It's important to hear both sides of a conversation. Or at least, that's been one of the (many) rallying cries during the #GamerGate scandal, an ongoing debate/argument/hissy fit currently raging across all forms of social media, which allegedly has something to do with corruption in games journalism but might actually be about something very different indeed. It's a topic that tends to bring up some strong opinions - as video games often do; anybody playing during the height of the Nintendo vs Sega wars will attest to that which means that, often, only one side of the story comes through. There have been some notable successes in some of the goals #GamerGate set out to achieve. But that's not to ignore all of the ways that the movement, or whatever you want to call it, has been an abject failure. It set out to uncover some of the hidden crumminess inherent in the medium and yet, in the process, also ended up reaffirming a lot of sad stereotypes about gaming that have still yet to be dispelled. It's a complex issue that deserves a nuanced look which is why, along with looking at some of those achievements, it's also important to discuss the ten reasons why #GamerGate was a failure.
10. The Shaky Premise
Okay, so corruption in video games journalism is a serious issue. Well, not as serious as actual problems like Ebola, or political corruption, or whatever but any lapse in journalistic ethics is cause for concern. There have been problems with bribery, backhanders, payola and the like when it comes to game reviews for yonks, with writers routinely shipped out to glitzy galas for the announcements of huge new titles or consoles designed to butter them up. It all came to a head when people started losing their jobs for trashing games that companies had paid a lot of money to advertise on their site. This is not the sort of corruption #GamerGate started out wishing to dispel. It began because, allegedly, a journalist for Kotaku had a relationship with developer Zoe Quinn, and then gave her game preferential treatment. Except he never actually wrote anything about her game, Depression Quest, only mentioning her briefly in an article about a failed TV show she was involved with; oh, also, Zoe Quinn is an indie developer with very little pull in the industry compared to, say, EA or one of the other AAA publishers who do throw their weight around and demand better review scores etc. Not the strongest starting point.
9. Inability To Engage In Conversations
One of the other most frequently heard rallying cries whenever #GamerGate is brought up is bemoaning people's ability to hold a conversation. This is true on both sides of the debate but, honestly, you can't really blame those against the movement for removing any sense of dialogue from their proclamations, given the sort of responses that are engendered from mentioning #GamerGate in anything but the most flattering, supportive light. Yes, debates require conversation, both sides working out their differences. That is very much not happening here. Conversations are a give and take. A dialogue is two people talking. It's not one person saying something - sometimes even just a personal opinion - and then ten people jumping on them, demanding "evidence" to back up their claims, hurling abuse their way, or just flat-out telling them that they're wrong. Clearly many of the people involved in #GamerGate could've done with joining their high school debate team, and learning how to actually discuss opposing viewpoints in a rational, (relatively) calm way. Which is not what they're doing right now at all.
8. General Harassment
Speaking of hurling abuse, that seems to be even more common that the failed attempts at debate. Now, it's definitely true that there are people involved in the #GamerGate movement who aren't abusive. They are people genuinely concerned about journalistic ethics in video games the bribes, the money paid for good YouTube reviews and the like and would like to see that change. People with good intentions. But, as they say, that's what they pave the road to hell with. And if you align yourself with a movement which does contain a large portion of disgusting people who send death threats to those they disagree with, you're even more likely to end up on that highway. It's like being the one liberal member of UKIP who agrees with their green environmental policies and just pretends the rest of their manifesto doesn't exist. It's impossible to deny that #GamerGate is free of harassment, since just a cursory glance through that hashtag on Twitter (or, even more saddening, the replies to basically any female developer of journalist) will reveal a torrent of the most abhorrent abuse this side of the internet hate machine. Again, sure, not every person involved in the movement is involved in such harassment, but enough of them are to completely rob it of any credibility at all.
