If history has taught us anything, it's that censoring media is almost always a horrible idea. What seems shocking today will probably seem tame tomorrow. For example, in the 1970s the Exorcist was denied release on home video in the UK due to the controversy surrounding the film. If you watch it now (and you can, as it's been officially available to buy since 1999) it's only as ominous and unsettling as an average Fox News broadcast. Movies and television were both prone to censorship and controversy when they first gained popularity. Now games are in a similar situation and their interactive nature makes them an even easier target. If little Jimmy is running around and shooting people in a virtual war zone while insulting their mothers, won't he want do to that in real life? Most likely not, but only because real wars tend to severely punish campers. Censorship and games have a long history together. The following 10 examples are the worst of the worst, ranging from the game-breaking to the downright petty. They're all ridiculous in their own way and only serve to highlight how pointless game censorship really is. Let's begin!
10. No More Heroes (Wii)
Our first entry is a wonderfully absurd game starring an Otaku with gravity-defying hair named Travis Touchdown. Armed with a beam katana (that totally doesn't resemble a lightsaber at all), he's tasked with fighting his way through a group of assassins to become number one (and get laid). In the American version of the game huge amounts of blood (and for some reason money) spatter the screen whenever Travis lands a finishing blow on an enemy. Unfortunately the European and Japanese versions of the game have no blood at all. Instead, enemies disintegrate into ash when killed. It's the cut-scenes that suffer the most, though. In the opening scene of the game, Travis jumps his motorcycle over two enemies and decapitates them. Their heads fall to the ground, sending streams of blood gushing upwards as Travis effortlessly lands on his feet like a badass in front of them. It's an iconic moment that establishes exactly what the game is about. The impact of this in the censored version is greatly diminished thanks to the removal of the blood and decapitation. The enemies simply disappear into clouds of ash. Considering that the rest of the game is unchanged and includes ridiculous things like clever camera placement making Travis look like he's masturbating when he 'recharges' his weapon, the removal of blood is an odd omission.
9. The Last Of Us
Even if you've been living under the most isolated of rocks over the past year, chances are you'd still have heard of Naughty Dog's The Last Of Us. The heartbreaking tale Joel and Ellie was one of the highlights of 2013 and was a perfect way to say goodbye to the ageing PS3. What you may not know is that the multi-player portion of the game was censored in PAL countries. European players were deprived of blowing an enemy's head clean off with a shorty and using nail bombs to make it rain human body parts. The Last Of Us was censored in the entire PAL region in order to comply with the strict ratings regulations of Germany and Australia. It doesn't really make much sense when you consider that dismemberment was not censored in the single-player campaign, yet it was in the multi-player.
8. Duke Nukem 64 (Nintendo 64)
Duke Nukem is a franchise that's all about being crude, vulgar and cheesy to the point of bad taste. Playing Duke's games was like being in your own awesomely terrible 1980s action movie full of aliens, drug abuse and silly one-liners. Removing any of these elements and the games lose a lot of their charm, as evidenced by the heavily censored Nintendo 64 version of Duke Nukem 3D. Duke's one-liners were toned down ("Die, you son of a bitch!" was replaced with "you're the disease and I'm the cure!"), sexual and religious themes were removed and steroids were replaced with vitamins. In the uncensored version, Duke encounters women trapped in alien pods that beg to be put out of their misery, giving the player the choice of killing them. In the Nintendo 64 version the women are silent and can't be killed. Instead, it's possible to save them from captivity. Duke Nukem 64 offers new weapons, superior graphics to other console versions as well as competitive and co-operative multi-player modes. Sadly Duke Nukem just isn't Duke Nukem without crass humour and scantily clad women.
