10 Popular Video Game Mechanics The Industry ABANDONED

Bring back the Nemesis system.

By Jack Pooley /

It's generally expected that whenever an inventive new video game mechanic rears its head, it's going to be imitated by all the competition until we're finally sick of it.

Advertisement

Yet sometimes, beloved mechanics end up going the way of the dodo long before we've had our fill, for one of a multitude of possible reasons.

And that's unfortunately the case with these awesome mechanics, each of which added something seriously memorable to their respective games and, in extreme cases, even proved quite literally industry-shaping. For a while, at least.

Despite these mechanics going down gangbusters with players, each was eventually ditched by developers en masse, enough that they're a depressing rarity in the modern gaming sphere.

The reasons for this are myriad and at times complex - perhaps the technical realities of modern games don't easily allow it, or it simply comes down to changing trends in the gaming industry. And then, most infuriatingly of all, there's good ol' fashioned publisher greed.

So many gamers would love to see these mechanics make a glorious resurgence, but let's be honest, you shouldn't count on it any time soon...

10. Destructible Environments

At the turn of the century, it truly seemed like destructible environments were going to be the next big thing in video games.

Advertisement

With Red Faction's innovative Geo-Mod mechanic allowing players to obliterate large swaths of the environment all the way back in 2001, it appeared that the floodgates had opened and environmental destruction would only become more complex and detailed in the years that followed.

Yet aside from a few notable examples - such as Battlefield: Bad Company - destructible environments quickly disappeared from the AAA sphere entirely.

Considering how popular open-world games are these days, it's a damn shame that destruction tech has basically come and gone.

Yet it's also worth noting the technical side of the equation. For starters, allowing players to deform the environment in a granular way is extremely resource-intensive, and in an era where modern games often struggle to hit a stable 60fps as it is, the performance-related risks speak for themselves.

Furthermore, there's the general game design issue, that it's difficult to create an immersive world if the player is then given carte blanche to level it all to the ground.

All the same, that this mechanic is largely absent from the modern AAA realm is a massive letdown given how much fun it's been in the past.

9. Integrated HUDs

Dead Space is a terrific game for many reasons, not least that it introduced an innovative immersive heads-up display (HUD) which was integrated into the diegetic world of the survival horror game itself.

Advertisement

Rather than crowd the screen with icons, life bars, and so on, the player's health and stasis meters are visible on the spine of protagonist Isaac Clarke's suit, while your ammo count is projected holographically just in front of your weapon.

Furthermore, inventory screens and the map are also displayed within the game world as holographic projections.

An intrusive HUD design can often severely cramp a player's immersion in an otherwise great game, and Dead Space is basically a note-perfect example of how to blend vital player information into the aesthetic in a way that feels totally organic.

Even accepting that such HUD design requires some serious thought and creativity, it's surprising that, almost 15 years after the game's release, integrated HUDs are still a serious rarity.

8. Split-Screen Multiplayer

Unless you're really young, you likely have fond memories of playing split-screen multiplayer games with friends on the regular, because once upon a time split-screen was the way to do multiplayer.

Advertisement

Before online play existed, local split-screen was of course how pals would play together, but even as online multiplayer took off, most games still included a local equivalent.

Yet in recent years this has become increasingly rare, to the extent that even many major AAA games no longer ship with split-screen multiplayer at all, making it impossible to play couch co-op with friends or family.

This is clearly a by-product of online multiplayer's popularity and how, if we're honest, couch co-op has steadily declined over the last decade-plus, such that developers don't consider it worth their while to implement.

Plus, from a technical perspective it can cause a host of performance issues, what with the game effectively having to render the same environment two, three, or four times.

And above all else, shifting the focus from local to online play heavily incentivises every member of a friend group to buy their own copy of the game, rather than crowding around a single TV with a single copy.

And so, outside of the Nintendo Switch - which certainly prioritises local multiplayer experiences - split-screen multiplayer is basically in its death throes, enough that younger generations likely don't even lament its demise.

7. Sanity Meter

Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem immortalised itself in the annals of gaming history by popularising the "sanity meter" mechanic.

Advertisement

That is, the player must manage the protagonist's sanity throughout the story, and if they're spotted by enemies enough, they'll begin to suffer reality-warping hallucinations.

These can range from the walls leaking blood to the protagonist suddenly dropping dead, or the game even pretending to reset the GameCube console.

It was a brilliantly executed mechanic, enough that Nintendo even patented the particulars of it back in 2005.

While games like Amnesia: The Dark Descent have employed similar systems where players have to manage their character's sanity or risk losing grip of reality, it's been used surprisingly sparingly in the horror genre despite the obvious potential for it to seriously mess with players' heads.

Even if some developers have exercised caution due to Nintendo's patent, it expired back in November 2021, seemingly leaving the door wide open for any and everybody to now do as they wish with it.

That so few developers have taken the miniscule risk of running afoul of Nintendo's lawyers over the last two decades, though, suggests we're probably not getting a sudden influx of games with mind-bending sanity mechanics because, for some reason, the interest isn't there.

6. Self-Updating Maps

Sticking with horror now, the genre deserves some major props for coming up with self-updating maps a whole quarter-century ago.

Advertisement

Both the Resident Evil and Silent Hill franchises have featured in-game maps which are automatically updated with new information as you interact with doors or attempt to navigate your way through the game world.

