10 Most Controversial Video Game Levels Ever

Did ANYONE think the No Russian wouldn't cause controversy?

By James Egan /

Video game companies spend years finalising their products to ensure they are of the highest calibre upon the time of release. But developers also have to ensure their games do not fall victim to another problem - generating controversy.

Advertisement

Obviously, titans like Nintendo, Sony, and Microsoft don't want to cause a stir (usually), knowing full well that anything inappropriate in their handles can cost them millions or tarnish their name irreparably. As a result, testers will play a game over and over to ensure every word, character, and level is incapable of causing offence.

But no matter how hard the developers try, some games are destined to have parents and politicians up in arms. And we are not talking about the usual suspects like Mortal Kombat and Manhunt. Those games were always going to get flak. We're looking at games that would've avoided a rumpus if it wasn't for one level.

Sometimes, there is a specific boss, section, or line of dialogue that becomes so contentious, it smears the entire game's reputation.

So, what video game levels created the biggest controversy?

10. Uprising - Battlefield 3

Because PETA was founded to protect animals, it sounds like the organisation has nothing but the purest intentions. But more often than not, PETA goes way too far. Over the years, they've claimed milk causes autism, suggested the word "pet" is a slur, and bad-mouthed Steve Irwin immediately after he died. They also called Super Mario an animal killer because he wears a raccoon suit.

Advertisement

As you do.

Sadly, this isn't the only time PETA has attacked the gaming community. In the second mission of Battlefield 3, there is a section where the player is prompted to kill a rat before tossing it away.

Even though thousands of people die throughout this first-person shooter (It is a war game after all), PETA only took umbrage with Battlefield 3 because it "treats animals in a sadistic manner". They also stated the rat-killing sequence will have "a brutalising effect on the young male target audience".

Although there's no evidence that players were traumatised by this rat being murdered, PETA's public tantrum caused Battlefield 3 to receive a lot of press (which may have indirectly led to it making more sales).

9. Tug O' War, Paddle Battle & Pedal Power - Mario Party

In the Mario Party series, four players must navigate around a board to obtain coins and stars. Every time the players complete their turn, they take part in a mini-game.

Advertisement

However, there were three mini-games which caused a lot of problems, physically and legally. In Tug O' War, Paddle Battle, and Pedal Power, the player needs to spin the control stick quickly to win. Many players discovered they could move the stick faster if they placed their palm on it and wiggled their hand around.

Unfortunately, this method caused players to develop blisters and other ailments on their hands. Even though the sequel had no mini-games requiring the player to spin the analog stick rapidly, Nintendo were pressurised to give out free gloves with every copy of Mario Party 2, costing them $80 million.

To avoid a similar incident, Nintendo didn't release Mario Party for the Virtual Console (but had no qualms releasing Mario Party 2). In fact, this incident is still being addressed in recent games! The 2021 entry, Mario Party Superstars, includes the infamous mini-game, Tug O' War, but warns players not to use their palms to move the stick since it will result in pain, blisters, and Nintendo getting sued.

8. The Fire Temple - The Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time

Mario and Zelda creator, Shigeru Miyamoto, always tries to avoid religious connotations in his games to avoid offending people's faith.

Advertisement

Nevertheless, references to religion have popped up in multiple Legend of Zelda entries, most notably LoZ: Ocarina of Time. Some players noticed the Gerudo crest found on blocks, signs, and the Mirror Shield is of a crescent moon, which resembles a prominent Islam symbol.

Although this issue was mild, Nintendo promised to remedy it in future ports. However, Ocarina of Time had a much bigger problem. If you listen to the background music in the Fire Temple, you can hear a group of people chanting an Islamic prayer, with the name "Allah" clearly heard at one point.

While the context of this name isn't clear, it's a reference to the phrase, "I bear witness that there is no god but Allah". Because of how stringent Nintendo is with their policies, it's baffling how the game testers didn't think this music was a problem. (You probably hear the song 20 times while playing through this temple.)

When the game was re-released, this section of the music was removed with a MIDI Synthesiser.

7. A LOT Of Levels Are Censored - South Park: Stick Of Truth

Since Matt Stone and Trey Parker's cartoon debuted, it has caused a stir worldwide. So, when Ubisoft developed the RPG, South Park: The Stick of Truth, everyone was expecting the game to be slapped with an R-rating.

Advertisement

However, fans were astonished to learn the game failed to receive a rating from the censor boards in Europe and Australia. The Stick of Truth was eventually released in Europe and Australia but certain levels were removed including the anal probe and the abortion clinic sequence. (The censors were totally okay with the part where you have to avoid your Dad's testicles teabagging you to death.That flew under the radar somehow.)

As a result, these missions were replaced with an image of the European flag or a crying koala (depending on where you're residing). The bottom of the screen has a piece of text describing what happens in the sections you aren't allowed to play.

The biggest issue with this decision is how it screws up the gameplay and the story. At one point, you get abducted on a UFO, break free, anally probe someone, and then battle aliens to escape. But since the censor board removed the anal probe segment, the player misses an entire section. Because there are seven censored missions, (including the final one), it makes the game feel incomplete.

6. Shy Guy's Perplex Express - Mario Party 8

Mario Party may seem like a harmless game for kids but it managed to create controversy, not once but twice. Ten years after the original Mario Party debacle, Nintendo found themselves in the middle of an another dispute thanks to Mario Party 8.

