The year of gaming in 2013 was one for the history books, with several major releases quite rightly sitting among the very best video games ever released. The birth of a new generation of consoles with the Xbox One and PS4 also ensured a new visual benchmark was set, one which should make 2014 a very exciting year to be a gamer indeed. That said, we as gamers are a pretty pedantic bunch, and we can't help but nitpick even when a game totally blows us away. Still, the year has seen its share of ridiculous declarations as far as the biggest games of the year go, ones which started significant "debate" (or more accurately, profanity-laced arguments) among gamers on both sides. Are first-party titles for the new generation just glossy show reels? Is GTA caught in a tailspin? Are too many franchises becoming "casualised?" Here are 10 of the most vocal complaints about the big games of 2013, and why they're nothing but totally ridiculous. Of course, if you for some reason actually agree with these arguments, feel free to pipe up (without profanity!) in the comments section.
10. Killzone: Shadow Fall Is A Glorified Tech Demo
When discussing the best looking games currently available on the Xbox One and PS4, Killzone: Shadow Fall is frequently the game mentioned as the most visually splendid, largely because it's one of the few games, along with Forza Motorsport 5 and Need for Speed: Rivals, that actually looks remotely next gen. Some have been quick to claim that the game, like so many launch titles, is really just a demonstration of the PS4's impressive lighting and particle effects, while the story and gameplay suffer as a result. To these people, I ask, "Have you even played Shadow Fall?" Easily my favourite PS4 game so far, the latest Killzone game may be far from perfect, with its dodgy checkpoint system and relatively forgettable plot, but the visceral gunplay is not so easily forgotten, and then there's the real icing on the cake by way of the superb multiplayer suite, which leaves Call of Duty: Ghosts' comparatively mild offering trailing in the dust. Shadow Fall does a huge service for launch titles, and will be spending much time in my PS4 in the coming months, as I try to hoover up those 1500+ challenges online.
9. Saints Row IV Is Too Dumb For Its Own Good
Complaining about Saints Row IV being too silly and stupid is like whining about oxygen giving you life. Believe it or not, there are apparently some people out there who feel that GTA IV's more serious tone was preferable to the more playful stylings of the previous games (and the pleasantly lighter tone of GTA V), and so when they saw a sandbox game boasting Saints Row IV's level of insanity, they just couldn't handle it. To them, it tipped the balance too far in favour of gratuitous nudity, violence and superhuman, physics-defying action. But that's what's so great about Saints Row IV. It takes the sandbox game and imbues it with an irreverent, off the wall, cartoony tone that's sloppier, messier and less clever than GTA, but still likes to occasionally wink and nod to players. To call Saints Row IV dumb is to miss the point. It might be busy, chaotic, noisy and insane, but stupid it certainly isn't, or at least not in any way that makes it less fun to play.
8. Battlefield 4 Has Terrible Single Player
Battlefield 3 remains the best online FPS I have ever played, yet many were critical of the meager single player mode, which was depressingly short and almost completely lacking in characterisation and memorable set-pieces. I can't remember a single thing about it. As such, when Battlefield 4's release arrived, most of us expected another so-so single player mode, despite DICE claiming that they had taken far greater consideration of it this time around. I will agree that Battlefield 4's solo offering is not spectacular, but it is far from terrible. The addition of Michael K. Williams (Omar from The Wire) lends proceedings a little more gravitas, though I will agree that it is far too short. Still, that's not even the main point here, the point is that Battlefield 4 isn't really about the single player at all, it's a minor diversion at best, one you're supposed to get to when you finally get exhausted from pumping hours into the superb online multiplayer mode. Does that excuse the merely OK single player? Not really, and I'm unsure as to why games like Call of Duty and Battlefield even bother with single player modes, because nobody pays £50 for them. The argument has some basis, in that the single player could be a lot better, but to rally against the game because of this is to miss the point. DICE have clearly pumped their best efforts into the online mode, which is superbly addictive and easily the best online shooter I've played all year.