Resident Evil's maps are colour-coded according to whether you've visited rooms or not, while the original Silent Hill crossed off inaccessible routes as you explored the fog-blanketed town.

Given how easily players can get confused and frustrated by the sheer number of rooms in a given area, having the map track everything you've discovered is a God-tier quality-of-life feature that ensures you need not keep a pen and paper nearby.

And yet, a baffling lack of games have adopted a feature that, at least in theory, seems incredibly easy to implement, and can save players some serious headaches.

5. Crash Mode

A highly specific example now, albeit one fans still fondly remember.

Advertisement

Burnout 2: Point of Impact will forever go down in history as an all-timer racing game for one reason: it blessed the world with Crash mode.

Crash mode was a mini-game in which players crashed their car into traffic and then attempted to cause as much slow-motion vehicular damage as possible before landing, while controlling their car's path as it flies through the air.

It was an instant hit with fans and quickly became a franchise staple, enough that EA even released a game centered purely around Crash mode - imaginatively entitled Burnout Crash! - in 2011.

Yet Burnout Crash! was the series' last entry to date, and while Crash mode would slot quite perfectly into any number of current racing games, it remains a firm relic of the past.

Though some former Burnout devs did collaborate on 2017's Danger Zone - a low-budget attempt to make Crash mode into its own game again - it largely fell upon deaf ears due to the lack of gameplay variety on offer.

All the same, a Crash mode in Forza Horizon, The Crew, or Need for Speed? Why the hell not?

4. Manual Saving

While there's an undeniable convenience factor to autosaving, which theoretically prevents you from losing progress in the event that you forget to save or suffer a power outage, there's no beating the flexibility of a manual save.

Advertisement

Being able to pause the game and save at any time was a common feature once upon a time, especially in PC games, allowing you to exit at a moment's notice without losing any progress, and also promoting experimentation with risky gameplay via "save-scumming."

Even accepting that it's not always possible to save at any point, the number of major AAA games which allow players to save whenever they want has dwindled massively in recent years.

The uptick in autosave functionality is certainly partly to blame, and also that so many modern games are developed first with consoles in mind, which with their more limited hard drive capacities can't necessarily support hundreds of manual save files for huge RPGs.

All the same, options are certainly a nice thing, and while manual saves aren't really necessary for short, linear indie games, for more wide-open titles where freedom is encouraged, they should be an absolute must.

As it stands, though, bar some outliers the industry as a whole is moving away from allowing players control over their game saves.

3. Speed Limiter

Though many rather ignorantly dismissed the original Mafia as an ersatz Grand Theft Auto III, it's a terrific open-world action game in its own right with a number of merit-worthy original mechanics.

Advertisement

Case in point, due to the game's more "realistic" gameplay, whereby players could find themselves on the wrong side of law by running a red traffic light, there was the option to toggle a speed limiter, effectively preventing you from exceeding the posted speed limit.

This was a great feature if you wanted to cruise around the game world and soak in the sights without having to think about attraction the cops' attention.

Though it reappeared in the second Mafia game, it was bizarrely absent from Mafia III, where the police admittedly didn't seem to give much of a damn about the rules of the road anyway.

Despite how simple and effective the speed limiter is as a mechanic, it's been largely ignored by the open-world action game genre as a whole ever since Mafia II came out in 2010, which sucks.

2. The Nemesis System

Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor's standout feature was its much-ballyhooed Nemesis System - a mechanic which tracks the player's interactions with Uruk enemies throughout the game.

Advertisement

For instance, Uruks who survive an encounter with the player will return later in the game and remember their previous fight, possibly even sporting injuries from it, while those which kill the player will be promoted to captaincy.

On the flip-side, players could attempt to trigger infighting among the Uruks' ranks in order to destabilise Sauron's army.

It was a terrifically creative mechanic which merged gameplay with story and world-building in a meaningful way, and yet has only been used in a substantial capacity in one other game - 2017's sequel Shadow of War.

Despite the mechanic's obvious potential across a bevy of game franchises and genres, developers have mostly steered clear of imitating it, likely due to Warner Bros. aggressively pursuing a patent for Nemesis, which was finally granted in 2021.

Outside of Assassin's Creed Odyssey's mercenaries system - which, generously, was a severely dumbed-down facsimile of Nemesis - it's nowhere to be seen.

This proves all the more frustrating given that Warner Bros. hasn't bothered producing a Shadow of War follow-up or doing anything with the Nemesis system since its release six years ago.

1. Cheat Codes

Cheat codes are such an ingrained element of classic gaming that you might not even think of them as mechanics - they're just... part of the game.

Advertisement

But the joy of finding cheats for your favourite game to enable God Mode, infinite weapons, and considerably sillier options like GoldenEye's DK Mode, have largely gone up in smoke in modern gaming.

The primary reasons for this? Achievements and DLC.

For one, because cheats would largely eliminate the reward factor of achievements - one of the biggest drivers of player "engagement" these days - it's not in the interests of most developers to include them. And certainly not for free.

After all, when DLC is a thing, why would you let players unlock secret characters or modes with a few button presses? Charge a few bucks for it instead.

As such, modern games with honest-to-God cheat codes you don't need to re-open your wallet for - like Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga - are serious outliers, and for generations of players who grew up with them readily available, it's a sad loss.

Advertisement