7. Believing A Jilted Ex
Nothing could ever game from a jilted ex. Watergate wasn't uncovered because one of Richard Nixon's frustrated mistresses divulged a load of information to the press - it's because a couple of dogged, passionate journalists dug around (in the most ethical way possible, natch) into a government that was rotten from the core. Similarly, the French Revolution began because of rising class tensions and the growing gap between theocracy and democracy. Again, it didn't kick off because somebody had been dumped and they wanted to get their own back on the aristocracy. #GamerGate had not such auspicious beginnings. The whole thing began because the aforementioned Zoe Quinn's ex-boyfriend, Eron Gjoni, had been broken up with and was moping about it. And wrote a blog post about it. Yes, the entire movement was sparked by somebody's whiny diary entry about how they'd been dumped and life was unfair. Somehow he managed to spin it into a "journalistic ethics" scandal which, as previously mentioned, is 100% untrue. All of this is down to, essentially, a LiveJournal post. That's pretty embarrassing when you think about it.
6. Not Being A Secretive As They Thought
Once again, a disclaimer: obviously not everybody involved with #GamerGate is an abusive monster. But there are enough of those to go around in the movement to completely taint their reputation. Which is clear from the vast caches of evidence Zoe Quinn herself (amongst others, corroborating her claims) has amassed of internet users who class themselves as part of the movement organising the systematic doxxing of herself, friends and family, discussing death threats and the like, along with a whole lot of examples of them admitting the whole thing has nothing to do with ethics, and everything to do with bad old fashioned misogyny. You can look at a whole chronological timeline of such evidence, collected from the 4chan message boards and supposedly "covert" IRC chat rooms, which puts paid to many of the arguments mad against Quinn and other people who have received endless harassment as a result of #GamerGate: there are those who were sceptical that they'd been hacked, received any threats, all that jazz - which would've been way more believable if they hadn't discussed doing those things in public. Also, Elon was involved, so that's cool.
5. Not Understanding Who Zoe Quinn Is
There are a lot of weird assumptions about Zoe Quinn in the #GamerGate movement. Allegedly it was her involvement with a journalist that started the whole thing off but, well, that's been proven as patently untrue. The characterisation provided of her by her ex-boyfriend has been less-than-charitable but, well, they are broken up. People tend not to think too highly of partners after a bad break up. The strangest assumption amongst all of this, however, is that Quinn was trading sexual favours so that her games would get better reviews. Zoe Quinn, indie developer, who makes games like Depression Quest a simulator of what it's like to suffer serious mental health issues. Not all over IGN, is it? Not only is the whole ethics thing totally nonsensical when it comes to Quinn, it also doesn't hold up when you consider the coverage her (excellent) games get. They're fairly small, acclaimed in some quarters, but not the sort of mainstream hits that are plastered all over the web. It also seems that #GamerGate has severely underestimated the developer's willingness to fight back - some of that misogyny showing through again - as she has done, systematically building up all that evidence to forward onto the police and, apparently, the FBI. Is there really any doubt over how badass she is? She has a microchip in her hand that lets her stream Deus Ex to any laptop and a magnet in her finger. She's a literal cyborg. Don't mess with her.
4. #NotAllGamers
Right, so this has been danced around for long enough. Many of the people who have argued against critics of #GamerGate are those that don't see themselves as being part of the abusive, disgusting people who use death threats - online, in person, and via phone calls - and the dissemination of harmful material in order to achieve their goals. Sometimes those people are actually pretty terrible, and either are in denial or simply don't see that they're misogynistic douches. But then there are a lot of people who align themselves with #GamerGate because they want things to change when it comes to games journalism, regardless of whether the Zoe Quinn stuff is true. Crying #NotAllGamers when people criticise the many, many harmful parts of #GamerGate doesn't help anything, though. No more than yelling #NotAllMen over women's discussions of the negative effect being around men has almost constantly on their lives. Nobody is saying all men are terrible, or all gamers. They're saying that the social construct of those identities is inherently flawed and that, in their experience, there have been plenty of examples of harassment and abuse coming from people who identify as those things. Not all gamers are of the more toxic side of #GamerGate, but enough of them are that, honestly, do you want to associate with the sort of people who threaten to kill someone for pointing out that games are kinda sexist sometimes?
