10 Major Missteps By Video Game Companies
"Do you guys not have phones?"
The gaming industry is barely into its teenage years compared with the likes of film and TV, having only reached the mainstream in recent decades. Developers and publishers are just now figuring out what does and doesn't work (and what they can and can't get away with).
As smaller indie developers grow and merge into corporations headed by executives that have never played a game in their lives, they seem determined to push the boundaries of common sense to their absolute limits.
Year after year, the gaming industry continues to torch its fanbase, as the rest of us watch on in a mixture of horror and amusement. Where once, gaming allowed us to escape the drama of the world, now we must watch as the industry gets assailed by lawsuits, scandals and even legislation aimed at curbing some of the wildest tendencies.
Following are the worst examples of this; events we must never forget if we are to force the industry to change for the better.
10. When A Constant Online Connection Ruins Everything - SimCity 2013
City-builder's are a genre designed to slow-paced and relaxing. Our inner perfectionists come out to play, as we swear we are having fun redesigning a roundabout for 3 hours because "it wasn't round enough".
The SimCity franchise was king of the city builders for decades, producing hit after hit for decades. Then SimCity 2013 happened. The game was reviewed positively before release - I mean, it was following a successful predecessor, what could go wrong?
Oh, SO much.
Focusing too hard on DRM to prevent piracy, EA somehow forgot to actually make the game work. Requiring a constant online connection while also having too few servers meant thousands of players were unable to play due to network issues, for a single player game.
The backlash was so severe the franchise has still not recovered, and other city builders have risen by the dozens to take its place.
9. "Error 37" - Diablo 3
The Hype for this long awaited sequel was extremely real. Fans were salivating to step back into the world of sanctuary and meet the rest of the Prime Evils. The player base for Diablo 2 was still going strong 12 years after launch, and the pre release footage looked strong, Diablo 3 was set to take the world by storm.
Cut to several weeks later and no one is playing, but not for lack of trying. Diablo fans were left stranded at their computer monitors for days, with nothing but the sight of error 37 for company. Once again a publisher had spent so much time fiddling with the details of their always online DRM, they forgot to actually make the game work.
Ensuring you have enough server space for a game where you require everyone to be online sounds fairly obvious to most of us, but maybe we just aren't cut out for the world of game development.
8. Redefining What "Finished" Means - Assassin's Creed Unity
Every group of friends has "that friend" that goes too far and spoils everything for everyone else. Before the online revolution games had to be shipped complete and debugged, or else it was broken forever. As the ability to patch games after shipping became available, gaming companies became a bit more loose with the debugging process. However in 2014 Ubisoft became "that friend".
Following the universally praised Black Flag, expectations were high for Ubisoft's next adventure, they were gonna have to do something unexpected, to be fair what they did WAS unexpected. Unity released in such a broken state that many actually questioned whether the game had been debugged at all. People fell through floors, characters faces wouldn't load and games crashed constantly.
Ubisoft was forced to apologise and issue refunds, but the damage they did to the industry was far more severe, they showed the world that you could indeed release a broken game and just apologise and fix it later. Worryingly instead of learning from this mistake, it is more common than ever for a game to be unplayable for weeks after launch, and we have Ubisoft to thank for it.
7. "Do You Guys Not Have Phones?" - Diablo: Immortal
Blizzard steps onto our list for a second (and worryingly not the last) time.
Hinting at a Diablo-related announcement in the months up to Blizzcon 2018 - and charging $200 a ticket - fans were expecting to finally be given an announcement for Diablo 4. Fans packed into the audience and the atmosphere was palpable.
When Blizzard finally took to the stage to announce a new Diablo phone game, one clearly looking towards the more mobile friendly Chinese market, you could hear the beads of sweat dripping from the announcers forehead.
Clearly misreading the situation, he asked the bewildered audience "do you guys not have phones". Things went from bad to worse when a disappointed fan took to the microphone during the Q&A to ask "is this an April fools joke?", to which he was applauded by the audience.
To charge your fans so much money and not deliver is a display of supreme disrespect.
Diablo Immortal is already dead in the western market, blizzard stock fell by 7% and the trailers are some of the most down voted videos in you tube's history. A company once so beloved by its fans has fallen so far from its peak that many are turning to boycotts.
6. Not Delaying When You KNOW It's Necessary - No Mans Sky
Hype For No Man's Sky had been building for years, with claims of a never before seen experience being created by Hello Games.
It seemed like an impossible task to create a game with such potential, it seemed too good to be true. Unfortunately that's because it was.
People playing pre-release versions of the game began to notice massive inconsistencies with what they were experiencing and what they had been promised. Multiplayer was missing, the game was far shorter than claimed, and many of those who played for several hours felt the game had reached its end.
No Man's Sky is actually a great game today, with content expansions, patches and bug fixes being periodically applied. If Hello Games just admitted the game was not up to standard and insisted on a delay, then people may have been annoyed, but would have received an excellent game with critical praise eventually.
Ultimately their decision to hide issues instead of delaying the launch made things much worse. Reviews were terrible, players were in uproar, and even years later players are still bitter about it, even as they enjoy the now finished game.
