10 Great Video Games That Almost Never Happened At All

GTA's success was always a certainty, right? Nope, it nearly didn't even happen.

By Ben Gibson /

Though you might not be aware of the scale of it as you sit in your pants wondering what that smell is (and hoping it's not you,) video games are incredibly hard to make. Not only do they require a small army of tirelessly working keyboard-minions, but the adversity they face makes you wonder how their developers don't fling their hard drives out the window and go feral in the woods, away from the pressures of publishers, fan outrage and censors. Inevitably, all works of art have a backstory: you can't have something as complex as a film, album or video game without an interesting tale to go with it, even if all but the most extreme or disastrous are summarily ignored when it comes time to appreciating the product itself. There's too much emotion and effort put in over a long period of time for something interesting not to happen, and it seems like something of a kick in the teeth to have all of that effort and drama to be boiled down in a few lines of a review: "This game was made by Ubisoft Montreal." The sad fact is that while magazines are littered with stories of rock stars coming up with even the most banal of lyrics while off their faces on something illegal and delicious, too little is ever mined from the rich landfill of gaming back stories. But that's down to human interest: there aren't many games made on drugs, mainly because it's hard to program when your fingers are conspiring against you. But there are untold stories worthy of being told and shared: where developers snatched victory from the face of over-whelming adversity and got games that very nearly didn't happen at all onto shelves, gaining the adulation of fans worldwide. These are stories about murder, communism, bankruptcy and lost friendships - and about people who refused to give in when it looked like it was game over.

10. Manhunt 2

On February 27th 2004, 17 year old Warren Leblanc murdered 14 year old Stefan Pakeerah by stabbing him to death with a claw hammer: a method of execution similar to one performed in the original Manhunt game, which became the focus of a media frenzy surrounding the case. Despite the police denying any link between the murder and the game, this didn't stop professional moaner Jack Thompson from pointing the blame squarely at Rockstar. To give you an idea of what a stand up chap this guy is, he was disbarred as an attorney for for inappropriate conduct, including making false statements - similar to those that claimed that Manhunt was responsible for Leblanc's actions. Ignoring the actual reason for the crime (a drug-related robbery) he used this tragic event to satisfy his own prejudices. Unmoved by the controversy, Rockstar continued work on the sequel, surviving multiple lawsuits and a refusal from the BBFC to rate the game, releasing Manhunt 2 in 2007 to positive critic and player acclaim. Still, it stands as an underrated game, overshadowed by the controversy surrounding it.

9. Devil May Cry

The original Devil May Cry was wonderful: cool, stylish and positively dripping with a gothic ambiance few games can match, which shouldn't be surprising as the game was originally intended to be the fourth instalment of another fan favourite franchise, Resident Evil. It seems hard to believe, considering it doesn't really look, play or feel anything like a survival horror. For a start, see how easy it is to turn around. Damn, that's swish. But then it wouldn't, because series producer Shinji Mikami decided following a trip to the UK where he photographed gothic textures, that it was just too different to fit in with the Resident Evil world, and the initial direction was changed. The call benefited both series in the end, as Resi 4 was eventually released to mass critical acclaim, with many considering it among the best games ever released by Capcom. Devil May Cry also got its own franchise. Despite never quite topping the original action-packed thriller, it remains a fine collection of games in its own right.

8. Fallout 3

Due to the financial issues of Interplay studio and the closing of Black Isle Studios, the uncompleted Fallout 3's future fell into uncertainty. With a massive portion of the game completed, the developers must have been over the moon to discover Elder Scrolls developer Bethesda Softworks had purchased the game, at the hefty price of $1,175,000. That's a significant cost, but it made sense when you consider that the first two games were moderate successes, they had a glowing reputation among PC aficionados and the game was well into development. At least, it was until Bethesda Softworks decided to scrap all the work that had gone into it so far and start from scratch. We can't be sure of the reasons behind this: Black Isle Studios had done a sterling job on the previous two entries and there was no suggestion their work was not up to standard, but then hat kind of perfectionism is to be expected when you're dealing with the studio that created Skyrim. The gamble paid off: Fallout 3 was released in 2008, receiving high praise and shifting several million copies. It's sequel New Vegas did almost as well, so whatever the problem they identified was, they certainly fixed it.

