10 Legendary Nintendo Characters We're All Sick To Death Of

Nintendo experienced mammoth success with the Wii and DS, yet we're getting sick of many of the characters who continuously grace the box art of the next sequel or spinoff that are utterly predictable.

By Jon Negroni /

You may have recently heard about Nintendo's woes concerning sales for the Wii U. They were bad enough for the CEO Satoru Iwata to issue an official apology (which included a formal bow) and the cutting of his own salary in half, along with salary cuts for some board members. This is coming off a great run Nintendo experienced through the mammoth success of the Wii console and the evolving DS, but many of us worry that the company is beginning to fade into irrelevancy. Microsoft and Sony have utterly demolished the Wii U in terms of sales and cultural impact, whilst mobile gaming continues to drive nails into the coffin of handheld devices like the 3DS. Amid all of this bad news lies the fact that many of us are simply getting sick of Nintendo games. Specifically, we're getting sick of many of the characters who continuously grace the box art of the next sequel or spinoff that has come to be expected, especially with the latest new console already being a year old. We've listed some of the most well-established heroes, you'll find that their problems vary but the solution to revitalising the Nintendo pantheon really comes down to some clever risk-taking and even gutting of some played-out games.

10. Samus Aran

It saddens me that circumstances are forcing me to include Samus Aran on this list. For decades, she's actually served as one of the few beacons of hope within Nintendo's arsenal; an example of the rewards gamers bestow upon studios when they decide to actually take risks with character development. Samus has always been a lightning rod for surprising turns. The reveal that the space-suited hero you had been playing as in the first Metroid was actually a woman took everyone by surprise, and empowered a new generation of female gamers. Since then, the Metroid franchise reinvented the gaming mechanics to bring us Metroid Prime, a huge risk that shifted gameplay to a first-person perspective. It paid off quite well. There have been 11 games in total, but it only took one to completely sour our experience with the wickedly-cool bounty hunter. Metroid: Other M ruined the character of Samus by giving her a character that was the complete opposite of the cool, unattached bravado we had always assigned to the masked hero. By giving her a (terrible) voice, Nintendo managed to undo the decades of progress they made with a character we now have to only partly love.

9. Link

He may not be the most famous Nintendo character, but he is probably the most critically-acclaimed thanks to The Legend of Zelda being held by many to be one of the greatest games of all time, along with other great entries like Ocarina of Time. Another thing Link has going for him is the fact that Nintendo has frequently changed up his character design a bit throughout the games, most noticeably in-between the games Windwaker and Twilight Princess. Still, one thing Nintendo seems incapable of is reinventing the personality of Link, as well as the experience of actually playing as him. His character changes little from game to game, and the games always feature the same objectives and basic story-structure throughout, albeit with some cool tweaks to make sure the game sells well. Though Skyward Sword continued this tradition of moving the same character types to a new-ish setting, we're ready for something akin to the shift in style we experienced in Metroid Prime, perhaps by throwing the Zelda storyline into a completely new era. I would even settle for the addition of an interesting story mechanic similar to the time-bending concept of Ocarina of Time (that's way more interesting than the whole "turning-into-a-wolf" thing).

8. Kirby

Kirby has always been one of the most fascinating to me, if only because of the unique fun derived from the gameplay. With the exception of Megaman, I can't think of any other game that expertly uses a copy ability to move a game forward and keep it interesting to the very end. Unfortunately, Nintendo has done literally nothing else with the character or the games. The closest they got to "revolutionising" the formula was with Kirby's Epic Yarn, which was a fun and beautiful game that expertly made us aware of how it came to be ("Well guys, we turned Mario into paper...I guess we could turn Kirby into yarn?). The main reason I'm sick of Kirby has nothing to do really with the actual games. I'm just sick of trying to care for a character that is so one-dimensional. Of all of the top-tier Nintendo characters, Kirby has to be the most indifferent to anything resembling a personality or foundation for things like motivation or even courage. He's just...there. This was fine about 15 games ago, when we were just focused on how fun it was to eat our enemies and gain power from their blood or something. But when you decide to throw the same character at us each year, you should at least give him something to say.

7. Wario

Wario's rise to becoming one of Nintendo's most recognisable characters is a fascinating tale rife with sheer luck and some brilliant game mechanics. Most notable was the decision to make him invincible in his early games and then completely transition the game into a comedic funhouse of minigames. I have a lot of nice things to say about Wario, but one thing that has really brought him down is Nintendo's decision to essentially sideline him. He went from being an interesting antihero/villain to becoming a silly mascot for decent minigames. As a result, I cringe every time I see the once promising Nintendo character being ambiguously evil in Mario Party or Super Smash Bros. The main problem is that Wario hasn't had his own game (aside from WarioWare) in about six years, as WarioLand was essentially abandoned for unclear reasons. It's tragic because these were his best games in my opinion, and they gave us a much more interesting look into the character of Wario without having to compare him to his long-time rival and sometimes villain, Mario.