7. Ni No Kuni Is Just For Kids
Ni No Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch finally landed on the PS3 last year, following much hype due to its association with Studio Ghibli, and despite receiving masses of critical and fan acclaim, the game had only sold 1.4 million copies as of August of last year. Not exactly GTA V figures now, is it? By its niche nature this makes sense, but something became clear when I attempted to discuss the game with friends and on message boards, that too many people felt that it was a "kids game", akin to the more colourful titles that so often frequent Nintendo consoles rather than Sony ones (not to knock Nintendo here). Playing Ni No Kuni, it doesn't take more than a few minutes to be enraptured by its wonderful charm, its vibrant visuals and infectious sense of fun. It is a game aimed at kids only in the way that Ghibli's films or Pixar films are, in that they have a superficial surface appeal to youngsters, but also possess a more artful, sophisticated appeal for adults. It might not be as "mature" as the sensationalism of the Call of Duty or Grand Theft Auto franchises, but that doesn't mean a 3 year old could finish it in five minutes. This is a brilliant game for slightly older kids (aged 8 and up, I would suggest), and also for adults of any age.
6. Gran Turismo 6 Should Have Been On PS4
When the announcement was made that Gran Turismo 6 would be releasing solely on the PS3, the world was shocked. Why wasn't it a PS4 launch title, or in the very least, why was there not the announcement of a planned PS4 version later down the pipeline? The web soon set alight with angry Gran Turismo fans proclaiming that Polyphony Digital were basically throwing their own credibility away (as they sorta already did with the last game's horrendous delays and underwhelming final result) by lazily opting for the "lesser" platform of the PS3. It's important to remember that while we all would have loved a PS4 Gran Turismo game on launch, the development of these games take years, and Gran Turismo 6 had been in development long before any dev-kits for the PS4 would have been ready for experimentation. Of course, we can't forget that Gran Turismo 3 was a launch title for the PS2, and easily one of the best launch titles in in gaming history too, but that regrettably seems to have been a bit of a fluke as far as the development window for these games is concerned. Still, had GT6 been a PS4 title, we likely would have been waiting another 2 or 3 years for it, and I imagine the routine complaints, that the cars are just upscaled versions of the PS3 counterparts, would still persist. To expect a PS4 GT6 on launch was a pretty tall order anyway, but from a company like Polyphony, it was reaching for the stars. Though it might not be the best game in the GT franchise, GT6 is still a lot of fun and another fine addition to the PS3's respectable swan song collection last year.
5. DmC: Devil May Cry Is A Pointless Reboot
I'll admit that before playing the new DmC, I was totally on the bandwagon of haters. Why reboot a franchise as popular as Devil May Cry? Furthermore, why make Dante look so different and so fundamentally change the look and feel of the game? Like many, I am against remakes and reboots most of the time on general principle, because it's an indication of laziness and a lack of imagination to actually make a decent sequel or better yet, a new IP worth playing. However, this all evaporated the second I played Ninja Theory's superb reboot of the franchise, which was arguably the slickest, most insane and entertaining entry in the franchise yet. For sure, it was also the easiest and most accessible title, but given how infuriatingly difficult sections of DMC3 were in particular, I wasn't too mad about that. I'll admit that Dante's new look isn't fantastic, but the cocky demeanour and voice work of his character remain superb, as do the insane special moves he's able to pull off mid battle. Simply, the thing that really matters, the gameplay, was a vast improvement over everything that came before, and as a bonus, it also had awesome graphics. It's a shame the game was a commercial bomb, though, because we probably won't get a sequel.
