10 Pro Evolution Soccer Legends Who Flopped In Real Life

Played like a dream on PES but endured a nightmare in real life.

By Jack Beresford /

There was a time when Pro Evolution Soccer led the way for football gaming – the early 2000s, to be precise.

Back then, FIFA might have had the names, the kits, and the badges, but it couldn’t come close to PES for pure, footballing brilliance.

Pro Evo was so much more than just a football sim though.

Thanks to the Master League mode, in which gamers took control of a specific team, moulding them into a successful one over a succession of seasons, PES also gave Football Manager a run for its money.

And like Football Manager, players developed on PES Master League, improving season by season.

This particular mode saw some players emerge from nowhere to be superstars on the game.

Other times, players who were already established as ones to watch got better and better.

However, in both instances, there were occasional examples where the Konami number crunchers got things wrong. Players who they tipped for big things – or even bigger things – who then ended up failing to justify the hype among gamers.

Some enjoyed solid enough careers, slightly overshadowed by a lingering sense of what could have been. Others disappeared entirely.

From the bad to the ridiculous, these are just ten Pro Evolution Soccer legends who ended up flopping in real life.

10. Rahmane Barry

The name Rahmane Barry won’t mean a lot to the casual football fan, but for Pro Evolution Soccer players, the man was nothing short of a Master League legend.

Essentially Pro Evo’s answer to Football Manager, Master League saw gamers take control of their very own team and squad, with the aim of becoming the strongest in the league and eventually, the world.

It was a mode that saw players grow and develop into world superstars, with stats often improving season after season. That was where Barry came in.

A rising star on the books at Marseille in those early incarnations of PES, anyone playing Master League for more than a handful of seasons would soon note the emergence of the Senegalese striker as one of the best forwards on the game.

He was strong, fast and brilliant in the air. Or, at least, he was on Pro Evolution Soccer. It didn’t quite go as planned in real life though.

Barry only managed five appearances in Ligue 1 for Marseille, instead embarking on a string of disappointing loan moves to teams lower down the football pyramid in France.

To this day, no one is entirely sure if the Dakar-born striker was any good – he only managed to score six goals in his senior footballing career.

Despite earning nine caps for Senegal, Barry’s career ended at the age of just 27.

He was one hell of a player though – on the game, that is.

9. Hatem Trabelsi

There was a time when Hatem Trabelsi was tipped to be the biggest and best right back in world football. Pro Evolution Soccer 4, to be exact.

That was the edition that saw the Tunisian start the game at Arsenal. It was certainly a good fit – the Gunners needed a full-back and, if Trabelsi’s stats on the game were anything to go by, he was more than up to the task.

A good defender with strong stamina and a decent burst of pace, he was the kind of player Pro Evo connoisseurs were regularly telling their friends about.

Unfortunately, for Konami, they had slightly jumped the gun in adding the north African to the Arsenal ranks. In fact, Trabelsi didn’t end up signing for Arsene Wenger’s team and returned to Ajax.

The north London club’s loss ended up being Manchester City’s gain when, in 2006, he signed for the Blues on loan.

It didn’t end up going well though, with Trabelsi a shadow of his former self at the Etihad where injuries and a general lack of form restricted him to just 20 league appearances.

Despite his God-like status on PES, City opted against making the move a permanent one and he headed off to Al-Hilal in Saudi Arabia where he lasted just one year before hanging up his boots for good.

8. Valeri Bojinov

Valeri Bojinov’s career was by no means a disaster. He played at the highest level in the Premier League, Serie A and Portugal’s Primeira Liga.

But there will always be a lingering sense of “What if” concerning the diminutive Bulgarian, especially among Pro Evo gamers.

Bojinov was nothing short of phenomenal on the game, whether you were taking control of him at Lecce or Fiorentina - his first two clubs as a senior pro.

Similar in some ways to Lionel Messi, he was short, quick and surprisingly strong. He also had a rocket of a shot. PES fans loved him. Having first debuted at Lecce at the tender age of just 15, it looked as though Bojinov had the world at his feet.

Solid spells at Fiorentina and Juventus suggested he was worthy of the hype and Sven Goran Eriksson appeared to agree, making Bojinov one of his first signings as Manchester City manager.

His time in the Premier League would prove disastrous however, with Bojinov first suffering a knee ligament injury that side-lined him for six months before enduring further heartbreak after snapping his Achilles while warming up for what was supposed to be his comeback.