6. All Of The Miis

Miis aren't legendary in the sense that they're among the best Nintendo characters, but they are still major additions to what made Nintendo stand out during the last console war with the Wii. Using Miis as personalised characters to accompany almost every Wii lifestyle game was marketing genius, as it opened up the doors for a casual gaming market that revitalised Nintendo's brand image and profits...for a while. The problem came when we got embarrassingly tired of seeing these odd, misshapen characters every time we powered up our Nintendos. This became even more excruciatingly painful when Nintendo got it in their heads to just start making fully-fledged games that were completely Mii-centric, down to the game's box art. At this point, seeing any game that features Mii gameplay is enough for me to determine it as code for "don't play this shoddy, pandering mess of a game that probably got a score of 5 on GameInformer." If Nintendo was smart, they would have rebranded the Miis' image and likeness in order to convince people that buying the Wii U was actually worth their time. Instead, they basically did nothing except make Miis just as ubiquitous on the Nintendo DS.

5. Pikachu

We probably would have gotten less annoyed at Pikachu over the years if game makers hadn't decided that "Pikachu" was the only phrase he's capable of uttering, leaving you readers to now have that dreaded phrase ringing in your ears right about now. I don't mind the fact that Pokemon settled on Pikachu for its mascot. From a business perspective, Pikachu is still the most recognisable Pokemon in the world, making him the ideal choice for remaining a crucial aspect of the Pokemon series, as far as gaming goes. The problem, however, is that they won't let the character make a decent exit from the TV series. I know we're just talking about games here, but many young and even old fans of Pokemon still tune into the concurrent show, despite its lack of anything resembling quality. On the show, Pikachu is still trudging along as the sidekick to the world's most immortal 10 year old. That said, it's time for Nintendo to find a new Pokemon to push as one of its mascots from the slew of somewhat-cool characters that are churned out with each new release.

4. Bowser

Considered by many to be the greatest video game antagonist of all time, Bowser has been in almost as many Nintendo games as his greatest foe, the legendary Mario. But he's changed little throughout the years, as he is always the hot-tempered, fire-breathing lizard-turtle that is obsessed with princess-snatching. As much as I like his character and the classic, visual style of this cool-looking villain, the time has come for Bowser to take a break. Aside from Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story (a handheld game), Bowser has been completely played out as the archetypal video game villain the he actually helped to establish. An alternative to outright nixing him from future titles is to give him the Wario treatment and let us actually play as him. Exploring the character of Bowser and his unique family dynamics that we've seen with Bowser Jr. would be much more enticing than having to watch him lose - yet again - to the red plumber. Also, the return of Giga Bowser would be an event that almost every Nintendo lover would line up for, just as long as he maintains his epic size and grotesque looks.

3. Donkey Kong

In some ways, the Donkey Kong franchise has done almost everything right. Spin-offs, like the rhythm games, have been playful distractions that stay true to the tradition of the lovable gorilla and his jungle world. With the exception of the overall-boring racing series, the games have done well to branch off in fun avenues, while still providing us with core games from the Donkey Kong Country series. In fact, the upcoming Donkey Kong game, Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze, shows off the latest attempt to spice up the franchise by changing the setting aesthetic and introducing viking-like characters as fitting antagonists. The problem is that the critical success of the last game Donkey Kong Country Returns, means that we're in store for many more sequels and spinoffs similar to Tropical Freeze. As much as I like DK, I can't say I feel the same way about his pals (except for Diddy, of course). This makes me tire of the silent hero for the same reason Kirby makes me roll my eyes whenever I see him. There's just no heart to his character, and I have no reason to care about DK or his gang of cool-looking-yet-shallow misfits.

2. Pokemon Trainer/Ash

As I stated earlier when talking about Pikachu, this kid is immortal (and I'm not just talking about Ash Ketchum). The entire story arc of an innocent Pokemon trainer achieving his destiny by becoming a Pokemon master has been completely played out, to the point where the TV series - where Ash still hasn't achieved his goal in two decades - is almost a parody of itself, at least in my eyes. Some Pokemon games have actually managed to get away from this archaic formula, with concepts introduced in Pokemon Stadium and Pokemon Colosseum. The latter is a game many of us want Nintendo to revisit, as it featured a protagonist with an agenda aside from winning gym badges or taking pictures on rails in a park. It hurts to think about the amazing potential a Pokemon game would have if you played as a villain, or even grunt member of the infamous Team Rocket. The world of Pokemon is filled with awesome content for developers to shape a game around, yet they continue to focus on mildly fun adventures we've already had over a dozen times.

1. Mario

I've tried really hard not to get sick of Mario over the years. He's the most recognisable video game character of all time and the reason video games are a cultural success with triple-A titles being distributed to a hungry audience each year. We owe the red plumber a lot for his contribution to making video games a mainstream success. But we're so sick of him. After 200 (two hundred) games, he's become a bit of a running joke for excessive job-hunting. He's been everything from a doctor to a paper aeroplane (seriously), with spinoffs and sequels veering off into yet more spinoffs and sequels with every console generation. We've honestly had enough. We've explored every facet of this character within the consistent paradigm of Nintendo gameplay and storytelling. We need either a break from Mario, or something radically different, though that seems impossible to achieve. The last Mario game to shake things up at least a little bit was Super Mario Galaxy, which utilised gameplay mechanics that made sport of gravity-based physics and beautiful graphics. The fun RPG aspects of the Mario & Luigi series has also been a significant step forward for the character, especially during these times when Mario himself doesn't constantly steal the spotlight. Are there any Nintendo characters you're sick of? Let us know in the comments.