10 Most Shocking Gaming Betrayals

Deception and duplicity from some of gaming's most memorable turncoats.

By Liam Lambert /

Unless they’re doggedly individualistic or just too darn powerful to need them, video game protagonists tend to get by with a little help from their friends.

Advertisement

Whether they assist us through combat, moral support, quest-giving, item drops, or just through not constantly trying to stab us, video game allies are always there for us, on the front lines or back at home base.

So, when they do finally decide to stab us in the back, they twist that knife in deep. You have a certain level of detachment when an actor pretending to be a character in a movie betrays another actor, but when it’s a character you’ve been controlling this whole time, somebody whose mind and body you've effectively been inhabiting, it stings that little bit more.

It’s likely you’ve shared some tender moments or dark secrets with these characters, or have been put through the ringer by them in order to achieve what you thought was a common goal, only to have the rug pulled out from you when it's almost too late.

Have some unresolved trust issues getting you down? You might be able to trace a fair few of them back to these rotten apples...

10. Big Bo - Binary Domain

Binary Domain is one of the best, most ludicrous games nobody played last generation. Part-Blade Runner, part-Gears of War, it was a robot smashing TPS extravaganza that dealt with trans-humanism and the very real questions posed by artificial intelligence.

Advertisement

Throughout the game, you’re surrounded by an initially very stereotypical cast of characters. There’s the snarky British guy, the butch woman, the strong, quiet, sexy Asian sniper, and of course, the black comic relief sidekick.

The latter is your right hand man, Roy ‘Big Bo’ Boateng, who starts the game as part of the ‘Rust Crew’, a group of soldiers tasked with eliminating robots that can pass as human. In fact, he’s been in the Rust Crew for four years prior to the events depicted in Binary Domain.

But Bo eventually reveals himself to be in the pocket of the US government, who actually wanted to keep the game’s final ‘big bad’ Japanese AI all to themselves. It’s possible for Bo’s betrayal to be revealed as a ruse, depending on whether the player has gained his trust throughout the rest of the game. If not though, he’ll hold you at gunpoint, before jumping in a mech to join the other side of Binary Domain’s final boss fight.

Believe it or not, your best friend going bad is only the second most shocking twist in Binary Doma, but I'll leave that one for you to discover.

9. Citra - Far Cry 3

Conventional wisdom dictates that if you’re consistently being drugged and going on trippy, murderous adventures, you’re either playing a Far Cry game, or could do with finding some better friends.

Advertisement

But despite spending pretty much the entirety of Far Cry 3 getting spiked, thrown off cliffs, and betrayed by the people you thought were your allies, it was still a shocker to be so royally shafted by Citra, the frankly psychotic leader of the game's Rakyat tribe.

After burning down the benevolent Dr Earnhardt’s house and capturing protagonist Jason Brody’s friends, Citra delivers a brutal conundrum.

It turns out her affections for Jason – an intensely unlikable and blatantly murderous dude-bro – have led her to believe he is a mystical Rakyat warrior destined to save the Rook Islands. She gives him a choice: he can either kill his girlfriend, or he can be banished from the island he just spent 60+ hours climbing watch towers in order to save.

The first choice leads to a sexual encounter with Citra, after which she stabs Jason. The second choice (the one that actually makes sense) results in Jason leaving the island, feeling pretty darn sorry about the mess he caused.

8. Roy Earle - LA Noire

Roy. Roy. The name that will remain forever unpopular for new-born boys, at least for any parents who played LA Noire.

Advertisement

Roy Earle was never a particularly likeable character. His smarmy attitude made him a dead giveaway as a corrupt cop, taking bribes on the side in exchange for a lighter hand. But his betrayals soon became personal, when he sold protagonist Cole Phelps down the river in order to make him a scapegoat.

By revealing Phelps’s affair with German singer Elsa, Earle distracted the media from his (and the LAPD’s) secret involvement in the Suburban Redevelopment Fund, a crooked operation that dealt in insurance fraud and drug-pushing.

As a result, Roy gets his former partner demoted, and ensures that almost nobody will listen to Cole’s theories regarding the SRF.

To really spread the icing on the cake, Roy attends Cole’s funeral in the game’s closing moments, delivering his eulogy and slamming the corrupt officials he was working for. Earle ultimately escapes justice and rubs it in the face of a deceased Phelps, making him one of the slimiest and most underhanded video game characters of all time.

7. Al Mualim - Assassin's Creed

In the Assassin’s Creed universe, the Templars are fascistic and domineering, while the Assassins believe in free will at any cost. There’s some wiggle room for interpretation, but for all intents and purposes, the Assassins come out looking like the heroes in this scenario, a position that’s upheld by Al Mualim, the leader of the Assassins during the Third Crusades.

Advertisement

But seemingly in an attempt to foreshadow his sudden but inevitable betrayal, Al Mualim also taught Altair the eponymous ‘Assassin’s Creed’: “Nothing is true, everything is permitted”, and explained that the “creed does not command us to be free, it commands us to be wise.”

What he meant by this, was that he’d secretly been in cahoots with the Templar Order, before using the Assassin’s to seek out the Apple of Eden for his own uses. He sought the Apple’s mind control powers, the use of which would render the concept of freedom a thing of the past.

For all the stabbing that occurred prior to his betrayal, it was Al Mualim’s duplicitous ways that left the deepest scars of all.

6. Wheatley - Portal 2

Is it fair to blame artificial intelligence, when it ultimately goes rogue and tries to destroy humanity? After all, we created it, and moulded it in our image, so surely the fault lies with us rather than the machines themselves.

Advertisement

Like all AI mishaps, Wheatley didn’t initially seem like a terrible idea. He was the polar opposite of glaDOS, a joyful and bouncy companion who briefly made Aperture seem like a less terrifying place to be.

