10 Great Games with TERRIBLE DLC

Even though we wanted more of these games, these DLCs diluted the experience.

By James Egan /

When a video game is a massive success, it isn't long before there's demand for a sequel. A follow-up can take considerable time, so developers may drop a DLC or two to whet the appetite of the masses.

Advertisement

On paper, downloadable content is a recipe for easy money. So long as the price is reasonable, die-hard fans should be fine with forking over a little cash in exchange for more missions or levels.

Sadly, there are times where the expansion doesn't measure up. Occasionally, developers cobble together the bare-minimum and expect fans to pay almost the same price as the game itself. Even though some post-release content promises the world, they end up feeling like an afterthought. 

Even if the extra material isn't that bad, it can be anticlimactic if it's mismanaged. I mean, if the added content was ready when the game was released, why wasn't it included for free in the first place? That's unfair regardless how well it turned out.

Now, there's no doubt the ten titles on this list are great. But based on how atrocious these DLCs turned out, it seems like the creators already used up all their best ideas.

10. Resident Evil Village

The expansion for Resident Evil Village promised a new narrative, which centred around Ethan Winters’ daughter, Rose. More importantly, it would explore Rose's mysterious powers, offering a brand new way of playing.

Advertisement

At least, that's what we should've got. Rose's abilities are underutilised throughout this DLC, resulting in repetitive and simplistic gameplay. The campaign is surprisingly short and lazily reuses environments from the base game. On top of that, the linear structure removes the exploration and puzzle-solving that made Village engaging.

Beyond its brevity and sloppy gameplay, the new story falls flat. Rather than expanding on the Winters' relationships with one another in a meaningful way, the plot relies on familiar tropes that don't deliver much impact. Basically, it came across more like a mild subplot instead of a continuation.

Adding to the problems, the third-person mode and Mercenaries mini-game failed to impress. Third-person mode feels awkward and doesn’t really change the overall experience. The new playable characters in Mercenaries, including Lady Dimitrescu, offer brief amusement but not enough to leave a major impression.

Even though Resident Evil Village further cemented the survival horror series was back in its element, the DLC was a missed opportunity.

9. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2013)

After the recent release of Friday the 13th and Evil Dead video game adaptions, it was no surprise when The Texas Chainsaw Massacre brand got the same treatment. Though the former properties received mixed reviews, 2023's TCM was praised for its faithfulness to the source material and its cat-and-mouse gameplay. And when Sumo Nottingham announced more juicy features were on the way, it was a cause for celebration.

Advertisement

Although players had hoped for more maps, expanded modes, and glitch fixes, the post-launch updates primarily consisted of cosmetic packs that were simply recolors or minor outfit variations.

Adding salt to the wounds, new characters were often sold individually at high prices. Persistent balance problems remained unaddressed, with certain new characters feeling overpowered or underwhelming.

Compounding the disappointment was the announcement that no further content or bug fixes would be coming out. This declaration signalled the end of long-term support, which was annoying, considering the survival horror title was only released two years prior.

If Sumo made more of an effort to sustain The Texas Chainsaw Massacre's early momentum, it could've fostered an engaged player base for years to come.

8. Street Fighter X Tekken

With Street Fighter and Tekken being among the most celebrated fighting franchises, it seemed inevitable the Capcom and Namco IPs would crossover. Sure enough, Street Fighter X Tekken hit shelves in 2012, much to the joy of both fan parties. The tag-team extravaganza offered a vast roster, gorgeous visuals, and a balance of both brands' mechanics, while still being accessible to newbies.

Advertisement

Several months later, a DLC was made available, adding 12 characters to the roster, six from the Street Fighter series and six from the Tekken series. Although players had to pay for this, it didn't seem unreasonable on the surface.

But it ended up creating one of the biggest controversies in either property's history. Firstly, certain characters were initially planned to be unlockable through gameplay but were made DLC exclusive purely to maximise profits.

But that's just the tip of the iceberg. Through data-mining, it was unearthed the additional fighters were already on the disc but were deliberately rendered inaccessible. Unsurprisingly, gamers thought it was ludicrous how they needed to pay for content that was available on the disc from Day One.

7. Kingdom Hearts III

Kingdom Hearts III had high expectations, considering it was the long-awaited conclusion to the Dark Seeker saga, which had been building since the original. As such, fans were hyped, especially since the Re:Mind DLC was intended to tie up everything, particularly around Sora’s fate and the Keyblade War.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, it's hard to think of an aspect which the DLC doesn't fail in. Re:Mind relies on cutscenes that rehash events from the main game, so it feels like it's retreading familiar ground rather than offering anything new. 

New plot-threads are introduced, such as the Chamber of Repose, but are too convoluted to be satisfying. Such sub-plots have no direct connection with the game or the trilogy's plot, so they feel tacked on. The antagonists lack personality or backstory, so they're rarely compelling.

The battles themselves aren't enjoyable since the preposterous difficulty spikes encourage grind-heavy gameplay, which is sure to alienate casual players. Sora gets several different forms and attacks, but they feel like extensions from pre-existing mechanics.

Re:Mind is such a hodgepodge of unfinished ideas, it probably didn't need to be released at all.

6. Asura's Wrath

With a Capcom entry appearing on our list for the third time, it seems like the company isn't cut out for DLC. The very same year Capcom dealt with the Street Fighter X Tekken snafu, they found themselves embroiled with another game they published, Asura's Wrath.

Advertisement

The over-the-top action title stood out, due to its anime art-style, godlike battles, and the way it creatively mixed Hindu and Buddhist mythology with sci-fi themes. It also utilised quick-time events in a way that smoothly integrated into the story.

