2K GamesIn any game that lets you fight against enemies, how the combat is handled can make or break the entire experience. A game with no plot and bad graphics can be forgiven if it has an incredible combat system. However, if fighting the bad guys is no fun, then it can be irredeemable no matter how compelling the story. There can be any number of reasons for why a game's combat can be disappointing. Floaty controls, clunky animations, sloppy movement and convoluted skill systems can all lead to an unpleasant experience. Other times, the actual combat can be adequate, but totally lacking in variety. Either way, it's hard to find the strength to push through and complete a game when it's overly light on the entertainment front. Ranging from duds that could have been great, to classics that should have been better, this list takes a look at games with disappointing combat that otherwise did almost everything right. Each game might be worth a play for the things it did well but, ultimately, every entry fell short of its full potential.
10. Risen 2: Dark Waters
Deep SilverRisen 2 has a truly great premise for an action-RPG. The game combines classic Caribbean pirate themes with dark fantasy, filled with monsters and voodoo. A lot of the game works brilliantly, serving up one of the best atmospheric experiences of 2012. The game has some beautiful environments to explore, and is marked by a fantastic sense of humour throughout. Unfortunately, the combat was an absolute mess. Featuring overly long recovery animations and many unblockable enemy attacks, Risen 2's combat just wasn't any fun. Worst of all, the main character just felt sluggish, with difficult-to-execute dodges and a ridiculously long transition between standing still and running. What should've been some awesome swashbuckling action just felt like slowly wading through mud while waving a sword. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RCGFtNTWewA
9. Mass Effect
Electronic ArtsThe first Mass Effect game really set a new standard for epic sci-fi storytelling in video games. With its intergalactic exploration and revolutionary dialogue system, Mass Effect was an astoundingly good experience. Unfortunately, there were two facets of the gameplay that held it back somewhat. For starters, the inventory system was horrible. Thanks to the game's habit of throwing every bit of useless crap at you constantly, the inventory management was fiddly and time consuming. It was the game's combat that really held it back though. The recharging weapon idea was cool on paper, but just felt too slow and frustrating during intense gunfights. Mass Effect was very combat heavy, and the system just wasn't as smooth and polished as those seen in many non-RPG action titles. Fortunately, Bioware felt the same, revamping the combat in time for the sequel. The new combat may have been a bit generic compared to the first game, but it was also far more streamlined, satisfying, and fun. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CGcoWj8tud8
8. Alan Wake
Microsoft Game StudiosWith its Stephen King inspired story and strong characterisation, Alan Wake was a well-made, spooky narrative experience. The game also made good use of light and dark, entwining the theme into both narrative and gameplay. The mechanic of using light was an interesting one, and it mostly worked quite well. However, just about everything else in the combat wasn't great. The dodging was unreliable and clunky, while the guns felt like you were firing BB pellets. The intention was to make the player feel under real danger, but this was at the expense of high levels of frustration. The fights were also wildly unbalanced, with long stretches of the game being far too easy, interspersed with occasional difficulty spikes when confronted with groups of four or more enemies. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0m0G2_t16WY
7. Morrowind
Bethesda SoftworksMorrowind is still considered by many to be the greatest entry in the Elder Scrolls franchise. With a weird, richly detailed world, and less hand-holding than is now common in AAA releases, Morrowind is widely considered to be a quintessential RPG experience. It's a shame then, that the combat pretty much sucks. The Elder Scrolls isn't a series known for having a daring, complex combat system, but Oblivion and Skyrim were vast improvements over Morrowind. The definition of clunky, Morrowind's combat was unsatisfying and inconsistent, particularly when using melee weapons. This was made even worse by the frequent surprise attacks from some particularly annoying monsters. We're not naming any names, but if you played the game then you know the terror of seeing a certain winged shadow appear in front of you... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kKDkf_IB_i8
6. Bioshock Infinite
