10 Huge Gaming Moments That Didn't Matter At All
The biggest gaming plot points that amounted to NOTHING.
A far cry from the binary blocks of yesteryear, video games these days have become a full blown artistic medium for incredible character development and narrative storytelling. Whether it’s the world-spanning adventures of Final Fantasy or the more esoteric lore of Dark Souls, you can’t switch on a modern game without some form story to get yourself truly lost in.
Just like film or television though, a story has to have some pretty big moments to keep the players engaged, and it’s not always the easiest job in the world to make these moments stick. Whilst some games manage to pull this off and create story beats with ramifications across generations of games, every now and then the pressure to create tension and excitement is too much, and these previously massive deals either drift inconsequentially into the narrative, or have their significance reversed as soon as they appear.
Be it characters, locations, battles or plot twists, these are the times that the cardboard sets fell down, and the world the games created turned out to be more hollow than they previously appeared.
10. Try Again - Sonic The Hedgehog
Despite its simple premise of going fast and collecting rings, Sonic 1 was a game where you were always on the edge of a slip up - and you felt it.
Speeding through the levels, its easy to lose all your life-saving rings, or watch the timer run out on a bit of surprisingly tricky platforming. Add this to Dr Robotnik’s increasingly inventive boss battles, and a water level that can get right in the bin, the game could often become a trial-and-error affair if you weren't used to it. Still, the sense of reward was substantial as you reached closer to the finale.
Oh, you did remember to pick up the Chaos Emeralds though, right?
You better hope so, because after all that slog from Green Hill to Final Zones, if you missed the six emeralds hidden in the tricky Special Zones, you would be greeted with a post credits panel of Robotnik juggling the Emeralds you missed with the simple command: ‘Try Again’.
On seeing it for the first time many gamers will have panicked, thinking their work has all been for nothing and that they have failed. Fortunately for them it doesn't really change anything, you still finished the game ok - and if anything it serves as a cheeky reminder that just because you finished the game doesn't mean you've beaten it.
9. Upgrading Freddy - Five Nights At Freddy’s: Security Breach
Despite its runaway success, buoyed by popularity amongst big YouTubers, Five Nights at Freddy’s is a franchise often dismissed as being a cynical rehash of the same jumpscare mechanics.
As time has gone on, the franchise has gone through a fair few reinventions, but none have strayed as far from this initial formula as the latest entry: Security Breach.
Unlike the previous titles’ static setting, Security Breach casts the player as Gregory, a young boy trapped in an aggressively 80s Mega Pizza Plex. Gregory finds himself alongside a Freddy Fazzbear animatronic, whose refusal to murder the little lad is deemed to be a ‘malfunction’.
The player must navigate the Pizza Plex whilst being stalked by the other animatronics, eventually dismantling them to upgrade Freddy with their harvested parts. After Freddy’s second upgrade, the clock immediately darts to 6am and the game’s final escape sequence begins.
After all of that hassle for the second upgrade, with a grand total of one sequence to use it, you’ve got to wonder what the big deal was in the first place. Granted, players aiming for 100% or ‘True’ endings can return to harvest the third part in a lengthy post-game sequence with NO SAVE POINTS, but more casual fans will largely take the chance to finish the game and enjoy one of three endings depending on progress.
8. O’Brian Removes The Mask - Days Gone
Set in a zombie-apocalyptic world, Days Gone follows bounty-hunter Deacon following his tragic separation from his wife. Tracking a government helicopter, he meets O’Brian, a hazmat-suited researcher, who offers information on her whereabouts in exchange for Deacon’s help with research on the zombies (called Freakers). After a series of impressive but predictable plot points Deacon is reunited with his wife and the two resume their lives together in this apocalyptic hell hole.
Players who made the effort to 100% the game were treated to a secret final mission where O’Brian makes contact once again, warning that the Freakers are mutating. He removes his hazmat mask to reveal that he is in fact... an evolved Freaker. As Deacon recoils in shock, O’Brian remarks that the government is aware of the latest mutation, and ominously declares, "They’re coming."
Sadly, the most interesting moment in the whole franchise would prove to be the last, as an April 2021 article revealed a planned sequel was rejected due to the game’s poor critical reception. We can add this one to the pile of twists that never went anywhere.