Advertisement

The game itself is considered among the weakest in the series, with critics taking issue with the poorly structured singe-player and the lack of creative mini-games. But over time, the only critique anyone remembers from Mario Party 8 was an unfortunate encounter with the robed magikoopa, Kamek. When you encounter Bowser's lieutenant in Shy Guy's Perplex Express, he uses a specific word to reference the trains' movements.

Although the word he uses means "spasm-like movement" in America, it's considered a derogatory term in England and Ireland, forcing Mario Party 8 to be recalled in Europe. It was eventually rereleased in Europe with the flagrant word changed to "erratic".

Even though the situation was a simple misunderstanding, it encouraged Nintendo to have the English localisations of all their properties reviewed by American and British employees to ensure such an occurrence never happened again.

5. By The Book - Grand Theft Auto V

Because Grand Theft Auto has the player driving around and shooting passerbys, you can understand why the series has been controversial since it debuted back in 1997. So when GTA V was released in 2013, you'd think people would be desensitised by the game's violence.

Advertisement

But this instalment received so much controversy, it has its own wikipedia page (which is actually pretty impressive). News outlets, concerned parents, and British Labour Party MP, Keith Vaz, were demanding the game to be banned due to its portrayal of murder, misogyny, and sexual violence.

However, it was the mission, By the Book, which drew the most ire. In this section, everyone's favourite lunatic, Trevor, interrogates a man to extract information about a terrorist suspect. To complete the mission, you need to use multiple torture techniques including electrocution, teeth removal, and waterboarding.

Some players saw this horrific sequence as a political commentary while others believed it was put in the game purely for shock value. The controversy spawned from this mission was so relentless, it led to the Grand Theft Auto V being banned from certain retailers.

4. Manji Dungeon - The Legend Of Zelda

The criticism which the original Legend of Zelda is unique. Players had an issue with one dungeon, not because of its content, but because of its structure. You see, each dungeon you enter has a specific shape. One dungeon is shaped like a bird, another is shaped like a crescent, another is shaped like a snake, etc. The third dungeon is shaped like a manji, which is a Japanese symbol that represents structure and patterns.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, the manji is known by a different name in the Western world - the swastika. Because the swastika was used by the Nazi regime to represent their twisted cause, the symbol has been synonymous with evil ever since.

However, the manji was used in Japan a thousand years before World War II. It's also been used by many cultures and religions throughout history to represent peace, hope, honour, and love.

But this wasn't common knowledge back in the 1980s, so many Westerners assumed Nintendo snuck the swastika into the game to indoctrinate players with Nazi ideology. Even though it was all a big misunderstanding, it's pretty weird that one of Nintendo's biggest IPs contains this infamous symbol.

3. Mountain Temple - Tomb Raider

The 2013 remake of Tomb Raider created a mountain of controversy before release due to a scene that occurs early in the game. While exploring the Mountain Temple, Lara Croft is captured and bound by mercenaries.

Advertisement

While navigating through the hideout to find a means of escape, one soldier grabs Lara, triggering a quick-time event. If the player doesn't respond quickly, the man will strangle Lara to death.

If the player inputs the correct sequence of attacks, she will break free and kill her attacker. This scene is meant to be impactful, being it's the first time Lara Croft takes a human life.

This became one of the most memorable moments in the series but not for the reason the developers hoped. Just before the attacker strangles Lara, he makes a movement as if he is preparing to sexually assault her. Even though Tomb Raider has zero depiction of rape, news outlets across the world condemned the game due to this scene's implication.

Although the game is 18-rated and has some incredibly gory moments, nothing caused more debate than this section.

2. No Russian - Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

You know a level is going to be controversial when the game gives you the option to skip it entirely. That was the case with the fourth mission of Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2, No Russian. In this segment, you play as an undercover CIA agent who infiltrated a Russian terrorist agency. To gain their trust, you must take part in a mass shooting in a Moscow airport alongside them.

Advertisement

Even though you don't have to shoot anyone to complete this mission, the fact you had the choice to gun down civilians was too horrifying for major news publications to ignore. The outcry was so intense, the level's violence was toned down in international versions and removed entirely from the Russian version.

The developing team, Infinity Ward, could've avoid all this strife if they stuck to the original plan of having the player battle zombies in this level. But after the fantasy elements were removed, lead writer, Jesse Stern, reworked the mission so the protagonist would be involved in a terrorist attack.

Upon researching the Columbine High School massacre, Stern thought that having the player being directly involved in the attack was a great way "put you as close as possible to atrocity."

Despite the outcry No Russian caused, the level was included in the remastered version.

1. Chapter 1: Jackson - The Chalet - The Last Of Us: Part II

-- Spoilers for The Last of Us: Part II --

Advertisement

-

The Last of Us: Part II may have won more awards than any game in history but that doesn't change the fact it also garnered a ton of hate. But what makes this game different from Call of Duty or GTA is how the controversy did not stem from the media.

Instead, it came from the players.

Even though there are many issues which infuriated fans, the most shocking moment was when the antagonist, Abby, beats Joel to death with a golf club. Since this story takes place in a post-apocalyptic society, killing off the main character of the series doesn't sound too surprising.

But the reason why so many people were pissed off is because Joel is killed at the beginning of the game. Because he was the protagonist of the first Last of Us, everybody assumed it would be the same for the follow-up.

The trailers gave every indication you would play as Joel so fans felt cheated to see him being snuffed out after only playing as the character for an hour. Some players were so enraged, they review-bombed the game to oblivion and sent death threats to the actress who portrayed Joel's killer.

Advertisement