10 Lessons Pokémon Needs To Learn From Palworld

Palworld is a better GAME than Pokémon, but will Nintendo listen?

By Joe Pring /

Nintendo and The Pokémon Company's intent to investigate any potential case for plagiarism in light of Palworld's release has become the opening act of 2024's inevitable list of gaming controversies.

Advertisement

On a superficial level, the two IPs couldn't be more different. Pocket Pair's spontaneously popular title bills itself, first and foremost, as a survival affair, while Game Freak's iconic mainline games have always adhered strictly to the realms of traditional RPG. A chasm separates the two genres' intricacies. Yet, the former has unquestionably taken substantial inspiration from Pokémon, far beyond aping Game Freak's character designs to give its titular 'Pals' life.

The trouble is that many of the components that make up Palworld's irresistible whole are superior to what inspired them.

From creature companions that prove more useful and lively outside of battle, to a user interface that riffs on Pokémon's largely unchanged presentation while boasting vastly expanded accessibility.

Such disparity in quality beggars belief when one IP is barely a month old and the other has been going for over two decades.

But it's not all a 1:1 affair.

Palworld follows suit with its contemporaries in providing all of the basics one would expect of a game released in 2024. That it shares DNA with Pokémon has simply made it a catalyst for change.

Better multiplayer, an open ear to the community, and acceptable technical performance are improvements Pokémon is in desperate need of before we start talking about giving Trainers AK-47s as companion pieces to a Charizard.

10. Expanded Interaction

Pokémon doesn't need to wholesale lift everything that works about its fierce competitor. Shoehorning survival mechanics - namely base-building - into the former isn't necessary or even desired, but being able to utilize hard-earned creatures when they're not actively battling in your name is an opportunity-gap that Game Freak has failed to ever capitalize on.

Advertisement

That's not to say the studio hasn't tried to give unused 'mons a purpose besides filling up space in the PC, but having them potter around aimlessly while you're testing sandwich recipes ain't it. There are already plenty of accompanying systems in the mainline franchise that serve only to waste time, so why not enable the player to utilize their private army to carry out menial tasks?

Instead of making berries and raid dens a manual affair, expand the Day Care system and let the Trainer leave unimportant or unused 'Mons with NPCs so they can passively accrue resources while their master is out in the wider world adventuring and battling. Considering how long it can take to accrue items necessary for training competitive Pokémon such as Bottle Caps and vitamins, Game Freak would do us all a solid by introducing some sort of minigame centered around the storage PC that allows inactive catches to supplement both without requiring constant input from the player.

9. Functional Multiplayer

Multiplayer in every Pokémon game (where it's present) is sporadically thrilling on one hand and frustratingly obtuse on the other.

Advertisement

The excuse that Game Freak doesn't have the expertise or know-how to implement such systems doesn't fly anymore. Perhaps it's a result of Nintendo's stubborn refusal to have a more open online platform compared to its competitors, but archaic friend codes and antiquated net code only serve as a constant headache. You'd be forgiven for thinking these are purposefully user-unfriendly to discourage sharing your Pokéadventure with others.

Palworld does what any other developer with sense does. It gives players the agency to decide whether they want to allow randos or friends to join their game on the fly without having to deal with egregious loading times, error messages, and a constant requirement to input codes just for the privilege of seeing another human's avatar.

8. Linearity

Fair's fair — Scarlet and Violet made great strides in giving players the freedom to choose how they progress in its world, but the façade quickly fell apart when it became apparent that difficulty scaling was non-existent. 

Advertisement

Sure, you could go straight to the eighth gym, artificially handicap yourself with an under-levelled team, and succeed with enough guile and perseverance, but you wouldn't be able to use that very same line-up you've become attached to in the first gym without absolutely trumping it with zero effort.

Palworld's sandbox nature enables it to naturally sidestep this issue and, truthfully, Game Freak has already succeeded in offering a similar experience outside of the mainline franchise. Pokémon Legends: Arceus did a tremendous job of reining in the series' tendency to handhold; smushing together the best of both worlds would allow for a more organic experience akin to Palworld without resorting to straight-up derivation.

7. More Animated Pokémon

There are 1025 Pokémon to Palworld's paltry 113 Pals.

Advertisement

Naturally, expecting Game Freak to individually animate that many characters with bespoke movements and attacks isn't feasible but then again, it has no need to do so. A great deal of natural overlap already exists across Pokémon's thousands of different species, they're just not all of a modern standard. A reliance on turn-based combat (more on that later) has made Game Freak complacent, not seeing the necessity of revisiting antiquated animations lifted from older titles in the 3D era when core combat remains largely the same.

Scarlet and Violet, as well as the pair's predecessors, got rid of random encounters and had Pokémon frolic in the overworld, so the right decisions are already being made on that front. The only foible worth scrutinizing there is a desire to see these sprites engage in other activities beyond just wading through grass without aim.

Pokémon Snap does a terrific job of showcasing how different species would behave when humans aren't around. The inspiration is already there. Why not take full advantage of it?

6. Performance

Palworld doesn't boast perfect performance by any stretch of the imagination but for now, at least, any issues players are encountering are forgivable while it remains in early access.