He ended up missing nearly two years of football – and it showed. Moving on to Parma, Bojinov rediscovered some of his old form, but the old magic was lost.

The injuries also persisted in the years that followed with the Bulgarian eventually turning out for a further 14 different teams with middling results.

7. Obafemi Martins

While the Nerazzurri were a distinct second best to Juventus and AC Milan in Serie A in the early 2000s, it was a different story in the digital world of PES.

Inter had one of the best squads on the game, especially in attack where the likes of Alvaro Recoba and Adriano (more on him later) were bolstered further by stars like Obafemi Martins.

The Nigerian was pure pace and speed. It was just a case of getting him on the ball and hammering the sprint button. It didn’t always work, of course, but when it did, it was glorious.

Martins’ burst of pace, coupled with his somersault goal celebration (which featured on the game) made him one to watch and, for a while, the Nigerian more than justified the hype.

In an inconsistent Inter team, he was a shining light. Then he went to Newcastle United.

Martins impressed in his first season on Tyneside, but the ill-fated arrival of Sam Allardyce eventually saw Martins relegated to the bench.

Though things improved under Kevin Keegan, a long-term injury saw Martins miss most of the season with the Toon relegated in his absence.

A nomadic few years followed with Martins spending spells in Germany, Russia, England and Spain without ever impressing. While the Nigerian retained his trademark speed, he lacked the finesse of a top player.

Despite starting his career with goals in the Champions League, Martins saw out the peak years of his career over in the MLS.

6. Anthony Vanden Borre

As a youngster, Belgian full back Anthony Vanden Borre was considered as good, if not better, than his friend and fellow Anderlecht academy graduate Vincent Kompany.

Both players were certainly earmarked for big things on Pro Evolution Soccer, where early versions of the game on PS2 saw the defenders rank among some of the very best, stats wise. It got even better if you happened to sign either one of the dynamic duo on Master League.

The pair would go on to enjoy contrasting careers though. While Kompany went on to win a glut of trophies at Manchester City, the closest Anthony Vanden Borre came to Premier League glory was a loan spell at Portsmouth.

Despite breaking through at Anderlecht, Vanden Borre was regularly criticised for his attitude off the pitch and struggled after making a big money move to Fiorentina. He fared better with Genoa but eventually fell out of favour there too, resulting in a loan move to Fratton Park.

Already in financial freefall, Portsmouth ended the season relegated with Vanden Borre eventually returning to Belgium with Genk, where he won a league title before heading back to Anderlecht.

The reunion ended up not being an altogether happy one after the full-back was heard using homophobic language to describe a teammate. Shipped out to Montpelier on loan, Vanden Borre retired in 2017 only to reverse the decision and joined TP Mazembe in DR Congo.

Incredibly he’s now back at Anderlecht working under Kompany, who is their manager.

5. Adriano

Adriano was nicknamed “The Emperor” by Inter Milan fans and, for a time, he ruled all before him on Pro Evolution Soccer.

A cover star on PES 6, the Brazilian was quite simply the greatest striker to ever grace the game.

Rumours abound that the brains behind Pro Evo, Shingo ‘Seabass’ Takatsuka, was an avid Inter fan with Adriano his favourite player.

Whatever the case, the South American was blessed with incredible stats in every department.

Strong, agile and surprisingly quick, Adriano was great in the air but even better on the ball, boasting impressive shot accuracy and a shot power rating of 99. Out of 100.

The Brazilian also had great balance and a wealth of special abilities that made him capable of shooting from almost any angle.

Throw in the fact he could smash in free kicks and it was hardly a surprise to see many PES gamers tipping Adriano to replace his compatriot Ronaldo as the world’s great no.9.

It’s heartbreaking that things didn’t quite work out. While Adriano had a fine career with Inter and Brazil, the death of his father and mentor at a key juncture derailed his development.

Adriano lost focus, partied too much and put on weight. Spells back in Brazil hinted at a revival but Adriano’s poor discipline on and off the pitch soon saw his career descend into farce.

Thankfully, Adriano is living a healthier life after football, but he’ll always be the one that got away.

4. Ryan Babel

Great things were expected of Ryan Babel when he first emerged on the scene at Ajax.

The Amsterdam giants had a proven track record when it came to unearthing young Dutch talent and brains over at Konami evidently thought Babel would be the next big thing in world football.

