10 Plot Twists That Change How You See Video Games

Nothing was ever the same again.

By Patch Huish /

We all love a plot twist, don't we? If well-executed, a shock reveal or unexpected narrative shift can turn a straightforward story into a mind-bending masterpiece.

Advertisement

Some of the greatest tales of all time are fondly remembered precisely because their twists are so mind-blowing, they leave you a changed person afterwards, and these examples do exactly that.

But what separates a video game plot twist from twists in non-interactive media (such as film and literature) is that games inherently involve the player in a way that passive viewing doesn't. Smart game writers know this, and can directly incorporate the player's expectations into their plot twists, allowing them to manipulate you in any number of surprising ways.

The greatest twists play with the player. They shatter convention and transcend the boundaries of the story they are part of, often creating complex meta-fiction. They cause you to reel in astonishment, question your perception and re-evaluate not just the game you're playing, but the medium of games as a whole.

10. The Turing Test - Droning On

The Turing Test begins as aptly named engineer Ava Turing is woken from stasis by an AI known as T.O.M. This charming chap informs you that he's lost contact with the research crew (phone signal must be pretty bad in outer space) and he needs you to investigate.

Advertisement

You discover that the crew have fashioned the research base into a complex series of puzzle chambers designed to keep artificial intelligences at bay. These are Turing Tests, only solvable by humans (and gamers).

With all this ominous foreshadowing there was bound to be a twist on the way. Turns out that Ava is a drone, a human puppet being remotely operated by T.O.M. The story shifts up a gear from this point on, but what's more surprising is that the gameplay is also augmented in a way rarely seen in video games.

Now that Ava is aware that T.O.M. is controlling her, the player can shift between multiple perspectives, taking control of T.O.M.'s surveillance cameras and robotic rovers to assist Ava in the puzzle solving. It's like playing co-op, but without your mates constantly trying to screw you over.

This twist makes you consider the nature of player characters: are they characters at all? Or are they simply drones obeying your commands?

9. Half-Life Alyx - The Vault

As Valve's flagship VR title loomed, fans wondered how they would address the infamous cliffhanger at the end of Half-Life 2: Episode 2? Surely they wouldn’t ignore it… would they? But as the light of Gaben shined upon us, the truth was revealed.

Advertisement

The death of Eli Vance is alluded to a number of times throughout Half-Life: Alyx by the Vortigaunts, despite the small issue that it hasn’t actually happened yet. If you’re someone who subscribes to the linear nature of time (like most of us), this should already be setting off alarm bells that a major plot twist is coming.

When Alyx reaches the core of the Combine vault at the end of the game, both Alyx and the player sense that something isn’t right. A spooky silhouette of a skinny man in a suit appears before you, and as he turns to face you it all falls into place. The vault contains G-Man, the omnipotent reality-altering entity at the centre of Half-Life’s mystery.

G-Man shows Alyx the future: Eli’s death, the infamous cliffhanger. He allows Alyx to prevent this future event from occurring, altering the course of time itself and allowing the Half-Life series to continue. This changes the way you see story in video games, as one of the biggest moments in gaming history has now been forever altered.

Turns out that prequels can have an effect on future events after all.

8. Undertale - Omega Flowey

The first character you meet in indie darling Undertale is a little flower by the name of Flowey. He seems pretty harmless... until he tries to kill you. If you think that's disturbing, wait until you see what he really looks like.

Advertisement

Just as you're about to make peace with King Asgore at the apparent climax of the game, Flowey comes out of nowhere and kills him, then mocks you for trying to save him... and then the game crashes. You've been booted back to your desktop. What!?

When you start the game again, the intro cinematic glitches out and your save file has been replaced with one that reads "Flowey: My World", making Flowey the only video game boss to perfectly recapture the nostalgic frustration of having your little brother erase your save file.

Upon loading the file, Flowey himself appears and vows to destroy you. Then, he transforms into a horrific behemoth composed of numerous semi-realistic images photo-bashed together.