7. Goldeneye 007

Originally intended as a side-scrolling platformer following the monster success of Rare's magnum opus Donkey Kong Country, the mack daddy of console first person shooters would have been a very different game if Nintendo had got their way. Consisting of one of the most inexperienced development teams to ever work with a major license, 8 out of 10 of Goldeneye's developers had never worked on a single game before, but what would have been a disaster for most, ended up being the driving force behind one of the most influential titles of all time. Goldeneye played like nothing ever made, because their team had never made anything before. Most surprisingly, they never wanted the film license in the first place: according to developer Karl Milton, tie-ins with major franchises had a bad reputation, following poor releases such as 2D side-scrollers Robocop and Batman - or in other words, exactly the kind Nintendo wanted Rare to make. Luckily for us, Rare stuck with the license and to their guns. Despite moving from the SNES to the N64, changing from a platformer to on-rails shooter to FPS, they managed to continually stumbled forward towards genius. Oh, and they chucked in a multiplayer mode that defined the genre and state of multiplayer gaming as we know it. Not bad for a first try.

6. Tomb Raider: Legend

It's hard to appreciate - even now her renaissance is in full swing - just how big a deal Lara Croft was during the mid-nineties. Considered to be a major factor in the success of the original PlayStation, she was one of the first major female leads in gaming, and having become an instant icon, she made millions for developer Eidos, leaving a film franchise, a Walk of Game Induction and a place in the Guinness world records in her wake. Unfortunately, few franchises have felt rot wear in as quickly as the tomb raiding temptress, and by the third installment, critics had already begun bemoaning the lack of originality in the series. Much like fellow nineties icon Crash Bandicoot, Lara Croft was dying the slow death of mediocrity, and Legend was not even the first attempt to revive the series. The Angel Of Darkness brought in a new story, setting and revamped gameplay, but was a critical disaster which left the series reputation in tatters. Core Design had actually killed Lara off at the end of The Last Revelation, presumably feeling they had run their course with the franchise, and after being dragged into making a sequel, it seemed to be only a matter of time until the old girl was finally going to be put out to pasture. Thankfully for us, parent company Eidos made the call to take the series away from creators Core Design, who were a shambles by the end of 2003. Instead of letting Croft fade away, new developer Crystal Dynamics resurrected the franchise with a bold, exciting new direction that paved the way for the wonderful Tomb Raider (2013). A narrow escape there: one close enough to make Lara herself break a sweat.

5. Grand Theft Auto

Plagued with controversy from the offset, the GTA series never had an easy ride. Gaming's greatest underdog had troubles long before the media tried to have them shut down: their very own production company was at it first. "The writers were driving it one way. The level designers were driving at another way. They weren't meeting in the middle," said creative director Gary Penn, in a video interview with the Guardian. One of the first open world games of its time, not a single milestone was met during the game's protracted four year development. "We'd have conference calls at least once a week with the US. They wanted to kill it every week. Every week they wanted to kill this game, and we'd have to argue to try and keep it going, because we had some faith." Much like Goldeneye, which was released a mere two months earlier, the development team for GTA was made up of young, inexperienced staff trying to create something that hadn't been done before. They eventually managed to struggle towards something truly impressive through a painful process of trial and error. While not on the level of Rare's masterpiece (for that they would have to wait until the groundbreaking GTA 3), this set the stage for all sandbox games to follow. When you look at the gaming industry today and see it dominated by first person shooters and open-world titles, it's funny to think that it all stemmed from the efforts of two small and unsure development teams.