Advertisement

But even ignoring this, Pokémon has over 20 years of history and Game Freak, no stranger to developing for Nintendo-owned hardware, doesn't have such a luxury. Despite claiming that it needed time to get to grips with porting the mainline franchise from full-fledged handhelds (à la the DS family of consoles) to the Switch, Scarlet and Violet arrived in 2022 in a worse state than 2019's Sword and Shield. Comical bugs (pictured), a frame rate slower than molasses, and crashes aplenty resulted in a justified furor among the fan base expecting more from a company owned by a multi-billion dollar corporation.

While the two games cater to different audiences in several aspects, the comparison even being made should be the powerful kick in the backside. Game Freak needs to know that other developers are going to come along and deliver surrogate alternatives that run and perform better if it doesn't buck its ideas up.

5. Raid-Like Content That Doesn't Suck

Pocket Pair is still putting the finishing touches on proper raids for Palworld but even in its fledgling state, existing overworld boss fights are far superior to Pokémon's Raid Dens/Dynamax Raids, not least because they're actually integrated into the world organically instead of being walled off behind egregiously long loading times. Likewise, Palworld allows free movement around each arena which, while not revolutionary by any means, allows for a more interactive and cinematic feel to each encounter instead of being forcibly rooted in one spot like a lemon.

Advertisement

Contrary to the above, what Pokéfans get instead, is a series of static crystals littered around Paldea that, when interacted with, whisk you off to a loading screen to deal with Scarlet and Violet's obtuse multiplayer systems before a 'raid' can even kick off. There's no freedom to how you approach a battle, either, and the godawful Terastal system makes the copy-and-paste feature from Sword and Shield somehow less inspiring than before. No other singular portion of the series better puts forward the case in favour of real-time Pokémon combat.

If nothing else, its inclusion would solve the exasperating desynch issues that make it impossible to gauge how much health a raid boss has remaining thanks to turns between players consistently being taken out of order.

4. Player Agency

No, Pokémon doesn't need guns.

Advertisement

What it does need, on the other hand, is more ways to have Trainers engage in encounters to help tip the scales in their favour when it comes to battling other opponents and wild Pokémon. You are, after all, resigned to standing on the sidelines and barking orders at your teammate whenever any sort of conflict emerges, which makes little sense, especially as we've seen in spin-off media and games that this doesn't need to be the case.

Simple it may be, but Pokémon Go, while forfeiting the ability to engage in battle with wild Pokémon, adds variety to encounters by allowing players to trigger modifiers through the use of berries. Likewise, Legends: Arceus adds an element of danger by making it possible for the player character to take damage from aggressors. These are wild animals, after all. Why would you adhere to the rules of a gym battle when your mission is to catch or defeat your prey via any means necessary?

3. The Option Of Real-Time Combat

The ol' Catch-22. Does Game Freak give in to the requests for real-time Pokémon combat at the risk of alienating others? Or does it go the whole hog and consider the latter collateral damage in the name of bringing the mainline series into the 21st century? There's a reason why turn-based combat fell out of common use over a decade ago. It's an antiquated approach to combat necessitated by limited hardware. Even Octopath Traveler and Persona, which have opted to carry the torch, have found other means of spicing up the status quo.

Advertisement

Conversely, if the decision to retain turn-based trappings is final, there's still ample opportunity to spice up the formula. Sega's Like A Dragon: Infinite Wealth showcases this better than any by giving the player multiple moving pieces to think about during battle, namely movement and positioning. Both are fantastic accompaniments proven to enhance turn-based gameplay.

The to-and-fro of taking turns to select options from a menu and watching them play out after the fact leads to a level of disconnect desperately lacking in engagement. Change takes time, though, and there's no reason why Game Freak couldn't retain its existing combat as an option while championing a brand-new way to play for existing generations as well as those to come.

2. Deliver On Long-Awaited UI Improvements

How difficult, truly, can it be to introduce a method of filtering between owned Pokémon with varying parameters? Why, dear Game Freak, are we forever resigned to having to sift through hundreds of catches in search of a single individual when said database could contain multiple of the same Pokémon that, at a glance, look completely identical?

Advertisement

Admittedly, Palworld doesn't have to accommodate for over a thousand different species but that's neither here nor there. Niantic has proved perfectly capable of providing an option to sort 'Mons by power level, type, and date of acquisition with Pokémon Go, so if said options are available on mobile, there's little justifiable reason why Game Freak can't follow suit on the markedly more powerful Switch. Likewise, even Pokémon Home, official software intended to house gigantic collections hailing from multiple generations, provides more options than is available in mainline titles.

Players shouldn't have to use periphery software and the like just to better organize what, at this point, is a mega zoo of digital animals.

1. Listen To The Community

If even a handful of the suggestions made here had already been acted upon, there'd be one less entry adorning this list. But they haven't, so we must continue to bemoan the fact that Pokémon's guardian has little interest in listening to or even interacting with the people who helped lift it to where it stands today. 

Advertisement

At what level of the food chain the disconnect exists isn't entirely clear, but it's a reasonable assumption to make that, as with any institution that continues to rake in money hand over fist without fail, it sees little reason to listen to disquiet while coffers continue to fill up.

Pocket Pair has already outlined some of its plans for future Palworld updates. Game Freak doesn't have to follow suit identically, but when it comes to hot topics like Dexit and Scarlet and Violet's performance issues, taking account of constructive criticisms for both and addressing them head-on instead of sticking its head in the sand in the hopes that everything will blow over only serves to foster even more resentment.

Advertisement