10 Most Unreliable Video Game Companions Ever

Sometimes it feels like it'd be much easier to go it alone...

By Greg Hicks /

When the odds are against you, you're backed against the wall, you often want someone in your corner with you. A companion that can help even the score, carry your burdens and help you live to see another day.

Advertisement

For every Marcus there's a Dom, for every Ratchet his Clank. There's been many a fine example of companionship across the decade. You need someone that's got your back in a pinch, after all.

Sadly, not every pairing that share that special connection. Players need someone who's got their back in a firefight, not standing in front of them playing "Catch each shot with their face". When players are making that calculated jump, what they don't want is an enthusiastic fox plucking you out of the air.

The last thing a hero needs, when he's fighting off nightmare monstrosities, is his ward trying to smell what aftershave he's wearing. Or someone that wastes all of the medical supplies on the tiniest of booboo's.

Whether it be down to some misread programming or just good intention gone wrong, companions can sometimes be more hindrance than helpful.

Sadly, this lot can't be left to fend for themselves, so it falls on players to tolerate them that little bit longer.

10. Bravely Default - Airy

Fairies or some kind of pixie-like aiding character are part of the framework of an Eastern RPG. I could list examples, but chances are you've already thought of one. You know, the annoying, squeaky voiced companions that get more insufferable as time goes on, much like Navi from Ocarina of Time.

Advertisement

When it comes to Airy from 3DS hit Bravely Default, however, she's not just an unreliable companion. She's also an unreliable narrator.

In short, the fairy guides players to light crystal pillars throughout the land, apparently saving the world. Yet this creates a sort of parallel world/time loop scenario, bringing you no closer to saving the proverbial day.

Across the parallel worlds and time goes on, characters will hint that the oh-so helpful little aide may not be all that she seems...

Which becomes apparent when our heroes break the cycle (and a crystal), halting the schemes of Airy's master, Ouroboros. She's far from a sweet and innocent fairy when that happens, revealing her true nature in shocking form.

Even the title screen alludes to this deception as time goes on, if players aren't getting it.

9. Dead Rising - Any Survivor

Frank West may have covered wars, y'know, but nothing could prepare him for this. Not the zombie outbreak, he handles that quite well, surprisingly.

Advertisement

No, I refer to the arduous task of making sure those he rescues actually make it to the rescue point.

Now, it'd be fair to think some in need of rescuing would adhere to their saviour and follow their commands. Alright, some disarray and panic may ensue.

Yet in Dead Rising, where Frank can yell, "Follow me!" and some will indeed follow, but not at all. So players might think, "Right, let's arm them. Give them a fighting chance whilst they follow Frank".

That's just worse, as a plank of word to a survivor turns them into a would-be Conan the Barbarian. With about the self-preservation instinct of a lemming. Like unsupervised kids in a play pen, taking your eyes off of what a survivor's doing is lethal. Lose that focus and you'll be seeing, "Sophie has died" before you know it.

At least the Pied Piper had it easy. The rats didn't mutiny or refuse to follow him to apparent safety.

8. Sonic 3/Sonic & Knuckles - Tails

In terms of companionship throughout the ages, Tails has proven most of his worth behind the scenes. The two-tailed tinkerer of a fox has helped Sonic and friends with aircrafts and ingenuity.

Advertisement

It's when he's in the fray that he becomes a right little sh*t.

Sonic the Hedgehog games are largely about precision platforming. Not to the controller-crushing degree of Super Meat Boy, but can be tricksy enough in places that demand attention.

So imagine the dismay on players' faces when you're soaring through the air, having nailed the timing, and Tails plucks you out of the air in a vain attempt at helping. It kills the trajectory of the jump and if the player hits jump again, it may drop them into an unwarranted death.

Or when the AI fox hits a switch at the wrong time, resulting in a hedgehog pancake because Tails has gone on without you.

When a friend is playing, it's not so bad, as you can coordinate. But much like another example later on, when the AI is in charge, all logic goes out the window. Stick to aircrafts and tinkering, Tails.

7. Fallout 4 - Dog Meat

Dogs are generally considered man's best friend. Unwavering loyalty, a constant and faithful companion, you can't really fault them. You can fault their digital counterparts when they cause players to die umpteen times, though.

Advertisement

Dogmeat, the stray that the player adopts early on in Fallout 4 is a prime example of this, prioritising wilful obedience over something as integral as longevity.

You can't blame him, really. He's not going to know the difference between loyalty and suicidal tendencies, is he? At least, that's the only reason I can think of as to why he'll charge into proximity mines if you accidentally direct him that way.

Or why he'll wander into your line of fire/explosion in a valiant effort to defend you. Good thing there's no morality meter in this game, or players would seem like right bastards.

It's not the end of the world if Dogmeat does catch some friendly fire or accidental blast radius. It's just a constant pain in the arse for players to wait until a battle is over to pick the dopey bugger back up.

Immortal? Maybe.
Annoying? Absolutely.

6. Enslaved: Odyssey To The West - Trip

In this loose adaptation of the Chinese fable, the relationship between Tripitaka and Monkey is already strained from the start. Well, putting an explosive, proximity-controlled device on someone and enslaving them tends to do that.

Advertisement

But as the unlikely pair start to bond, Trip trusts Monkey to do the grunt work and scout out safe passage. Which is fine, except for when she decides not follow and Monkey goes one step too far and explodes.

