10 Overblown Video Game Controversies

Video games promote Satanism, apparently.

By Jake Parr /

Video games have brought amusement and joy to countless gamers across the world for several decades now. Despite their growing popularity, they have been subject to numerous controversies for quite some time.

Advertisement

In the nineties, there was a big scare on video game violence potentially turning gamers, especially young ones, into becoming killers. A ridiculous idea, yes, and a lack of actual evidence put towards said argument did not help. Unfortunately, it did not stop uninformed parents and American senators from demanding bans upon games numerous times throughout the decade.

Today, there's rarely a day when a game, developer, or studio is not receiving flak. Social media is a double-edged sword. Whilst it offers easy access to information on almost any topic, the problem is, there is just as much opinionated, bias, misinterpreted assumptions that might come across as the truth.

And that's one of the biggest issues with video games these days: arguments can kick off over the most trivial things. Sometimes a lack of context and research will result in the misinterpretation of an otherwise tame scene as a notorious and horrible spectacle that only the cruelest of the cruel could possibly stomach.

Prepare to scowl at your monitors in confusion and anger at these ten overblown video game controversies.

10. Divinity: Original Sin – Exposing Armour

Armour is worn to protect the player from devastating attacks, and trying to impress other players into thinking you're the coolest dragon-slayer on the server, even though picking fights with rats and boars are a big problem for you. Protecting yourself in medieval-themed games is always a necessity.

Advertisement

Admittedly, female characters aren't as lucky as the men. On some occasions, their armour seems to offer the same amount of protection as a male's attire, while exposing more of their flesh. Divinity: Original Sin's original front cover depicts a fully-fledged male holding the hand of a female with her navel and breasts partially exposed. Armour like that doesn't exactly scream "warrior".

According to Larian Studios' Thierry Van Gyseghem, the criticism received for the artwork over Kickstarter was minor at best, and he also noted the team's trip to E3 2012 was free of hatred towards the cover. Nevertheless, it was still controversial enough to persuade some people to send threats and harassing e-mails to the team.

Gyseghem told BlogJob in an interview, regarding the threats that were being sent, “When you own a pizza place and one day the mob enters your little shack, threatens you by saying if I don’t stop selling pepperoni pizza’s they’ll do anything in their power to make sure you go out of business, then what should we call this? Blackmail? Censorship? Harassment? Extortion? or simply a trade embargo?”

While they made something of a faux pas with the revealing cover design, the backlash the developers received was far disproportionate the the crime.

9. Bully – Promoting Bullying And Simulating Genocide

Bully was like a junior version of Grand Theft Auto. Instead of stealing cars and blowing up gang members, you were beating the snot out of jocks and attending classes. You could even fulfill your lifelong dream of stealing a fire extinguisher and bludgeoning the teachers with it until they pass out, like the rebel inside you always wanted.

Advertisement

Some groups were weary of the game before release, assuming that it promoted bullying as hilariously horrible. In actuality, the rebellious teen Jimmy Hopkins is led to take on the worst that the school has to offer, such as the narcissistic preppies and the brutish jocks, in order to make school life better for the oppressed students.

The government of Brazil classed the game as psychologically harmful to adults as well as children, and even implemented a ridiculous fine of a million Brazilian real (over £200k) to anyone who attempted to sell this banned game. Which is like caning a child with a barbed wire bat for passing notes in class.

Then came notoriously uninformed American senator Jack Thompson, known for his painfully underdeveloped arguments about the dangers of video games. Thompson described Bully as the sort of game that simulates school genocide. With stink bombs and slingshots? Really?

Even when he took his argument to court and received a crushing, humiliating defeat, he remained unmoved that a game about rising up against bullying would persuade players to commit mass violence.

8. Metal Gear Solid V - Quiet's Skimpy Outfit

Admit it, Metal Gear fans: Quiet was a stupid excuse for series creator Hideo Kojima to strip her down to barely any clothes.

Advertisement

Quiet's design was risqué enough to hit the mainstream press, describing her as a sex symbol that demeaned women by prancing around in a bra and some broken tights. According to Kojima, he wanted to create an "erotic" character.

Talk about awkward word choice; people weren't happy with that explanation, and the accusations of sexism swarmed in like a tidal wave of negativity. By "erotic", he meant 'sexy'. And that still didn't do him any favours.

The developer was quick to try and clarify over Twitter that, "I created her character as an antithesis to the women characters...who are excessively exposed. But once you recognize the secret reason for her exposure, you will feel ashamed of your words & deeds."

