10 Potentially Great Video Games That Were Dead On Arrival

Remember when Driv3r readied the gun to its temple with that name, and then blew its own brains out with terrible gameplay? Those were the days.

By Callum Shephard /

Every era is recognised as much for its failures as its successes, from the ones which deliver on their promises perfectly, to the likes of Ride to Hell: Retribution. The sad thing about video games is that the vast majority of such let-downs are the disappointing kind. Even when it€™s so dire the developers might as well be mocking your very existence, you can realise how they might have succeeded. Put in enough hours or look far enough into the behind the scenes work, and you can just about see the great game developers were trying to bring to life, even in the absolute worst of games. The shovelware tie-in for Batman Begins might have been dreck of the worst kind but you could at least see the beginnings of ideas which would make it into Arkham Asylum. You're likely already thinking of a few in your head. Anything from a few potential classics, EA releases ruined by executive interference, and probably at least one game with Peter Molyneux involved. Others perhaps were just games which couldn€™t live up to their hype, promising to completely change the face of gaming entirely only to deliver an average experience. Surprisingly no, Fable isn€™t on this list; it was beaten out by even worse offenders. To commemorate a few of these failures, brief selection of bitterly disappointing titles which promised the world to players but crashed and burned even as they hit shelves...

10. Driv3r

As the likes of Warhammer 40,000: Fire Warrior will attest, promoting a game with the promise of burying a famed franchise is inviting trouble. As such when Atari introduced Driv3r as the €œGrand Theft Auto killer€ it was only setting itself up for failure. With a plan nothing short of creating a game which could revolutionise open world titles to a point unseen since Grand Theft Auto 3, Atari launched a massive promotional campaign. Hard facts were flashed, citing how Driv3r contained 35,768 separate buildings with 156.14 miles of road, each one detailed right down to the very blinds in windows. Vehicles were now truly built, with everything from mirrors to windshields separately modelled then slotted together for maximum realism. Even Ridley Scott Associates was hired to make a short film introducing the public to the game€™s stylised world of crime. Unfortunately high details and flash graphics mean little when a game€™s enemy AI is downright brain-dead. It was soon discovered police could easily be fooled through a few simple tricks, with some methods being as easy as merely jumping into water. To try and make them compete with the player, enemies could suddenly move cars at twice their normal speed if they were falling behind. This minor tweak made the police effectively inescapable, ruining the classic tension of high speed pursuits by robbing them of any chance to lay low. For all its visual splendour, Driv3r played like something which had been pushed out the door early. Initial sales were solid, but word of mouth and poor reviews quickly harmed the game and it never reached the heights Atari had dreamed of.

9. Lair

Tired of rendering X-Wings, the legendary Star Wars: Rogue Squadron developer Factor 5 leapt at the chance to help kick off the launch of the Playstation 3 with Lair. Giving players the power to ride dragons and making use of the new Sixaxis motion controls, this looked as if it was going to be Sony€™s killer app. The hype built up with emphasis placed on the new control system, high quality graphics and the involvement of John Debney composing the score. Oh, and the fact you were flying giant fire-breathing mythical beasts. The release was a very different story. The much anticipated Sixaxis control system made the title almost unplayable, with unresponsive movements and difficult turns. This proved to be the least of its problems with an extremely choppy frame-rate, aggravating mission multitasking and an infuriatingly obtuse lock-on system. For all the hype, gamers were just left with a visibly unfinished mess marred by poorly conceived mechanics. What makes this unique on this list is that even following Lair€™s disappointing release, Sony kept trying to turn it into a hit. In an act of arrogance worthy of Hammerpoint Interactive, the publisher began mailing magazines a Lair Reviewer€™s Guide. No, really. Along with multiple pages outlining how the game€™s control system worked, it asked reviewers to open their minds to what the game offered rather than negatively score it. For some reason this failed to improve critical opinions of the game and Factor 5 folded soon afterwards - an ignominious end to a developer who deserved far better.