It breaks the flow of the gameplay when players want to push forward and the fickle Tripitaka decides she won't climb that ledge and sets off the proximity-popper on Monkey's brain-case.

Or when players are off exploring when the game allows some extra length, only to be cut short by Trip startling some enemies and getting herself kidnapped and taken out of range. Sure, there are times when the game calls for it, but all other times it's a right pain when your companion literally brings your progress to a halt.

Why Monkey doesn't carry her and chucking her in a bush when he needs to fight is beyond me.

5. Silent Hill 2 - Maria

When it comes to survival horror, it's usually hard enough trying to keep the protagonist from meeting a terrible fate, let alone anyone else.

Advertisement

If they can handle themselves then more's the better, but as this list demonstrates, it's usually not the case.

James Sunderland is already having a right time of it in Silent Hill already. Y'know, what with the whole "Letter from dead wife, geometric-headed relentless fiend in pursuit" schtick going on. What he doesn't need is a survivor with a death wish bigger than James' guilt complex (that'll make sense if you've finished it).

Escort missions are a burden most of the time anyway, but this one goes the extra mile. Should Maria take took much damage from either James or the manifestations that the titular town has conjured up, it can and will affect an ending.

Which wouldn't be so bad if Maria didn't have an obnoxious habit of getting right in the way of James' flailing about in a fight.

In a game like this with such sticky combat, it can be an extra contrivance to keep an eye on her.

4. Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six: Vegas 2 - Jung

In the world of highly trained special operatives, sent in to dangerous locales and volatile situations, you expect your team to work as a well-oiled machine. But all it takes it one loose cog to disrupt that flow, and that's where Jung Park comes in.

Advertisement

When your team works well in the R6: Vegas games, it's great. The level of precision and tactic required to clear missions room by room is some of the slickest around (for its time). But keeping the protagonist alive isn't the player's only concern, they have to look after their team too. Your other companion, Walker, is self-sufficient and has the common sense to not get shot (much).

Not Jung though, oh no.

Take your eye off of him, or leave him to [what you'd think is] taking out the enemy shooting at him, and you'll hear, "Jung down!" more often than you'd like to.

Which is a good dozen more times than necessary. What makes it worse if players have to risk themselves to pick the daft spod back up again, repeatedly.

Seriously, Jung could incapacitate himself in a room with a folding chair if you left him there.

3. Resident Evil 5 - Sheva

Ashley Graham gets a load of flack in Resident Evil 4, what with the annoying voice and the kidnaps, but that could be tolerated (mostly). What she didn't do, however, was waste all of your precious ammo and healing items at every opportunity.

Advertisement

No, that honour goes to Sheva Alomar, BSAA agent, Chris Redfield's partner and all-round inconvenience when being handled by the AI. In human-controlled co-op, it's great to have a helping hand.

It's when you go solo that's the issue.

Normally, you'd think rationing out the firepower accordingly would be fair. And it would, but Sheva doesn't do normal. She'll waste a few magnum rounds on a standard enemy, rather than the surplus handgun ammo she's carrying.

But worse than wasting ammo is wasting your high strength healing items instead. For example, if Chris takes a tiny bump or throwing axe to the head, that's nothing a little green herb can't fix. Yet if Sheva's got a full-health filling first aid spray in her hands, she won't hesitate to use it.

You literally have to run away and heal quicker than it takes your AI partner to catch up to you. Which is worrying when there are bigger threats in the game.

2. Goldeneye - Natalya

In Pierce Brosnan's first outing in GoldenEye, Natalya Simonova broke away from the "Bond girl" trope... well, a bit. She still becomes a love interest by the end, but for the majority is a savvy foil to Brosnan's Bond.

Advertisement

A survivor throughout, Natalya becomes integral to the spy's plan to thwart Trevelyan and the titular weaponised satellite device.

In the video game tie-in on the Nintendo 64, however, that logic didn't carry over. Rather than accepting that she's not a battle-trained agent, the polygonal counterpart would do her best to eat every bullet. It's almost like she took national patriotism too far, taking the bullet for each of her fellow countrymen over this English pig-dog killing them all.

Or at least that what it feels like, as you attempt to clear a room of enemies intent on killing you both. You had to pick your shots carefully on these escort missions, as Natalya has an annoying habit of running in the way of fire, friendly or otherwise.

It wasn't uncommon to see the words, "Natalya has died", which can be so very frustrating near the end of a mission.

1. The Witcher 3: The Wild Hunt - Roach

When you start a Witcher game, it may seem odd that Geralt has a disconnect with his horses. Calling each one Roach, our hero seems to bear no significant attachment to his mares unlike, say, Wander from Shadow of the Colossus.

Advertisement

Then, as you come out of a tavern and find your house atop the adjacent roof, you begin to see why.

Whilst it's unreasonable to expect your horse to stick to you every step of the way, when you summon them and they're in what seems like the next county, it can be a pain to wait.

Or better still, when a player summons their trusty steed and finds her stuck on a branch. Or a fence post. Or something that may not even be real yet still enough to hinder them coming to you.

Over time, CD Projekt Red did work out some of the kinks with Roach's AI. Not all of them though, with even new players finding frustration at what seems like a simple concept.

Whilst the world of Temeria and bordering lands is beautiful to take in, when your horse decides that it wants to be a scaffolder when you summon it somewhat ruins the illusion.

Advertisement