10 Impactful Ways Hardcore Fans Ruin Video Games

They couldn't even let Mass Effect 3 end properly.

By Tom Baker /

If you are a gamer, you have an unprecedented amount of influence over your hobby of choice. Sure, it might seem that developers are living in their own little world and at times are actively trying to annoy you, or go against the wishes of the majority of the audience €“ take, for example, the wholly unsatisfactory ending to Mass Effect 3, which caused widespread internet outrage €“ but really, they'd do anything to please you €“ take, for example, BioWare's scrabbling to put out a new, better ending to Mass Effect 3. The internet has rallied fandoms like no convention or zine culture has ever managed before, and its influence is being felt in comic books (which are becoming more diverse and less sexist by increments), TV (Steven Moffat seems to run Doctor Who on the whims of his fans, and The Legend Of Korra recently made an audience-originated romantic pairing canon in the series finale). But nowhere is that audience or influence stronger than in video games. Despite having more in common with the movie industry in terms of huge budgets, dreams being crushed and profits wrought, video games are entirely beholden to fans. That's why they push to release stuff on the date set, even if it's not finished (unless it's Duke Nukem), why DLC artificially extends lifespans - and why careers are made or broken on Metacritic scores. That sounds like utopian vision of democracy, where the walls of capitalism are broken down so that creators and audience can converse on a level playing field and influence can go both ways, rather than gamers being as passive as moviegoers or book readers. In reality, it's a little more complex. Here are ten ways that fans ruin video games.

Advertisement

10. Expectations Can Never Be Met

Release dates are only malleable and changeable when you're a huge studio working on a huge title. Valve have still not announced Half-Life 3, because they know they don't have to until they're good and ready, and people will still buy it. Similarly, Batman: Arkham Knight has been delayed for almost a year at this point, but the series is such a hit gamers will buy it anyway. And yet, for the most part, release dates are otherwise taken as sacrosanct, written in stone and impossible to change. The immediate reason for this is because game studios are a business, and businesses predict profit margins and the like so they can better plan for their future, and the future of later games they plan to develop. So, release dates are important because, if not, it messes up the business. But the way it messes up is that people will be less likely to buy a game that's been delayed, which is an attitude that comes from the games-buying public. Which is why you end up with titles like Assassin's Creed Unity, which shipped with so many game-breaking bugs.

9. Resisting Criticism

The culture of video games is like no other. Sometimes than can be good, like the ability to wield influence over developers so they don't get away with dodgy things like spying on you from your always-on camera peripheral or ensure your every action is recorded by insisting your game can only be played when connected to the internet. Sometimes it can be bad, which is uniformly the case with GamerGate harassment campaign which is somehow still in existence. Besides being an opportunity for the grossest parts of gamer fandom to really flex their prejudices and to harness social media's unparalleled capacity for sending innocent people anonymous death threats, the very core of the GamerGate €œthing€ has a simple starting point: not Zoe Quinn's insane arse of an ex-boyfriend launching an attack on her, but the existence of Anita Sarkeesian. Sarkeesian is a cultural critic and gamer, whose Feminist Frequency video series has pointed out some sexist stuff in games. In a pop culture (and just culture) that's still a far way off from actual equality, that's not so wild. And she's not saying this makes the games bad, just it needs thinking about. And yet gamers reacted very poorly €“ the same gamers who fight for games as a viable art form, but resist the criticism inherent in all art forms.

8. Forcing Out Voices They Don't Like

The resistance of criticism and considered (and even not-so-considered) critique has the same cumulative effect that forcing out the voices that bring them up does. The GamerGate campaign means that there are dozens, if not hundreds, of mostly women in the games industry €“ developers, designers, journalists, fans €“ who have been scared off of the entire form, because it's not worth all the rape threats and bomb scares called into public appearances. What happens when you have an art form that nobody critiques? It becomes stagnant and, honestly, boring. Without a wide and diverse base of people making and talking about games, you create a sort of echo chamber which ensures no new ideas ever come through, and the gaming industry becomes endless sequels and copies of Call Of Duty and Watch Dogs. Besides being a horrible, nasty and just plain bad thing to do to specific people, by ignoring the voices of anyone who isn't a triple A studio fronted by some macho dudes who like shooting things means that you're limiting games. It means that new developments and breakthroughs have less chance of happening, and that's the fault of the audience.

7. Sales Can Make Or Break Careers

€œVoting with your wallet€ is a strategy that's been suggested to everyone from campaigners wanting tech companies and high street clothes retailers to stop relying on sweatshops, to people who don't like the idea of the new Human Torch being a black guy. In neither of those cases is it likely to have an effect, but in video games, everything is made or broken on the amount of sales a game gets. There's not much of a margin for error. Not that video game development is a zero-same deal, per se, but sales really do matter more than anything else. There are directors in Hollywood who manage to get by even without having huge hits, simply because there are some willing to fund artistic expression over commerce. That is not a infrastructure that currently exists in games, and may never exist. Just look at Ken Levine. He presided over the BioShock games, which were huge successes critically and commercially. Yet they didn't make enough to recoup the games' huge budgets, and his studio Irrational Games shut down. Loads of people lost their jobs. That's an extreme example, but if Levine can't make it work, what hope do smaller studios have if their games aren't mega hits?

6. Fans Don't Forgive, And They Don't Forget

It's not as simple as just making a good game, however. The people who market video games have almost as tough a job as the people who actually make it, because it's up to them that players actually want to spend money on their product. Which means they have to effectively control the conversation around their games, and they have an even tougher job that your average PR person working in other sectors of the entertainment industry. Spun the right way, Roman Polanski can continue to direct movies despite being a convicted child molester, you still like Brad Pitt even though he cheated on then-partner Jennifer Aniston with current beau Angelina Jolie, and everybody has conveniently forgot Sean Penn's past as a violent pr*ck who effectively kidnapped and tortured Madonna when she tried to dump him. In most cases, we forgive and forget everything from these actual crimes to actors making some crappy movies, or saying some mean things about our home town. Then they're free to carry on their careers. Not so with gaming, which sees studios close down because players didn't like a particular rushed sequel, or Dragon Age writers forced out of their jobs because of an interview quote.

