10 Least Imaginative Pokémon From Generation I
"Are they even trying anymore?"
Behold, the Genwunner - the special brand of Pokémon fan who only played the Generation I games and vehemently lambasts any Pokémon from any generation that succeeded it. Observe how superior they believe themselves to be as they condemn Klefki and the Vanillite line. "A key ring? An ice cream cone?!" they grumble with disgust to anyone who will listen. "Whatever happened to great Pokémon like Charizard and Pikachu?"
How soon we forget...
Look, most Pokémon fans understand that Generation I gave us some of the best and most nostalgic character designs in the franchise, such as Gengar, Jolteon, and Arcanine. But what about some of those other Pokémon; the ones that so few of us cite as we don our nostalgia goggles? You know, like Magnemite, the magnet Pokémon? Or perhaps we'll mention Mr. Mime, the terrifying clown man masquerading as a Pokémon? Or what about Jynx, the once-racist humanoid... opera singer? Thing?
Alright, nobody really knows what Jynx is.
Point is, for all the awesome Pokémon that we remember from our childhoods, there were plenty of lame or underwhelming ones as well. So, let's stick it to that haughty Genwunner from paragraph one and look at a few...
10. Exeggcute
Exeggcute is lower on this list than some may have expected because it's a bit misunderstood. The reason for that is that there isn't a definitive consensus on what Exeggcute is supposed to be.
This ambiguity surrounding Exeggcute's identity dates all the way back to Pokémon Red and Blue, in which the Pokédex says that it is "often mistaken for eggs". Yet, in Ruby and Sapphire, it says that Exeggcute "consists of six eggs that form a closely knit cluster". While many of its Dex entries reference it having a shell (like egg), Pokémon FireRed was the first game to suggest that Exeggcute is actually "more like plant seeds"... with eyes.
It could also be based on coconuts (with eyes), as they are regularly hunted by Crabrawler in Alola and coconut crabs are a thing. It could also be a reference to eggplants (with eyes), even though they don't look anything like eggplants.
But regardless of what they actually are, Exeggcute is just a pile of six eggs/seeds/coconuts/eggplants with eyes, and that's a pretty unimaginative design.
9. Farfetch'd
Fun fact - did you know that Farfetch'd is based on a Japanese saying, which translates to "a duck comes bearing green onions" and refers to something unexpected yet convenient? Yeah. Take that to the water cooler tomorrow.
Anyway, Farfetch'd is unimaginative not because it's based on an idiomatic expression that is completely foreign to the western world, but because it's not much more than a cartoon duck holding a leek. The only thing that separates it from an actual duck is its "angry eyebrows," but even that does little to differentiate it from any old duck.
By now, it's become evident that this list is composed of two different subsets of Pokémon - those that are just normal objects with eyes on them, and those that look more like regular animals than they do "Pocket Monsters". Consider Farfetch'd among the latter of those two.
8. Fearow
Much like Farfetch'd, Fearow's design doesn't really suggest "this is more than just a cartoonish depiction of a bird".
While not specifically based on any in particular, it does borrow characteristics of many different birds, such as storks, cormorants, and anhingas. Strangely enough, those last two birds are water birds, yet the only Water-type move that Fearow can learn is Rain Dance.
Adding Water-typing to Fearow could have been the solution to its mediocrity. Having spent its entire fictional existence playing second bananas to the much-cooler Pidgeot, Fearow would likely welcome a different type combination to set it apart from its long-feathered rival. Perhaps a Mega Evolution or a Galarian Form is in order for Fearow? After all, Pidgeot got one, so it's only fair.
But until that day, which may never come, Fearow is doomed to live a humdrum life of blandness; a life of neglect in favor of more appealing and more useful Flying-types. It's not easy being boring.
7. Electrode
Electrode also ranks lower than expected on this list because the Pokéball, in and of itself, is an innovative design. Plus, the idea that there are Pokémon that look like pick-up items but are actually sentient, exploding balls of death.
That being said, it's just an upside-down Pokéball with eyes.
Electrode earns a spot on this list over its pre-evolution, Voltorb, because it does little to nothing to improve upon Voltorb's design. Yes, Voltorb is just a Pokéball with Haunter's eyes, but again, the Pokéball is a creative design on its own. For Electrode, all they did was turn Voltorb upside down, make its eyes smaller, and add a s**t-eating grin to its bottom half.
There was so much they could have done with Electrode. They could have made it quadripedal and given it collapsible robotic legs, or they could have had the two sides of the "Pokéball" split and make them part of its metallic arms, like a precursor to Tapu Koko. Either way, it would've still been able to disguise itself as a Pokéball, but it would've been more appealing and less lazy.
Maybe someday, Electrode can get a more inspired Mega or Galarian form. I suppose we can only hope.
6. Geodude
Objectively speaking, Geodude is an uninspired design.
