilize its equipment as was as its sequel and therefore wasn't as visually impressive. IX was pretty impressive too.
8. FIFA 13
I know, I know it's not really a sequel in the traditional sense but FIFA has become a great example of a game series that doesn't have to change too much to be able to sell copies and gain critical respect. The FIFA franchise is a phenomenon in its own right. In many ways, they are a love-hate game for hardcore gamers; on the one hand we say that games need development time and shouldn't be released every year but on the other we pick up yearly versions of FIFA to satisfy our footballing needs. We just have to look at the sales figures, critical success and the response on WhatCulture! in the last month to acknowledge that EA still release brilliant sequels for their football games. FIFA hasn't always had such an easy ride though; throughout the mid-2000s they had intense competition from rivals such as Pro Evolution Soccer as their dominance over the sports genre was questioned. Fifa always had a big advantage of their rivals though due to their use of exclusive licensing, which now includes up to 30 of the world's football leagues. EA's constant tweaking of the series combined with great original features has seen FIFA once again hold a dominance over the football genre. There has been a FIFA game released every year since 1993, some years there are even more than one. They continue to sell and continue to innovate as well change the way we play football games thereby making them a leading example in the sport-genre. There really isn't much more to say about this entry than that. What can be learned: Make sure you're able to capture your niche market and kill off all opposition if you're going to repetitive release similar games each year. Honourable Mention: Madden (any) Personally I've never been as a big fan of the Madden Series, they are usually very confusing for non-American Football fans. This is not to say they are bad games though, they've sold slightly fewer copies than FIFA but have a similar level of critical success.
7. Uncharted 2
The most impressive aspect Naughty Dog's Uncharted 2 is that it doesn't really do anything new and nor does it even try to. The shooting mechanics are bundled together from loads of other third-person-shooters, the cut-scenes have a hint of Metal Gear Solid to them and the story could be straight out of an Indiana Jones film. What Uncharted 2 manages to do is bring together all of these elements and create a game that is not only exciting and brilliant but also far surpassed the first game in the series. Uncharted 2 isn't an industry innovator but it shows what can be done when a developer brings together all the right aspects of gaming. Uncharted 2 is a beautiful game to look at but that doesn't necessarily mean that it is going to be a good game, what makes it a good game is the characters, the story, the subtle use of humour and the fact that the game is a joy to play. Granted, most of these features were present whilst playing the first game but Uncharted 2 manages to take the series to a new level which was then replicated (but not quite beaten) with it's successor, Uncharted 3. Basically, Uncharted was a good game that made a decent platform; Uncharted 2 is the game that turned the series into one of the most acclaimed franchises of modern time and also gave Sony a new icon. If Uncharted 2 was a movie it would be a multi-million blockbuster in the same vein as The Dark Knight Rises, indeed the game manages a level of professionalism that is rarely seen in games. Reviewers at the time said that the game had the same appeal as a Hollywood film but obviously had an advantage as the consumer could interact with what was going on the screen. The fact that Naughty Dog were able to create a game that not only blurred the medias of film and game but was also incredibly fun to play is evidence enough that it should be on this list. What can be learned: If use aspects from other games, make sure you're able to better them. Honourable Mention: God of War 2 Similar in many ways as it launched a new icon and franchise for Sony. It practically re-launched the hack 'n' slash genre but just misses out on Uncharted 2 due to the fact that it wasn't so much of a surprise hit.
6. Resident Evil 2
Few franchises have made such an impact on the video-game genre in the last sixteen years than Resident Evil: the game practically popularized the survival horror genre and has been a constant innovator of the industry. Resident Evil is also fairly unique as it has made a successful jump onto the big screen - I haven't personally been too impressed with the films, but they are certainly a popular money-spinner. Sadly, the latest games in the franchise have taken a similar vein to the films, with little or no innovation but plenty of mainstream success, but the current state of the Resident Evil franchise should not diminish the achievements or success that the games enjoyed up until a couple of years ago. The second game in the series is widely seen as one of the best. It is from this game that we get most of the images we associate with the Resident Evil franchise; the licker, a city full of zombies, the police station and two of the franchise's best characters - Ada Wong and Leon Kennedy. Resident Evil 2 does the classic sequel routine by replicating the original game but also making the game larger, more full of life and on a bigger scope. In other words, Resident Evil 2 didn't do anything fancy; it polished up and expanded the story from the first game and brought a level of story-telling that was missing from the first game as well as most games at the time. The fact that there was the choice of two characters with their own branching story-lines was an attractive feature but more so was the feeling that the player felt genuinely trapped in Raccoon City just as they had done in the Spencer Mansion from the first game. In 1996, Capcom had released a good but slightly short horror game. By 1998, they had evolved this monster into Resident Evil 2 which had a better story, better characters, better scares...The fact that Capcom keep trying to bring us back to high points of Resident Evil 2 with the most recent games is all the evidence that is needed to prove that this is one of the best sequels ever. What can be learned: Don't go out of your way to please the mainstream audience, especially when the game is already fairly popular. Honourable Mention: Resident Evil 4 Resident Evil 4 is one of my favourite games ever, I enjoy it more than all of the Resident Evil games but is it a good sequel? It re-launched the series but at the same time, a little bit of the original franchise died... and it's only gone downhill from there.