5. A Bizarre Marketing Strategy - Battlefield V
Battlefield 5 is the first game on our list to be fully functional and enjoyable from day one.
While not as impressive as previous entries in the franchise, and somewhat lacking in content, it was a solid multiplayer experience. So how did the game end up being considered one of EA's commercial disappointments?
In what became a controversial move, EA focused their marketing around the depiction of female soldiers on the front line. Being women are rarely shown in these positions, many thought the game had an "unrealistic" edge - especially when combined with swords and spiked batons. Between being angry about the "inaccuracy" and wondering just what was actually new this time, it didn't make for a clear message.
The strategy connected with no one, and lead many fans to realise early on the game was lacking content, and that EA was attempting to draw attention away from this.
The situation left those on the fence about the game to looking elsewhere for their shooter needs, and sales suffered.
4. From Development Hell To The Executioner's Block - Anthem
Having been in development for 7 years and the subject of several impressive trailers, Anthem was riding a wave of hype similar to Biowares previous titles. Even with the teams divided between Mass Effect: Andromeda and Dragon Age Inquisition, many believed Anthem would be the start of an exciting new franchise.
On release Anthem was praised for the flight and combat mechanics, however it was brutally criticised for its repetitive and tedious game play. Described as bland and hard to enjoy, many players gave up before realising that the majority of content included for the game was held out of reach in the endgame.
The issue obvious with hindsight. Without Director Casey Hudson of Mass Effect fame manning the helm, Bioware began showing noticeable signs that they were not up to the task of developing the game. EA seems to have ignored these early signs and pushed ahead with development, even as experienced Bioware staff began leaving the company in waves.
What we were eventually left with feels like a game that was half developed, and rather than cancelling or delaying the game, EA simply pushed it out the door to die, hoping it would recoup some of their costs as it did so.
3. Literally Everything - Fallout 76
Bethesda games are widely known to be broken and full of unintended hilarity. It is a part of their charm, and we the fans walk into each new game knowing it will be several things: Epic, massive, and buggy as all hell.
Players watching mammoths sinking into the ground or being send flying by giants in Skyrim roared their approval. But not even the most cynical Bethesda fans were expecting the mess that Fallout 76 turned out to be.
Announced to much excitement, fans were ecstatic to finally be able to share the open world experience with their friends. The decision to create a multiplayer ONLY experience in which there was no single player, NPCS or even really anything to do, was a baffling one which lead to severe fan backlash. On top of this the game is broken well beyond what fans consider acceptable or part of the Bethesda charm.
Dull, monotonous and unplayably broken, all we had wanted was two player Skyrim, it is amazing that Bethesda could a simple demand so incredibly wrong. Even after so many months of fixes Fallout 76 remains the lowest rated Bethesda game of all time, and that's not even including the fallout from the infamous Nylon bag controversy.
2. Pay To Win - Star Wars Battlefront 2
It is common these days for multiplayer games to have a lootbox or online transaction component, and while many games let you purchase skins or cosmetic items to customise gameplay, some include the ability to level up faster and experience the game a bit differently.
Battlefront 2's loot box system though? It was so despised, EA's stock droppted. They were also forced to pull the system altogether right on launch, and the endeavour even inspired anti-lootbox legislation in some countries.
The lootbox mechanic was very much pay to win - or "pay to keep up", as those who'd purchased better Star Cards would have better perks and abilities. Fans quickly realised they could grind out the currency to buy upgrades and characters... but it would be 40 hours just to unlock a single hero, of which there are several.
EA were forced to remove micro transactions at launch, then severely dial them back when they were reintroduced.
The company lost $3 billion in stock value, and several world governments are in the process of passing legislation to ban the use of in-game lootboxes. The game launched to a rating of 0.8 on Metacritic, the lowest in the site's history at the time.
That was, until our next game launched...
1. A Remake So Bad It Actually Ruins The Original - Warcraft III: Reforged
Blizzard tops the list with a remake of a classic game that was so bad, and so universally hated by fans, that it is officially the worse rated game on Metacritic, with an appalling 0.5/10.
The list of things that are wrong is actually spectacular: Cutscenes were not remade as promised, graphics are reduced from what was advertised, many of fans' favourite online features have been stripped away, and gameplay and balance have changed notably.
Even worse, the changes have been applied across Blizzard's live client in such a way that players of the original who didn't purchase Reforged have to play the disastrous new version anyway.
Blizzard's reaction sent the situation from bad to a full blown crisis.
Refusing to refund players even if they were unable to play the game due to bugs, banning players from the forums for helping others receive refunds, and blatantly denying they were breaching country's consumer laws. The list goes on.
They have since been forced by lawsuits, claims of false advertising and overwhelmingly negative responses to reverse this position, and the refunds are flying.
In a decade we have gone from the company that produced Warcraft 3, Diablo 2 and Starcraft, to one fans are actively boycotting. It is sad to see our heroes fall, but consumers have to let developers and publishers know they will be respected.