Honourable intentions? Or exaggerating? You be the judge. Turns out her exposed skin helps her breathe, similar to a plant photosynthesizing. It's ridiculous, but there's no shame in admitting it here.

Was the outfit worthy of quite the level of opprobrium it received however? In a game series that has never been shy about provoking debate with a series of challenging themes, perhaps a skimpy outfit was the tamest of the bunch.

7. Overwatch – Tracer's Booty Pose

During the Overwatch open beta, many fans were delighted at Blizzard Entertainment's latest multiplayer-shooter. One fan in particular decided to share on the forums a long post about the time-travelling speed-demon Tracer.

Advertisement

While the post was full of praise at first, it then expressed disgust at one of Tracer's cocky victory poses. According to the fan, this exposed her bottom, and thus reduced the “fast elite killer” to “another bland sex symbol”.

The post ended by saying that the person's daughter loves watching the game's trailers, and wants her to grow up with a team of oddball murderers as inspirational role models.

This was persuasive enough for the developers to formally apologize and replace Tracer's pose, much to the dismay of many fans. The news started to spread like wildfire. Both sides were just as hot-headed about it, as well.

Tracer's pose, standing with her back to the camera while looking over her shoulder, was likely to imply she was trying to say "Sorry to leave you in last place, luv!" to the losing team, though her exposed posterior unintentionally painted a different picture.

Blizzard's response to it all was a bit tongue-in-cheek. Tracer's pose was replaced with a cheesecake pin-up girl pose instead. Some were still offended by the supposedly over-sexualized pose. Others were too busy laughing at the company's cheekiness (no pun intended).

6. Left 4 Dead 2 – Racism

What is the first thing that comes to mind when you play a survival horror game against hordes of the undead? Are you tensed up due to lack of supplies? Are you happy to know you've finally been paired up with some competent allies? Or are you disgusted at the blatant racism against African-Americans in the game?

Advertisement

During the beta phase of the cooperative zombie frag-a-thon Left 4 Dead 2, a blog post on the Houston Chronicle appeared and condemned the game for setting one of the levels in New Orleans and featuring many black zombies.

During this time, New Orleans was hit by Hurricane Katrina, but even then, it seemed a stretch to call out Valve and slander them for the setting.

Of course, bravery and stupidity easily intertwine with one another. Not realizing that the zombies could easily have been tanned by the hot sun, or that there were two other black protagonists to play as in the game, it still caused quite an uproar in the community, the average response being something in the lines of “What the hell are you talking about?”

Valve's response was the same thing, but on a more professional note. Left 4 Dead writer Chet Faliszek described the accusation as “utter insanity,” and with good reason. As this dumbfounded moment in gaming proves, sweeping generalizations is no substitute for arguments backed up with sufficient evidence.

5. Pillars Of Eternity – Transphobic Poetry

An in-game poem could be found on the memorial of a gentleman named Firedorn. It read:

Advertisement

“Here lies Firedorn, a hero in bed.

He once was alive, but now he's dead.

The last woman he bedded turned out a man,

And crying in shame, off a cliff he ran.”

Some might argue that it was just a bit of dark humour about a dopey, sex-driven macho man who is punished for sleeping around, and accidentally ends up sleeping with a man. Thus, his idiocy resulted in his demise.

A small minority openly decried that the poem was transphobic and trans-misogynistic. It made headlines quickly, brewing up tensions in the gaming community.

Nothing in the poem openly decries those who have changed their gender, yet it didn't stop the backlash. Eventually, the poem was eventually replaced with:

“Here lies Firedorn, a bard, a poet

He was also a card, but most didn't know it

A poem he wrote in jest was misread

They asked for blood, so now he's just dead.”

Ouch. Firedorn himself wrote a post both apologizing while scratching his head on the matter. It was a fine example of putting 2 and 2 together to make 37. A simple, tongue-in-cheek poem, interpreted as four lines of spite and malice. A dicey decision on the developer's end, nonetheless.

4. Fire Emblem Fates – Homophobia And Drugging

Fire Emblem Fates was subject to its fair share of criticisms. It was already under fire for the barmy dialogue (replacing lines from the Japanese version like “We'll always be together, right?” with “Rawrgrr! That's dragon for 'I love you!'”), the removal of the petting mini game, and for being split into four versions.

Advertisement

One of the characters, Soleil, is distracted by the cute girls on the battlefield. While she is not explicitly a lesbian, and can be married by a male avatar, she asks the player for help. In the Japanese version, her drink is spiked with a magic powder so that she sees men as women, and vice versa..

