10 Seriously Dark Video Game Endings
Yup, Ciri can die if you play bad enough.
Getting to the end of a video game is no easy feat, I just rolled credits on Persona 5: Strikers a couple of days ago and there’s something so satisfying about a heartwarming conclusion, but not every game wants to give you the warm and fuzzies at the end.
If you’ve been a WhatCulture devotee for some time you’ve probably already experienced for yourself or heard about epicly dark endings like those of Spec Ops: The Line and Shadow of the Colossus. Now, these are some incredible endings but I want to dig into some other truly depressing finales.
10. The Last Of Us
Yeah, okay, I said I wasn’t going to cover any obvious choices and now I’ve gone with Last of Us but this ending is brutal in a whole bunch of different ways, so on the list it goes.
After one of the most brutal beginnings of all of gaming, The Last of Us takes you on a journey centred around Joel and Ellie seeking a cure for the zombie plague--I’m sorry--Cordyceps fungus outbreak. Ellie appears to be the key as her infection never transformed her into a mindless cannibal, as such she seems to be immune.
Come the end of the game, post plenty of clicker-dodging and Joel and Ellie bonding, Ellie is rendered unconscious by almost drowning, and the two are captured by a Firefly patrol. Back in the Fireflies base, Joel discovers that the way they are intending to create a vaccine is to remove part of Ellie’s brain, which will kill her. Well, he isn’t about to let that happen. He bursts into the operating room and kills the lead surgeon along with anyone standing between him and their freedom.
The final nail is when Ellie comes to, on the drive out of the city, when she experiences survivor’s guilt and Joel lies to her. He insists that the Fireflies discovered plenty of other people immune to the virus and concluded there was no way to make a cure after all.
9. Braid
Jonathan Blow’s 2008 puzzle platformer Braid is an interesting one. From the outset you’re a dude called Tim travelling through a series of bright, whimsical levels using your handy power of time manipulation to save a princess from a monster.
Or so it seems.
In the game’s final level everything but Tim moves in reverse. It depicts the princess running from a knight, working with Tim to dodge obstacles in order to reach her home. In Braid’s final moments, however, time moves forward again reversing Tim’s actions which shows the Princess running from Tim, placing obstacles to try and evade him and finally being rescued by the knight.
It’s revealed that the monster she’s running from is actually Tim, the dude you’ve been playing as the whole game.
The implications of you being the villain of the story the whole time, and the recontextualising of Tim’s reflection on himself and comments on his journey and the princess the whole time are pretty damn unsettling. That’s doubled down given you’ve already connected with Tim quite a bit due to the frustrations of many of the game’s tricky puzzles. Only to find out he sucks.
8: Conker’s Bad Fur Day
Since we’re on the topic of games that seem all bright and fun and find wildly depressing ways to end, let’s talk about Rare’s 2001 action game for N64, Conker’s Bad Fur Day. Your first tip off that this isn’t Mario is that Conker is an alcoholic squirrel heading home after a night of heavy drinking and s**t-talking to go back to his girlfriend Berri. What ensues is a series of complications including taking on a giant singing pile of feces, having to fight militant teddy bears, and countering a scheme set by the Panther King to capture Conker.
In your confrontation with the Panther King, Berri is shot and killed by the head of the Weasel Mafia. Fast forward and we’re fighting an alien in space with a katana that Conker demanded the programmers provide him with. After winning, he’s crowned king of the land.
Yeah, this game goes places.
But Berri is still dead and Conker expresses remorse for not asking the programmers to bring her back, realising he lost his chance to bargain with them. The game ends with Conker ruminating on wishing he appreciated what he already had, and after the credits we see him drunkenly exiting the bar as a storm approaches, heading off in the opposite direction than he took at the game’s start.
If that sounds pretty dark the original ending allegedly had Conker put a gun to his head but Rare decided it was too dark so maybe we got off easy.
7: The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt - The Bad Ending
The Witcher games are famous for some truly heavy questlines, many of which don’t ever have a ‘good’ outcome. And some where you think you’ve made the right choice only to find out some devastating consequences unfolded as a result of your choices. I’m looking at you Bloody Baron.
This narrative approach is also super present in the end of the main game, if you get the bad ending.
In this series of events, Geralt finds himself at the end of his tumultuous journey alone, having tried to romance Yennefer and Triss and, you know, chicks don’t love that. If he doesn’t have enough faith in Ciri, she either never becomes a Witcher and leaves him to become Empress, or she straight up dies, unable to return from the other world because she’s become too reliant on you. Which is obviously worse.
At the very end monsters close in around Geralt looking gravely defeated in a house and it’s highly suggested that he doesn’t make it. It’s also a pretty heartbreaking reflection of the person Geralt has become through his bitterness and expectation that he will die alone.
And I’m sure getting that ending after the dozens or hundreds of hours you poured into this epic made you decide to take a break from video games for a while.
6. Limbo
Playdead’s Limbo was Inside before Inside was Inside. Well, there’s no giant amorphous meat blob but otherwise the hallmarks are all there. You play as a little shadow boy in a puzzle side scroller where everything is already pretty bloody dreary.
You awake in a forest and a spider tries to kill you after which you take off trying to find your missing sister. While seeking her any humans you encounter are either running for their lives or also trying to kill you.
When you reach the end of the monochrome hellscape, you’re thrown through a pane of glass and land back in the forest where you find your sister and then the screen cuts to black.