It's nothing more than a floating rock with a face and arms. Its name is similarly noncreative because it basically just means "earth guy" or "ground guy". There's arguably not another Rock-type in the game that's this basic overall, so Genwunners would have had a field day with Geodude if Game Freak had introduced it in a different generation.
"Hah-hah! It's just a Pet Rock!" they'd chortle as they sip from their respective bottles of Mountain Dew.
Anyway, I will concede that Geodude was quite charming in the anime and that its final evolution, Golem, is awesome, but that doesn't change the fact that Geodude's design is incredibly simplistic. Also, Geodude and its evolution, Graveler, can be real f**king annoying in caves.
Seriously, stop self-destructing and killing my Pokémon.
5. Seel
First and foremost, its name is "Seel". It's just a misspelled version of the animal it's based on (a baby harp seal, to be specific). I mean, what if they released a Gen VIII dolphin Pokémon called "Dolfin"? Genwunners would have a field day with that, all while blissfully ignoring the existence of Seel.
It's just a goofy-looking seal with a horn on the top of its head (which might be a reference to narwhals, but they deserve their own Pokémon, not some narwhal/seal hybrid). Sure, Dewgong isn't much better in that it's just a misspelled version of "dugong," which is an animal that is closely related to manatees. But Dewgong is pretty elegant and looks more like a sea lion than it does a dugong, so it gets a pass.
But Seel? Seel inspires so little imagination in the player. Using Seel feels like trying to fight monsters with a real-life baby seal, leaving the player questioning their morality.
4. Ekans
It's the word "snake" backwards... that's it. That's all there is to say about Ekans. Next page.
...alright, fine, I'll say more about Ekans:
Ekans doesn't have much that differentiates it from a regular rattlesnake. It's completely fine to base Pokémon on animals, as long as they have characteristics and traits that make them unique from those animals. Take, for example, Beedrill. Beedrill is very clearly a bee, but it has spear-like arms and red eyes that say, "hey, I may be a bee, but I mean business".
But Ekans? Ekans is just a snake.
While its evolution, Arbok, is just a big cobra that spells "Kobra" backwards, it has this menacing purple color and this large, face-like pattern in the scales of its hood. Arbok looks like a genuine "Pocket Monster," while Ekans looks like a regular old garter snake that you found while gardening.
3. Dugtrio
"Wait, why is Dugtrio here and not Magneton?" Well, before you go calling me a hypocrite, understand that Magneton makes sense as an evolution because magnets link to one another.
But how the hell does Dugtrio make any sense? It's just three Digletts. Are they connected? And if so, how? Are the heads stuck together? Are they intertwined with one another beneath the dirt? On that note, what's going on under the ground? Is it just a mole body? Is it three bodies? So many questions surrounding Dugtrio remain unanswered.
The only reason that it doesn't rank higher is that Diglett is a somewhat imaginative and cute mole-based creature. But they could have done a lot more to improve upon its design upon evolving. Like, I don't know... letting it come out from underground? Giving it large arms or claws?
Anything else would have been more inventive than what they came up with.
2. Krabby
I shouldn't have to say much more than this, but Krabby's Japanese name is literally just "Crab". No funky spellings - just "Crab".
Looking at Krabby, it's easy to see why Japanese developers didn't see much of a need to come up with a creative name for it because... well, it's just a crab. Nothing more, nothing less.
Of all the "it's just a [blank]" Pokémon out there, Krabby is absolutely the least original. It's basically the end result of asking a college animation student to draw a crab. It's so uncreative that it leaves this author struggling to think of many things to say about it. I mean, what does one say about a cartoon crab?
Sure, Kingler is also a cartoon crab, but at least it has that "one giant claw" gimmick going on. Krabby is just a crab. A red and tan crab. That's all.
1. Muk
Muk earns its place on the top of this list almost solely because of how often Genwunners trash Trubbish and Garbodor (pun definitely intended). They say, "a garbage Pokémon? Really?! God, they're really running out of ideas, huh?"
How easily they forget Muk, who is just a disgusting pile of sludge with a face.
Grimer is excluded for essentially the same reason as Voltorb - while both designs lack ingenuity overall, their evolutions did nothing to improve upon them. In Muk's case, it's just a bigger, more pissed-off Grimer.
How anyone can earnestly claim that Muk is a more imaginative Pokémon than Garbodor is beyond comprehension. At least Garbodor expanded upon Trubbish's design. At least Garbodor gave itself new arms, hands, and feet. Can Muk claim that? No, it cannot. It just took everything Grimer had and increased its size, like a PhotoShop novice trying to make themselves look taller.
In conclusion, I'd like to pose a question to Game Freak - what are you even doing anymore? A pile of s**t Pokémon?! What's next - a Water-type that's just pee?! Whatever happened to awesome Pokémon like Decidueye, Salazzle, and Golisopod? Now those are REAL Pokémon!
...doesn't feel so good, does it, Genwunners?