Babel was the player to sign on Pro Evolution Soccer 6’s edition of Master League, with the Dutchman famed for boasting an impressive “development curve” on the game that saw him quickly become one of the best and most valuable forwards out there.

Only Fernando Torres could match him in that respect, with both players starting the game with great stats and enjoying exponential rises in development during the course of a standard Master League campaign.

Perhaps someone at Liverpool was a big PES fan because soon after Pro Evo 6 came out, both Torres and Babel ended up signing for the Reds.

That was where the similarities ended though. While Torres hit the ground running and scored goals aplenty for the Merseysiders, Babel proved somewhat more inconsistent.

Though Liverpool persevered with the wide forward, after three years they cut their losses by selling him to Hoffenheim on the cheap.

Spells in Turkey, Spain and the UAE have followed with Babel also popping up at Fulham briefly and twice more at Ajax. Though he’s impressed at times during the past few years, it’s fair to say Babel hasn’t quite lived up to his Master League billing.

3. Bernard Mendy

When Hull City announced the signing of Bernard Mendy in June 2008, Pro Evolution Soccer fans were almost as excited as Tigers supporters over the news.

For years, they had taken control of him at Paris Saint-Germain on the Konami football sim. Mendy’s preferred position on the game was full-back, but his impressive attributes made him an effective winger able bomb up and down the wing without tiring.

In that sense, he was something akin to France’s answer to Javier Zanetti. Well, in the game at least.

What PES fans probably didn’t realise was that the Mendy who joined Hull was not the one who had rocked up as PSG from Caen all those years ago.

That Mendy made an electric start to life with the capital club where his strength, stamina and love of attacking shone through. Those first few seasons saw him earn a France call-up and a Coupe de la Ligue title – won via Mendy’s decisive spot kick in the final.

Rumours persist that Sir Alex Ferguson wanted to sign Mendy at Manchester United only for the Frenchman to decide to remain in France.

As time wore on at PSG, however, Mendy’s performances began to be characterised by great attacking play but very bad defending and costly errors.

While the Mendy of PES Master League improved exponentially with age, the real one got worse. Relegated with Hull, Mendy went on to endure spells in Denmark, Cyprus and India before hanging up his boots for good.

2. Park Chu Young

Konami had a habit of inflating the stats of some of Pro Evo’s most notable Asian stars. The likes of Park Ji-Sung and Hidetoshi Nakata ranked among some of the best midfielders on the game, for example.

But while Park and Nakata did plenty to warrant those padded numbers, others were decidedly less deserving. South Korea’s Park Chu-Young was a prime example.

The forward was a force to be reckoned with on early editions of PES where his dynamic dribbling skills and unerring accuracy in front of goal saw him rank among the game’s best kept secrets.

He was even better on the game’s Master League feature – emerging as one of the very best players on the game.

An expert free kick taker, the South Korean’s stats put him on a par with Chile legend Marcelo Salas on those initial incarnations – but it didn’t last.

Despite impressing during his first spell in Europe with AS Monaco, Park made the fateful error of turning his back on a move to Lille in favour of joining Arsene Wenger at Arsenal.

Park went on to play just seven minutes of first-team football in his first six months at the Emirates. He ended up making just one Premier League appearance for the Gunners during a reputation-wrecking four year stay at the club that included loan moves to Watford and Celta Vigo.

The former South Korea national team captain is now back with his first club FC Seoul in the K-League.

1. Tijani Babangida

Tijani Babangida was one of the first breakout stars of the Pro Evolution Soccer franchise on PlayStation 2.

An explosive right winger and forward by trade, Babangida was the jewel in the crown for both Ajax and Nigeria on the first two editions of the game.

Much of that was down to his pace - the Nigerian boasted a 96 acceleration and a 99 rating for speed. With those kinds of attributes to play with, it was just a case of getting Babangida on the ball and making a beeline for the opposition’s goal.

Given his imperious form on the game, a career at the very top of the game looked inevitable.

But despite impressive spells as a teenager at Roda JC in Holland and with Ajax in the years that followed Babangida’s star soon began to fade.

A bout of malaria coupled with a major dip in form and behind-the-scenes turmoil at Ajax soon saw him deemed surplus to requirements at the Amsterdam club.

Babangida’s last game for Ajax came in 2003, but he remained on the club’s books for a further three years, embarking on a series of underwhelming loan moves before one final swansong in China.

A disappointing end for one of fastest players in the history of PES.

Advertisement