8. Command And Conquer 4: Tiberium Twilight

Intended to be the finale to the long running Tiberium storyline of Command and Conquer€™s main series, Tiberium Twilight was hyped to high heaven. Trailers depicted the world on the very edge of collapse with tiberium poisoning having overrun Earth€™s last bastions. Promises were made of a dramatic conclusion, with Kane allying himself with the Global Defence Initiative in order to salvage something of the planet. It looked dark, dramatic and with a new base building element which was set to take gameplay to the next level. The reality of it was that none of this was planned on the part of the developers, and this was instead forced upon them by Electronic Arts. Originally conceived as a multiplayer-only title with account progression suited for lighting-fast internet café matches, Tiberium Twilight was never meant as a full-fledged instalment. The story was something thrown together at the last second, resolving the very issues the trailers had hyped before players even reached their first mission. Worse even than this, the gameplay was so far removed from past titles it might as well have abandoned the RTS genre entirely. Base-building and resource management were gone, one of the three major factions was nowhere to be seen, and a level cap prevented you deploying vast legions of troops. While critical reviews were middling to positive, the fan backlash was immense with hundreds of one star reviews on Amazon and Metacritic. In an effort to grab more cash and directly interfering with their games, Electronic Arts ultimately doomed what looked to be a promising multiplayer RTS release. Is anyone really surprised?

7. Metroid: Other M

While many titles on this list botched their stories, few managed to so effectively destroy any semblance of their hero€™s dignity as Other M. Following on from the smash hits of the Metroid: Prime series and Metroid Fusion, Other M was set to introduce the franchise to a new generation. Abandoning previous series staples in favour of acrobatic third person combat, it was planned to be a much more in-depth story examining Samus Aran€™s history. Written and directed by co-creator Yoshiro Sakamoto himself, writer of the Metroid manga, this looked to be a major advance in the series. Or so fans thought. Upon shipping it was quickly clear things had gone horribly wrong. Within days of its release, a major coding error was discovered which prevented access to the plot-critical Ice Beam weapon, and the Wii-mote combat system was unwieldy at the best of times. However, these could be forgiven, what truly ignited a terrible firestorm of fan-rage was the terrible writing which seemed to go out of its way to destroy Samus as a credible character. Contradicting even the manga is was supposed to build upon, Other M turned Samus from a shell-shocked survivor forced to overcome great fear into a shrieking, subservient caricature. Even ignoring the monotone voice acting and storytelling narration even Hideo Kojima would balk at, the writing was downright disturbing at times. Nearly all of this blame can be levelled at Sakamoto himself, who took a near dictatorial control over the entire project. Despite a hefty promotional campaign on the part of Nintendo, the game failed to meet even half of its intended sales. Copies can still be found filling up bargain bins everywhere, and with no sequel in sight this may have killed off the entire series.

6. Hellgate: London

Once a seemingly sure-fire hit, the story of Hellgate: London has since become a cautionary tale among developers. Created by Flagship Studios, and with the involvement of Blizzard North€™s co-founders, the game was set to feature in a demon-infested London. Earning attention for the big names involved an explosive presentation; millions of dollars were put into comics, novels and action figures long before the game was ever released. Suffice to say the hype behind the game was enormous. So high in fact, that Flagship Studios itself began to buy into it. For the developers Hellgate: London was the first of many things. Their first FPS/Action-RPG hybrid, their first title to involve an ongoing subscription and even their first game to be rendered in 3D. The ideas behind the game were experimental, fantastic concepts which could make it stand out from the crowd, yet not one person working on it seemed to have a backup plan in place just in case Hellgate: London somehow failed to be an instant hit. Surprise surprise, the impossible happened and the game bombed. Many of the ideas behind the setting were half-baked and hamstrung thanks to a lack of experience, but worse still were the bugs. The disc contained a veritable plague of programming errors and problems which made progression it impossible. Complete system crashes, were common, but even beyond that NPCs could fail to load along with plot essential items, leaving players stuck. While some developers would later find success with Torchlight, the failure of Hellgate: London was enough to cause Flagship Studios to close its doors barely a year later.

