10 Huge Video Game Franchises That Are Doomed To Fail

Far Cry fatigue is finally setting in.

By Jack Pooley /

There are very, very few video game franchises that are truly too big to fail in any grand sense - Mario, Pokemon, and Grand Theft Auto for sure, but most others aren't above taking a catastrophic hit if their new release isn't up to snuff.

Advertisement

Now, no game franchise is perfect, and most of them have at least one dud entry among the lot, but sometimes a series suffers enough critical and commercial indignities that its future begins to be cast into doubt.

That's certainly true of these franchises, which despite their enormous visibility and brand identity feel fated to end up flaming out sooner rather than later.

Whether throwing away their strongest developmental partnership in years, enduring poor sales of several recent releases, or showing blatant desperation by cashing in on current gaming trends, these AAA franchises are all circling the drain as we speak.

It's certainly possible that some of them could return with an inspired reimagining that finally perks players and critics up, but history dictates that publishers are far more likely to just drive their IP into the ground until there's no money left to be made...

10. Sonic

The Sonic the Hedgehog franchise is one of the most commercially successful video game IP in history, but let's be honest, the series has been on the skids for years now.

Advertisement

Well it was, at least, until the release of 2017's Sonic Mania, which after about 15 years of mostly-mediocre Sonic titles was a major breath of fresh air - a nostalgia-tinged love letter to the franchise's better days that in turn received the series' best reviews in 25 years.

With Sonic Mania's critical and commercial success and the presumably instant greenlighting of a sequel, then, it seemed like Sonic was back on firm footing.

But after years of speculation about Sonic Mania 2, a rumour recently did the rounds that the sequel was scrapped after Sega failed to make an agreement with the first game's developers, who were largely members of the Sonic fangame and hacking community.

Since 2017 things have basically been business as usual for Sonic, the various spin-off titles scoring wildly mixed reviews from critics and suggesting Sonic Mania was less a new direction for the series than a flash-in-the-pan success.

While it's unlikely that Sonic will ever do something bad enough to lose all of its faithful hardcore fans, the mainstream goodwill rustled up by Sonic Mania has basically evaporated once again, and there's little sign of it being regained anytime soon.

Basically, Sonic can go back to being a critical punching bag largely ignored by casual players.

9. Watch Dogs

The Watch Dogs series sure is a strange beast. Though the original 2014 release received mixed reviews from critics it was a strong commercial success, leading to a sequel releasing just two years later.

Advertisement

Ironically despite being a much better game with a more colourful, less-serious style, Watch Dogs 2 sold 80% less than the original game in its launch week, though by last year had still impressively sold 10 million copies.

After the second game's iffy launch, though, Ubisoft made the decision to change things up again for last year's Watch Dogs: Legion, which despite its intriguing multi-protagonist setup released to mild reviews and just 54% of Watch Dogs 2's physical launch sales.

Now, it's important to factor in the uptick in digital purchases since 2016 and also the fact that some may have chosen to play the game on Ubisoft+ instead, but with the lukewarm response from players and press alike it really feels like the IP is massively losing ground.

Ubisoft will clearly be fine with the glut of AAA franchises at their disposal, but given Legion's soft commercial performance out of the gate and lack of major sales figures released since, the series is probably letting out its death rattle right now.

8. Need For Speed

There's absolutely no denying the iconic status of the Need for Speed franchise - it has been around for close to 30 years and sold 100 million copies in that time.

Advertisement

But the series has also struggled to find satisfying ways to innovate over the last decade-or-so, with the likes of 2015's reboot, 2017's Need for Speed Payback, and 2019's Need for Speed Heat struggling to strike much of a chord with players.

The problem, inevitably, is that Need for Speed has basically had its lunch eaten by the Forza Horizon franchise, which while exclusive to PC and Xbox has been going from strength to strength in recent years.

In much the same way that the Medal of Honour franchise began to feel passe and failed to carve out a new niche for itself, Need for Speed feels like a relic of the past that just can't keep up with the vastly superior racing titles that have gobbled up its slice of the market share lately.

EA will inevitably keep making attempts to restart the franchise because they can't bear letting a brand name go to waste, but honestly, maybe it's OK if Need for Speed just gets put out to pasture.

7. Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon

Ubisoft is so, so desperately trying to make fetch happen with the Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon franchise, which while storming back to life with 2017's Ghost Recon Wildlands has struggled to make players care since.

Advertisement

2019's Ghost Recon Breakpoint received wildly mixed reviews for its dull open world mission design and gameplay, leading to sales which Ubisoft CEO Yves Guillemont deemed "disappointing."

Ubisoft then announced the next entry into the series, a free-to-play live-service battle royale game, Ghost Recon Frontline.

Fan reaction to the reveal trailer was overwhelmingly negative, citing the utter cynicism with which Ubisoft was clearly trying to cash-in on current gaming trends without actually delivering a quality, worthwhile Ghost Recon game.

In response to this, Ubisoft cancelled Frontline's planned Alpha test and delayed the game "indefinitely" while they attempted to address players' concerns.

But ultimately it's clear that Ubisoft is just chasing the gravy train here and trying to compensate for Breakpoint's failure by milking battle royale and live-service frameworks for every drop they're worth.

This is the sort of cynical business mindset that makes fanbases dry up, as while nobody will need to pay to play Frontline, that doesn't mean it'll convince fans to fork out for the inevitable microtransactions.

6. WWE 2K

Depending on who you ask the WWE 2K franchise is very much a failure already, though until recently still performed well enough commercially to make an annual release worthwhile.

Advertisement

The WWE 2K series has been widely criticised by fans for years for the insulting overabundance of bugs, shockingly dated graphics, and general lack of compelling updates to the formula.

For around a decade the series' reception has ranged from decent to terrible, though the release of WWE 2K20 back in 2019 was for many the straw that broke the camel's back.

Inexplicably even buggier and more low-effort than usual - seemingly due to the departure of regular developer Yuke's - WWE 2K20 received a brutal backlash from fans and critics alike.

The game's "disappointing" sales suggested that even ultra-loyal WWE fans weren't biting, which in conjunction with the pandemic led to the planned WWE 2K21 being cancelled.

Instead, 2K rushed out WWE 2K Battlegrounds as a stop-gap title, but it was basically a glorified mobile game and received mixed reviews to that end.

WWE 2K22 is currently set to release this coming March, and though 2K has promised it will offer a more refined experience, you'd be incredibly naive to believe that.

While it's possible 2K22 is a return to decency for the series, given the company's track record it's far more likely to be another mediocre-at-best effort that's really not worth your money - at least not at full price.

With WWE's fast-rising rival company AEW also hard at work on their own game, don't be surprised if they end up taking a huge bite out of the wrestling game market and potentially even killing WWE 2K outright in the long run.

5. Metal Gear

As far as many Metal Gear fans are concerned, the series basically ended when creator Hideo Kojima acrimoniously departed from Konami following the release of Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain.

Advertisement

Since then Konami has attempted to push on without him by releasing the widely-panned commercial failure that was Metal Gear Survive, players sending a clear message that they're just not interested in lazy cash-in spin-offs.

While many franchises could survive without their original creator, Metal Gear fans are uncommonly loyal to its creator, whose unique authorial style is near-impossible to replicate.

Given that Kojima is surely never coming back to Konami, it's clear that Metal Gear's dubious future lies in the long-rumoured remake of the original Metal Gear Solid, and a possible sixth game produced without Kojima's involvement.

The remake could work fine enough because it will be working off Kojima's existing blueprint, but nostalgia can only be exploited through remakes for so long, while a sans-Kojima Metal Gear Solid 6 will be met with massive skepticism and even hostility from fans.

It really feels like there isn't much of a good place for the series to go without Kojima, and so while it might limp on for a little while longer, its long-term outlook isn't good - unless Konami can extend an olive branch and mend their rift with Kojima, at least.

4. Shenmue

The story of the Shenmue franchise sure is a fascinating one. The original 1999 Dreamcast game was a massive critical hit but failed to translate all that praise into strong sales, in large part because of its monstrous $70 million budget.

Advertisement

However, Shenmue II was developed in conjunction with the first game, meaning that it was ultimately released despite the original's commercial under-performance.

