10 Garbage Games Everybody Bought Anyway
It's hard to believe people lined up across the streets to buy this trash.
If there were any justice in the world, gems like System Shock 2, Grim Fandango, Okami, and the recent Alan Wake 2 would've made a killing in sales. After all, critical success should go hand in hand with commercial success.
But not only do masterpieces like these fail to get the attention they deserve time and time again, there are a plethora of games that make bank, despite being absolutely garbage.
It's difficult to believe customers will spend £50 or more on pure tripe, especially when there were obvious signs it was going to bomb. If the project suffered multiple delays, the promotions looked poor, and the embargoes weren't lifted until the eleventh hour, it's sensible to wait until the reviews are out before forking over some hard-earned cash.
Of course, there are times when the gaming community came to their senses in the nick of time. Even though Skull & Bones and Mortal Kombat 1 generated buzz, bad word-of-mouth caused the public to put away their wallets, which led to both properties tanking.
However, there were times when the hype was overwhelming, causing consumers to buy certain games in droves, regardless of their quality, or lack of.
10. Ryse: Son Of Rome
Serving as a Xbox One launch title, Ryse: Son Of Rome looked like it had potential. With its remarkable visuals, high production value, emotional depth, and powerful soundtrack, Crytek's hack-and-slash seemed destined to become the next big thing.
Despite showcasing the Xbox One's power, Son of Rome was all show and no go. Based on the insultingly brief story mode, simplistic narrative, the disruptive QTEs, and uneven combat system, this hunk of junk left a lot to be desired. The multiplayer option was so lacking of anything distinctive or imaginative, it's a wonder why the developers bothered with it in the first place.
Also, Microsoft knew they had a misfire on their hands since they were caught paying Machinima Inc. to give Son of Rome a glowing review. (That's pretty embarrassing.)
With all that said, people still bought it. Although Crytek CEO, Cevat Yerli, deemed the Ancient Roman epic an epic failure, Ryse was purchased or downloaded over a million times, making it a best-seller. It didn't make a major impression with critics but there's no question Son of Rome Rysed (sorry) to top in terms of sales.
9. Frogger
There are certain video games that don't need to be remade, regardless of their popularity and influence. Although Frogger dominated the arcade back in the early 1980s, its rudimentary gameplay was unlikely to entertain the masses in the '90s, especially when consoles had made the transition to 3D.
Nevertheless, Hasbro thought this was the perfect time to remake the traffic-hopping title for the PC and the PSOne. Even though the graphics were spruced up, the revamped Frogger was a disaster. Due to the extreme difficulty curve and unreasonable time restraints, players are required to memorise every vehicle's movement to survive, which is tedious and exhausting, especially with the shoddy controls.
But thanks to the nostalgic factor, Frogger managed to sell over three million copies on the PlayStation, and four million over all.
However, sentimentality wasn't the only factor that affected Frogger's sales. Several months after the atrocious reboot's debuted, Seinfeld released an episode called The Frogger, which centred around the classic arcade game. Being the biggest tv sitcom at the time, it's not hard to believe Seinfeld had an impact on Frogger's sales, especially since Hasbro increased production of the game just before the episode aired.
8. Shadow The Hedgehog
Envisioned as a one-off character in Sonic Adventure 2, Shadow the Hedgehog proved hugely popular, inspiring SEGA to launch a spin-off.
Though 2005's Shadow the Hedgehog featured Sonic staples like ring-collecting and high-speed gameplay, it felt disconnected to its predecessors, due to its mature themes and dark tone. Rather than focusing on bashing Badniks and performing loopdeloops, the broody antihero sprays enemies with bullets while riding his motorcycle.
Even if Shadow the Hedgehog was disassociated with Sonic completely, it wasn't good in its own right thanks to its awful camera, laughable performances, and clunky controls. Also, Shadow's homing attack proves so unreliable, there's a solid chance he'll careen to his death when he uses it. Although the guns were a selling point, they're annoying to use, due to the sporadic auto-aim and non-existent target lock.
Thanks to its abundance of flaws, Shadow the Hedgehog was the worst-rated mainstream entry in the series (before Sonic '06 nabbed the crown for good).
But at the end of the day, the fanbase love the character, which allowed Shadow the Hedgehog to sell over two million copies, making it among the most successful Sonic games. Shadow the Hedgehog might've been dubbed a failure, but the numbers suggest otherwise.
