10 Scariest Video Game DLCs Ever

The scariest video game DLC ever - Dead By Daylight, Resident Evil 7 & more!

By Amy Rapeer /

Surely by now it’s not controversial to say that sometimes DLC can be really hit or miss, especially when it comes to horror games. Lots of additional content can fall into a few well-known traps: showing itself to be half-baked, lacking in substance and/or sort of pointless overall.

Advertisement

It’s a real shame when a game you admire and thoroughly enjoyed in its base form lets you down with the DLC, proving that you can’t always trust a title to maintain its acclaim.

But in order to avoid being too pessimistic, we have to acknowledge that the reverse of this is also true - sometimes DLC can be a welcome and truly impressive addition to the main game.

A comprehensive list of the very best DLC out there would be a mile long, so in this list we’re focussing on one particular aspect of a good DLC: the scares! These add-ons offer up some truly terrifying bosses, locations, stories and more, offering up something welcome and innovative to their associated game proper.

Overdone or controversial though some may be, they all have their own merits that deserve discussion. So let’s take a look at some of the spookiest DLC offerings you can get your hands on.

10. Alan Wake - The Signal

Leading on immediately from the ending of the main game, The Signal offers a truly gripping additional chapter to this psychological masterpiece. For those who loved the game proper, this DLC quickly became known as a must-play - with one journalist even going on to say that really it was so fitting and essential that it should have comprised part of the main game itself, that without the DLC the game feels incomplete.

Advertisement

Delving deeper into the fractured mind of novelist Wake, we traverse the Dark Place being guided by friends and hampered by a range of foes. Where before there were complaints of boring, repetitive combat, The Signal attempted to fix this.

More enemies appear to present more of a challenge, aiming to evoke more of a fight or flight response, and the new mechanic of Wake’s words appearing and triggering drops or threats adds a unique new dimension.

It can (and probably should) be completed in one sitting, this concise approach and the revamped mechanics putting this DLC among the ranks of some of the best out there.

9. Fallout New Vegas - Dead Money

As far as horror games go, Fallout probably wouldn’t rank in most people’s top ten most terrifying playthroughs. It’s not really what the franchise is about, when it comes down to it. Fallout New Vegas was no exception to this rule but people were left pleasantly surprised when the Dead Money DLC came along.

Advertisement

Centring around the long-since fallen casino resort (Sierra Madre), this DLC excels in atmosphere, utilising its sunset-tinted aesthetics and jarring sound to unnerve the player at every turn. Stripping back the armour, weapons and allowances for useful pickups, the player is left feeling comparatively helpless.

Though not compatible with everyone’s ideal style of play, it’s a pretty well-known phenomenon that when left exposed the player will feel more on-edge. Combine this with its (literally) haunting enemies and the fear of the unknown in this unprecedented take on the Fallout franchise, and you’ve got a winning formula.

8. Dying Light - The Following

Almost identical in gameplay style to the main game, The Following offers a few changes for the player including a much larger map and access to a buggy that allows you to drive across said map quickly.

Advertisement

The player character Kyle Crane learns about the alleged existence of a cure to the zombie virus, and the game unfolds as he slowly uncovers more about this potential saving grace whilst battling an increasingly dangerous world.

As soon as you hear the word ‘cult’ your mind starts running wild, and luckily for you The Following offers up its very own set of religious maniacs. The cult are called the Children of the Sun and insist that they are immune to the virus because they worship the cult’s leader, The Mother. No, the science of that really doesn’t check out.

With the classic gameplay style and enemies this DLC is a good addition to the Dying Light title, with the added benefit of a little cult-ish madness to bolster the scare-factor.

7. Dead By Daylight - A Lullaby For The Dark

Sort of like Among Us but more terrifying and (assumedly) fewer 12 year old players, Dead By Daylight is an asymmetrical multiplayer where one lucky person gets to be the murderer hunting down all the other participants.

Advertisement

With different DLC comes different maps, survivors and killers to play. All DLC has its own merits and downfalls, but one of the most highly recommended is A Lullaby For The Dark. Not only is this content free, but it comes with a great map, a pretty badass survivor and a powerful, terrifying killer in the shape of The Huntress.

She is famed for her perks as well as her fantastic weapon, her throwing axe being a great way to take down particularly speedy survivors. Her appearance wouldn’t be out of place in any classic home-invasion horror film, her bunny mask evoking images of The Purge or The Strangers.

With this cinematic edge (complimented by her haunting whistle) she is a joy to play as and a terror to play against.

6. Alien: Isolation - Crew Expendable

This DLC is interesting as it’s the first on this list that introduces events that aren’t canon to its universe. Set after Samuel Brett’s death in Alien (1979), it offers an alternative series of events in which the crew devise a plan to get rid of the on-board Xenomorph by launching it out of the air-lock.

Advertisement

The player has to guide the Xenomorph toward the airlock, sealing doors along the way to keep the plan moving. Alongside the base game, it has huge appeal to fans of the original film, with its setting being a dutiful and largely accurate recreation of the Nostromo.