There is no narration in the game and the events are up for your interpretation but a leading theory is that given the main screen after you’ve finished the game shows the very same final area with flies buzzing around the two locations of the characters in this scene, this is where the boy and his sister both died.
Perhaps they fell from the treehouse and died, perhaps the boy is stuck repeating this series of events forever. Whichever theory you like, few of them look good for our hero.
5. Soma
Frictional Games is famous for their Amnesia games but their 2015 survival horror outing Soma was a serious sleeper hit that deserves your attention if it passed you by. The game centres around an underwater research facility which you’re exploring as Simon Jarrett, a man from 2015 who has awoken in the facility in 2104 after a mass extinction event took out all of humanity.
You believe you’re speaking with a woman named Catherine but discover she is a brain scan, as is Simon himself existing in a modified corpse of one of the ship’s personnel. Simon faces robots who want to kill him, and some who don’t, horrific circumstances, and the fallout of the events of the facility.
This is all in his effort to recover the ARK, a black box housing a simulated world and the brain scans of all the personnel aboard the facility. Yeah, this one is hard to properly describe in just a few sentences.
At the end of Simon’s mission he succeeds. Kinda. He sends the ARK off into space but, of course, he doesn’t go with it. It’s a copy of Simon and Catherine’s consciousness that were transferred into the ARK and not the versions we’ve been playing as and alongside. The two argue and Catherine’s cortex chip short-circuits, killing her, and leaving Simon helpless and alone, trapped in the facility on a devastated Earth.
The ARK versions of the two are pretty stoked though, so, let’s try to think about that.
4. Red Dead Redemption
Red Dead Redemption 2’s ending, especially the bad one, but even the good one, is pretty bloody depressing, but in terms of downer Western finales I think we have to give the cake to Red Dead Redemption.
Poor John Marston. You spend the whole damn game trying to be a good person and create a new life for your family, all the while essentially being blackmailed by the government.
In the end, though, John gets screwed over. His farm is surrounded by lawmen, among them Edgar Ross, the person who used John the whole way through to do his dirty work. John sends his family to safety and is gunned down. It’s up to you if you accept John’s fate or take as many of the goons out as you can before you’re inevitably overwhelmed.
The game then flashes forward to focus on Jack, John’s son, who duels and defeats Ross. This is badass, but it’s not the life John wanted for Jack and we know that. So it feels like the cycle continues and what lies ahead for Jack remains unknown.
3. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater
Metal Gear Solid games are a ride, perhaps none more so than Metal Gear Solid 3. Set 31 years before the events of Metal Gear, the story revolves around Naked Snake in his attempt to rescue a Russian rocket scientist, take out an experimental superweapon, and assassinate his former boss whose name is, quite literally, The Boss. Phew, busy times. A hell of a lot goes down, and if you haven’t played this one for yourself, you should. But the ending is absolutely brutal.
When all is said and done you defeat your former mentor, The Boss, and then learn that she was not a defector but a double agent working for the government.
This now infamous twist tore fans apart. In the game’s final scene we see Snake standing over The Boss’s grave saluting and shedding a single tear. It’s absolutely agonising.
Snake is still a hero at this point, but realises his naivety in blindly trusting the government and his assignment. It’s truly heart-wrenching.
2. Mother 3
Mother 3 was an RPG made for the Game Boy Advance that was released in 2006. It centres on Lucas, a boy with psychic abilities, who, alongside a party of characters, attempts to prevent a mysterious invading army from destroying the world. Which is not not a tall order.
This game is bleak piled on more bleak with a touch of super freaking sad. The game starts with the death of Lucas’s mother, the disappearance of his brother, and to top it all off his father abandons him. Then he and his mates track and confront a mysterious masked man dedicated to breaking the seal of the Dark Dragon which, if you didn’t get it from context, is a very bad thing.
Turns out that dude was Lucas’s brainwashed twin brother, the one that went missing. In his confrontation with Lucas he regains his humanity and commits suicide over his grief related his actions and his mother’s death. On top of that, the Dark Dragon is revived anyway, the world gets destroyed and everyone dies a brutal and terrible death.
The game later shows the game’s main cast of characters have survived and perhaps Lucas uses the Dark Dragon to make things right again, but still not a great ending for the millions of people who just violently died.
1. Telltale’s The Walking Dead Season One
Honestly, you couldn’t really go wrong with any of the endings to Telltale’s Walking Dead seasons for this list but Lee and Clementine’s bond was iconic so we’ll go with the original.
Part of the reason this one hurts so much is that the narrative expertly puts you in the shoes of Lee and the stakes are so high and constantly life-or-death that you naturally bond with the other zombie apocalypse survivors, none more so than your adoptive ward, Clementine.
Throughout the game you make brutal choices of who to save, who to feed, when to steal, who to leave behind, and how to educate or protect Clem through the realities of the nasty game world. All the while when you make choices the game tells you ‘So-and-so will remember this’. In the end, it’s just the two of you. Lee is mortally wounded and has been bitten by a walker.
Clem finds her zombified parents she hoped had survived and drags her only surviving surrogate parent to an abandoned store. You then have the option to ask her to kill you before you turn or tell her to run. No matter what you decide the game instructs you that Clementine will remember this.
If that’s not sad enough, you can always head on over to Season Two which is effectively a depression simulator with zombies.