10 Most Controversial South Park Moments
The show is all about going too far - but when did they go too furthest?
If you’ve ever watched South Park, you’ll know that crossing the line is basically the whole point. Trey Parker and Matt Stone have created a comedy behemoth, and its incredible success means that they can basically do whatever they want.
It’s a show with its finger ever on the pulse, and their remarkably quick turnaround times mean they’re almost always the first to take a pop at current events.
This, combined with their love for toilet humour and a penchant for making serious (and occasionally preachy) points about society means that the show has generated more than its share of controversy. Few episodes go by without a reference to a real life celebrity or event, and feathers are ruffled as a matter of course.
Sometimes, though, they go a little bit further, pushing a joke or an angle to the point that they raise the ire of some seriously powerful groups. From religious organisations to beloved public figures, South Park has trodden on some big toes over twenty three seasons. They’re yet to find out exactly how far is too far, but most likely they’ll keep pushing until they do.
10. Mormons
Trey Parker and Matt Stone have found a lot of success poking fun at the Latter Day Saints. Before their smash hit musical The Book Of Mormon, they brought out an episode of South Park whose main thrust was gently - but thoroughly - mocking the belief system of the whole religion.
In All About Mormons, a new family comes to South Park. When Stan attempts to befriend them, they turn out to be the perfect family unit, a model of togetherness, until they start to discuss their religious beliefs.
The episode details the founding of the Mormon church in straightforward terms, but with a singing narrator filling in gaps in the story with “dum dum dum”s, which quickly convey Parker and Stone’s feelings on the religion.
Gary, the main Mormon character, is voiced by South Park writer Kyle McCulloch, who was raised in the LDS church, and the episode ends by pointing out that a disagreement over faith doesn’t make you a bad person - indeed the Mormons are some of the most decent characters in South Park. Nonetheless, All About Mormons is one of the show’s most thorough jabs at a religion.
9. Tourette's
As a set up to an episode, it’s incredibly simple, but perfectly South Park: after learning about Tourette’s syndrome, Cartman seizes the opportunity to spout whatever horrible thoughts come to his mind, pretending that he’s afflicted, and in doing so becoming a spokesperson for the disorder.
When the premise was announced, the Tourette Syndrome Association was ready for the worst. They petitioned Comedy Central to air an announcement or apology before and after the episode aired, on the assumption the show would treat the condition with its usual irreverence and disregard.
Well, they were half right. While the TSA were quick to point out that “Le Petit Tourette” focused on the more sensational aspects of Tourette’s - that is, the involuntary swearing, the prevalence of which is significantly exaggerated in the episode - they had to concede that the episode was well researched, and for the most part accurately depicted the experience of sufferers.
With jabs at Chris Hansen and To Catch A Predator thrown into the mix, South Park lands just about on the side of the angels at the end of this episode - a good day at the office.
8. Timmy And Jimmy
When South Park introduced Timmy in season four, it seemed that Parker and Stone may have crossed a line too many. A severely disabled child who can only say his own name could easily have taken the show from edgy to downright unpleasant.
In fact, the show’s handling of Timmy has been highly intelligent, and at times downright sensitive. Timmy and his disability are seldom the direct subject of the joke; more often the humour is derived from how he is misunderstood by the incapable adults of South Park. In his debut episode, he is diagnosed with ADHD by clueless school staff.
Boundaries are pushed even further the following season with the addition of Jimmy, another child with unspecified special needs. While the writers feel slightly more able to poke fun at Jimmy’s condition, he has become one of South Park’s best characters, is clearly one of the smartest people in town, and is always portrayed as popular and talented.
Whether the writers felt reluctant to mock disabled kids or decided to skewer expectations, Timmy and Jimmy are fully developed and well fleshed out disabled characters on a popular TV show, which remains something you don’t see all that frequently.
7. Racial Epithets
There’s crossing the line, and then there’s really crossing the line. The whole idea behind South Park is that there’s nowhere they won’t go, but even long term fans would imagine that there are certain boundaries they won’t cross. With Apologies to Jesse Jackson, season 11’s opener, put paid to that idea.
Perennial town pariah Randy Marsh puts his foot in it big time after cheerfully - but without malice - exclaiming an ethnic slur on a game show. The episode then gleefully skewers racism, with Randy ostracised and abused for his use of the word. He becomes “the N word guy”, and eventually teams with others, including Michael Richards, to abolish the use of the N word in close proximity to the word “guy”.
While the sheer quantity of racial language makes for uncomfortable viewing and led to criticism from the Parents Television Council (who badly missed the point), other rights groups were quick to praise the incisive satire. It was one of South Park’s biggest risks yet, one that could quite easily have seen them yanked off the air, but instead it was something of a triumph for a show in a purple patch.
6. Difficulty
South Park’s two most recent video game adaptations, The Stick Of Truth and The Fractured But Whole, are unusually good gaming spin offs. Much of this is down to the hands-on involvement of Parker and Stone, who have ensured that South Park’s essence is maintained in an interactive format.
One of the best examples of this is the difficulty mechanic. At the beginning of the game, you’re prompted to create your playable character - the game will become harder the darker you set the character’s skin. Playing as a non-white character makes it more difficult to earn money, and changes the way some of the non-playable characters in the game interact with you.