5. SimCity

A seemingly thankful return to form for the series, 2013's SimCity was released early to critics with high praise. Despite the much more limited space to construct buildings, the way each city could supply one another and the server based regions was seen as a dynamic addition. As the days drew closer to its release, feedback consisted of nothing but glowing remarks of its ingenuity and brilliant design. The moment it was truly released all hell broke loose. Despite preventative measures, SimCity€™s always-on DRM system crippled the title just as it had Diablo III mere months before. The anti-piracy system required players to have online access and sign in to various company servers and verify the copy before allowing access. The servers were overloaded in minutes, with Maxis forced to disable multiple features to cope with the strain. Even as they fought to try and free up the servers enough to let players access their new purchase, tens of thousands found themselves completely locked out of the game. If this crippling problem were not bad enough, major flaws were soon found not long after release. Cities were concentrated into such a small areas that it was impossible to be self-sufficient, constantly lacking certain vital facilities. The game€™s balance also proved to be so inept that many players found easy ways to get cities with the happiness maxed out, albeit with no power, water or basic infrastructure. Between the inability to simply access the game they had purchased and a torrent of corporation-backed DLC turning the game into an advertising platform, SimCity was soon left barren. What was promised to be a booming community quickly died down to a comparatively small number of devotees, leaving regions of abandoned metropolises in their wake.

4 €“ Daikatana

Almost a byword for €œunmitigated disaster€ within the gaming community, Daikatana is a title the once revered John Romero will never escape. Hyped up as the magnum opus of the man who helped bring us Wolfenstein, Doom and Quake, players were promised something to revolutionise the whole genre. What they got after countless delays was a title so buggy plot essential NPCs could commit suicide by running into walls. What remains truly sad is the fact that, behind the massive coding errors and many problems, you could just about see what he had planned. Taking place across multiple eras, Daikatana featured a vast number of mystical and science fiction weapons, with a variety of locations and enemies not often seen in shooters of the time. The basic design elements themselves were also quite clever for the time, it was a classic shooter with RPG elements and squad based tactics. The two accompanying NPCs to carry out goals and hit certain targets, not unlike what the Mass Effect series would later accomplish. The real failure was in the execution, with overconfidence and development problems causing no end of issues right from the start. Romero himself initially set the goal of a seven month development cycle for this most ambitious of projects, missed it entirely, and was forced to repeatedly restart thanks to ever advancing technology. Infighting, departures and new engines followed; yet the Daikatana hype train only picked up speed. This lead to the tagline the game has become almost inseparable from €“ €œJohn Romero is going to make you his b*tch!€ While it will forever go down as a terrible mistake, with an even worse N64 port, at the time it was conceived Daikatana honestly seemed like a major leap forwards for the FPS genre. It's just unfortunate no one there seemed to be bring such ideas to fruition.

3. Haze

Yet another creator-killer on this list, Haze might as well have been Daikatana€™s second coming. The many errors which had doomed Ion Storm were repeated once again here, with the same hubris, same lengthy developments and same massive changes plaguing the title€™s development. Promising true innovation and a hard hitting deconstruction of the worst aspects of first-person shooters with Haze, Free Radical had everything they could have asked for. Trusted thanks to their success with the Timesplitters series, the studio was offered a lengthy development cycle to introduce a truly revolutionary AI system into their games. This was when the problems began: Not taking the time to actually check their task-based AI system would work on the Playstation 3, Free Radical suddenly found their main gimmick could not function with the console - before they had even started the developer was already making a massive loss of the game. Did Free Radical even take this as a hint to tone down their marketing? Nope. With marketing ranging from licensed rap songs to interviews openly making pot shots at the developers of Halo, they were determined to compete with the biggest names out there. Ubisoft then demanded countless revisions to the story, with elaborate pre-rendered trailers made based upon unfinished plotlines with no solid concept behind them. Unsurprisingly, the release was a disaster. With generic gameplay and obviously out-of-place assets it€™s message was merely a ham-fisted €œcorporations are bad, soldiers are violent man-children€ plot which made Avatar look professionally written. What once looked like a deconstruction on par with the later Spec Ops: The Line, later proved to be nothing more than a bland, poorly made shooter.

