10 No-Brainer Video Game Sequels That DIDN'T Get Made

Sequels we all wanted, but they never arrived.

By Rob Cain /

Sequels are often big business in the gaming scene; once you've established a series that resonates with the masses, it's time to expand. How do you go "bigger, better and more badass" as Cliffy B put it? You can generate a lot of anticipation under this banner, doubly so if it's a title many have been clamouring for.

Advertisement

A game that warrants a sequel was able to make a big impact because of its high critical reception among reviewers and fans alike, or it may have been a brilliant use of a popular license that already has a community lining up to demand a follow-up.

Developers are often at the whim of their publishers and when an IP is no longer financially viable, they won't hesitate to shelve a project and move on. Chasing the most popular trends in the industry is now more popular than ever and with development getting more expensive, creative freedom is lessened.

These are the ten sequels that were planned, but never made it past the finish line. They were abruptly cancelled or converted into less impressive projects over time.

10. Knights Of The Old Republic 3

Before Star Wars games fell under the banner of Electronic Arts, there were some real gems to found from a multitude of developers under the publisher Lucasarts. One of the most revered and enjoyed was Knights of the Old Republic, developed by Bioware and Obsidian Entertainment respectively.

Advertisement

Taking place thousands of years before the events of the films, KOTOR and its sequel, The Sith Lords, were both very deep role-playing titles with equally engrossing stories to tell. The way players could craft the Jedi or Sith Lord they wanted to be throughout the narrative created an unparalleled experience in the galaxy far, far away.

So why wasn't there a third game? It comes down to the numerous projects Bioware took on afterwards. They went from Jade Empire through to Mass Effect without so much of a hint of KOTOR 3. Obsidian had also moved on, having been put through an incredibly tight deadline to complete the second game. With that title having an inconclusive cliffhanger ending, this only increased hopes for a third entry.

What fans got instead was Star Wars: The Old Republic, an MMO that failed to impress investors or knock World of Warcraft off its lofty perch. It wasn't quite the successor they had wanted.

9. The Simpsons: Hit & Run

The Simpsons haven't had the best of times in the gaming industry; after many lackluster attempts to translate the license into video game form, only two titles reached solid status. 2007's The Simpsons Game and The Simpsons: Hit and Run from 2003. The latter was certainly the most popular all around.

Advertisement

Setting players loose in an open-world Springfield, players took control of different Springfield characters as they drove around and completed various missions. The style of the series, including its writing, humour, and overall wacky nature were all perfectly captured in the game. The fact that it took all the right inspirations from contemporaries like Grand Theft Auto was the icing on the cake.

A sequel was in the works at developer Radical Entertainment and had even reached the prototype stage. The plan was to get more creative with the cars that could be driven, including connecting them together for some manic results. Unfortunately, things didn't get very far after that as Electronic Arts won the rights to make The Simpsons Game to coincide with the upcoming movie.

Radical was locked out of making any more Simpsons content from then on and to this day, fans still hold the original in the highest regard.

8. Alpha Protocol 2

Of the many action RPGs on the market, Alpha Protocol stood out from its contemporaries. It was a title no one had undertaken before, an espionage RPG. But due to multiple development problems and overstepping on the budget, the game arrived in 2010 to a mostly negative critical reception.

Advertisement

Alpha Protocol may have been a flop both critically and commercially, but the ambition was there. Buried beneath all its problems was an incredibly deep and dynamic set of character interactions that changed greatly through player choice. Obsidian had plans to expand this and create a more Tarantino-esque style for the sequel.

Unfortunately, it was not to be as SEGA cancelled these plans. As the publisher still owns the licence, the developer is unable to produce AP2 without their permission. Going back further, the cancellation also came down to Disney as well; with Obsidian's cancelled "Dwarves" RPG, they had to hurriedly negotiate a project they had long wanted to work on. This led to selling the rights to Alpha Protocol to SEGA.