7. Resident Evil 6
Although Resident Evil has had its ups and downs, all of the mainstream entries have been a critical success. With the exception of RE6.
Even though the survival horror was toned down in the last two games, Resident Evil 6 eroded those elements completely. Worse still, it double-downed on the franchise's recurring flaws, including one-dimensional characters and cheesy dialogue.
Also, there's such a glut of tasteless action, bombastic chases, and needlessly elaborate battles, it has little resemblance to its predecessors. This decision could've been somewhat forgiven if the action was innovative. However, many of these sequences involve uncreative button-mashing and Quick-Time Events, which quickly becomes repetitive and tedious.
Resident Evil 6 was expected to move seven million copies, but couldn't break five million by the end of its fiscal year, branding this undead dud as a flop.
At least, at the time. However, the sales kept coming in at steady pace, allowing this trash to climb to eight million copies within a year. Thanks to re-releases over the last decade, RE6 has now sold nine million units, making it more successful than both versions of RE4, which is considered the crown-jewel of Capcom's zombie saga.
It may be the bottom of the flesh-eating barrel, but that didn't stop Resident Evil 6 from raking it in.
6. Wii Play
Anyone with a pair of eyes could see the Wii didn't have the graphical or computational power of its competitors.
Despite this drawback, the Nintendo system was astoundingly profitable, due to its revolutionary motion controls. The system's launch title, Wii Sports, was regularly used to advertise the technology's mechanics, accessibility, and precision. Wii Sports was so well-received, it became the Wii's #1 best-seller.
Since Wii Play was released around the same time and had similar gameplay, Wii owners flocked to purchase it, assuming they'd have the same experience.
Oh, how wrong they were. Wii Play had potential since it contained nine mini-games, including laser hockey, billiards, fishing, and a Duck Hunt-inspired shooting range. Unfortunately, each mini-game was let down by bland gameplay. Due to the lack of variety, players had little incentive to revisit this underwhelming collection after a single playthrough.
Having said all that, Wii Play was still an absolute triumph. Not only was it released around Christmas, it was packaged with a free Wii Remote. Who could say no to that?
Wii Play ultimately went on to sell 28 million copies, outperforming Nintendo's biggest heavy-hitters, including both Mario Galaxies, both Legend of Zeldas, and Super Smash Bros. Brawl.
5. Enter The Matrix
The Matrix Reloaded and The Matrix Revolutions were a textbook example of aggressive advertising. Arguably the most hyped movies of 2003, the studio hoped to fill up their accounts by churning out an animated spin-off, limited merchandise, and absurdly expensive tie-in phones.
On top of that, a Matrix video game was released the same day as The Matrix Reloaded called Enter the Matrix, which coincided with events in the sequel.
Not only did Shiny Entertainment's gun-fu title offer all the slo-mo kickass action everyone expected, it expanded on the lore and offered live-action cut-scenes that included central cast members. As a result, some Matrix veterans felt obligated to buy Enter the Matrix, hoping to get a better grasp of the overarching narrative.
Despite selling five million units, the reviews were far from generous. The bugs were so rampant, the developers could've almost gotten away with claiming they were intentional glitches in the Matrix.
The bullet-time effects are cool, but the action and combat were compromised by the janky controls. There are also moments where our bland heroes suddenly cut from one section to another, almost like an entire level was removed. In moments like this, it feels like the production was rushed to ensure Enter the Matrix hit its tight deadline.
Also, the plot adds nothing of substance to the big picture, so Enter the Matrix feels like it exists solely to squeeze cash out of consumers. Based on its remarkable sales, it achieved just that.
4. Nintendo Switch Sports
After Wii Sports sold 80+ million copies, Nintendo was obligated to launch a bunch of follow-ups. And when the Switch became the company's biggest console, a direct sequel called Nintendo Switch Sports was greenlit.
To make sure the project was done right, Nintendo had the original directors of Wii Sports and Wii Sports Resort oversee matters. If Nintendo played their cards right, the sports sim had the opportunity to reignite the dormant brand, bringing in a heap of profit for years to come.