7. The Circular Saw - Until Dawn
An early PS4 title, Until Dawn’s marketing material leaned heavily on its use of butterfly effect narrative, and how the choices made during this love letter to cabin-in-the-woods horror movies would change the story for better or worse. As any dungeon master in a D&D game will tell you though, sometimes you do have to corral people in the right direction.
A year after the supposed deaths of twins Hannah and Beth, their brother Josh invites everyone who was there (and thus semi-responsible) back to the cabin where it all happened. Up in the mountains, they soon find themselves at the mercy of a crazed psychopath in a mask, and some cannibalistic wendigos.
One sequence sees nice-boy character Chris find his crush Ashley and his best mate Josh both tied up, between them a circular saw. Chris is given the choice of selecting which of them gets chopped. It's incredibly hard to choose, but it turns out that whichever way the player goes the blade will still eviscerate Josh.
It’s later revealed that Josh’s ‘death’ was nothing but a bit of Hollywood trickery, and that he was the masked man all along, torturing his friends as revenge for his sisters. A dick move on the parts of both Josh and the developers; not only did you have no choice of the victim in the first place, but the choice made for you wasn’t even a victim at all.
6. Dylan And Paula’s Fate - Dino Crisis 2
Dino Crisis 2 follows returning hero Regina and Tactical Officer Dylan Morton, as they are thrown through time to rescue survivors from an entire city which has disappeared. Constantly under threat from the Jurassic juggernauts, the pair must also deal with masked assailants from the future.
Through a series of time-twisting revelations too bonkers to discuss in a short listicle, one of the masked attackers is revealed to be Dylan’s future daughter Paula. We find this out, of course, just in time for an unexpected self destruct countdown, and an inconvenient Gigantosaurus. A tremor causes Paula to be trapped under falling equipment, and Dylan stays behind to help her, instructing Regina to save them in another time.
Whilst fans waited desperately to see the resolution to this cliffhanger, Capcom instead decided to enact their own Extinction Level Event upon the storyline, and the third instalment takes place 500 years in the future. It maintains the premise but abandons all mention of Regina, Dylan and Paula, and with no plans whatsoever for a Dino Crisis 4, as far as satisfying conclusion would go, the prospect of resolution is all but extinct.
5. Defeating Sin - Final Fantasy X
In the franchise’s PS2 debut, Final Fantasy X centred around Tidus, a Blitzball player with a weird laugh, and Sin, a gargantuan flying whale monster who is also Tidus’ dad (long story). Tidus encounters Sin in the futuristic city of Zanarkand, and is purportedly hurled 1000 years into the future, where he meets the Summoner Yuna.
For 1000 years Sin has terrorised Spira, with only brief ‘Calms’ when it is temporarily dispelled by a Summoner wielding the self-sacrificial ‘Final Summoning’. Over the course of the narrative, Tidus learns that he is a dream, and that he and Sin are both products of the dreaming ‘Fayth’ of Zanarkand, the city’s Summoners who turned themselves into stone in the wake of a war 1000 years previous to create their ultimate weapon: Sin itself.
Realising that the only way to defeat Sin for good is to destroy this Fayth, Tidus, Yuna and the party defy all religious doctrine and fight the beast head on. Whilst they are victorious, this Eternal Calm is bittersweet, as the dream comes to an end and Tidus, with whom Yuna has fallen in love, drifts away.
Except not really. Players who completed the decidedly mixed bag of a sequel were able to bring Tidus back if they completed enough of it, and in the follow up audio drama ‘Will’, Tidus and Yuna are forced to end their relationship following the reappearance of…you guessed it…Sin.
Eternal Calm… sure.
4. The Rachni Queen - Mass Effect Series
Mass Effect is a franchise famed for its choice-based gameplay, so it would seem a strange entry for this list. But, as we’ve already discussed, sometimes players have to settle for the illusion of choice when narrative beats must be met.
Presumed extinct after The Rachni Wars, Commander Shepard comes across an incarcerated Rachni Queen in the first Mass Effect, which is being used to breed an army at the behest of original antagonist Saren and his lieutenant Matriarch Benezia. After defeating Benezia, The Queen appeals to Shepard to free her, stating that her kind intended to live peacefully following a temporary madness which caused the wars.
