10 Jaw-Dropping Video Game Fan Theories That Make Everything Better

Did you hear the one about Pokémon living together and fighting space aliens?

By Scott Tailford /

Nintendo

You'd think after spending thousands of hours across some of the greatest games of all time, we'd have seen everything the developers had to offer.

Advertisement

But what if some narrative elements, characters and worlds actually had incredible hidden messages and themes that connected them all together? There are some games - like the brutal mistress of Dark Souls - that thrive on such a thing, leading you through their labyrinthine worlds with barely a sniff of purpose or narrative.

Instead, we'll be focussing on incredibly successful games that nearly everyone has played or at least heard of, as those are the ones where we can assume the story being told was the most straightforward. For the most part, these titles have always been taken at face value, but the great thing about delving into fan theories is it opens up entire new perspectives on how our favourites are put together.

Advertisement

Adding an entire new element to the way you view something like Nintendo's loveable characters, or the cyber-enhanced world of Assassin's Creed, there's far more to these titles that meets the eye. In many cases, these potential alternate realities could easily be true, as they end up being far more enticing than the original premise anyway.

11. The World Of Pokémon Is Ravaged By War

Starting out with one of the most discussed Pokemon theories (of which there are many) and the actually extremely freaky realisation that the entire world you're walking around in has been the subject of a population-destroying war.

Advertisement

It might seem a bit strange that the joyously animated creatures and locales of Pokemon could have been privy to such an event, but you need only take stock of a few things before it starts making sense:

First up there's the fact that your character's father is never addressed whatsoever, instead your rival Gary (or whatever rude word you gave him) is an orphan who also never gets a background story either. In addition you'll notice when exploring Kanto that there are a huge amount of gyms and hospitals throughout such a very small area, with a distinct lack of males - aside from gym leaders or military personnel.

Advertisement

Why could this be? Well the best bit comes in conversation you'll have with gym leader Lt. Surge, where he exclaims that "electric Pokemon saved during the war!" In referencing some past event that seems to have completely devastated the vast majority of the male population, it appears to have left you without a father, as well as orphaning entire cities of children who take to the fields to catch Pokemon for something to do.

It's also worth pointing out that another popular theory going around is that Professor Oak actually created both yourself and Gary himself, adopting the latter and giving you away to a surrogate mother, knowing that some day you would resume your duties as a Pokemon catcher.

Advertisement

Only one childhood-destroying theory at a time though, right?

10. Metal Gear Solid 3: Creating A Time Paradox

Hideo Kojima's east-meets-west stealth-shooter has become the stuff of gaming legend, but for Snake Eater things went to a whole other level of weird - thanks to the likes of a man who shoots bees out his fingertips, another who can channel electricity, and an an ancient being who's spent so much time on the earth he's actually begun to photosynthesise. As you do.

Advertisement

Although it's one of the best games of all time, many series veterans already a bit perturbed by the vampires and octopus-armoured characters of MGS 2 thought this was a bit much. However, what if it was all a VR simulation? What if we were never actually embodying 1970's Naked Snake, and instead a modern day Solid? The evidence is subtle, but enough of it is there if you want to believe.

Remember if you failed a mission in a specific way, you'd get one of those 'Time Paradox' alerts? You even hear Colonel Campbell's voice shouting in out of the ether to mention you've done it wrong, despite the fact he's not even in the game.

Advertisement

This could easily be him shouting at Snake as he's jacked into some future machine the likes of which might exist in MGS 4's world. Secondly at the very start of the game we have Major Zero mentioning to Snake about the codename of the mission being the "Virtuous mission" to which Snake mishears as the "Virtual mission".

It's a tiny detail, but considering Kojima likes to treat the fourth wall like Zack Snyder does windows, chances are this is something he wanted us to ponder over forever more anyway.

Advertisement

9. Max Payne 3: The Ex-Cop Is A Ghost

When Rockstar took over development duties for the latest Max Payne it divided fans of the previous games in two:

Advertisement

On the one hand we now had the guys behind GTA taking on one of the most gruff, hard-ass characters of all time, but on the other it meant original developer Remedy were bowing out to work on something else.

What followed was a game that somewhat lost the personality of the first two, but gained a much harsher tale of drug violence and slow-motion face-shooting, wrapped up in a beautiful graphics engine and a very engaging story that crossed many different locales. Still, as they're known for in the GTA games, there's a whole heap of easter eggs within that eagle-eyed players managed to spot - but it wasn't always the most obvious that provoked online discussion.

Advertisement

In a hark back to the 'devil man' in Red Dead Redemption, MP3 also features a figure that many believe to be something of a ghost, or a figment of Max's imagination. One Anders Dedling - a relatively happy and family-loving ex-cop - turns up a few times in the main game's story, however even though during a firefight he locks himself inside a toilet cubicle, upon opening there's nobody inside.

Throughout the game Max is already in a very bad way, drinking heavily and taking large amounts of medication, so it's not too far of a stretch to imagine him talking to a version of himself that could have existed had the events of the first two games not driven him to the brink of death.

