10 Rivalries That Killed Video Games
Haze and Killzone killed *themselves*, not Halo.
Competition is everything in any form of art. Everyone will have a different viewpoint on any given topic and that's fine.
This is especially the case as it regards video games.
With such a broad range of gaming genres and an even deeper glut of video games under each banner, antagonism is to be expected between players, deliberating which is the leading example from said genre. Grand Theft Auto is objectively the more successful open-world sandbox, but Saints Row - up to Volition's 2022 reboot - deserves some love, too.
The FIFA franchise may contain a sweeping list of licensed football teams, but Pro Evolution Soccer plays more fluidly and is subjectively easier to grasp for new players.
Such rivalries between communities can break out between developers as well. It's not uncommon for developers of same-genre video games to become petty either before, during, or after production, the best examples of which are when both video games manage to withstand an onslaught of outcry and debate over which is better. The illustrious Mario vs. Sonic feud does this punctually; both are immaculate, well-presented, and cherished franchises.
If only it were that simple every time...
10. Doom Vs. Marathon
Marathon, the first-person shooter from Bungie, was deemed a monetary success upon its December 1994 release. Praised extensively for its profound storyline, the game spanned a trilogy, each instalment receiving a similarly praiseworthy reception for its era-centric uniqueness. Few other, if any, first-person shooters of the time contained such deep-rooted, perplexing stories brimming with Easter eggs.
Doom, its PC counterpart, certainly didn't - but it is often hailed as a greater triumph than the Bungie-developed franchise.
Alongside Wolfenstein 3D, Doom is oft-regarded as having been the benchmark for FPS', with subsequent games under the genre typically described as being "Doom clones". Marathon, unusually, didn't fall this way, but it was played significantly less than Doom was, purely on the basis of what platform it was released for; the Apple Macintosh.
Apple products have never been noteworthy for their gaming communities, whereas PC gaming is as much embedded in today's gaming world as console gaming itself. This was the case when Doom was released as well, to such an extent that aspiring players purchased a PC solely to play Doom.
Had Marathon, too, been released for the PC, it's incredibly probable that this rivalry would have ruled in its favour.
9. World Of Warcraft Vs. EverQuest II
The MMORPG community is inordinately monopolised by World of Warcraft. Released in November 2004 and thus being older than the inaugural iPhone, the film adaptation of Roald Dahl's Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, and the phrase "sexting", WoW was an immediate critical success and now stands as the genre's leading example, with a 2010 peak of 12 million active subscribers.
It didn't, however, popularise the genre; that feat belongs to the EverQuest franchise.
Released in March 1999, EverQuest was once adorned with the accolades currently sitting in World of Warcraft's inventory cabinet, oft-heralded as the best the genre had to offer through its use of a 3D game engine.
Its sequel should have done well, then - and it improbably would've, had it not been for its ill-fated release date.
Thrust into the public domain only fifteen days before World of Warcraft was, EverQuest II was doomed from the start, its leading criticism being that it wasn't as commercially successful for the MMORPG genre as its predecessor was. World of Warcraft, meanwhile, was as successful, remaining the premium example to this day.
Its unmitigated success will presumptively never be topped, either; every gamer either plays WoW or knows someone who does. EverQuest II barely enters the conversation.
8. Madden NFL 2005 Vs. ESPN NFL 2K5
Video game wars between sport-based franchises have continued - and will continue - to exist for as long as the genre remains in existence. There's only one way to acutely computerise the sport, so a second publisher issuing a video game surrounding the sport will automatically be looked down upon.
Before Madden NFL became the primary issuer of digitised American football, NFL 2K had its hand in the pocket of the genre, too, releasing annually between 1999 and 2004 to mixed responses. Its latest release - July 2004's ESPN NFL 2K5 - was met with universal commendation, so much so that a quote from Game Informer's Matthew Kato which read, "The best football title there is and the only one that's a must-have" was transcribed onto the title's keep case. Costing just $19.99 in comparison to Madden NFL 2005's pricey $49.99, choosing between the two was a no-brainer - until EA gave you no such choice.
Cognizant of the potential breakdown of their NFL franchise, EA signed an exclusivity rights deal with the NFL in December 2004, thus giving them sole use of the treasured American sport in video game form and prematurely concluding the NFL 2K series.