It's the stuff of nightmares, and it completely breaks the game's art style in the best possible way. Not only that, but every time you die while fighting Flowey, he laughs at you mockingly and then crashes your game again, forcing you to restart the fight. Ouch.

Turns out this cute retro RPG isn't as wholesome as it seemed, and if you thought you were in control of your save file, you were very much mistaken.

7. Silent Hill 2 - A Shaggy Dog Story

Silent Hill 2 is widely regarded as one of the greatest horror games ever to grace our screens. Or so it might seem, because deep within this suspenseful supernatural thriller lurks one of the most absurdly hilarious twist endings ever.

Advertisement

It’s only unlocked once you have completed the game’s three main endings, so you have to be dedicated to find it -- some would consider it the “true” conclusion.

Completing the three main endings allows you to find a key in a newly materialised dog kennel, which opens a secret door in the Lakeview Hotel marked “Observation Room”. Venturing inside reveals the greatest terror of all. Or rather, the greatest terrier.

That’s right, it’s a dog… wearing a pair of headphones and operating some kind of control station with dozens of buttons and levers. It’s an absolutely comical image that completely subverts the carefully constructed horror vibe (deliberately, of course).

Protagonist James Sunderland realises that this crafty canine was the mastermind behind the game’s events, manipulating everything he saw from behind the scenes. Not only does this completely change how you see Silent Hill 2, it makes you consider what's truly going on behind the scenes of all your favourite games.

6. The Beginner's Guide - Coda

Created by Davey Wreden (co-lead developer of the Stanley Parable) The Beginner’s Guide is a peculiar yet poignant game about game development.

Advertisement

Wreden walks and talks the player through a series of experimental mini-games created by his friend Coda, a reclusive game designer who underestimates his own talent. These games start off as charming minimalist experiences and grow increasingly surreal and unsettling.

The twist happens towards the end, when Wreden receives an email from Coda with a private link to a game that's impossible to beat.

Wreden cheats his way through the game and arrives at a startling message from Coda, telling him to stop sharing his games with other people and accusing him of altering his titles to suit his personal narrative of Coda as an emotionally tormented man. In reality he just really enjoyed making weird games.

The true genius of The Beginner’s Guide is its ambiguity: it’s not clear to what degree the events depicted are real or fictional. Are they based on true events? Are they a metaphor for a lived experience?

The emotional rollercoaster this game sends you through is guaranteed to leave a lasting impact on how you look at games and game developers, art and artists, creators and creativity.

5. Frog Fractions - Meta Maths

Frog Fractions is one of those “learning is fun!” type games that was probably among the few online games that weren’t blocked at school. It’s a cute, harmless educational flash game about solving simple fractions. At least, it is for the first couple of minutes. But then the twist happens…

Advertisement

What starts off as an anodyne arithmetic affair soon expands into a metafictional mathematical masterpiece. With just a couple of simple upgrades, the friendly turtle on which the titular frog sits transforms into a dragon fitted with a warp drive, allowing the frog to transcend the confines of his own game and eviscerate the fourth wall entirely.

Most frogs are pretty good at hopping, but not usually genre-hopping. This frog is the exception, as he bounds across boundaries between many different game genres, including a space shoot-‘em-up, a visual novel, a rhythm game, a text adventure, and an ocean exploration game accompanied by a lecture about the history of boxing.

It’s truly bizarre but utterly brilliant, pushing the medium of video games forward by deconstructing its very essence. Maybe fractions really can be fun.

4. Spec Ops: The Line - Do You Feel Like A Hero Yet?

To the uninitiated, Spec Ops: The Line looks like yet another mundane military shooter. You play as a soldier who looks like he's been ripped straight from an army recruitment poster, the gameplay is remarkably unremarkable, and the colour palette consists of fifty shades of beige.