Enter one very ticked off Tumblr user who took the scene out of context and wrote a scathing blog post about how Soleil is most definitely a lesbian and is portrayed as weak because of it. Of course, she had never played it and took it out of context because the game was not released in the West yet, while exclaiming people commit suicide because of forced conversions like these. Yikes.

News sites saw this at face value and joined the argument, resulting in the scene being rewritten. Instead of potions, Soleil was told to wear a blindfold on the battlefield of all places.

There were no implications of homophobia whatsoever. It was a simple case of using magic to help out Soleil in a light-hearted situation. Gay conversion does not have anything to do with magic or smacking monsters with swords on the battlefield, anyway.

3. Grand Theft Auto V – Banned In Australia's Target Shops

The open-world crime simulator Grand Theft Auto has always been rife with controversial moments. The game is a reflection on the sleazy, corrupt side of society that we exist in, and will often share satirical parodies or uncomfortable scenes to remind us as such.

Advertisement

A petition was started by a group of angry mothers to force the Australian branch of Target stores to ban the game, stating that it “encourages players to murder women for entertainment", and that they “commit sexual violence against women...[to] get 'health' points".

They really went all out by exclaiming that Grand Theft Auto V “literally makes a game of bashing, killing, and horrific violence against women", linking “sexual arousal and violence".

While the protestors might have easily turned a blind eye and refused to purchase the game for their children (since they alone obviously can't buy it), there are countless logical counter-arguments and statistics to prove that there is no link between violent video games and violent or misogynistic behaviour in reality.

Anyone who's actually played the game for more than twenty seconds will know that the game does not force players to kill women. Virtually all of the baddies are male. Plenty of men roam the streets, and the player can harm them, too. But no one cares about that, because equality.

Since health regenerates, health is not gained by killing women, or anyone for that matter. And for goodness sake, who honestly gets turned on by harming virtual depictions of females in games, anyway?

Despite the ridiculous accusations, the game was censored. Not that Rockstar must've cared, as seen by the awards and money earned.

2. Night Trap – Violence And Harrassment Against Women

Night Trap was one of the reasons why the ESRB (Entertainment Software Ratings Board) was created, slapping their age restrictions on all your favourite games.

Advertisement

Its gameplay consists of flicking between full-motion video camera footage and pressing a button when the blood-sucking vampire dudes, or whatever, stumble in. They're covered in black and hobble around in the barmiest of ways. And yet it was called out for its violence.

The game's “violence” is comical and exaggerated at best, as if the aforementioned pitch didn't give it away already. If you don't protect the girls in the house by activating the traps against the intruders, they will drain the blood from them with unrealistic, over-sized needles.

There was no nudity or violence against women – in fact, the most violent thing you'll see is if some of the women get captured, and is lightly tugged by the vampires in black - yet the US senators cried out and claimed it would incite gamers to trap and torture these poor ladies, probably for sexual arousal, knowing those old farts.

Night Trap was pretty rubbish, not to mention so cheesy you could wrap two slices of bread around it and call it a sandwich. While the criticism it received was incredibly far from the truth, it still resulted in the creation of the contemporary ratings system.

1. DOOM – Satanism And School Shootings

id Software's iconic shooter was so immensely popular, it resulted in delays at the workplace and crashes on countless online servers. Apparently, it also promoted genocide and Satan worshiping.

Advertisement

Religious figures went so far as to claim that the pentagrams, inverted crosses and the like would draw people away from the word of God and towards that of Lucifer. One of the level designers, Sandy Peterson, was a Christian himself and had no problems with it all. In fact, he himself designed most of the Hell levels.

The Columbine High School Massacre was undoubtedly a tragedy, yet the media were quick to make assumptions on what inspired Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold's atrocities (ironic, since they usually focus on crimes without regarding the reasons why). All they needed to hear was that they were social outcasts who liked DOOM and Heavy Metal.

DOOM is far from a realistic depiction of genocide. None of the weapons even reload, for starters, and the guns that the shooters used were not featured in-game whatsoever. Some said they designed levels based on their school to test their shooting skills, which was proven false. The game is a fantasy world, and features a fictional, tough-as-nails space marine fighting against hordes of nasty monsters from another dimension with chainguns and plasma rifles.

Apparently, DOOM and various heavy metal bands were to blame for inspiring this tragedy, simply because both were part of an underground culture, and the gunmen were fans of each. The papers decided to point their fingers simply because a game had guns, or bands were German and sang angrily, which was proof enough that they were Nazis.

Ridiculous justifications like these are exactly why this became the dumbest video game controversy in history.

Advertisement