Aside from some different dialogue with the Turian Council, Shepard’s choice to free or kill has little impact on the effects of Mass Effect 1, so fans were eager to see where this errant plot thread would go later on. Sure enough, after a passing mention in 2, fans were delighted to see The Rachni Queen return in Mass Effect 3
Or at least the ones who saved her were. Players who chose to let the Rachni Queen go find her imprisoned by Reapers, again being forced to breed soldiers for their cause. Players who opted to execute the Queen however, would find in her place an artificial Queen imprisoned by Reapers, again being forced to breed soldiers for their cause.
Whilst there are superficial differences to gameplay based on an artificial queen or the real thing, spanning a plot across an entire trilogy just for your initial choice to be largely irrelevant certainly sucked.
3. The Deleter - Metroid: Other M
Despite receiving a fair amount of praise for its gameplay during Metroid’s successful run in the 3D realm, Metroid: Other M did gain criticism for its narrative qualities. Taking the previously stoic and determined icon of female protagonists and demoting her to an anxiety ridden teenager who can only wield power when directed by a man, Samus found herself in a game so bloated by plot that some points just got abandoned altogether.
Arriving at the derelict Bottle Ship after receiving a distress call, Samus teams up with the stranded 07th Platoon and begins investigating the strange facility and its dangerous alien inhabitants. As the team makes their way through the treacherous ship, many are mysteriously killed, and Samus is attacked by a soldier piloting colossal mining equipment, whose face is hidden behind an armoured mask.
Nicknamed ‘The Deleter’, Samus theorises that this man is actually a traitor within the 07th Platoon, taking down the members of the squad to hide the secrets of the Ship.
After discovering Bottle Ship is actually an illegal bioweapons facility run by the Galactic Federation, it becomes clear that The Deleter’s mission is to cover up the Federation’s involvement. That’ll have to wait though, as Bottle Ship’s AI has gone absolutely postal, so Samus and the surviving marines are forced into a climactic conflict, ultimately emerging victorious.
The Deleter’s identity? Not important I guess.
2. Hush - Batman Arkham Series
Batman isn’t short of villains. Despite DC’s insistence on leaning on the Batman/Joker dichotomy in any media they can muster, some of comics’ most iconic ne’er-do-wells come from the seedy streets of Gotham. Whilst many, like The Penguin and the Riddler, have a long and storied history, some of the Dark Knight’s more recent villains have proven themselves as legitimate threats, including the ingenious and deadly Hush.
Hush appears in the seminal Batman Arkham series first as a mysterious murderer known as The Identity Killer, murdering political prisoners within Arkham City and surgically dissecting their faces. Although Batman manages to catch up to Hush, he is caught in a trap and finds himself face to face with, well, his own face. Hush’s surgical exploits were all in the name of altering his appearance to match that of Bruce Wayne, and he leaves the mega-prison promising to keep pursuing The Dark Knight.
Although Hush’s introduction was one of the more promising subplots going into the trilogy finale Arkham Knight, the final showdown with this calculating genius boils down to a short hostage situation and a quick punch to the face. Of the myriad things that made Arkham Knight somewhat disappointing, this squandering of such an iconic villain sat very high on the list.
1. Eli Steals Sahelanthropus - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain
Of all the victims of the nasty Hideo Kojima/Konami fallout, one of the most public and most cited ones is the botched back half of Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain.
The main focus of the game is the conflict between Venom Snake (original antagonist Big Boss’ code name in this outing) and Skull Face, a terrorist planning to use a parasite to kill the English speaking world whilst maintaining order with the nuclear threat of Metal Gear Sahelanthropus. Unlike other Metal Gears, Sahelanthropus would not contain AI, and instead be controlled psychically by ‘The Third Child’, a younger version of series favourite Psycho Mantis.
So far, so Kojima. Along for the ride is Eli, a leader of child soldiers, purported clone of Snake and MGS antagonist Liquid Snake in child form. With a fair amount of resentment and anger towards Snake and his military allies, Eli and The Third Child hijack Sahelanthropus from under Snake and pilot it away, never to be seen again.
When I say never, I absolutely mean it, as this is the one and only appearance of Sahelanthropus in the series, and the subplot or events between this and MGS is never explained or referenced again. Unfortunately, following creative differences behind the scenes Kojima and Konami parted ways, and the resolution to this and other massive plot points never materialised. A sad turn of events for sure, but at least it means I don’t need to keep spelling Sahelanthropus.