7. Mortal Kombat (SNES)
Mortal Kombat caused such a stir when it released in 1992 that it led to the creation of the ESRB ratings system. The gory fighter was famed for its brutal fatalities that looked frighteningly realistic (well, at the time anyway) thanks to its use of digitised sprites. When the time came to port the successful title to the SNES, several changes had to be made. Nintendo at the time were notorious for censoring violent games on their consoles in order to protect their family-friendly image. Consequently blood was changed to sweat and some fatalities were nowhere near as violent. In the arcade version, Johnny Cage's fatality involves uppercutting his opponents head off. This was replaced with him kicking his opponent in the chest in the SNES version, which may actually be the lamest way to die ever. Similarly, Kano's fatality was changed from ripping out his opponents heart and holding it triumphantly above his head to punching his opponent in the chest and holding absolutely nothing triumphantly above his head. It's worth noting that the Mega Drive version was also censored, but it had a gore cheat that restored the game to its former, wonderfully gory glory. It's sad that the SNES version suffered this fate because it's actually the best console port of the game in every other way. Its sound and graphics are vastly superior to the Mega Drive version and it was also much easier to play thanks to the SNES controller having more buttons.
6. Manhunt 2
The original Manhunt was so shockingly violent it made concerned citizens yearn for the good old days of Grand Theft Auto. After all, running over a prostitute and getting your money back seems mild when compared to sneaking up on an unsuspecting goon, forcibly jamming a crowbar into his skull and swirling it around a bit. The sequel to Rockstar's most violent game managed to cause controversy just by being announced. This did not work in its favour however, as it was initially refused certification before being given the dreaded Adults Only rating, meaning that many major retailers wouldn't stock it. Worse still, both Sony and Nintendo refused to permit its release on their platforms with this rating. And so, Rockstar were forced to censor the game. The released version applied a trippy filter to the visuals whenever an execution occurred. It was so severe that it was hard to make out what was going on (though the sounds hinted towards bloody, horrible murder). The weird thing is that Manhunt 2 wasn't even significantly more violent than its predecessor. The dated visuals of the Wii and PS2 made the violence seem crude and unrealistic when compared to games on the much more powerful HD consoles.
5. Carmageddon
Carmageddon's awesomely ridiculous name accurately describes what it's about: high-risk races through densely populated areas. This wasn't just a racing game, though. Sure, you could win by being first across the finishing line, but if your racing skills weren't up to scratch you could always destroy every other competing vehicle or mercilessly mow down every pedestrian in the vicinity instead. Well that was the original plan, anyway. It all went wrong when some bright spark decided to build hype for the Carmageddon's gory content by submitting it to the BBFC and obtaining an 18 certificate for the game. This resulted in the somewhat unexpected outcome of the game getting banned. A censored version was eventually released. In the UK version, the blood of the pedestrians and animals was changed to green to imply that they were zombies. In Germany, the humans were replaced with robots that bled oil, which is nowhere near as cool. The BBFC eventually certified the original version for release a mere 10 months later after numerous appeals by the developer, making this whole affair as pointless as life itself.
4. Wolfenstein 3D (SNES)
As we've already established, getting a violent game on the SNES with all of its content intact was harder than trying to tie your shoes in the dark without any fingers. iD's Nazi-slaying shooter Wolfenstein 3D suffered much worse than than the previously mentioned Mortal Kombat. Nazi references such as swastikas were taken out. Hitler was replaced as the final boss by a dude called Staatmeister that actually looked a lot like the Nazi dictator (minus the moustache and Nazi armband, of course). On top of this enemy soldiers spoke English instead of German and Nazi Germany had its name changed to Master State. Blood was also removed, dogs were replaced with giant mutant rats and health was changed to "H.P" for reasons only Nintendo will understand. But wait - there's more! Ammo was changed to shot in the HUD and bullets were removed from the clip's graphic. The censorship was pretty intense and took away a lot of what made Wolfenstein so great (namely shooting Nazis). Nintendo eventually learned that there was a place for mature content on their consoles and decided not to censor the later SNES ports of Doom and Mortal Kombat 2.