Again, it was lauded by critics but sold poorly at retail, causing a planned third game to enter development hell. Only in 2015, almost 15 years after Shenmue II's release, was it confirmed that a third game was in the works, aided by funding from Kickstarter backers, Sony, and publisher Deep Silver.

After numerous delays, Shenmue III was finally released in late 2019 to massively polarised reviews, some praising its faithfulness to the original style and tone while others knocked it for failing to revise the dated gameplay mechanics.

To the surprise of nobody paying attention, Shenmue III also failed to sell well outside of its core fanbase.

And while it's easy to suggest that Shenmue IV will come to life with the same crowdfunding efforts, given that Shenmue III left even some hardcore fans disappointed - especially with its laughably insulting cliffhanger ending - it's unlikely that the next sequel will muster the same enthusiasm.

If anyone can get a fourth game made it's probably franchise creator Yu Suzuki, the man who has willed a trilogy into existence so far, but given that Shenmue III fell short of expectations for many, this may well be all she wrote for the series.

3. Marvel's Avengers

The Marvel brand as a whole is so dominant across pop-culture right now that it truly does feel too big to fail, but impressively, Square Enix took quite the embarrassing stumble out of the gate with last year's Avengers game from Crystal Dynamics.

Advertisement

While on the surface it simply wasn't possible for a AAA live-service Avengers game to flop, underwhelming pre-release footage combined with lukewarm reviews ensured that sales quickly fell off a cliff after a strong start.

The underwhelming launch caused Square Enix to lose an estimated $63 million during the release window, and just recently company president Yosuke Matsuda confirmed the game to be a commercial disappointment.

Considering that Marvel's Avengers was supposed to be a Destiny-level commercial titan that would keep Square Enix well-minted for years with a sequel presumably releasing a few years on, it's looking like those plans are basically up in smoke.

Though Square Enix's recently released Guardians of the Galaxy game set in the same universe received much warmer reviews, its low concurrent player count on Steam during release week suggests sales will be relatively low, likely affected by Marvel's Avengers tainting the overall brand.

While it's likely that Square Enix will roll the dice on another Avengers game eventually, it seems like the cash cow has been mortally wounded.

2. Far Cry

Franchise fatigue is a very real thing - sometimes an IP just fails to provide enough stylistic, gameplay, and narrative innovation to keep players engaged, such that the critical and commercial reception begins a downward slide.

Advertisement

There's perhaps no greater example of a blockbuster IP just playing the played-out hits than Far Cry, which offers the most formulaic gameplay loop of any Ubisoft franchise - and that's really saying something.

Despite attempts in recent years to re-energise the stagnating brand with spin-offs like Far Cry Primal and Far Cry New Dawn, the just-released Far Cry 6 received the mainline series' worst reviews to date, many citing its frustrating willingness to recycle the same stale formula.

Far Cry 6 also released to underwhelming sales, posting 50% less digital sales than Far Cry 5 did in the UK, and while still sure to turn a profit for Ubisoft, seems to signify that players are finally growing tired of the series refusal' to offer substantial innovations.

Long-term, it's tough to imagine the series surviving much longer without some major refinements.

1. EFootball

The Pro Evolution Soccer franchise is one of the most lucrative video game IP of all time, though the release of 2019's game saw the franchise re-branded as "eFootball PES."

Advertisement

The recent follow-up, however, removed the PES branding entirely, which wouldn't be a bad thing were it not that eFootball 2022's release was an abject disaster.

The free-to-play football game was universally panned for its wonky, glitchy graphics and atrocious gameplay, such that it became the worst-rated game on Steam just a day after launch with a shocking 92% negative reviews.

Given that the game was monetised through in-game "premium" content, it's unlikely that few frustrated fans ended up giving Konami any money at all. And so, it's difficult to picture eFootball 2022 ever turning a profit.

While it's entirely possible the game could be whipped into shape with updates, Konami might be better off just focusing their energies on a relaunch with next year's title, because the damage done here - reputation-wise above all else - just seems too catastrophic to recover from.

Then again, it may well be that the franchise as a whole has been irreversibly damaged beyond redemption. It'd be a sad fate for a series that's been championed in the past for boasting superior gameplay to its more popular rival, FIFA.

Advertisement