10 Obvious Video Game Home Runs That Somehow FAILED
Publishers are exceptionally talented at sabotaging their own IP, it turns out.
Easy isn't a word that exists in the Game Development Handbook. The most watertight pitch can sound like a money-printing idea on paper. Still, colorful words don't magically become working code without hundreds, sometimes thousands, of talented hands working in unison. Even the likes of Ubisoft and Blizzard, masters of their craft, sometimes struggle to deliver on promises. Often, that's down to unfair expectations from an overzealous fan base demanding an unrealistic product, but the customer is, remarkably, sometimes right to criticize laughably poor decisions.
There's no shortage of them. Some of the most disappointing games of the last few generations were originally viewed under an altogether different lens. Believe it or not, Final Fantasy XIII was considered a surefire triple-A winner when Square Enix unveiled the next-gen sequel for Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3. Fast-forward four years to release, and public sentiment flipped from awe to scorn over the nonsensical decision to meddle with a core component of the series formula.
It's not just established franchises that suffer, either. By nature, new intellectual property is going to be a tougher sell. The upside is that no preconceptions exist; a boon for Anthem, which looked sublime when it first debuted at E3. BioWare wasn't given the time it needed to cook the so-called Destiny-killer and fell victim to its arrogance based on previous successes.
Nobody succeeds at self-sabotage quite like EA, though. You'd think it would have learned its lesson by now...
10. Titanfall Series
Granted, it's cheating a little to lump both entries in Respawn's cult series together, but in this instance, it's worth looking at the bigger picture.
Why? Because, incidentally, both instalments suffered commercial failure for wildly different reasons. Titanfall snapped up over 60 awards for its debut showing at E3 2013. When it rolled around less than a year later, release scores mimicked that initial success. Considering the FPS pedigree employed by Respawn, sublime gameplay was a given; everything else fell below par. Poor net code, the near-total lack of a single-player campaign, and the eternal struggle of establishing a new IP all contributed to Titanfall's, well, fall.
So Respawn went back to the drawing board with Titanfall 2. The sequel rectified every criticism of the original — the campaign is one of the best you'll find in an FPS — and then some, but fell far short of sales projections, nonetheless. EA, in its infinite wisdom as an industry-leading publisher, decided to engage in self-sabotage and dropped Titanfall 2 between the launch of its own Battlefield 1 and Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare. Two massive IPs compared to Respawn's.
To this day, nobody knows what the suits at EA were smoking to think competing with itself was smart business acumen.
9. Star Wars: Battlefront Classic Collection
At this stage, Star Wars: Battlefront is nothing but a cursed IP. The so-called Classic Collection, a compendium of Pandemic's first two original games, launched back in March of this year and swiftly earned universally negative scores across the board. Network issues aplenty ruined any chance of fans embarking on a nostalgia-fuelled adventure in a galaxy far, far away, and that was just the first offense.
If you want an idea of just how short-sighted the business decisions proved to be this time around; three 64-player servers were available at launch. A far cry from the number needed to accommodate players in their thousands. Sure, additional server space was deployed not long after, but once people were in, all that awaited them was a technical mess of bugs and questionable design choices. No attempt to modernise controls, missing cinematics, and, the kicker, the use of fan-made content without the creators' permission, resulted in what should have been an easy win appearing as little more than a quick cash grab.
The original Battlefront games are revered for a reason but this lazy port doesn't make it easy to see why. In hindsight, that Aspyr's in charge of the upcoming Knights of the Old Republic remake is as worrying prospect, to say the least.
8. Assassin's Creed III
Let's be real; Assassin's Creed wasn't great. Sure, it was a solid first entry in what would become Ubisoft's biggest cash cow, but it wouldn't be until a sequel was released in 2009, that the IP took off. That's thanks, in large part, to criticisms of Altair's adventure being taken into account. Still, it can't be stressed enough, that the most important ingredient for success was Ezio Auditore da Firenze.
