10 Most Important Video Game Deaths This Decade

Gone, but not deleted.

By Jules Gill /

Rockstar

This might be a terribly sad statement to begin an article with but, death is something that affects us all, and as we sally forth into the close of 2019 and on into a probably more confusing and strange decade, it’s worth looking back at what we have said goodbye to in the last ten years.

Advertisement

We've wished a teary farewell to Telltale Games and Visceral in the past twelve months alone: those two are just the tip of the iceberg of the gaming industry's gradual melt into a pool of a few major conglomerates.

Away from the boardroom, a whole host of video game characters have popped their clogs in the past ten years, not to mention an assortment of about a million unnamed soldiers, goons, henchmen and heavies.

Advertisement

Today we’re going to do the honors and look at the most impactful examples of those moments over the last decade that have made us reach for the Kleenex, pretend we're chopping onions, and generally, get some very wet cheeks.

It goes without saying: there are some *major spoilers* ahead. That's death for you.

Advertisement

10. John Marston (Red Dead Redemption)

Rockstar

John Marston's story in Red Dead Redemption just so bleakly unfair that it feels so wrong to watch him betrayed by the government and shot to ribbons.

Advertisement

The fact that the game lets you think you can outshoot the mass of men in front of you makes the situation even more impactful. You believe for a moment that John might actually taste freedom.

It's also a death that makes the story make sense. Up until this point, you're led to believe that you're redeeming John's name through his actions, but in fact it's only through his death that his arc can truly close. Plus he's a character that you grow to love and as such saying goodbye was never going to be easy.

Advertisement

It's almost a shame to carry on the game playing as Jack, not only because he's immediately foreign to the player, but also because his quest for revenge undoes the clean slate that his father had bought with his passing.

9. Naia (Brothers: A Tale Of Two Sons)

Starbreeze Studios

The word to describe the experience one gets with this game is "devastating". Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons begins, ends and persists beyond its playtime with the concept of loss and overcoming grief.

Advertisement

Starting with the image of the younger brother overlooking their mother's grave and then learning that their father is sick sets a somber tone, and as the narrative unfolds and you help the pair reach the Waters Of Life, you become incredibly emotionally invested in their story.

Which as you can imagine creates a visceral gut punch when it comes to say goodbye to your older brother Naia. His death removes a sense of security that the player almost becomes reliant on, and it's through his absence that you get an insight into what it's like to lose a loved one. That's a powerful emotional state, and one that is driven home when you look at his grave next to their mother's. A fantastic game hands down.

Advertisement

8. Mordin (Mass Effect 3)

Bioware

Mass Effect 3 might be renowned for how it failed to end things in the way that fans wanted, but there was something impressive with how the developers managed to say goodbye to Mordin Solus, a fan favorite ever since his introduction in Mass Effect 2. This was no Kaidan, whose death evoked little in the way of care, this was a Sassy Salarian who had a ton of personality and was incredibly useful in combat to boot.

Advertisement

However, as most of us know, he carried with him a dark past as well as the weight of what his people had done to the Krogans with their fertility nuke known as the Genophage. His actions and choices always seemed to come across as "doing what is right, no matter the road it takes to get there" and it's this attitude that leads him to sacrificing himself to undo the twisted bio weapon his people had unleashed.

As the Shroud is collapsing all around them, Mordin realises that in order to make sure the cure is released he needs to be at the helm making the final inputs. There is absolutely no chance of survival and no chance for the player to change his mind, but this is the right thing to do. And so with a final goodbye and a final song, Mordin sacrifices himself to heal past wounds.

Advertisement

7. The Joker (Batman: Arkham City)

Rocksteady

As you can tell from this list, it's very common to mourn allies that were close to the player, who aided beyond what needed to be done or provided a few laughs along the way. However the Joker is far from an ally to Batman; as a diametrically opposed force to The Dark Knight, The Joker looks to hound both Gotham and its protectors in ever escalating ways.

Advertisement

And that's exactly why his death is so important.

The cycle between the pair being broken has much greater reach than simply Batman going "thank god I can take Tuesdays off now I don't have to de-gas a school," as it effectively sends the superhero off the rails. This was his greatest foe and even though he almost met his end numerous times thanks to the Clown Prince of Crime, it was also his greatest challenge to save him. Batman doesn't want Joker to die because if he can convert him, he will prove to the city that it can be saved. Killing and death brings only more killing and death, so Batman tries his best to avoid either.

Advertisement

With the Joker gone, how does he carry on? Well the answer is... not without some deep scars. In fact, one could argue that watching Batman battle the choices of his past was the entire thrust of Arkham Knight.

6. Booker DeWitt (BioShock Infinite)

2K

Booker Dewitt is a fascinating character within the BioShock franchise, though not the most. That honour will forever go to Andrew Ryan who, if his game was released this side of the 2010s, would easily be on this list. However we'll have to ask you kindly to consider DeWitt and his tragic death at the end of Infinite instead.

Advertisement

His final memories are that of Elizabeth, his daughter, revealing his role as the nexus for all of the suffering caused by Columbia multiple timelines over.

In life, DeWitt was a psychologically damaged man who traded a life out of pure selfishness. As his alternate, he was a power hungry zealot with an unstoppable drive to perpetuate hatred.

Advertisement

As he is drowned by different versions of Elizabeth, he accepts his fate that in order to destroy Comstock, DeWitt must die; it's a powerful, saddening and quite frankly impossible end for the man.