2. Aliens: Colonial Marines

Having been stuck in gaming purgatory since early 2001, Aliens: Colonial Marines was initially met with celebration as it was revived by Gearbox. What it is known as now is a game which suffered a terrible development cycle and from poorly implemented ideas. Rumours circulate from various sources suggesting that even funding intended for Colonial Marines was redirected to assist in Borderlands 2's creation. The plot holes were so massive they threatened to swallow the entire game, the graphics were so outdated they could have been run on the Playstation 2, and the ending boiled down to pure sequel-baiting. Despite all of this, Gearbox unintentionally offered a glimpse at what the game could have become with some actual love and attention. In their efforts to polish this turd to a mirror shine, audiences were treated to a demo which displayed a vertical slice of gameplay. Despite being a complete fabrication, it played and looked vastly better than the actual game; enemies behaved like tactical, stalking creatures who would use the environments to their benefit, the guns gave real kick and the graphics were outstanding beyond words. To top this off we were shown classic re-enactments of sequences such as using gun turrets and close co-ordination with a variety of troops, even ones using Power Loaders. The demo even showed players actually fighting the queen, not just mashing buttons until she was ejected out the back of a ship Wile E. Coyote style. The demo showed no major steps forwards which would shake the entire genre, nothing to completely innovate all first person shooters, but had excellent visuals and seemed to do its enemies justice. Yet it seemed that Gearbox failed to even meet that low standard, instead making Rebellion's heavily criticised Alien Vs. Predator the far superior game.

1. Steel Battalion: Heavy Armour

Sequel to the cult classic Steel Battalion, the announcement of Heavy Armour was one met with considerable interest on the part of devoted fans. While many aspects had changed from the aesthetic to the design of the vertical tanks, the fact the franchise was being revitalised after eight years was something to truly be excited about. Then fans learned that, rather than using the expensive control scheme of the original, Heavy Armour was to use the Kinect sensor to interact with the tank's intensely complicated systems. Already infamous for its poor ability to read the movements of players and generally unreliable nature, the idea of using the controls within a tank's innards immediately put many off of the game. Rightfully so as it turned out as, despite advertisements doing everything short of announcing "No, it works this time, honest!" the Kinect single-handledly ruined the game - controls were atrocious and you were lucky to even find the right control let alone kill an enemy tank. The truly sad thing was that the Kinect was the only bad part of an otherwise fantastic experience. Unlike other items this list which merely presented themselves as fantastic titles through promotional campaigns or had great ideas they could not achieve, Heavy Armour succeeded in bringing many great ideas into the game. Your crew would individually react to damage, report on mission developments and had well-rounded personalities which often shone through even in the heat of battle. Every one of them could be killed at any point and they would be replaced by a new crewman with their own quirks. Some would load the main gun faster than others, some would break under pressure more easily and others could have a higher accuracy or better view of the battle. Yeah, that just with the crew alone. Unfortunately these fantastic concepts and elements meant nothing because few people could play the game beyond one or two levels before giving up out of frustration. The unresponsive nature of the Kinect meant players were just as likely to punch their crewmen in the face as find the weapon they needed. Ideas such as recoil from explosive shots throwing players away from the vision slit were fantastic, but because the Kinect could not register you reaching for it, again combat was made impossible. As a result, Steel Battalion: Heavy Armour was killed by the very hardware which was supposed to turn it into a unique experience. Did we fail to miss a potential great which failed to meet audience expectations? Please leave your own suggestions and thoughts in the comments below.