10 Most Absurd Lawsuits In Video Game History
Never underestimate the pettiness of people.
More often than not, lawsuits devolve into a circus show. Sometimes even the pettiest issues must be brought before a judge and jury to settle because neither party has the sensibility to find resolutions to unimportant squabbles.
If you thought video games were exempt from such tomfoolery then, well, ignorance really is bliss. Hardly a year goes by without a celebrity, overzealous attorney or misguided civilian taking issue with the way in which publishers conduct themselves. As recently as this year, a New York judge finally saw fit to quash Lindsay Lohan's non-issue accusation that Rockstar had unlawfully appropriated her likeness for its own gain, but that's not even the half of it.
From embarrassing copyright squabbles concerning great apes to one man's crusade to monopolise the use of the word 'edge', astonishment just doesn't cut it as a descriptor for some of the most absurd disputes to have entered a courtroom.
Here's to hoping the day comes soon that a fool thinks twice before attempting to sue a publisher for its games being too addictive.
Fallout 4 was good, but not that good.
10. The Romantics Vs. Activision
The case: 70s rock group The Romantics, despite giving Activision explicit permission to cover its track 'What I Like About You' in Guitar Hero Encore: Rocks the 80s, decided that suing the publisher over its use was a good idea. The band's argument, if you can even call it that, stipulated that the cover was too similar to The Romantics' original and could cause confusion for its fans.
As any rational human being would do, the band's members sought to have Activision forced into pulling this instalment of Guitar Hero from store shelves.
The outcome: A federal judge in Detroit did what any sane person would do and threw the case out of court, denying The Romantics' request outright. Activision was judged to have legally obtained and used the copyright and the world kept on turning.
Crisis averted.
9. The Olsen Twins Vs. Acclaim Entertainment
The case: Acclaim Entertainment's series of games starring the Olsen twins - including such woeful highlights as Mary-Kate and Ashley: Girls Night Out - came to an end in 2004 when the publisher cancelled the series amidst its steady decline into financial ruin.
The twins, through their production company, thought it best to sue Acclaim for what their lawyer described as a blatant abandonment of the girls' "brand in video games which had flourished" and subsequently been run into the ground by Acclaim.
An impassioned speech, no doubt, but given the universal critical revulsion aimed at each and every digital adventure for the Olsen twins, 'flourished' may not be the correct term to use. If anything, it contributed to Acclaim's demise. Fads don't last forever.
The outcome: Whether Acclaim ended up forking over the combined fee of almost $500,000 that Dualstar was seeking isn't clear, but given its non-existence today, the outcome in this case hardly matters.
The important takeaway that does matter is that there were no further instalments for the Olsen twins in video game form following the case's conclusion, and that can only be deemed a positive outcome.
8. Gate Five Vs. Beyoncé
The case: As proven time and again with exemplary examples like 50 Cent: Bulletproof, video games based on selling themselves by way of a starring celebrity role are often destined for failure.
Enter Starpower: Beyoné, a supposed motion-based dance title developed by Gate Five that would feature the music star in a major capacity, but never came to fruition. Having already sunk a reported $6.7 million into the project, Gate Five received the devastating news not long after that Beyoncé had abruptly pulled out of the project on a "whim."
Gate Five promptly countered by attempting to sue Beyoncé for $100 million on the basis that her pulling out had not only put people out of employment but scared off a potential financier that was about ready to invest in the project.
The outcome: The lawsuit came to a close when both parties agreed to an undisclosed settlement, meaning, sadly, we'll never get to bust a move alongside Beyoncé. On the flip side, the case will at least serve as a deterrent to celebrities from attempting to cash in on an industry they're not intimately familiar with.
7. One Russian Gamer Vs. Bethesda
The case: Drugs? Alcohol? Smoking? Bah, none of those substances hold a candle to video games as addictive substances, at least not in the case of a particular Russian man that opted to take Bethesda to court, following a three-week binge of Fallout 4 that saw his life fall apart.
As per RT's original report, the 26-year-old 'victim' - who opted to remain anonymous - described how he lost his job, wife and social life to the post-apocalyptic RPG, having skipped meals and sleep too, just for that little bit more.
"If I knew this game could have become so addictive, I would have become a lot more wary of it. I would not have bought it, or I would have left it until I was on holiday or until the new year holidays."
The Krasnoyarsk native was said to have been seeking $7,000 from Bethesda for 'emotional distress'.
The outcome: No further coverage of the case ever surfaced, implying that the man either saw sense, dropped the case and sought help for his addictive tendencies or settled out of court (unlikely).
We'd like to believe the whole thing was a hoax and that nobody is that foolish, but given the subject matter of this very article, that's clearly not the case.
6. No Doubt Vs. Activision
The case: Another inane lawsuit involving a spat between a music artist and Activision, only this time, the point of contention involved the former's dissatisfaction with their portrayal in Band Hero. The Gwen Stefani-fronted act No Doubt took Activision to court after it discovered that avatars of its members could perform songs other than its own, a feature not outlined in the contract it signed.