Even now, with 13 titles under its belt, Ezio remains AC's most memorable protagonist. The Florentian finally hanging up his robes at the climax of Revelations was a sad day, indeed, not least because his successor would prove to be inferior in every regard. Connor was devoid of the charisma, wit, and personality of his forebear. A drawback not at all helped by the fact that AC III's hero unwittingly found himself plonked in a setting objectively inferior to Middle Ages Europe as far as architecture was concerned.
Boston, New York, and Philadelphia circa the 1700s lacked the concrete playground vibe established in previous games and suffered as a result. Parkour, a core component of the series, was diminished and, to add insult to injury, the faux-historical narrative was dull, to boot.
7. Diablo IV
Diablo IV's campaign experience is fantastic. If you count yourself a casual gamer and the term endgame is alien to you, Blizzard's long-awaited sequel will be right up your alley.
Unfortunately, for the masses who count everything post-credits to be the real meat of what an ARPG has to offer, the world of Sanctuary is sorely lacking. Remember, this series prides itself on replayability, promising untold hours of entertainment grinding for the perfect loot. Get stronger, hit the big demon harder. It's a tried and tested gameplay loop as popular today as it was in the '90s. That's all present and accounted for in Diablo IV, but the problem on launch — and arguably even still — is Blizzard's 21st-century approach to endgame design.
Tree of Whsipers, World tiers, Altars of Lilith, Renown: there's plenty of content to engage with in the endless pursuit of power, but none of it is exciting. To be as blunt as possible, no individual portion of the gear treadmill feels organic. Couple uninteresting design with boring, incremental loot upgrades, and it's little wonder why Blizzard has spent the better part of a year attempting to rectify its mistakes for hardcore audiences.
6. Brink
Billed as a harmonious amalgamation of strategy, freedom of movement, and tight shmup gunplay, Brink looked primed to deliver a revolutionary competitive experience back in the early 2010s. Smashing together DNA from Mirror's Edge, Call of Duty and Team Fortress 2 to form a cohesive experience was always going to be an ambitious aspiration, though, and, despite topping most-anticipated lists all over the shop before release, Human Head Studios ultimately fell foul of biting off more than it could chew.
Not that there was anything inherently wrong with the end product. Contemporary reviews near-unanimously agreed that what Human Head shipped showed ample promise that could be built upon with future updates. The problem was that it was unfinished and lacked any semblance of balance critical to ensuring the longevity of what was primarily intended to be a competitive, team-based affair.
Games like these live and die based on the level of post-launch support afforded to them. Brink received very little and suffered as a result. Technically, it's still playable — official servers remain live — but you'll be hard-pushed to find another human on them.
5. Final Fantasy XIII
Final Fantasy XIII, much like its central character's namesake, was supposed to be lightning in a bottle.
Thanks to two stellar, critically acclaimed predecessors in FFX and XII, Square was on a streak of success with its flagship IP, and even had the added benefit of releasing the thirteenth installment on next-gen hardware to generate additional hype. Moreover, the studio publically likening aspects of XIII's character designs to Final Fantasy VII (specifically making Lightning reminiscent of Cloud Strife), was music to the ears. There was no way, based on precedent, that failure was possible.
We all know how swiftly that confidence turned to despair and for Square, it never should have come as a surprise. Shockingly, stripping a core gameplay feature from a series thirteen games deep is a surefire way to piss off a sizeable portion of the fan base. That's exactly what XIII achieved by doing away with open-world exploration in the first 25 hours of its runtime, making everything before Gran Pulse feel like a long-winded tutorial.
But that wasn't the only offence. Lightning, Snow, Vanille, Hope, and the remaining retinue of main characters in XIII never felt like a cohesive unit like in previous games. Most were dull, shallow facsimiles of heroes from yesteryear. Poor form.
4. Marvel Vs. Capcom: Infinite
Here we have a case study of why pandering to a highly specific audience is always a bad idea.