With the claustrophobic journey through the ship and interesting interactions with fellow crew-mates it is a love-letter to the film, allowing players to step into the shoes of one of the characters in their favourite movies.

With the Xenomorph just around the corner and the fate of the Nostromo on the line, the stakes are high and the atmosphere suitably tense. If you want to experience a scene of the well-loved seventies classic for yourself, then this concise but effective DLC is for you.

5. Resident Evil 7 - End Of Zoe

One of two DLCs that arrived after the release of Resident Evil 7, this one is notable for the tension it adds to the situation when depriving the player of firearms. Turns out that when you can’t defend yourself by shooting an enemy from afar, things can get pretty hairy up close.

Advertisement

The story sees a now calcified Zoe being rescued by her uncle, Joe. He must survive swamplands and quarantine areas alike in order to find a cure for Zoe’s deteriorating state, all the while having only melee weapons and his own two hands for self-defence.

This DLC introduces a new kind of Molded in the form of the ‘Double Blade Molded’, an even grosser version of what we’ve gotten used to. Both arms take the form of huge, hulking blades and spines protrude grotesquely from the beasts’ heads.

With its departure from the classic ‘all guns blazing’ approach, it offers something interesting even if the story is not essential to the experience of the game proper.

4. The Evil Within - The Assignment

This was the first DLC for The Evil Within, being episode one of a two-parter with the following part being The Consequence. Set prior to and concurrent with the events of the game proper, this story follows Juli Kidman and shows what she was out and about doing after being separated from the others.

Advertisement

She wasn’t having a good time, that’s for sure. With previously seen enemies including the Shade and the Haunted knocking about, the last thing Kidman needed was for another disgusting monster to be added to the mix - so of course they had to come up with Cadavers!

With the same deadly environment type as the main game and enemies both new and old, this makes for an equally terrifying addition to the canon. Like a few others on this list, this DLC differs in gameplay style to its main game counterpart. Kidman is unarmed, relying on stealth to survive as she is equipped only with a flashlight.

It adds an extra dimension to what we’ve already experienced, having the opportunity to play as Kidman and see what was previously a mystery.

3. Dead Space 3 - Awakened

In an announcement pre-empting the release of the Awakened DLC, Executive Producer Steve Papoutsis claimed that it would contain “some of the most disturbing content... ever seen in a Dead Space game” - making it perfectly suited to this list.

Advertisement

Following the boss fight against Brother Moon at the end of the main game, the DLC sees Isaac Clarke and John Carver attempting to traverse Tau Volantis and gather supplies necessary to return to earth.

Whilst crossing the lands of Tau Volantis, they encounter horrors that are products of both their own growing insanity and those of some seriously messed up super-Unitologists (no, that’s not a technical term). Without spoiling too much, if you thought the Unitologists were weird enough before then you don’t even know how bad it can get!

It delivered on the promise of some disturbing content, and with a darker vibe and bleeker tone than the main game this bit of DLC certainly gives a few good scares.

2. Bloodborne - The Old Hunters

If Bloodborne does one thing right, that would be its ability to craft uniquely terrifying bosses. This particular quality is one that is more than evident in The Old Hunters, an expansion DLC released in 2015 offering new locations, weapons, armour and (of course) new bosses.

Advertisement

As soon as the player finds themself transported to The Hunter’s Nightmare location, they know they’re in for a dark and twisted ride. The world of the Nightmare is home to Hunters consumed by bloodlust, spending eternity in pursuit of beasts whilst transforming into beasts themselves. A series of terrible secrets must be uncovered and awful powers unleashed - which doesn’t exactly sound like a pleasant walk in the park.

The location is just as intriguing as the characters you encounter and fight, with some of the newest enemies and bosses being sure to haunt your nightmares. If you’ve never seen Ludwig, The Accursed then first of all, I envy you, and secondly you must look him up immediately. They say that if you stare him in the eye long enough you will see the souls of a thousand screaming game developers...

1. Outlast - Whistle-blower

Outlast has been talked to death in all its forms but you can’t pretend that this isn’t for good reason. As off-putting as of all the hype (and some fans’ continued insistence that the first of this Red Barrels franchise is the Single Best Horror Game To Ever Exist) can be, the fact remains that the first Outlast game really is quite fantastic - and it is not let down by its DLC.

Advertisement

The Whistleblower DLC reached fans just over a year after the main game’s release, serving as a prequel to Miles Upshur’s infamous trip to Mount Massive Asylum. The player character is Waylon Park, an employee at the asylum who sends his whistleblowing email to Upshur after spending years watching the awful doings of the Murkoff Corporation.

Once again the player is unable to engage in combat, only armed with a camcorder and a furious will to live. Set in Mount Massive Asylum, the player is immersed in the same terrifying location as before but now with added areas and villains. One particularly horrible villain is Eddie Gluskin, a psychotic criminal set on capturing Park and mutilating him to turn him into his ideal ‘bride.’

Perhaps the worst thing about all this is that Eddie Gluskin has a notable fan-base, with some truly cursed fan-art floating around the internet made in his honor. Whatever floats your boat, I guess?

Advertisement