4. Splinter Cell: Blacklist Is Too Casual
One of the chief complaints among gamers these days is how everything is becoming "casualised" and toned down so that even the most casual player can breeze their way through a game. This doesn't just involve reducing the difficulty, but lightening the entire load of the game, by introducing more save points, and doing things like reducing stealth gameplay in favour of shoot 'em up action, as has been a recent complaint of both the new Hitman and Splinter Cell games. Splinter Cell: Blacklist was a game front-loaded with so much negative hype that I expected nothing short of an unplayable dud. Surprised why I was, then, to find that it is in fact one of the best games in the series, albeit one that purists might need a little time to adjust to. No longer is there the burden on players to be stealthy for most of the game, but instead you can shoot your way through most situations, even if doing so does most often prove more difficult than sneaking. The point here is that Ubisoft haven't even really casualised the game, they've just given players the chance to proceed with more freedom. There's nothing stopping you from taking the traditional Sam Fisher route, but at the same time, you're free to be Rambo if you so wish. The implication is that this will open the franchise up to players who find stealth gameplay annoying, and why not? It makes sense from a marketing perspective and simply allows players to choose how to play.
3. Bioshock Infinite Is Too Easy
One of the common complaints about the Bioshock series is that the Vita Chambers make it too easy, for upon dying, they will revive you, usually not too far from where you died. It's got to the point that some fans like to perform "non-Vita runs" of the game, in which using a Vita Chamber is prohibited because it makes the game too easy. With the release of the latest game in the series, Bioshock Infinite, these claims were refreshed anew, that the penalties for death, usually involving a loss of money and slight regeneration of enemy health, were not high enough. I've got two words for you: 1999 Mode. Basically, everything that made the regular mode a breeze is taken out. Spawn points, ammo and health are lessened, while the map arrow and auto aim are removed completely, and there's no ability to change the difficulty if you find yourself stuck halfway through. If you still find it too easy, then I think you'd best stick with Dark Souls.
2. The Last of Us Is Poorly Paced
The Last of Us is one of the best reviewed video games in history, and the happy recipient of countless Game of the Year awards, but that didn't mean it was perfect. One of the biggest complaints was that the ambling pace of some sections was simply too slow to be compelling or entertaining. The opening 3 or 4 hours have been particularly criticised as aimless, creating a wall of tedium that some players just didn't bother to continue with. Of course, this is ludicrous. While those opening hours are not the most intense or thrilling, they do something important, and that's immerse us in this world and allow us to get to know Joel and Ellie. The banter between the characters during these moments of calm are some of the most naturalistic and believable in any game I've ever played, and are important in the success of the emotional beats that show up later in the game. The Last of Us takes its time, that much is certain, but it is in the service of creating one of the most involving and engrossing worlds in gaming history. Patience is a virtue.
1. GTA V Glorifies Sexism & Violence
A Grand Theft Auto game courts controversy by default, and the recent mammoth hit GTA V was no different. It wasn't long before the various accusations of glorifying violence and rampant sexism rolled out, and Rockstar were no doubt loving all the extra publicity that the game totally didn't need. The scene in particular that caused the most controversy was the torture mission in which, at the behest of the FIB, Trevor uses a number of weapons to torture a suspect in the quest of getting information out of him. As for sexual content, there's the ever-popular hooker murders, and the generally lascivious positions you can find most of the female characters in at one point or another. To critique the torture mission is to gloss over the fact that said mission is very clearly a satire of the "enhanced interrogation" tactics used most infamously by the American army against terror suspects in Guantanmo Bay. The grand irony is that, after torturing the man, the person you assassinate with this information turns out to be the wrong man, highlighting the futility of obtaining information through torture. More to the point, though the game allows players to perform a multitude of ugly acts, we are never expressly told that what they're doing is right, but instead, Michael, Franklin and Trevor are all pretty morally reprehensible people, likeable more for their roguish charm than the content of their character. The sexism debate is a little less straightforward, because the game isn't exactly brimming with decent, upstanding female characters, but then neither is it brimming with any upstanding male characters either. Everyone is fair game in GTA, from men, to women, to lazy teenagers, politicians, the fans of the game themselves and everyone in between. To force a female protagonist into GTA would be to kneel to the very overly-sensitive political correctness that these games are satirising from the outset. As the game's creators have said themselves, these games are so inherently about masculinity and its culture that to turn away from all the strip clubs and casual sexism of the characters would be dishonest and a disservice. But still, what do you think?