2K GamesThe Bioshock series' strength has never been in its combat. The games have excelled in creating worlds that drip with atmosphere, and tense, scary moments, but the fighting just isn't anything special. That's not to say the combat is particularly bad. The act of combining antiquated weaponry with fireballs and lightning bolts can be very fun, and occasionally exhilarating. Despite this, the combat in Bioshock can often feel like a necessary function to progress the storyline, rather than being a fundamental part of the experience. While it still worked well in Rapture, it was in Bioshock Infinite that the cracks began to show. The floating city of Columbia was a beautiful place, but there was never much time to admire it thanks the constant fights against swarms of robots, rebels and patriots. The huge focus on combat in Bioshock Infinite just didn't match up to how fun the actual gameplay was, making the continuous battles fatiguing and often frustrating. In fact, we truly believe that more stealth and platforming, sprinkled with occasional gunfights would have made for a far more effective and refreshing way of journeying through Columbia. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RcO4hM7w4bY
5. The Secret World
Electronic ArtsWe wish The Secret World became more popular than it did. One of the few MMORPGs that can claim to be truly original since World of Warcraft's release, The Secret World is set in a universe where just about every conspiracy and legend is completely true, making for an exciting place to explore. That's why it was crushingly disappointing when it emerged that The Secret World had a combat system that was about as dull as you can get. While it was initially fun to come up with a good build, combat quickly devolved into tapping the same few button cycles over and over and over again. The repetition wasn't helped by the floaty animations, or attacks that lacked any sort of oomph. While most MMOs feature their fair share of repetition, the battles in The Secret World bring a whole new level of mind-numbing boredom to the genre. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Am58WL1TWzU
4. Game Of Thrones
Focus Home InteractiveUnless you count the excellent mods for Crusader Kings II and Mount & Blade: Warband, there hasn't been a decent Game of Thrones video game yet. Considering how entertaining the CKII mod is, we're certain that an official Game of Thrones adaptation could have the potential to be truly great. The action RPG simply titled 'Game of Thrones' came close to brilliance. The characters were expertly written (though poorly voiced), and the story genuinely did justice to the franchise. Unfortunately, the gameplay was absolutely horrible. The combat was a weird blend of The Witcher, Assassin's Creed and The Sims, in which you queued up attacks in real time and sort of watched them be performed in order. There was an interesting idea hidden away in there somewhere, but the game sadly just couldn't pull it off. Although the story would be of great interest to any fan of the books or show, we'd recommend just reading the plot online over slogging through this title. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J_7DS6GrRS4
3. Mirror's Edge
Electronic ArtsMirror's Edge was a truly excellent game, featuring a unique aesthetic and smooth free-running gameplay. While the game received decent reviews on release, six years later it has widely been recognised as something of a modern classic. The majority of the game was magnificently realised, but the combat was Mirror's Edge's low point. The melee combat was a bit sloppy, and overly relied on the trial-and-error of anticipating the timing of punches and gunfire. Fortunately, the combat wasn't a big part of the game, and it was almost always encouraged to just run from fights (other than one or two compulsory segments). However, it did serve as an unwanted break from the wonderful platforming, unnecessarily disrupting the game's flow. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n6ERFR0gHO0
2. Gothic 3
Aspyr MediaGothic 3 was an attempt by developers Piranha Bytes to make the dark fantasy-themed RPG series more accessible to a wider audience. Many of the major changes were great, such as the vastly improved graphics and more cohesive quest design. Unfortunately, the combat was totally watered down in comparison to its predecessors, turning it into a hack-and-slash-athon that was lacking in the first two games' strategic depth. It was extremely unsatisfying, particularly when factoring in the clunky animations and bad AI. Ultimately, Gothic 3 wound up disappointing both long-term series vets and newcomers alike. Attempts at simplifying the combat were jarring to fans of the originals, while the bugs and lack of oomph left many wondering why the Gothic series was so revered in the first place. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EJ-xJWkSAHk
1. Alpha Protocol
ObsidianOne of the most disappointing releases of all time, with a few changes Alpha Protocol could've been a masterpiece. Alpha Protocol puts the player in the shoes of a field agent, blending stealth, actions and RPG elements. The poor combat played a large part in the game's mixed reception. With a badly designed cover system and terrible enemy AI, Alpha Protocol featured sloppy, unpolished fights, totally outshone by other contemporary titles that blended action and RPG elements. Alpha Protocol's biggest flaw though, was its weird mix of weapon stat upgrades and action gameplay principles. For example, if you haven't levelled up your pistol skills, then it's almost impossible to hit an enemy even with a direct hit. This sort of system worked in games like Fallout, with its V.A.T.S mechanic, but in Alpha Protocol it proved to be a broken mess.Do you disagree with any of the entries on this list? Are there any that you would have chosen to include? Let us know in the comments below!