It's always refreshing to see video game developers with ambition. In such a risky industry it's easy to see how tempting it is for publishers to push for the safest option, following a proven formula. A market full of safe options isn't healthy though, and it's the ambitious, pioneering titles that help push the industry forwards though, Unfortunately, there have been many video games through history that have proven the high risk associated with too much ambition. From incredibly bloated budgets to narratives too epic in scope for the developers to handle, some games were simply too ambitious to possibly succeed. This list takes a look at 10 ridiculously ambitious games that failed horribly. Whether they were masterpieces too ahead of their time to succeed commercially, or just average games that never came close to their ambition, each of these entries were felled by the developers' lofty ambitions.
10. Beyond: Two Souls
Developers Quantum Dream could never be accused of sticking to what's tried and tested. Known for releasing games that more closely resemble playing through a movie than their more 'gamey' brethren, titles like Heavy Rain and Indigo Prophecy managed to put Quantum Dream on the map as one of the most exciting game developers out there. When Beyond: Two Souls was announced, it looked to be a fitting love letter to the retiring Playstation 3 console. Unfortunately, Beyond: Two Souls just wasn't as tight or engaging as Heavy Rain, despite fantastic motion capture and performances from Ellen Page and Willem Dafoe. The plot was overly ambitious in its scope, the gameplay restrictive, and the whole game fell victim to Quantum Dream trying to control the player experience too much, rather than letting players experience the story in their own way.
9. Destiny
Destiny is a game that seemed to start with a huge amount of ambition, that lessened and lessened as development went on. Bungie's plan was to release a multiplayer first-person-shooter that captured the fun gunplay of their Halo series, while offering the long-term progression and sustainability of an MMO. While most agree that Destiny isn't a bad game, it was certainly overhyped for what was delivered. Many players reported that they'd gotten bored or run out of content within weeks of release, thanks to missions that felt repetitive and relied too much on backtracking previous content. Destiny offers a fun shooting experience, but falls way short of the lofty ambitions and extreme hype that lead up to the release.
8. Duke Nukem Forever
Once upon a time, Duke Nukem Forever looked all set to be the greatest FPS ever made. Anticipated to be a continuation of the pioneering Duke Nukem 3D, Forever looked to be a ridiculously fun shooter with an unprecedented level of interaction with the environment. It was this ambition that led to Duke Nukem Forever's demise. The development was plagued by constant changes to the game's engine as the devs attempted to keep up with the industry around them. For a few years, it seemed like Duke Nukem Forever would never see a release, until the disastrous mess was finally launched after 15 years of development, to a totally unimpressed gaming audience.
7. Jurassic Park: Trespasser
Often hailed as both the worst and most ambitious game of 1998, Trespasser was a highly anticipated game that offered a number of pioneering features. With a number of innovations, such as a regenerating health, a HUD-less display and a physics-based engine, Trespasser could never be accused of playing it safe. Sadly, Trespasser was just too ahead of its time to live up to its ridiculously advanced vision. Many gamers complained that the game wouldn't run on their computers properly, while reviewers derided the game for being buggy and overly difficult due to clunky controls. Trespasser has since gained something of a cult following thanks to its innovations, but it was a downright failure on release.
6. Advent Rising
Advent Rising was supposed to be an epic space opera game for the Xbox generation. A clear inspiration for the Mass Effect series, the devs behind Advent Rising wanted the series to be at the head of a cinematic revolution in gaming. Although the game's ambition was admirable (including a script and story written by Ender's Game author Orson Scott Card), the technical execution was subpar. Many of the cut-scenes would awkwardly bug out, while the AI consisted of little more than moving target practice. Advent Rising was still an enjoyable game on some level, but the poor technical aspects of the game held it back from greatness.
5. APB: All Points Bulletin
Despite being developed by a relatively young development studio, Realtime Worlds, APB: All Points Bulletin had a reasonable level of hype before its release in 2010. The game was to be a massively multiplayer online game set in urban sprawls wherein players could join a gang of criminals or a group of law enforcers and complete missions, catch criminals or just cause mayhem. The words "Grand Theft Auto" and "online" were thrown around a lot, as APB looked set to be one of the most ambitious online multiplayer games ever. Unfortunately, the relatively small studio couldn't cope with the financial pressures of starting up a fledgling MMO, and Realtime Worlds entered administration only two months after release. APB now exists as a free-to-play game, but it's a husk of its former self and a mockery of the lofty ambition of the original.
4. Daikatana
Back in the days when John Romero could do no wrong, Daikatana was one of the most highly anticipated FPS titles ever. Built using the Quake engine, Romero wanted Daikatana to weave an epic journey through time, with puzzle elements to accompany the gunplay. Unfortunately, Romero's team was just too small and inexperienced to produce the game within the timeline given. Daikatana's development dragged on and on, until it began to look hideously dated in comparison to the AAA efforts being released at the time. By the time Daikatana was released in 2000, it felt like a buggy relic, receiving poor sales and a terrible critical reaction.
3. Messiah
One of the most-hyped PC games of the early 00s, Messiah seemed to more focused on marketing the product than actually making the game deliver on its promises. Messiah seemed to be on the cover of every gaming magazine in the late 90s, while advertisements lauded it as the Next Big Thing in gaming. The game's premise was excitingly ambitious, putting players in the shoes of a Cherub who could possess Earth's people in order to fight against Sin itself. Things started getting troubling when it missed its Christmas 1998 release date, and again in the summer of 1999. Once Messiah was finally released in 2000, critics and gamers were left wondering what the fuss was all about. The gameplay was clunky, and the hype had died by the time it limped onto the scene, leading to disappointing sales and cancelled console ports.
2. Too Human
Like several others on this list, Too Human is notable for its long time spent in development hell. Originally planned as a big exclusive for the PlayStation in 1999, the rights for Too Human were eventually sold to Microsoft in 2005, finally releasing as an Xbox 360 exclusive in 2008. Set in a science-fiction setting based around Norse mythology, Too Human's marketing was squarely focused on advertising the game as one of the most ambitious ever made. Taking elements from Western RPGs, fighters, and action games, Too Human was to be a killer app for the Xbox 360 with an epic story like none before. By the time it released, critics were generally indifferent, earning it mediocre reviews thanks to repetitive gameplay, a dodgy camera and an infamous unskippable death sequence cutscene that many cited as adding unnecessary frustration.
1. Shenmue
Now, before you get your pitchforks out, nobody is saying that the Dreamcast's Shenmue is a bad game. In fact, it's one of the best ever made, with a rich open-world that rivals even today's offerings. The complex but compelling plot, huge variety of things to do, and tight combat meant that Shenmue will forever be remembered as one of the greatest games ever released. Unfortunately, while Shenmue was a huge critical success, the scope of its ambition meant that it was technically a commercial failure. The budget was reported as being as high as $70 million (far higher than any title before it), which meant that every Dreamcast owner would have had to purchase Shenmue twice before Sega made a profit. In other words, Shenmue was so ambitious that the budget required to fulfil the ambition made it literally impossible to be a commercial success. What's the most ambitious game you've ever played? Did we miss anything? Join the discussion below!