But for all is strengths, Asura's Wrath is infamous for its ending, or lack there of. The main campaign ends on a huge cliffhanger, with the last three episodes only available on the DLC. Basically, you have to pay to play the game, then pay again to complete it. Unless you're willing to splash out more cash, you'll never experience the last few levels, the final boss, or the true ending.

Considering the payable chapter was released shortly after the game launched, it seems like the studio's intended to sell it separately early on, exasperating the controversy further.

5. Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

When it comes to bonus features for Call of Duty, it should be easy to satisfy the fanbase. By throwing together a few new maps, missions, weapons, and modes, players should be willing to pay up.

Advertisement

Although Modern Warfare 2 was a monumental hit, it was marred with controversy (and not just for the No Russian mission). Firstly, the story-related DLC is pretty much non-existent. Instead of getting mission expansions or different campaigns, the added content focused almost entirely on multiplayer.

Now, that wouldn't be so bad, at least in theory. Too bad many maps from the first downloadable batch, the Stimulus Package, are rehashes from Call of Duty 4. Due to the backlash, the developers should've been a lot more cautious the next time.

On the contrary, they pulled the same stunt with the Resurgence Package, repackaging more maps from COD 4. (They could've at least ripped off a different instalment this time.)

The Stimulus and Resurgence Packages would be deemed mediocre if they were free, so it's understandable how negative the reception was when COD players learned they paid for a slight variation of familiar maps.

4. Assassin's Creed Odyssey

When it comes to Assassin's Creed, Ubisoft often puts almost as much effort in its bonus material as the game itself. The additional missions in AC III endowed our hero with newfound powers, completely changing the gameplay. Black Flag's DLC allowed you to play as different heroes, gaining great insight into the overarching narrative.

Advertisement

Even though Odyssey is among the best entries in years, Ubisoft dropped the ball with the downloadable mission, Legacy of the First Blade. Many players found the gameplay repetitive and lacking innovation, since many mechanics are recycled from the base game. This led to a sense of monotony, as players engaged in similar activities without fresh experiences to maintain engagement.

What's worse is technical problems plagued Legacy of the First Blade, leading to performance issues, quest glitches, and crashes. The DLC's integration of micro-transactions also detracted from the experience, since players were expected to pay extra... after already paying extra.

Fortunately, the developers learned from their mistakes, since the next two DLCs were solid and glitch-free. However, Legacy of the First Blade turned out so poorly, it should've been free. 

3. Mafia II

Mafia II's biggest strength was its cinematic story, centring around Vito Scaletta's rise and fall in the Empire Bay underworld. Although 2K Czech's crime-oriented title was riveting, the story ended on a cliffhanger, leaving many wondering what happened next.

Advertisement

Disappointingly, the DLC packs didn't continue the main Mafia narrative at all. Rather than exploring Vito's time in prison or the fallout between the main characters, the bonus content focused on side characters or unrelated figures like Jimmy, who wasn't in the main game at all.

Being the devil's advocate, this could still work if the DLC was enjoyable. However, the new material is so bare-bones, it feels like it was thrown together at the last minute. Missions like Jimmy's Vendetta and Joe's Adventures have little to no meaningful cutscenes, character development, or cohesive plot. 

Instead, these modes focus on score-attack missions, timed objectives, and arcade-style gameplay, which doesn't gel with the rest of the game. The missions are far from enjoyable, since they usually involve driving to a specific point, shooting a few enemies, and escaping before the timer runs out.

Considering how much effort went into Mafia II, fans expected a lot more from the post-release content.

2. Donkey Kong Bananza

Even though Donkey Kong has been consistent over the last 20 years, the banana-munching, barrel-blasting gorilla hasn't been top-tier the way he used to be.

Advertisement

But all that changed with Donkey Kong Bananza. Boasting destructive environments, animal transformations, and beautifully crafted worlds, the Switch 2 exclusive singlehandedly brought the big ape back into the major leads. Veterans had to wait an eternity but DK is back, bigger than ever.

But Nintendo had to ruin it all. A mere two months after Bananza launched, a DLC was announced called Emerald Isle, where the tie-wearing primate must perform challenges and collect jewels on his home island. It isn't spectacular, but it's a nice little addition to an already terrific game.

However, the problem is that players have to pay for Emerald Isle. Considering Bananza is almost £60, demanding an additional £17 for a mild upgrade is plain greedy.

Also, having Emerald Isle come out so soon after Bananza itself is ridiculous. It demonstrates they could've been packaged together but the powers-that-be chose not to, solely to squeeze every penny imaginable from consumers.

Though Donkey Kong Bananza captivated Switch 2 owners, this move didn't do Nintendo any favours.

1. Mortal Kombat 1

As bad as the DLCs on this list are, they didn't turn out as badly as Mortal Kombat 1's, which ended up tarnishing its reputation.

Advertisement

Serving as a sequel and a reboot of Mortal Kombat 11, players were curious to see how MK1 would turn out. It had a few problems (especially the Switch port), but the blood-soaked fighting title offered great kombat, imaginative mechanics, clever reinventions of iconic kombatants, brutal finishers, a wealth of fan-service, and a bold new direction for the franchise. Not only that, the main campaign ended on a To Be Continued, which would be explored in the DLC, Khaos Reigns.

But the bonus chapter was so reviled, it rebranded the once beloved reimagining as a failure. With a completion time of two hours, Khaos Reigns is embarrassingly short. Though new playable characters were included, core elements of them were pointlessly changed. (Rather than being cyborgs, Cyrax and Sektor were revised into Iron Man wannabes.)

Worst still, Khaos Reigns was almost the same price as the actual game. Asking devoted fans to spend another £50 for this shoddy slop wasn't just bewildering but insulting. This negativity was so overwhelming, NetherRealm Studios cancelled another planned DLC.

Although the future for series was initially bright, it's starting to look like Mortal Kombat is in desperate need of another reboot.

Advertisement