5. Super Mario 64
It may be a shock to some inexperienced gamers out there, but there was a time that Mario was a side-scrolling 2D platform game. Yes, everyone's favourite plummer could only be viewed in two dimensions until the release of Super Mario 64 in June 1996. To gamers today this may not seem like too much of a big deal, after all almost every platformer today has 3D graphics with a dynamic camera but back in 1996, Super Mario 64 completely revolutionized the platform genre and the games industry with these features. Super Mario 64 was not the first 3D game as it sometimes claimed to be: both the action-adventure and First-Person Shooter were already popularizing the use of 3D polygons, however Mario 64 was the first platform game to use the technology successfully. Both Sony and Sega attempted to make 3D platformers with mixed success: Sega's Sonic X-Treme was cancelled and contributed to the company's eventual fall from grace whilst Sony's Crash Bandicoot helped them to launch a new icon. Even compared with the success of Crash Bandicoot, Mario 64 was on a completely different level. More importantly, Nintendo were not afraid to show their superiority as demonstrated with the opening screen, which allowed players to interact with Mario's newly rendered 3D features. Super Mario 64 also had a brilliant variety of missions in a world that seemed endless and was filled with atmosphere which far surpassed all of its rivals but overall there is something extremely satisfying in seeing all of Mario's friends and enemies rendered in beautiful 3D graphics. Platform games have never been the same since... What can learned: Continuing to innovate is key if the franchise is to continue over generations of consoles. Honourable Mention: Mario Kart (any) The Mario Kart games are extremely addictive but have done little to change or innovate the industry, they have continued to remain successful without really testing the patience of gamers or the power or Nintendo's console.
4. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
'What?' I hear you say. 'Call of Duty being mentioned on an article about how originality isn't necessary?!' Don't worry, I haven't gone completely mad - as some of you may have realised by now, there is a method and logic to this madness. Most of the sequels mentioned here are good because they were released before a franchise got stuck in a mold and became boring - Resident Evil is one such example, the series became stale after Code Veronica X and seems to be going stale again despite a very successful re-launch with Resident Evil 4 seven years ago. Perhaps, the best (or maybe worst) example of sequelitus staleness is the Call of Duty franchise, however there was a time just prior to the release of Modern Warfare 2 when Call Of Duty could still be classed as a cool innovator. Lets be honest here, when Call of Duty 4 was released back in 2007 the game revolutionised the gaming industry and first-person shooters, and it is difficult to think of a modern game that has had such an impact. The fact that the game was universally acclaimed by both the general public and the critics proved how it took the video game industry by storm, especially when we compared it with current reputation of the franchise. Call of Duty 4 also literally popularised online gaming for consoles: sure, there were some pockets of gamers playing online - I loved Resistance: Fall of Man for example - but n0-one expected the level of depth and addictive content that Call of Duty 4 brought. It wasn't just the online that made it special though; it was the balls-out story, the cinematic pieces and the re-imagining of Call of Duty by setting it within a modern conflict rather than World War 2. The series has admittedly gone very stale over the last few years but it is still the best-selling franchise around at the moment and this is purely due to Call of Duty 4. Call of Duty 4 set an example within the industry, which other developer have copied and followed. Whether good or bad, the influence of Call of Duty 4 is undeniable. What can be learned: Changing the franchise can be good as long as you don't once again get bogged down in repetitive content. Honourable Mention: Assassin's Creed 2 Sticking with the current generation: Assassin's Creed was a good but ultimately flawed game; Assassin's Creed 2 changed the game from flawed genius into the brilliant franchise the series has become.