5. White Phosphorus Attack (Spec Ops: The Line)

2K Games

No one expected Spec Ops: The Line to have hit with as much impact as it did with it dropped in 2012.

Advertisement

And yet moment after moment managed to bowl over players, breaking the boundaries of war shooters and the fourth wall in the process. However, there is one set piece in particular that has endured for years: the white phosphorous scene.

Despite resistance from his team, Walker insists that they must use white phosphorus to attack the 33rd, at which point the player has to control a drone which fires down a rain of the explosive, skin-searing material onto white dots. When the fire clears, you walk through to see several dying, severely burned people crawling around in their final moments, begging for help, before Walker and co. realise they've condemned a group of civilians to death.

Advertisement

The most haunting image is unquestionably that of a woman with half her face burned away, cradling her young daughter. What makes this moment so impactful though is when Walker tries to rationalize what they've done and move ahead with the mission. It's a direct challenge on the whole "just following orders" defense, and it leaves the players questioning real life events of the same manner.

4. Chloe (Life Is Strange)

Dontnod

Now, this death is one that the player can choose to enact, but the decision is a truly difficult one to make. No one will blame you for choosing to bid farewell to Chloe in order to save the entire community of Arcadia Bay.

Advertisement

Chloe might be a character that is in her own words "hella" annoying at times, and almost completely at odds to the life that her friend Max is looking to achieve, but underneath all of the punk crust is a character looking to make meaningful connections and validate her own existence.

The pair need each other - that's made painfully clear by the end of the first season of Life Is Strange - and their movement from fractured relationship to deeply connected is genuinely enthralling. Yet it's a connection that was, at its core, never meant to be, as the player finds out that Max's ability to rewind time to change the past is actually putting Arcadia Bay on a path to destruction.

Advertisement

Therefore, she needs to make a choice: stay in this current timeline where Chloe lives and the storm ravages the bay, or choose not to save Chloe from being shot and saving everyone who lives there. It's interesting to note that through death Chloe achieves what she always wanted: to make a difference to a town she'd always felt trapped in.

3. Lee Everett (The Walking Dead: Season One)

Telltale Games

The emotional linchpin of Telltale Games' brilliant graphic adventure series was always the relationship between player character Lee Everett and Clementine, a young girl who is desperately trying to find her parents.

Advertisement

Over the course of the five episodes, the pair develop a clear father-daughter bond, which, if you've read the comics or watched the Walking Dead TV show, means that disaster isn't just a possibility. It is and inevitably.

In the final episode of the first season, Lee wakes up to find Clem missing, and in the ensuing search for her, ends up being bitten by a walker. This moment alone is like a nail in the heart, but it gets worse as the player then has to decide their own fate; they can ask Clem to shoot them before they turn, or they can allow themselves to turn while telling Clem to leave the scene.

Advertisement

It's one of the toughest recent dilemmas in a game, but Lee's death is important because in a way, he had to die. Lee was the dying remnants of the old world, he had taught Clem everything and in his passing she is forced to take charge of her own life. It's a horrible lesson to learn, but it's something that helps her survive.

2. Sarah (The Last Of Us)

Naughty Dog

Woof. Talk about an emotionally intense opening to a game right?

Advertisement

The prologue section of The Last of Us is pretty much a masterclass in how to build suspense and emotion, putting the player in the shoes of Joel's daughter 20 years before the main game actually begins. The back and forth between father and daughter instantly pulls the player in because it manages to feel natural and loving.

However, things soon take a catastrophic turn when the Cordycep outbreak begins. After dodging the chaos in the streets and outrunning the hyper-aggressive enemies, the game plays a cruel trick: it makes you genuinely believe that Joel and Sarah will get through this. And that's when it hits you with the awful scene of Sarah being shot by a soldier and Joel frantically, desperately trying to save her.

Advertisement

Much like the opening to Pixar's Up, this sudden death brought players to tears in short order, but it teaches you some important lessons. No one is to be trusted, anyone can die, and worst of all, the concept of "fair" does not exist here.

This is what makes the follow up to this event so powerful, as we see the relationship between Joel and Ellie develop from seeing her as cargo to seeing her as a daughter. Joel won't lose another member of his family. He'll make sure of it.

Advertisement

1. The Boy/The Huddle (Inside)

Playdead

When you first look at the mass of limbs and skin called 'The Huddle', you probably don't think it'll be a being conjuring up any emotion within you other than disgust. However, by the end of your playtime with Playdead's brilliant cinematic platformer Inside, this hunking mass will teach you a valuable lesson about freedom, the evils of mankind, and the desperate drive to survive. And it does this without ever saying a word.

Advertisement

The game takes a massive tonal shift as the unnamed protagonist boy who we've been playing as throughout the game gets absorbed into The Huddle. Now, the power has shifted in your favour and with this extra mass you destroy the facility and make a break for the outside. It empowers the player and despite the confusing images on screen, you feel determined to escape, yet this is a misdirection designed to make the ending all the more powerful.

Tumbling down the side of a hill, battered, bruised and broken, The Huddle finally comes to a rest outside of the facility in a single ray of sunlight. It has made it outside, but it has perished in the process. The emotional gut-punch of this is completely unexpected but one that really lives on with the player long past the credits. A fantastic delivery if ever there was one.

Advertisement