Nintendo Switch Sports may have amassed a small fortune, but that's not an indicator of its quality. Each of the nine mini-games had one major flaw or another, whether it was slow pacing, lack of variety, or finicky gameplay. It also suffered game-crashing bugs so infrequently, the servers were taken offline.
Unlike Wii Sports, Nintendo Switch Sports doesn't attempt to do anything revolutionary with its motion controls. This isn't just disappointing but confusing, considering there are plenty of Switch games that utilise the Joy-Cons in a creative way, like Just Dance, Arms, and Ring Fit.
In hindsight, it's baffling how something so forgettable and mediocre as Nintendo Switch Sports turned a profit.
3. 50 Cent: Bulletproof
With 50 Cent's career on the rise during the millennium, the hip-hop rapper started popping up in everything, including films, cartoons, and reality tv shows.
And so, it was only a matter of time before the Grammy winner had his own video game. Sure enough, 50 Cent: Bulletproof hit the shelves in 2005, with a PSP port released the following year. In Genuine Games' gritty shooter, 50 Cent takes him upon himself to hunt down the men who left him for dead.
Bulletproof seemed like a lot of fun on the surface, since it offered gun-toting street-action, plenty of music from the lead star's catalogue, and appearances from Dr. Dre and Eminem.
Ironically, the critics reminded everyone it was anything but bulletproof. With its tiresome missions, lazy combat, and capricious aiming, 50 Cent: Bulletproof had "vanity project" written all over it.
But since the multimillionaire musician was at the top of his game at the time, this dreck made a profit. It did so well, it spawned a sequel called 50 Cent: Blood on the Sand (which wasn't half-bad).
With that said, not even 50 Cent purists should waste a moment on this abomination.
2. Pokémon Scarlet/Violet
Debuting on the Game Boy back in 1996, Pokemon has remained one of Nintendo's most consistent IPs.
Too bad 2022's Pokémon Scarlet/Violet put an end to that hot streak. Many qualities synonymous with the monster-catching saga, such as the exploration and battle mechanics, weren't up to standard in this Pokemon Gen 9 title. Due to rampant bugs, game-crashing glitches, poor performance, and shoddy online features, Scarlet/Violent wasn't just bad but amateur. Also, fans of Pokemon Legends: Arceus were disappointed to see many of its new features weren't included in this instalment.
For this reason, it was no surprise to learn the latest entry was the lowest-rated game in the mainline series.
However, it was a surprise to see how successful it was. Despite the heavy criticism, Scarlet/Violet sold a whopping ten million copies... in three days. It was also the most pre-ordered Pokemon game ever and the best-selling game in Japan in 2022. It sold over 25 million copies (so far), making it the seventh best-selling Switch game, just behind its predecessor, Pokémon Sword/Shield.
Though the Pokemon brand has plenty of sway, it's still bizarre to see people going out of their way to experience the lowest point in the franchise.
1. Kinect Adventures!
After seeing the success of the Nintendo Wii's motion controls, Microsoft decided to implement motion technology for the Xbox 360.
In 2010, the company released the Kinect, a motion-tracking camera which relied on gesture and voice recognition. Since the Kinect effectively made the player the controller, it sounded like a game-changer. As such, there was a ton of hype for the first game to utilise the peripheral, a sports mini-game title called Kinect Adventures!
Although the mini-games weren't great, Kinect Adventures! had a bigger issue - the tech didn't work. The Kinect ranged from being overly sensitive, not sensitive enough, imprecise, or unresponsive.
Despite being advertised as "real-time," the Kinect occasionally suffered a delayed reaction, making it impossible to perform time-sensitive motions effectively. And if clicking on an option is frustrating, you can imagine how unbearable it is to play any of these mini-games.
For all its faults, it goes without saying that Kinect Adventures! was a critical failure. However, the same cannot be said commercially. In fact, Kinect Adventures! sold a mind-boggling 24 million units, making it the most successful Xbox 360 title.
Granted, the fact it was packed with the Kinect is the main reason this clunker sold the way way it did. Nevertheless, it's bewildering to learn Kinect Adventures! outsold classics like Skyrim, Minecraft, Halo, and Call of Duty. Heck, this dumpster fire sold more than Grand Theft frickin' Auto V. Not only that, it's still in the top 50 most successful games of all time.
The moral of the story is gamers need to really really read the reviews before they purchasing things they'll quickly learn to regret.