The yearly series, tragically, has been on a downward spiral ever since, such is the case with annual sports titles.
7. Bayonetta Vs. Bullet Witch
The Sega-published Bayonetta series - which spans three games and an anime film adaption, Bayonetta: Bloody Fate - has been met with such a whirlwind of positive response that many players forget that it came after its supposed rival, Bullet Witch.
Bullet Witch, Cavia's first FPS for seventh-generation consoles, hit western shelves in February 2007 (following an initial July 2006 Japanese release), meaning it was playable for almost three years before the first Bayonetta title. It was, however, consistently lampooned for its archaic and clunky gameplay, being remembered more for this than it was for its laudable atmospheric, post-apocalyptic setting.
When Bayonetta arrived in October 2009, it, too, drew a grey response in some areas, being questioned for its storyline and quick-time events.
However, its downfalls were backed by its admirable combat and presentation that resulted in a wider negative response aimed at Bullet Witch. One such remark branded the latter 'BETA-netta' in a comical jab.
The two games were never really in competition, despite the rivalry between them. The wholly distinct release dates confirm as such. This was more an example of the games' communities targeting each other for what they perceived as a lesser rip-off; indeed, there were few, if any, resemblances between the two.
6. Team Fortress 2 Vs. Team Fortress Classic
Video game fandoms abhor whenever a new title under the same genre enters the chat. It's a common occurrence - as is fans of the franchise debating which of the franchise is the best.
Many, for example, believed Grand Theft Auto IV as being above Grand Theft Auto V, touting a better cast, storyline, range of missions, and minor details. This goes both ways; GTA V preferers believe GTA IV's driving mechanics to be too floaty.
Fans of the Team Fortress franchise, too, have debated which is better, with the second incarnation typically dominating chatrooms. Praise goes to its pleasant gameplay and use of character, however, the former game perceives this as being too gruff in presentation, believing the vast new features to be unnecessary and "noobish".
Keep in mind, there was an almost decade gap between the two titles releasing, with the second being confirmed in 1998, before twice being delayed and a period of six years without any formal updates. Such development hell for a game that was eventually released is punishable by strongly-worded messageboard comments in today's era.
That it stands up to this day - and is still receiving regular Valve support - exemplifies the clear line drawn between it and its measly predecessor.
5. Overwatch Vs. LawBreakers
In a similar sense as World of Warcraft has done for the MMORPG genre, Overwatch has modernly popularised the team-based FPS, managing to maintain its position of sovereignty through a myriad of fan-fuelled rivalries against opposing communities. Paladins, Battleborn, and Apex Legends have been a handful of the titles struck off by the community as Overwatch rip-offs - but none were perhaps as deserving of the title as LawBreakers.
Being almost entirely influenced by Blizzard Entertainment's latest franchise, LawBreakers - the 2017 FPS from Nexon - did attempt to develop upon the Overwatch-established formula by introducing assorted concepts to the genre, namely low gravity, but the game failed to take off as hoped, and eventually shut its servers just thirteen months into its shelf life.
What's shocking is that initial reviews positively favoured LawBreakers. It garnered a score of 76 on Metacritic, with other notable outlets praising the title with four-star reviews. Hosting a closed beta on Steam with 7,500 players, this dropped drastically by 40% during its open beta; upon launch, it dropped by 60%.
Game director Cliff Bleszinski did, however, state that player figures for PlayStation 4's copy of LawBreakers were significantly higher, though he refrained from specifics. He told GameSpot:-
"There is a situation where players look at numbers on Steam; that doesn't happen on PlayStation 4. I don't have the numbers in front of me, but you look at PC, [concurrent user] health versus PS4, PS4 is doing fine. People cough up 30 bucks and hop online and they don't overthink it."
4. Grand Theft Auto III Vs. Driver
As a foremost franchise, Grand Theft Auto has encountered franchise warfare more than others, but none more infamous, more cheerful, more flagrantly this-is-so-stupid than their harmless dispute with Driver.