Marvel Vs. Capcom: Infinite, just like its forebears, was supposed to be a celebration of the characters belonging to both studios in balls-to-the-wall fan service like no other. What it ended up being was a thinly veiled attempt to capitalize on the success of the MCU by omitting a huge number of popular Marvel mainstays that had yet to appear in Disney-owned live-action. There's a reason, after all, that Captain Marvel and Iron Man found themselves the poster child for this entry in the series.
Frustratingly, the nuts and bolts of Infinite were mechanically sound and arguably superior to MvC3, though that came at the expense of no fan-favourite X-Men appearing on the roster. The AWOL status of Charles Xavier's gifted children, combined with character models and animations straight out of Uncanny Valley territory, led to Infinite earning the unwanted status of a red-headed stepchild.
Unsurprisingly, there's been no talk of sequels since and, judging by Infinite's poor sales, Capcom's going to think twice before revisiting what was once one of the best crossovers in gaming. Sad times.
3. SimCity (2013)
If there's any overarching theme to be gleaned from this article, it's that EA's ability to do itself over is unparalleled in the gaming space. 2013's SimCity was supposed to be a grand modernisation of the seminal city-building series kickstarted in the late '80s. Leading up to release, Maxis Emeryville earned endless praise for its ambitions. Not only did SimCity look the part — finally transitioning to fully 3D environments — but aimed to provide unparalleled immersion via the introduction of multiplayer. City owners were able to establish concrete playgrounds in the same space and co-exist (or the opposite, if you were role-playing a ruthless arsehole) if they so wished,
But looks aren't everything. When the doors opened to the public in 2013, no disaster relief team on the planet could save this digital landscape. Egregious technical issues completely engulfed the post-release conversation. Only fuelling the inevitable hate train headed straight for EA HQ was the revelation that an internet connection was mandatory to play, even if the player wanted to go solo. Not being able to save progress offline and total network outages attributed to server overload resulted in a messy launch that Maxis Emeryville never recovered from, leading to its closure in 2015.
2. Anthem
When even the staff responsible for creating a game haven't the foggiest idea what it's about, that should be the first sign that trouble is brewing. That's exactly what happened with BioWare's first foray into the live service market. The final result, without hyperbole, ended up being one of gaming's biggest-ever blunders; Anthem was supposed to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with Bungie's Destiny as the ultimate offering of an always-online, evolving world which, to be fair, it achieved. Sort of.
The issue, thanks to a lack of foresight, as well as arrogance on the part of BioWare's management that it could do no wrong, was that Anthem didn't know what it wanted to be, let alone its creator. It was only when the IP was officially announced at E3 2017 that BioWare staff realised what they were seeing on-screen was the very same game they were working on, and by then, it was already too late to ship anything resembling the tech demo.
What did ship in 2019 was a disjointed mess of ideas with no direction and a worrying lack of content. Jason Schreier's 2019 exposé for Kotaku provides an excellent, in-depth breakdown of events that preceded one of gaming's biggest blunders but suffice it to say, Anthem was doomed from the word go.
1. Cyberpunk 2077
Living up to expectations is never easy. CD Projekt RED had a figurative Himalayas to climb following up The Witcher 3 with something as grand and ambitious in scope and folded under pressure as a result. Accounting for the disastrous post-launch, it's easy to forget how much hype followed Cyberpunk 2077's pre-release. The dystopian action RPG was hailed as the second coming in gaming before it even went to print — an accolade that, based on its handling of Andrzej Sapkowski's Witcher books, was understandable, if hasty. If nothing else, such assuredness only spoke to the quality of Geralt's video game adventures.
The science fiction romp eventually manifested in 2020 and only a travesty followed. Initially downplaying accusations of cut content, game-breaking bugs, and poor performance on last-gen hardware, CDPR ultimately found itself forced to confront Cyberpunk's problems head-on. Sony pulled V's troubled story from its digital stores, class-action lawsuits were filed and apologies were written. Years would pass until the stigma of its initial release would soften and only with the release of expansion Phantom Liberty, would many fans offer forgiveness for the sins of the past.