Advertisement

Ingeniously however, this is all a carefully crafted façade. Things quickly spiral out of control when you command player character Captain Walker to bomb a hostile area with White Phosphorus, a horrific chemical weapon. As Walker approaches the scene, one of the victims of the attack pleads with him, asking why he did such a thing and saying to him "we were helping".

In a moment of regretful realisation, Walker rounds the corner to see his chemical attack has killed dozens of innocent civilians who the enemy soldiers were assisting.

The disturbing image of a mother's charred corpse shielding her child's eyes haunts Walker, and as he continues on his mission he is stalked by hallucinations as his sanity unravels. With constant chiding from Konrad, Walker begins to break down as the atrocities he has committed fracture his mind, leading the player to consider the nature of choice and consequences surrounding violent acts in games overall.

3. Prey - Through The Looking Glass

At the start of Prey, you wake up in your luxury apartment with a gorgeous view of the futuristic city skyline outside. You go through a series of routine tests in preparation for being launched into space… but something’s wrong.

Advertisement

The scientists monitoring you seem confused and disappointed, as if you’re doing everything incorrectly. It’s a bit like that dream where you turn up late for school and you’ve forgotten your pencil case or your pants.

Out of nowhere, one of the scientists is murdered by an alien tentacle creature disguised as a cup of coffee (Mondays, eh?) and you’re knocked out by sleep gas. But don’t worry, because soon you wake up in your luxury apartment with a gorgeous view of... hang on, didn’t we already do this bit? What’s happening?

Thinking quickly, the player picks up a wrench and smashes their apartment window to get to the city outside… except it doesn’t lead to the city at all. It leads directly to the Talos I space station. The view of the city was actually a virtual environment.

The entire opening sequence was an elaborate simulation, and you're already in space. This twist acts as a meta-commentary on the fact that everything you see in video games is accomplished through a series of clever conjuring tricks, and that you can't always trust your perception.

2. Doki Doki Literature Club! - Monika

Doki Doki Literature Club! begins with a warning: "This game is not suitable for children or those who are easily disturbed". Most players will breeze past this warning without a second thought.

Advertisement

After all, this is a cute anime dating sim, right? What could possibly be disturbing about that? And indeed, the game appears to absolutely harmless... until the player discovers their best friend Sayori hanging from her bedroom ceiling.

At this point, the game immediately ends, and upon starting a new playthrough it glitches and freezes as if somehow corrupted. Group leader Monika seems decidedly nonchalant about the disturbing events.

Something is very, very wrong.

In the game's terrifying finale, it becomes clear that Monika has complete control over the game itself. She proceeds to address not your in-game character, but the real you, confessing that she is completely obsessed with you and is fully aware that she's in a game. Monika manipulated the other characters to make them appear undesirable, in an attempt to coerce you into falling in love with her.

The only way to end this nightmare is to access the game's folder and manually delete Monika's character files. Phew. But long after the horror is over, the question of whether there's a difference between player and player character will linger, making you consider your connection to every game you play.

1. BioShock - Would You Kindly?

Dripping with atmosphere and overflowing with immersive storytelling, BioShock is one of the greatest games of all time, so it’s only appropriate that it should also feature an all-time classic plot twist that completely changes how you think about not only this game, but games in general.

Advertisement

Upon arriving at the office of underwater metropolis Rapture’s founder Andrew Ryan, the player learns the shocking truth about their character and the friendly voice in their ear, Atlas, who has been guiding them up until this point.

Turns out that silent protagonist Jack was actually created in Rapture as an experiment, and is being mind controlled by his apparent ally Atlas using the recurring trigger phrase “would you kindly?” Not only that, but Atlas is actually gangster Frank Fontaine, Andrew Ryan’s arch-rival.

With the twists coming thick and fast and the player’s head reeling with shock, the big reveal is quite literally driven home as Jack beats Andrew Ryan to death with a golf club at his command, demonstrating his absence of autonomy. Not only is this a gut-punching plot twist, it also acts as a commentary on the nature of free will in video games: is the player really just a slave to the developer’s intentions?

Advertisement