With over a decade having passed and the digital version having been removed from Steam due to music licenses expiring, the prospects of an Alpha Protocol sequel are now further away than ever. The best we can hope for is that Microsoft gives the studio more free rein over their future projects.

7. Mega Man Legends 3

Capcom's Blue Bomber has had many a spin-off over the years; the X series and Battle Network spin-offs are two such examples. Arguably the biggest cult favourite of these was Mega Man Legends which debuted the long-running franchise in the third dimension while going deeper with its story.

Advertisement

Fans were certainly drawn to its charms and the first two entries gained strong followings across the PlayStation and other consoles. The plan was to launch the third Legends title on the 3DS upon its announcement in 2010. However, once creator Keiji Inafune left Capcom, doubts started to circulate around the project; despite insisting that development would continue.

Mega Man Legends 3 would end up being cancelled a year later; according to Capcom, there wasn't enough interaction between the developers to keep pushing forward. This didn't stop the fanbase from banding together on a Facebook page titled: "100,000 Strong for bringing back Mega Man Legends 3", but it failed to persuade the corporation to continue.

Over a decade later, the third entry still hasn't arrived to continue the story with Mega Man still stranded on the moon. Recently, the game's composer stated he wants to go the route of Shenmue 3 and crowdfund Legends 3, but no further details of this have surfaced.

6. Alien Isolation 2

The terrifying Xenomorph has always had excellent potential in the gaming scene, but very few titles were able to deliver on this promise. In 2014, British developer Creative Assembly created the solid Alien: Isolation in 2014.

Advertisement

Isolation came at a very opportune time; for the most part it helped to wash out the bad taste of Aliens: Colonial Marines from the year before. Here was an Alien game made with great care and attention to detail, perfectly capturing the style and tone of the 1979 classic.

There were some musings and releases following the game's release; a sequel comic followed Amanda's escapades after the events of the game. But when it came to making a true successor, fans were very disappointed to find Alien: Blackout. This mobile spin-off appeared to take inspiration from Five Nights at Freddie's with the protaganist placed in the control room and directing other characters.

Considering how the mobile scene has never been known for immersive horror titles, the community expected better. Over six years after the game's release, Creative Assembly has now returned to making their flagship franchise under SEGA. While Total War is a deep and involving title in its own right, the one Alien game that finally got it right on modern systems has been cast aside and forgotten about.

5. Star Wars Battlefront 3

Another Star Wars game to make the list, Star Wars Battlefront 3 was in the works at Free Radical Design. Its two predecessors, produced by Pandemic Studios, are held in very high regard for seamlessly translating the combined arms warfare of Battlefield into the Star Wars universe.

Advertisement

There were big additions planned for the third entry, most notably seamless transitions between planetary and space combat. Sadly the ambitious project would be cancelled by Lucasarts executives, who feared the project was getting too expensive. Free Radical would collapse into administration and be bought out by Crytek shortly thereafter.

Star Wars itself fell into the hands of Electronic Arts several years later. Now that the brand has left high prominence with the sequel trilogy wrapping up, the custodians of the license are unlikely to pursue a third modern Battlefront. Still with the bare-bones 2015 version and its greedy 2017 sequel, much of the community would argue that it's for the best.

Seeing what EA did to the once proud Battlefront series makes it all the more damning at what could have been. Years after the cancellation though, fans have been building the Star Wars Battlefront 3 Legacy Mod. This complete conversion aims to resurrect the title and create a more faithful successor to the 2005 classic.

4. Silent Hills

Silent Hill and its publisher Konami had been placed on a downward spiral in the seventh generation of gaming. Weaker releases and a botched HD re-release had made the industry rather reluctant to create scary games for fear of losing profits.

Advertisement

However in 2014, an unassuming demo called P.T found its way onto PlayStation 4. It was thick with atmosphere and creeping dread, impressing many gamers. Once they unravelled its mysteries, it was discovered to be Silent Hills, a return to series form from video game auteur Hideo Kojima.