It’s not exactly the most subtle piece of commentary from the South Park team, but it’s certainly effective. The design of your avatar had aesthetic effects in The Stick Of Truth - primarily racy dialogue from Eric Cartman - but the decision to make the game far more difficult for those playing as a black character is one that could easily have backfired on the creators, though for the most part it seems to have been recognised as sharp satire.
5. Censorship
An ambitious two parter covering the South Park team’s dislike of Family Guy and the Danish cartoon depictions of Muhammad, Cartoon Wars led to one of Parker and Stone’s biggest rifts with their network, Comedy Central.
The story revolves around Family Guy courting controversy by announcing they’ll be airing a depiction of the prophet Muhammad, causing consternation in the Muslim world. Cartman, who loathes Family Guy, intends on using the furore to have the show cancelled, while the rest of the town plan on literally burying their heads in the sand to avoid retribution.
The saga was supposed to build to a conclusion in which Muhammad’s depiction was incredibly benign, the whole thing a fuss over nothing. The writers’ creed against censorship was blunted, however, by Comedy Central’s refusal to air the image.
More annoying still to Parker and Stone was that an earlier episode, Super Best Friends, depicted Muhammad uncensored and continued to do so in reruns. The complaints fell on deaf ears, though, and Cartoon Wars, along with another two parter which revisits the whole affair, remains excluded from some streaming services.
4. Too Soon
Some of the targets chosen by South Park are worthwhile: bloated or nefarious organisations, or pompous celebrities. On other occasions, though, their swipes are directed at more benign personalities. It can seem a little arbitrary and even mean, never more so than their far too soon mockery of the late Steve Irwin.
Season 10 episode Hell On Earth 2006 is for the most part a fairly tame episode about a party thrown by Satan. The edgiest material involves depictions of various serial killers, with some cartoon gore thrown in for good measure.
Then, Steve Irwin appears with a stingray stuck through his chest. Airing under two months after the crocodile hunter’s death, this unsurprisingly was met with substantial backlash, including a statement on behalf of Irwin’s widow.
With the show’s famously short turnaround time they’re able to spoof recent moments faster than any other comedy, so it seems that they simply couldn’t resist the shock gag. In the grand scheme of things they’ve done far worse, but a tasteless joke about a well liked and decent man just for the sake of doing it did not sit well with some viewers.
3. Catholics
By season nine, South Park had taken shots at just about any group you could imagine, so an episode featuring a statue of the Virgin Mary bleeding out of her backside, and the Pope declaring it a miracle with healing powers, didn’t seem like too much to be concerned about. Naughty, sure, but not a cause for alarm after stuff they’d done up to this point.
This confidence turned out to be unfounded. The episode aired the night before the Feast of the Immaculate Conception, and the timing, as well as the content, turned out to be enough to light a fire under various Catholic organisations.
In the US, the Catholic League demanded the episode was essentially expunged, and managed to get an apology from the practising Catholic president of Comedy Central’s parent company. In New Zealand, a multi-faith group campaigned against the episode’s airing, which led to an audience six times South Park’s norm.
The episode was removed from Comedy Central schedules for the best part of a year, but has since returned to normal rotation. While this generated more outrage than most episodes, if anything the controversy seemed to boost fan interest.
2. China
It’s a little surprising that it took South Park so long to dedicate a whole episode to the state of affairs in China, but when they did, they went in two-footed. Band In China is a two pronged attack on the economic powerhouse: Stan’s band is the subject of a biopic whose content is heavily dictated to appease Chinese standards, while Randy finds himself locked up in a brutal jail as a political prisoner.
The episode attacks human rights in China, as well as Hollywood’s complicity, with a pointedness rarely seen in the show. There are no funny characters on the other side to give a bit of personality to the Chinese government.
Unsurprisingly, this did not go down well at all, with China taking the step to immediately ban South Park. Stone and Parker, who presumably expected such a reaction, quickly issued a sarcastic mock-apology, which has done little to mend fences.
The episode was screened in a busy Hong Kong street by way of protest, but it’s unlikely Comedy Central will be exporting to this economy any time soon. It’s a rare example of action actually being taken against the show - not that the creators will likely care too much.
1. Scientology
An episode incendiary enough to lead to the departure of longtime voice artist Isaac Hayes, Trapped In The Closet puts South Park’s scattershot comedy to the best possible use, managing to simultaneously offend scientologists, Tom Cruise and John Travolta, and for no particular reason R Kelly in one fell swoop.
In one of the earliest high profile swipes against scientology, Parker and Stone pull no punches, taking aim at the church’s induction practises, paywall, and faith system (a sequence illustrating the foundations of the religion is captioned “This is what scientologists actually believe”).
With scientology particularly prevalent in Hollywood, the episode was always going to ruffle feathers, and rumours that Tom Cruise had threatened to pull out of Mission: Impossible 3 promotional duties led to South Park fans boycotting the film.
Worse still, Isaac Hayes, the voice of Chef and a scientologist, left the show shortly after the episode aired. In a reference to the religion’s litigiousness, all credits for the episode are given to Jane or John Smith. They escaped without a lawsuit this time, but as far as South Park maulings go, it’s one of their most ruthless.