That is, until he replaced glaDOS as the facility’s primary AI core, whereupon he went mad with his newfound power.

Nobody would suspect a machine with Stephen Merchant’s charming and slightly dorky West Country drawl to be evil, especially not to the extent that working with glaDOS would seem like a good idea.

5. Yoshimo - Baldur's Gate II

BioWare games often begin with the player being introduced to an obviously temporary character, somebody to guide you through a short tutorial stage and get you accustomed to the game’s basic mechanics.

Advertisement

In Knights of the Old Republic, this role was undertaken by Republic soldier Trask Ulgo, who heroically sacrifices himself to allow you to escape. In Mass Effect 2, it was the devious officer Wilson, who was revealed as the Cerberus station’s betrayer about fifteen minutes into the game.

None of these stung quite like Yoshimo though, because Yoshimo wasn’t so obviously portrayed as a temp party member. Nobody expected Wilson or Trask Ulgo to make it past their introductions, because they weren’t advertised in any pre-release material, and were one-dimensional figures simply there to move the plot forward. Yoshimo was a fully-fledged character, a knowledgeable and skilled thief with some impressive combat abilities and a badass katana.

So when Yoshimo approaches you, claiming to be another prisoner escaping the evil Irenicus’s dungeon, you’re glad to have him along. In fact, you’re probably wishing you’d picked to play as a character more like Yoshimo.

That’s what makes it all the more heart-breaking when he’s revealed to be a puppet of Irenicus, and has been leading you into his clutches this entire time. It wasn’t exactly Yoshimo’s fault though – he was forced to obey Irenicus, and would be instantly killed if he didn’t.

4. General Shepherd - Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

If a shepherd’s job is to lead his flock, then Modern Warfare 2’s Shepherd lead his right off the edge of a cliff. This was a game, nay, a series that instilled in its players a belief that the Russians, the Germans and Middle Easterners were not to be trusted, at least within the confines of a Call of Duty campaign.

Advertisement

But it was all a ruse. The true mastermind behind MW2’s evildoings was General Shepherd himself. Not only was he American (gasp!), but he was also the very man who had assigned the likes of Roach and Soap to Task Force 141 in the first place.

It was a fairly daft twist – that the man who had been claiming to fight terrorism was actually perpetrating it in order to increase military funding and conscription – but it was damned effective in the moment.

It wasn’t even what Shepherd did that hurt us so badly, it was how he did it. Arriving to extract Roach and Ghost in a helicopter, the General appeared like a saviour descending from the sky.

Only, he was the very worst saviour, and would end up shooting both Roach and Ghost, before burning their bodies while they were still alive.

Flock this guy.

3. Bastila - Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic

Bastila is one of very few video game characters who technically betrayed the player twice.

Advertisement

Her first betrayal is one of misinformation. For the duration of Knights of the Old Republic, she neglects to mention that you are in fact the former Sith Lord Revan, and that you have been rendered memory-less after losing a battle with Bastila and her Jedi cohorts.

The second is perhaps even more brazen, but arguably less Batila’s fault. After staying behind on the Leviathan to battle Darth Malak, Bastila is captured and put through a gauntlet of Dark Side torture methods. Eventually, she succumbs, submitting to Malak and becoming his apprentice.

As a result, she begins using her rare battle meditation ability to improve the focus and skills of the Sith fighter pilots fending off the Republic around the Star Forge.

The player boards the Star Forge, only to find Bastila decked out in black robes, with her previously condescending attitude turned up to a Dark Side eleven. It’s even more shocking if the player had previously been romancing Bastila, although she can either be talked down or joined once beaten in a duel, depending on your Force alignment.

2. Edgar Ross - Red Dead Redemption

Edgar Ross was always a scumbag, a holier-than-thou fat-cat with little respect for anyone outside of his professional circle. But it seemed as though he had at least some semblance of a moral code; what kind of monster would make a man jump through such an arduous series of hoops in order to gain his freedom, only to mercilessly gun him down for his efforts?

Advertisement

Edgar Ross would.

Not content with simply betraying John Marston, this crooked Bureau chief wanted to rub salt in his wounds. So he lets John enjoy peaceful ranch life with his wife and son, as a reward for tracking and killing his former gang members.

He gives John a taste of what his life could have been like, had he not set out on the wrong path, before ordering a posse of more than twenty men to fill him with holes. There’s no honour in his actions, nor is there much in the way of justice.

Edgar Ross displayed all the traits of a cowardly man; it wasn’t the betrayal itself that shocked us, but the lengths at which Ross would go to ensure Marston was not only put in the ground, but humiliated every step of the way.

1. Atlas - BioShock

BioShock’s now infamous twist plays on our ingrained expectations of video game conventions. We never actually see Atlas, apart from a brief glimpse of his silhouette from afar. We speaks to us over a radio, telling us what to do. We can see a picture of him in the corner of our screen, and he looks to be a friendly chap.

Advertisement

But Atlas takes advantage of this trust – not only is he actually a criminal revolutionary called Frank Fontaine, he’s also the protagonist’s father. To make things even worse, he’s been controlling our every move through deep hypnosis, which is activated using the trigger phrase “would you kindly?”

Everything you knew to be true about Atlas – his boyish good looks, his soft Irish brogue, the fact that he was a loving husband and father – was completely untrue. He has a strong Brooklyn accent, is a downright despicable father, and looks like a GI Joe that’s been caught in a meat grinder.

All this time, he’d been using his own son as a pawn in a fiendish power play, without ever letting on his true intentions. If that’s not the ultimate betrayal, we don’t want to know what is.

Advertisement