Where Grand Theft Auto was more sly (sort of...), Driver's comeback was in-your-face anti-GTA, which only pulled back the curtain on how far behind they were. Having been mocked by GTA III's Two-Faced Tanner mission - in which the player is tasked with eradicating a man described as being "more or less useless out of his car" - Driver 3 was a bit more liberal in its attempted mockery.
They included a character named Timmy Vermicelli, a depressingly obvious caricature of Vice City's Tommy Vercetti, adorned in a blocky Hawaiian shirt and a pair of water inflatables. Get it? Because GTA protagonists couldn't swim in this era!
It was admittedly hilarious - until they went overboard.
They effectively made what was once a bad GTA jab into something of a focal point of the game that awarded players; they had to find every Vermicelli hidden around throughout the game, of which there were 30, and if they killed each one, they'd receive...some gameplay tweaks.
The side quest as a whole was objectless and the reward was anything but. It scans more as free Grand Theft Auto advertising than it does a jab and revealed Driver at their worst.
3. Mass Effect Vs. Too Human
Too Human was a destitute product in comparison to Mass Effect, the latter title spanning four as yet published games, a forthcoming and untitled fifth, and a remastered release of the original trio.
Silicon Knights - Too Human's developers - were forced to recall all unsold Too Human copies following their $4.45 million lawsuit loss to Epic Games in regards to Epic's Unreal Engine 3 usage in Too Human. This ultimately led to the developers filing for bankruptcy in May 2014, releasing just one game post-Too Human - X-Men: Destiny.
It wasn't beneficial to their cause, then, that Too Human was an abhorrent, inferior take on the sci-fi RPG genre. Denounced for its litany of issues, namely its graphics and control scheme, Too Human was never truly a competitor to Mass Effect, which had sold almost two million copies within two months of its release.
What's bizarre is that it was Too Human which was the more anticipated title pre-release. Both were given extensive periods of hype and the promise of deep storylines across a supposedly long line of titles - but only Mass Effect delivered on this promise.
Too Human barely escaped development hell before becoming immersed in legal hell.
2. Halo Vs. Haze & Killzone
Halo was a genuine needle-mover in the FPS genre.
Proving that such games could be played marvellously without the need for a mouse, the series has since grown, authentically, to be a heavyweight in the video game market with ten official games and a smattering of re-releases, stand-alone expansion packs, numerous short-lived web shows, and a 2022-released television series.
Both Haze and Killzone, however, set the genre back.
Prior to their respective May 2008 and November 2004 releases, the duo was heavily anticipated. Props went to their unique, intriguing concepts, but their glut of issues was too high to honestly consider it on the same level as Halo.
Dubbed in the media as "Halo killers", neither Haze nor Killzone had the chance to escape its lifelong second-place status, regularly being included in lists from assorted outlets that discuss the worst and/or most disappointing titles of the generation.
They were dull, feeble attempts from Ubisoft and Sony, respectively, at capitalising on the newfound extol surrounding FPS games, failing to make even the slightest dent in the market, whereas Halo amplified Xbox sales and, with its second title, broke first-day sales records with a weighty $125 million earnings.
Haze and Killzone actually killed themselves, not Halo.
1. Marvel: Ultimate Alliance Vs. Justice League Heroes
Asking comic fans to choose between DC and Marvel is like asking a parent to choose their favourite child. They may have a preference, but it's oft-unmentioned.
The two media leviathans have rivalled over comic books, video games, television series, and films for as long as they've been in operation but in 2006, the video game rivalry stemmed between Marvel: Ultimate Alliance and Justice League Heroes. They were similar in creativity, both encompassing hefty superhero lineups and clean, captivating storylines - but one accomplished its goal significantly better, while the other died in the week before its rival hit shelves.
The two games were released just seven days apart; Justice League Heroes was first on 17 October 2006, followed by Marvel: Ultimate Alliance on 24 October. Although the first was met with somewhat positive reviews, it failed in many areas where Ultimate Alliance succeeded, namely the inability to play as any character on any level, which Ultimate Alliance did offer.
MUA subsequently saw two sequels released in 2009 and 2019, whereas Justice League Heroes was killed off quicker than Task Force X was in The Suicide Squad, having left a putrid taste in players' mouths that Marvel: Ultimate Alliance swiftly purified.