3. So Many Lies
One of the biggest revelations from those IRC and 4chan screenshots is quite how much of the #GamerGate "debate" were entirely fabricated by those gross Social Justice Warrior-hating people at the centre of the movement. By the way, since when is Social Justice Warrior a bad thing? Those are all good words. The opposite would be Antisocial Facism Loser. Which would you prefer to be? Anyway, one of the ways that people have been trying to destabilise any of the counter arguments (namely pointing out the amount of misogyny that appears on the opposing side) with stuff like #NotYourShield which, it turns out, was mainly a sock puppet campaign where a bunch of pro-GG types created a load of fake Twitter accounts. #NotYourShield was supposed to disprove all the accusations of misogyny and racism by showing that there were women and people of colour who supported #GamerGate. How can they possibly be prejudice when there are people agreeing with them? Well, because most of those people weighing in saying I am a woman and I don't think this is sexist! were just the same straight white dudes who were being sexist, racist and homophobic in their hysterical defence of video games, only they were pretending not to be to add some more credence to their arguments. It's the infinitely more insidious equivalent of I can't be racist, I've got loads of black friends!, and infinitely more problematic to boot.
2. Breaking All The Laws
#GamerGate and the law have a strange relationship. The timelines of pro-GG Twitter accounts are littered with thorough misunderstandings of how the law works, with people claiming that releasing the private contact information Zoe Quinn, Anita Sarkeesian and their families is totally cool because they're a matter of public record (note: it's not, and they're not, as evidenced by the hoops people have to jump through in order to obtain them ie through hacking), lawyers claiming that they have claims against "bullying" Social Justice Warriors, and that one guy who tried to launch a crowdfunding attempt so they could hire his lawyer wife and do...something? People say that #GamerGate is a movement about journalistic ethics. Based on the majority of their activities, they have more in common with a hate group. They have engaged in smear campaigns against people by illegally releasing private information. They have driven people form their homes by making death threats which is, again, illegal. The torrents of abuse they unleash online may very well lead to jail time if new laws pass through. And obviously there's the guy who said he was going to kill Feminist Frequency's Anita Sarkeesian at a university speech this past week, something else the law tends to frown upon. Look, Batman's against #GamerGate, what more do you want?
1. People Are Already Against Corruption
#GamerGate has nothing to do with corruption in video games journalism. That much is evident from its targets: liberal-leaning websites and magazines, indie developers, and overwhelmingly either women or women-friendly publications and people. Why is that obvious? Because many of the places it has accused of being corrupt have some pretty stringent rules in place to make sure they don't break journalistic ethics. Like, say, the Society Of Professional Journalists' Code of Ethics which sites like Polygon follow, or the rigorous manifesto drawn up at the advent of PC gaming site Rock, Paper Shotgun. Plus the Kotaku stuff that has been pointed out as totally false. What's interesting is that, when actual examples of corruption have cropped up during #GamerGate, there's been nary an outcry. Whilst the movement was busy forcing Intel to remove its advertising from Gamasutra, an industry website which had come out against the misogynistic side of #GamerGate, Jim Sterling of The Escapist (a website that had given a worrying amount of space to pro-GG people who were of the, erm, less-than-sympathetic end) uncovered an actual conspiracy regarding how Shadow Of Mordor made sure to get the "right" coverage on YouTube reviews. #GamerGate has failed. It has shown that it doesn't care a jot about actual corruption. It has shown that much of it is rooted in prejudice and oppression. It will fail to change anything because the mainstream press has branded them a hate group. The Dark Knight is on their case. If you're a pro-GG who actually wants to do something about corruption? It's beyond time to jump ship, and let all the awfulness sink below the surface forevermore.