3. Metal Gear Solid 4
Metal Gear Solid 4 is one of those games that makes you take a deep breath after playing it: you begin to wonder if a game could achieve much more and you think back on all of the amazing scenes you've played through as well as the emotional roller-coaster that you are unlikely to go through again. It is one of those games that confirms that video-gaming is an art and prove that they can be just as engaging as any big cinema release. Basically, Metal Gear Solid 4 is a once in a life-time experience. Sure, other games in the series were arguably more innovative such as the utilization of First-Person controls in MGS 2 but the other games in the series had their fair share of problems. For example, the story on MGS 2 almost derailed the series and the fan-base was split down the middle by the appearance of Raiden. However, this is not to say that Metal Gear Solid 4 lacked original scenarios for the series, the whole of the first two chapters are like nothing seen in the previous games. By far the most impressive aspect of Metal Gear Solid 4 though is the game's use of story-telling and character progression. There are some obvious references to previous games but they are cleverly done so the game doesn't become a parody. Throughout the whole game we can feel attached to the characters in a way that is rarely conveyed in Video Games; we wonder what will happen to Snake, will Otagon ever grow out of being a geek and will Liquid ever be defeated? The game brings together elements of the series together in such a fashion that it is sometimes easy to forget about its other impressive feats such as the ground-breaking graphics that still look perfect today. Metal Gear Solid 4 does precisely what a sequel is meant to do, tying up the loose ends, giving the better a better playing experience than the previous games and also remaining innovative. Saying all of this, Metal Gear Solid 4 still does not eclipse the impact of the first game, even despite the return to Shadow Moses. What Can be learned: Make your sequel tie up any loose ends in the story, even if previous games have made the story somewhat confusing.Honourable Mention: Metal Gear Solid 2 As previously mentioned, MGS 2 was arguably the most innovative game in the series but the confusing story and the decision to cut Snake from the majority of the game almost derailed the series.
2. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City
To this day, I think most of us have fond memories of the anticipation for the release of Rockstar's GTA: Vice City - it was the first game I was truly excited for, and I followed news and rumours about the game in tidbits from any other source of information I could find. Gaming would never be the same again: it lost some of its innocence but it also lost some of its elements of secrecy - before, Vice City I didn't care about release dates or rumours, I just cared about the game once it was in my hands but this all changed after the game's release. But what exactly made the game so good? The Grand Theft Auto series had already made a successful jump onto PS2 and into 3D Graphics with the release of Grand Theft Auto III in 2001. GTA III had already made a massive impact upon the gaming industry, but it was missing some key components; for example III didn't have a cohesive story that the player could get involved in due to the mysterious nature of main-character Claude. GTA III also had fairly low quality graphics for the time and a troublesome lighting engine that made Liberty City appear too dark and dingy for its own good. Rockstar not only took these criticisms on board but also improved the general game-play and usability for GTA: Vice City. Unlike many of the games on this list Vice City was not particularly revolutionary, the ground-work had already been done but it should be seen as a great sequel as it bettered an already excellent game. I'm sure of us still have fond memories of taking over the Diaz Mansion, acquiring property, completing side missions, spotting the pop-culture references, jumping over the river on a motorbike and thousands of other activities that took place in Vice City. It is truly one of the memorable games ever and even more importantly, it is a game that one can find very few faults in. What can be learned: If a previous sequel has broken new ground, make sure you better it within a short space of time. Honourable Mention: Grand Theft Auto III I think this another one that will split fans down the middle. GTA III was a brilliant game in itself but the fact that it was beaten by at least two of its sequels has shown how talented Rockstar are as developers.
1. Half-Life 2
In 1998, a newly formed games developer called Valve released a game that would not only set an industry standard for First-Person-Shooters, but also for the whole gaming industry. This game was Half-Life. The game introduced a level of detail and personal involvement that had never been seen in games before, but most surprisingly they achieved these heights by using a character that didn't speak. Half-Life also didn't use cut-scenes like other games, which made its deep story-telling and level of character engagement all the more extraordinary. The game is still fun to play and the only 'dated' feeling to the package are the fourteen-year-old graphics. In 2004, Valve decided to release Half-Life 2, the much anticipated sequel to their 1998 classic. Could it really be any better? Of course it could. Valve went back to their roots, built the new Source engine and made full potential of Havok Physics. The combination of this new technology enabled Valve to make a game that looked stunning compared with the top-selling games of 2004 and gave us a glimpse of what future gaming was going to look like. The graphics on Half-Life 2 were so outstanding that it was only 2-3 years ago that console games began to just as impressive and many games still struggle to look as good. Half-Life 2 was far more than a pretty face though: it had attitude and it had balls; it took you on an adventure that far surpassed the first game and most games that are released today. It had a story that was full of emotion but was also full of action and variety. One of the most impressive aspects of the game sees the player wield a gravity gun which can be used to pick up almost every piece of furniture, object or device and turn it into a weapon; an idea so original that it is sometimes fun just to see what exactly can be picked up and used. Finally, Half-Life 2 is impressive because it shows what exactly can be achieved when a developer takes their time. This brings us nicely back to the original point of this article: sequels can be innovate, they can be original and they don't have to be rushed out every year to be considered good or to sell a lot of copies. Half-Life 2 took six years to make, but it made far more an impact upon the industry than this year's Call of Duty probably will. What can be learned: It is sometimes best to take your time and develop an outstanding game rather than an average one (hopefully not too long though; after all, it's been eight years since HL2) Honourable Mention: Portal 2 Another game built off the Source engine and has great connections with Half-Life. The original game was a fairly short experiment by Valve but it proved so successful that it boasted an excellent sequel with a fully-fledged story and more intelligent puzzles. What do you think gaming fans? Are there other sequels that prove originality isn't necessary? Share your own choices below... Please feel free to comment below...