4. Fez

Developer Phil Fish's struggle to get cult masterpiece Fez released is gloriously captured in the brilliant Indie Game: The Movie. During the film Fish is amidst a legal battle with former business partner Jason Degroot in the build to the first ever public showing of the game at PAX East 2011. The two co-founded development company Polytron, but that partnership collapsed amongst personal differences. Due to their business arrangement, Fish needed Degroot to sign a waiver for the game to be shown, despite having long abandoned the project. What we see is the struggle of a man who has put his life into a project, knowing that somebody else could take it away at will, and in the film's most unsettling moment, Fish resolves to kill himself if the game is not released, with dead-eyed conviction. The game was developed over an achingly slow five years, characterised by press outbursts, fractured friendships and endless delays. But Fez made it. Released in 2012, its puzzles, design and open blue sky atmosphere were praised by critics. That's the most compelling aspect of playing Fez - within minutes you forget all you know about its troubled origins and are transported to it's peaceful pixilated paradise. Despite selling over a million, Fez 2 was cancelled after Phil Fish publicly condemned the gaming industry on Twitter. It remains a solitary work of perfection.

3. Sonic The Hedgehog

These are tough times for Sega's spiky blue mascot: where he once stood as Mario's fiercest rival, he now stands as a relic of a bygone era. In a way, he's a victim of circumstance: trapped on the doomed Sega Saturn and Dreamcast, Sonic fell badly during the switch to 3D, and he's been running with a limp ever since. Then again, Sonic has been playing fast and loose with good fortune from the offset. The finger-wagging hedgehog was conceived while Sega were seeking to replace their original mascot Alex Kidd, in the hope of competing with the smiling moustachioed juggernaut of fun that is Mario. But it's not all that hard to see Sega's reasoning there: Alex Kidd might be fun to play, but the guy was lame - he wore this weird Logan's Run style jumpsuit with a little elfin haircut and big ears. They needed someone smooth, someone hip, someone ready to party like it's 1991. They needed funkadelic aliens ToeJam & Earl... Wait, what? According to Sega president Hayao Nakayama, the two were very nearly selected, even going so far as having their game greenlit for development, and it was only down to the last minute entry of 'Needlemouse' and the consensus that the alien duo were "too laid back" that they made the call for Sonic instead.

2. Donkey Kong

Undoubtedly one of the most important releases of all time, the original Donkey Kong arcade game was Nintendo's first major success in the video game industry. It was developed by a young Shigeru Miyamoto and is among the earliest examples of the platforming genre, as well as introducing a plucky moustachioed carpenter, who would later be known retooled as a plumber and renamed as Mario. Originally though, the game was intended to be based on a Popeye comic strip, but the license fell through forcing Nintendo to create its own characters that they hoped could be marketed for later games. Over 150 games later, it's safe to say they pretty much nailed that one. The roles of the characters were based on the roles of the Popeye characters, casting Donkey Kong as Bluto, Mario as Popeye and Peach as Olive Oyl. Perhaps if Mario really wants to impress the Princess, he should get on the spinach. Donkey Kong went on to be a huge financial success and paved the way for Nintendo to go on to bigger and better things, as would the gaming industry as a whole.

1. Tetris

Technically the term "never happened" doesn't apply here, because Tetris - the hardboiled, fiendishly simple game - would have existed, but only beneath the steely gaze of the iron curtain. The addictive nature of this game meant it was a surefire hit for its creator, ready to set him up for life with a sweet beachfront pad and ladies of the night on tap, but that is not how things are done in Soviet Russia, you decadent Western swine. Despite proving as popular in Moscow as heavily discounted vodka, creator Alexey Pajitnov had no intention, nor any means, of making money from his masterwork. Nonetheless it continued to spread like wildfire until it wound up in Hungary, where it was picked up by a British software house. They naturally tried to strike a deal with Pajitnov, because if you think there's treasure in your backyard, you better hope you can afford a shovel. It turns out communication wasn't great in 1980's Russia, and by the time they managed to get through, the rights had already been sold. Somehow though, Andromeda were able to gain a license for the Commadore 64; the details of this arrangement were sketchy, so we can only assume it involved an AK47 and a padlock. Ultimately though, Tetris is a story about a game that was too good to contain. The licensing issues that surround it could fill a novel, but the way it got out of Russia was beautifully simple: it was shared because people loved it. By 1988, Russia realised resistance was futile and began marketing it across the world, and it ended up on almost every games console, computer and even mobile phone in the world, selling in excess of 170 million copies. Did we miss any great games that notoriously almost didn't even exist? Share your own stories below in the comments thread below.