5. Sycophancy Is Just As Damaging

On the other hand, it's equally as unhelpful for fans to just accept everything that gets shoved down their greedy throats. Whilst there are many who will jump on a perceived slight €“ either from an individual or by taking a less-than-great title way too personally €“ and boycott a developer into the ground, there is equally the side of gaming fandom which uncritically buys every single Grand Theft Auto or Call Of Duty sequel and demands it be called art. It's another form of voting with their wallets, and it has the same effect of eventually making every single game into either a grimy, grey, post-apocalyptic first-person-shooter or the latest FIFA update. The GTA franchise is a good example: a lot of the actual mechanics still suck, the stories are awful, and the level of humour in them is €œtwelve-year old trying to remember a South Park bit€. And yet Rockstar doesn't change any of these obvious problems, because people keep buying their titles without complaint, and it receives across the board positive reviews. And if it doesn't, the fans are more than ready to silence those critics €“ and voluntarily, too. Never pointing out flaws, even to be constructively critical, means that you get inferior products.

4. They Don't Allow For Nuance

You'll notice that video games are, by their nature, quite binary. You either win or lose, they're either good or bad, and that's an attitude that comes from computer programming and the tech industry in general. It's a mentality that's carried over into the stories you get in your average video game, which are almost always €œGOOD VS EVIL IN THE ULTIMATE BATTLE (and good will probably win)€, from the mythical Zelda to the militaristic COD. That's the conflict you get in most of your blockbuster movies as well, and it's not necessarily a bad thing. It only becomes a problem when that's literally the only sort of conflict you ever face €“ the average film goer has a wider palette than can encompass dramas without goodies and baddies, or even stories that delve into more complex morality €“ which is very much how it is with video games. It's also the way that people respond to video games, as either worth spending your time and money on or not. In films, you'll excuse a low budget effects and bad acting in horror flicks like The Evil Dead because charm and personality and interesting direction carry it through. That same level of nuance isn't applied to games, where a slight issue will mean the whole thing isn't worth bothering with. That's the same for games journalism, or with the fates of people like Microsoft's Adam Orth.

3. The Narrow Definition Of €œGame€

It's become quite clear at this point that video games have far outstripped their origins. The reason the €œgame€ part appeared in the title is because the earliest titles were exactly that €“ digital renderings of existing, real-life games, like Pong's monochrome approximation of tennis. And yet €œgame€ is a frustratingly narrow concept, necessitating a €œwinner€ and a €œloser€, a way to €œplay€ and accumulate points so that you can win. In games theory, those are called boolean win states. Win states are the binary, absolute results of your inputs into a game. In chess, your actions mean you win or lose. In Battlefield, you either kill someone or they kill you; it's game over, or you advance to the next level. Which is why so much of video games is about slaying your enemies, from Space Invaders right up until your modern FPS or even mushroom-squashing platformers. When a game dares to diverge from that set definition €“ like Gone Home, where you explore a deserted family home and play is more about piecing together a story; or the even more experimental Mountain, where the purpose seems to just be relaxation and meditation €“ they get derided as €œnot real games€. There's no win state. And yet again, isn't that just limiting what this art form can do?

2. They Don't Understand Games Development

The reason the €œethics in journalism€ angle of GamerGate has entranced so many is because there really is an issue with integrity amongst the games press €“ it just isn't a small-level Twine developer being pals with somebody from Kotaku who then mentions their game in passing. It's in the desperate tight-rope walk PR people run with journalists. Games journalists will not only get to see previews of games, they will also be wined and dined, taken on ludicrously expensive adventure holidays that tangentially tie into a game, and then will be served with a huge non-disclosure agreement that states what they can and can't say about a title, and even then they have to wait until the review embargo is lifted. If they don't agree, they get no review. But that's because reviews will decide whether people keep their jobs or not, and game development involves such a huge team of people that if it doesn't do well, it means HUNDREDS of lay-offs. And that's why review scores are so closely guarded: so people keep their jobs, because nobody is particularly sympathetic to a slightly naff game.

1. Everyone Is Scared Of Them

All of this can be boiled down to the core issue of gaming fandom, the way that the audience is actively making their chosen art form worse, day by day. Everyone is scared of them. Gamers wield so much power over the industry, over people's jobs, over people's personal and professional safety alike, over what new ideas are assimilated and which are discarded. It's not democracy, either, since it's the most powerful voices that drown out all others. Developers are entirely beholden to their audience, foregoing artistic expression in favour of placating fans. Every sequel is a head stroke, a confirmation that you were smart for buying the earlier titles and supporting this endeavour, now don't you deserve to be rewarded? It's understandable. Who wouldn't rather by the super-duper Battlefield action hero, rather than the troubled soldier of Spec-Ops: The Line, a game which openly chastises the player for being violent, yet giving them no other option to advance? You don't get to read critical reviews of titles because PR people try to keep a lid on them. That's because they know if the fans get wind a game isn't all that, word will spread, and the power of their wallets will make the game a failure, and they'll all lose their jobs. Developers literally change games thanks to outcry from fans, like Mass Effect 3. Being a devoted, passionate fan of something is the best thing in the world. What's less inspiring is when that passion means stunting the growth of the thing you love. How are finding the current gaming landscape? Let us know in the comments how much or little you agree!