After many years of stagnation, Silent Hills looked like the game we had all been waiting for. The promise on display in the initial P.T demo spoke of a game that would bring back the survival horror genre that had been thoroughly abandoned in the early 2010s.

In one of the most crushing disappointments in gaming history, Silent Hills was cancelled by Konami in April 2015. The publisher was widely criticised by both fans and journalists alike, which contributed massively to their rapid downfall. What could have been one of the finest horror experiences in gaming met an abrupt demise. At best, the legacy of Silent Hills lives on in the latest Resident Evil games and smaller indie productions.

3. Fez 2

The next entry is a sequel that was cancelled due to its own creator rather than the pressures of publishers and high management. Released in 2012, Fez drew a large following thanks to its dazzling art style and unique gameplay of changing orientations to traverse levels.

Advertisement

It was an underrated yet celebrated indie title, one that stood alongside the likes of Minecraft and Super Meat Boy to lead the charge into smaller scale releases.

The game was the product of one Phil Fish, who developed the concept himself with assistance from programmer Renaud Bédard. His appearance in "Indie Game: The Movie" showed he went through many difficulties getting Fez to market, especially when it came to publishing deals. Once it did finally arrive, most were generally pleased with how it turned out.

Naturally, the man started to look into a sequel, aiming to deepen the game's well established formula. What happened instead was a very abrupt cancellation. Phil Fish ended up getting into a nasty spat on Twitter with game journalist Marcus Beer, who started insulting the developer. This quickly boiled into a full on comment war with the wider community. As the abuse thrown by by sides got worse, Phil Fish snapped, cancelled Fez II and left the industry entirely.

2. Prey 2

Having spent over a decade in development, the release of Prey in 2006 vindicated Human Head Studios. As Tommy Tawodi, the player finds themselves battling the hideous alien forces of the Sphere.

Advertisement

Prey's strong trappings in sci-fi horror made it a cult classic and as the ending proclaimed that it would continue, Human Head Studios got to work on the follow-up. It was set to take place in a vast dystopian city in which bounty hunter and marshall Killian Samuels would traverse. The game's reveal trailer, though pre-rendered, had a lot of ambition behind it, but Prey 2 would find itself trudging along in development.

Following an acquisition by Bethesda, Prey 2's production would quietly end in 2011 and the game was subsequently cancelled. It was reported that disagreements had arisen between Human Head and the publisher. The Prey property would not end entirely as a new version of the game would be produced by Arkane Studios instead.

The new Prey certainly has its merits, most notably with its unique combat system and mind-bending story. Be that as it may, some areas of the community still wonder what Prey 2 could have been. Perhaps it could have predated Cyberpunk 2077 by nearly a decade.

1. Dead Space 4

Last but not least we come to another highly regarded franchise that ended up being gutted by its publisher. Since its debut in 2008, Dead Space was a market leader in gaming horror. In the boots of engineer Isaac Clarke, the original game was a claustrophobic struggle for survival and its sequel an intense action roller coaster.

Advertisement

Things went sideways with Dead Space 3 which dropped the pretense of survival horror and threw in some crappy microtransactions for good measures. With a muted critical reception, the franchise ended on a meek note. Yet developer Visceral Games was very keen to continue the property on their own terms.

Since 2013, further details for a proposed Dead Space 4 have emerged. Creative director Ben Wanat stated it would have been a hybrid between linear and non-linear chapters while continuing from where the story had left off. The developer clearly had great passion for the project and had it proceeded, Dead Space could have redeemed itself among the masses.

This was not to be as Dead Space 3 sold under expectations, compelling Electronic Arts to abandon the series. Visceral Games later met their end in October 2017 when EA, viewing them and their planned Star Wars game as financially unviable, closed them down to the dismay of many.

Do you have any other highly anticipated sequels that never arrived? Stick them in the comments down below...

Advertisement