Activision responded by countersuing, stating that it was "publically known" that avatars could be used in this fashion, essentially running with the rebuttal that No Doubt should have done its research before signing away its members' digital likeness.
The outcome: Mere weeks before the trial was due to commence, a settlement between Activision and the band was reached. Given that the 'offending' content in question remained in-game as is, Gwen and Co. likely received a tidy sum from Activision.
Funny how swiftly some extra cash can change minds, isn't it?
5. Tim Langdell Vs. The Games Industry
The case: Edge Games founder and CEO Tim Langdell, intent on monopolising the use of the word 'edge' in video games, bit off more than he could chew in 2007 when he decided that getting into a legal debate with EA over its use of the word in Mirror's Edge was a winnable crusade.
Bear in mind that this was after Langdell had already managed to have popular iOS game Edge removed from Apple's store and the reason why Soul Edge had to be renamed as Soul Calibur in the West.
Not petty at all, then.
The outcome: In October 2010, four months after Landell filed a trademark infringement lawsuit against EA, a settlement was reached, resulting in Edge Games surrendering several trademarks containing the word.
Following the result, EA spokesman Jeff Brown said that "while this seems like a small issue for EA we think that filing the complaint is the right thing to do for the developer community."
Well fancy that, EA has a heart after all.
4. Universal Studios Vs. Nintendo
The case: Nintendo may be a household name the world over today, but in 1982? Not so much. Following the successful launch of its now-legendary Donkey Kong in arcades, Universal, keen to get in on the explosive popularity of video games itself, began sending cease-and-desist notices to the Big N and its licensees.
Universal claimed that Ninty's oversized ape and the game's features amounted to copyright infringement on King Kong, stipulating that failure to either remove the game from sale or purchasing a license from it would result in the film studio suing the pants off this small Japanese company. Refusing to back down, Nintendo faced Universal head on and thus, a court date was booked.
The outcome: In short, the total humiliation of Universal. Not only did the court rule in Nintendo's favour - that at best, Donkey Kong could be considered a parody of King Kong - but Nintendo's representative in court pointed out that Universal didn't even hold the rights to the latter, leaving it with no legal leg to stand on.
As a further insult to injury, Nintendo was given the right to seek damages from Universal due to its cease-and-desist nonsense. Chalk this one up as a victory for the (former) underdog.
3. Every Case Involving Jack Thompson
The case: Prior to his permanent disbarment in 2008, Florida-based attorney Jack Thompson represented something of a nuisance for the games industry. Whenever a violent video game (especially of the Rockstar kind; catnip for Thompson) arrived, Jack was there. Violent crime with strenuous (at best) links to video games? Jack was there, ready and waiting to blame interactive entertainment for warping the minds of offenders into bloodthirsty thrillseekers.
From Grand Theft Auto and Bully to Manhunt and Mortal Kombat, Thompson has locked horns with the industry's biggest players numerous times in the past in an effort to get such 'filthy smut' removed from sale or banned, belting out uncited, unsourced claims about the dangers they posed to anyone who would listen.
The outcome: Not one of Thompson's short-lived crusades against violent video games ever ended in his favour, itself speaking for the absurdity of the claims he made before the Florida Bar said enough is enough and sent him packing.
2. Lindsay Lohan Vs. Rockstar
The case: Fresh off the (long) line of incomprehensible accusations aimed at games developers, Rockstar once again found itself on the receiving end of controversy when Lindsay Lohan accused the studio of using her likeness without permission in Grand Theft Auto V. Now, we've all seen the comparison image in question (look up if you haven't) and while superficial similarities exist, that's all they are.
Even if Rockstar's intention was to satirise Lohan with the character, GTA V is wholly a work of fiction, rendering the debate entirely moot.
The outcome: As if there was any doubt, the New York County supreme court dismissed the case despite Lohan's claim that the depiction used her "signature 'peace sign' pose" and other 'trademarks". Boy, how could such a strong defence be shut down without a second thought?
Sorry to be the bearer of bad news, Ms. Lohan, but that hand gesture has been around since before you were even able to manipulate your fingers in such a fashion.
One day, Rockstar. One day you'll be able to make a game that doesn't result in a legal battle. Hang in there.
1. Nintendo Vs. Blockbuster
The case: Unable to achieve its original goal of eliminating video game rentals Stateside due to U.S. copyright law, Nintendo, unsatisfied, decided to take a petty jab at the rental market's biggest player, Blockbuster Video, over a harmless act.
As a means of replacing old, worn out copies of game manuals, Blockbuster would make photocopies, a practice that it would soon learn, thanks to Nintendo's probing, was illegal. Blockbuster had the law on its side as far as rentals were concerned but copying intellectual property? That was a big no-no, even if the content in question was nothing but a series of arbitrary instructions.
The outcome: Rather than run the risk of racking up huge legal fees, the case was eventually settled out of court in Nintendo's favour, but it was nothing more than a token victory. The Big N had stopped Blockbuster from photocopying its manuals, but rentals continued to flourish.
At least until digital media came along a decade later and achieved Nintendo's ultimate goal for it.