Advertisement

8. Mass Effect: Shepard Was Always Being Controlled From The Start

Most of the time when you start typing the words 'Mass' and 'Effect' into any number of search engines, you'll come across the Indoctrination Theory. However the most popular implementation of this is for the third game, as we were all grasping at straws looking for any information to explain that terrible ending.

Advertisement

Instead though, one very educated user has pieced together a theory predicated on the idea that Shepard never recovered his/her full sanity following the run-in with the Prothean beacon on Eden Prime. Now it seems like something of a reach being that very action is the thing that kickstarts some major events in the trilogy, but hear us out:

First up many will remember the conversations with the other aliens that have been indoctrinated in original game and how they describe the noises in their head as a 'scraping' sound, along with a lot of whispering buried underneath. Well if you listen carefully, that's exactly the same as what can be heard during Shepard's first trip, leading to the idea that the fact he ended up believing what he was seeing was purely down to the fact that he was being indoctrinated by the Protheans.

Advertisement

When you think about it, the very idea that Shepard - a militaristic individual regardless of your choice of origin - would just believe the crazy blur of imagery right in front of him is a bit suspect, and the idea of your actions being controlled by the Protheans as a planted motivation to take down the Reapers turns everything on its head.

It's all very Bioshock, but in a slight script-tweak this actually makes the universally-hated Starchild more of a potential overseer for the entire trilogy's events, rather than a last minute inclusion.

Advertisement

7. Assassin's Creed: Those Crazy Animus Conversations

Did you ever play Assassin's Creed, and just after taking down your target as you're chatting away to them you wonder; "Wait, why has the world around me completely stopped? How am I able to have a full conversation with a dying person, when just a few seconds ago I shot them from atop a roof, or ran in blades-first?"

Advertisement

Well, being that we're already in a virtual simulation it's mostly believed that these scenes are the Animus machine pausing the world, or establishing a connection between the user and the victim... or something. The problem is that this specific element of the game's premise is never fully explored. Instead we got entire halves of games devoted to playing as Desmond, milling around science labs and modern-day settings - never fully understanding exactly what the Animus is or does.

So what if these conversations never really happened? If we take the idea of the Bleeding Effect (where abilities transfer from the person being watched to the user in the Animus) and run with it, we know the machine can somehow harness DNA and transfer it to someone like Desmond.

Advertisement

A certain fan theory purports that because of this ability, the Animus is 'recreating' these conversations for the user alone - even though they didn't happen. Based purely off the idea of two people coming into contact with each other, DNA is transferred and stored between each person in any given scenario - which in this case would be the assassinations themselves.

It's weird that in a game whose lore now contains gods and ancient races, we still don't know how a core piece of machinery works, but this is a pretty cool way of looking at it.

Advertisement

6. Nintendo: All The Characters Live In The Same World

Nintendo have been referred to as 'the Pixar of gaming' multiple times, but another similarity that ties the two companies together is the fan-theory that all of their works are in the same universe.

Advertisement

Even though it's easy to look at something like Super Smash Bros. and assume it's just an excuse to throw every single known character together for a giant mash-up, what if this was the showdown for the ages of every character, battling it out to save their universe?

This very elaborate theory goes into an incredible amount of detail about how a Nintendo universe was created from scratch by Zelda's goddess Hylia. It then sprouted life that would become Pokémon - who would then gradually become more intelligent Planet of the Apes-style, turning into the Animal Crossing series.

Advertisement

It's all extremely enticing, especially when you factor in that Starfox could actually be one of these creatures after thousands of years of evolution, burning off around the galaxy to find more inhabitable worlds after his entire bloodline got sick of bartering with Tom Nook.

5. Limbo: You're The Villain

Okay okay, we said "make games better" but in this case 'better' might have to be 'slightly less depressing', as Playdead's incredibly beautiful (in a twisted, macabre sort of way) indie revolution-starting Limbo is one completely devoid of narrative exposition.

Advertisement

Instead it's an experience that's packed full of symbolism and interpretive imagery, leaving the story up to you. The main idea behind the whole thing is that you're a small boy who wakes up in a very dark, dank nightmarish world. You then set about moving forward, killing certain creatures along the way only to discover your sister at the end, before the screen goes blank.

The most obvious theory is that the entire game itself is this boy's version of purgatory, an idea supported by the fact that the game's final area mimics that of the opening, and as both the ending and intro contain fades out and in from darkness respectively, it's fairly easy to connect them together.

Advertisement

A more enticing theory though, is that throughout this nightmare the boy is actually the villain. Many of us were pretty disturbed by the way we had to dispatch the spider boss, ripping its legs off before then rolling the body through the woods to progress. In addition the theory suggests that the spider only wanted to restrain our character, as it acts as some sort of 'guardian' throughout this plane of existence - attempting to do so by encasing him in webbing at the start.