3. South Park: The Stick Of Truth
Tired of third-parties spectacularly failing at making good South Park games (South Park Rally still gives us nightmares), series creators Matt Stone and Trey Parker decided to write and design one with the help of Obsidian. The end result of years of hard work is The Stick Of Truth - a fantastic RPG full of inside jokes and references to the show that will undoubtedly please hardcore fans. Unfortunately fans in PAL countries didn't get the pure South Park experience Matt and Trey intended. A total of 7 scenes were removed and replaced with descriptive text, including an anal probe mini-game that takes place on board an alien spaceship. Players have to mash buttons to destroy the probe with their unusually powerful sphincter. This is followed by several other censored mini-games that task you with pressing buttons in the right order to save Randy from getting probed. In a typically hilarious South Park twist, the button prompts soon flash up so quickly that they're impossible to memorise, resulting in poor Randy's sphincter getting another workout. Additionally a mini-game in which you give Randy an abortion in circumstances too damn bizarre to explain was also removed. This is referenced later on in the game and actually becomes an important (and hilarious) plot point. In the grand scheme of things censoring 7 scenes in a game that lasts over 10 hours doesn't sound like much, but the anal probe mini-games happen so close together that the censorship really gets in the way of Stick Of Truth's otherwise excellent pacing. It pulls you out of the experience and ruins the illusion of actually playing in an episode of South Park that Matt, Trey and Obsidian worked so hard to create.
2. Twisted Metal Black
David Jaffe's demented car-combat game was one of the best titles to grace the PS2 in its early life. Its dark tone, huge, destructible levels and clever weapons made it the undisputed king of its genre. Sadly so much content was cut from the PAL version that it almost feels like a different game. All of the famously messed up story cut-scenes were removed, adding up to an hour of content in total. Story-related comments from the drivers were also removed from loading screens. Changes to the gameplay were also made. A plane can be shot down in the first level of the American version to reveal a new area. In the European version, it's already crashed when the level begins. Violence was also toned down in other areas. Drivers no longer exit their destroyed vehicles engulfed in flames, running round hysterically just waiting to get run over. The PAL version of Twisted Metal Black feels horribly incomplete. Dark, unsettling and sometimes funny cut-scenes are a staple of the series. Their absence makes the game feel like Mortal Kombat without its fatalities or Mario without mushrooms and kidnapped princesses.
1. Left 4 Dead 2
Ignoring increasingly whiny pleas for Half-Life 3, Valve went ahead and developed a sequel to their hit zombie shooter Left 4 Dead, basically taking everything that was great about the first game and turned it up to 11. It also added a plethora of new modes and weapons. Melee combat was a particular highlight. Going crazy with a katana and seeing a pile of severed heads and limbs accumulate on the floor is strangely satisfying. The chaotic violence of the zombie apocalypse was deemed too much by the Australian and German governments. Much to Valve's shock, Left 4 Dead 2 was refused classification. With a release date looming over their heads, Valve decided to release a censored version of the game while appealing to get the original version approved. The censorship of Left 4 Dead 2 was so over-the-top it ruined the overall gameplay experience by making your actions feel like they have no impact. Zombies disappear immediately after being killed, limbs and heads can't be cut off and blood has almost been completely removed. It gets worse: riot gear zombies were taken out and fire damage is no longer visible, meaning that zombies just flail around for a bit and disappear when subjected to flames. Using a pipe bomb no longer sends dozens of bodies and limbs flying through the air in all directions. Instead, the majority of zombies disappear in the explosion and only a handful of fully intact bodies get launched skywards. The impact this has on the game overall cannot be understated. It's hard to feel any sense of accomplishment when everything you kill simply fades into thin air. The gritty, realistic atmosphere of Left 4 Dead is completely absent, having been replaced by an empty shell of a game, devoid of any sense of palpable fear and tension. What makes this sad case of censorship even more tragic is that Valve lost their appeal, meaning that German and Australian gamers are now stuck with the censored version forever. Have you encountered a case of game censorship that's not in our list? Let us know in the comments!