What if the boy actually caused his sisters death, and his journey through the world is one of anger and lashing out? The other children you come across in the world flee from you at every turn, and going off the fact the main menu shows two fly-covered graves, whatever happened to the boy and girl before they ended up in Limbo was definitely not pleasant.

Advertisement

4. The Legend Of Zelda: Its All One And The Same

Nintendo

Branching off from the previous theory about all the Nintendo franchises taking place within the same world, it's easier to focus on just the Zelda series as evidence for this.

Advertisement

Although the major Mario games have remained fairly similar in their graphical stylings (forgoing spin-offs like Paper Mario), Zelda has seen everything from the extremely cute minimalist aesthetic of Wind Waker, to the more realistic-looking Twilight Princess.

However, what if these striking graphical changes were the result of "The Legend of Zelda" being retold across different generations, in different cultures?

Advertisement

When you retell campfire stories, part of the fun is embellishing certain aspects and exaggerating them for your audience, but at the core of this story we always have a small magical boy on an adventure, who wields a sword and shield, wears a green costume, and fights monsters. Lots of fans have different favourite games specifically because of these huge aesthetic differences, but with this perspective it all comes together quite nicely.

In addition some have theorised that the Zelda series actually becomes that of Mario, being that across time, events and details get distorted when told by word of mouth. If the only things that remained were tales of adventurers who wore green and red (Link's costumes/ Mario and Luigi's uniforms), as well as descriptions of fantastical lands that ended in thwarting big demons such as Ganondorf or Bowser, it's a great way to bring the two together.

Advertisement

Even Breath of the Wild's islands and various locations being named after characters - rather than remaining as characters themselves - only supports this.

3. Silent Hill 2: James' True Horror

One of the best horror franchises in gaming hit its defining high point with part two, where not only was the atmosphere and art direction incredibly effective at conveying the dilapidated town of Silent Hill itself, but we also got one total zinger of a plot twist along the way.

Advertisement

In addition to the realisation that you actually brought all of this on yourself after murdering your own wife and repressing the memory, many fans have assumed that as we never see such a thing, the body of Mary is nowhere near us throughout the game.

However, a truly horrifying idea - that was later half-confirmed by one of the team Masahiro Ito - is that Mary's body was in the trunk of your car the whole time. Ito's twist on the popular theory was that it was actually in the backseat, only James couldn't see it due to his level of repression around his actions.

Advertisement

Although the game features multiple endings, the 'In Water' version has James state that "now can be together" by driving into the lake and committing suicide. What this could really mean is that following the revelations throughout the game, he's now aware of where Mary really is, making that their final resting place.

2. Metal Gear Solid: Twin Snakes - Otacon Imagines All The Crazy Stuff

Thousands of Metal Gear fans were (and continue to be) utterly outraged at the fact the re-released version of the original Metal Gear Solid only ever made an appearance on the Gamecube.

Advertisement

Yeah we know the original Metal Gear's saw the light of day on the NES, but come on Kojima, why not give us a Sony version? Regardless, one of the biggest differences between the original and the remake is the direction of the cutscenes. Where before we had Snake take a rocket launcher to the roof of a tower to confront his brother, who was inside a helicopter gunship. Instead, on the GC version Liquid Snake actually lets fly a rocket in Snake's direction, to which he manages to backflip onto, only to launch himself back off and fire another missile back at the gunship, destroying it.

Advertisement

It was a completely ludicrous scene that to be honest would almost work in the world's of MGS2 or 3 with either Vamp or The Fear on acrobat duties. As it stood here though, many fans of the slightly more 'realistic' sensibilities of the original were utterly put off.

However, the saving grace is that thanks to a certain fan theory purporting to the idea that due to how much Otacon idolises Snake, the whole thing is him imagining how the battle played out, based off his interaction with Snake, and the way the scenes are introduced and edited.

Advertisement

There's no other information to support this other than just the want to believe it, but hey, it definitely makes everything okay again - at least until the next ridiculous thing happens and Otacon's nowhere to be found.

1. Final Fantasy VII: Aeris Wasn't Supposed To Die

Remember that artwork inside the Final Fantasy VII instruction booklet, with Aerith looking up at the flying ship Highwind? That never actually happens in the game, but why is that?

Advertisement

Could it be that the life-scar of an entire generation - the moment that changed evil villain Sephiroth from a total badass to someone who just had to be stopped - wasn't actually part of the game in the first place?

As has been compiled in many places online, there's a multitude of evidence that points to the idea that everyone's favourite Ancient was supposed to remain a part of your team all the way through. From things like the final battle area having an empty stone section where Aeris could have stood, to a certain conversation with Tifa mentioning how she was convinced Aeris would return, it seems like the decision to kill her off was added after the majority of the rest of the game was completed.

Advertisement

The aforementioned scene with the Highwind is actually sketched out in the instruction booklet too, giving away that maybe she was going to go all Gandalf the Grey on us and emerge as a resurrected version all along.

Still, we applaud Square for taking the risk and killing off one of the most loveable characters in gaming history, as even if it was done last minute it's one of many reasons everyone remembers FF7 so fondly.

Advertisement