There's a sort of unwritten rule in horror films that, against the usual advice of showing something rather than telling it - ie instead of having everyone describe a character as a badass, simply have a scene of them doing something badass - to make a scary monster, you should never actually see it. Or, at least, you should hold off on showing it in any sort of detail for as long as possible, because as soon as it goes from a figure glimpsed in the shadows to an actual being you can see in the cold light of day, some of the terror dissipates. Unfortunately, that's not so much of an option in video games, so they've adapted the rule somewhat. Outside of, like, sports and puzzle titles, the main objective and way of succeeding in video games is by killing or otherwise destroying your enemies - it's been like that from Space Invaders all the way up to Call Of Duty. In video games, you have all the power. So what could be scarier than a game villain who you can't kill? What could be scarier than making the player powerless? Now you've got some terror back in your games. Not only is the character in the game powerless and scared, but so is the person playing them - and what better time than October, the month of Halloween, to take a look at ten of the most terrifying unkillable video game enemies (and then spend a few hours watching Let's Play from behind the sofa)?
10. Slenderman From Slender
Slender Man actually benefits from that aforementioned cinematic rule of keeping the villain hidden - at least, he does in his first video game appearance. The character himself is actually a piece of fake folklore developed on the SomethingAwful comedy forums, where users challenged each other to come up with a spooky story similar to the sorts you get in different cultures around the world. By far the greatest success of this exercise was Slender Man, originally simply a creepy, faceless figure Photoshopped into the background of otherwise banal photos, his presence imbuing them with a whole lot of sinister vibes. Slender: The Right Pages was a free title released for the PC, designed by one dude, and without any real objectives or win state. Sure, you get instructed at the start to collect a bunch of pieces of paper, but having them doesn't really protect you from that ghostly figure in the woods who will randomly appear behind you and eat your soul, bumping you back to the start after a static-filled GAME OVER screen.
9. The First Big Sister In BioShock 2
The first encounter with the hulking Big Daddies in the original BioShock was, without a doubt, one of the most terrifying moments in modern gaming; but, eventually, you figured out that these huge dudes in old-school diving gear that scream and run at you with giant drill bits aren't quite as invincible as you thought - still pretty tough, but not unkillable. BioShock 2 sees you return to the underwater setting of Rapture, this time as a different conflicted protagonist, and this time with a different set of challenges to contend with. The Big Daddies were terrifying in the way that having Andre The Giant sit on you would be terrifying - they can crush you like a bug, and they've got terrifyingly deep voices. The Big Sisters, meanwhile, are more lithe, always seem to be angry, and so are a constant danger. Especially the first one you encounter after booting up the game, who you can't actually defeat...
8. The Gatherers From Amnesia: The Dark Descent
Speaking of hiding in the shadows, the absolute sadists at Frictional Games are one of the few exceptions to the struggle of video games to nail the "tell don't show" rule of horror films, whilst also providing some of the single most terrifying unkillable enemies in the history of the form. And everybody, rightly, hates them for it. The infamous Amnesia series of first-person puzzlers see you play as a succession of people in historical time periods suffering from, duh, memory loss. The gaps in your memory seem to be large enough to be filled by a bunch of nasty monsters whom you can't look at for too long without going insane, so avoiding them by hiding in the shadows is a primary element of the game's mechanics. But if you spend too long in the shadows, you'll start freaking out and getting paranoid that the monsters are about to jump out and kill you, which can also result in a game over. So periodically you have to return to the light...which lets enemies see you, and come running. And all you have is a lantern, so you better run from these deformed freaks, too.
7. Chris Walker From Outlast
A name like Chris Walker seems pretty mundane. Nothing scary about a dude called Chris, right? If you really think that, there's a good chance you've never played Outlast. Here's a tip: don't. Unless you're prepared to have one of the most pant-wettening experiences of your life, anyway. This first-person title sees you play as a nosy journalist who takes his video camera and decides to document an abandoned mental asylum which, apparently, has had a bunch of weird, scary stuff happening in it. The psychiatric ward Outlast takes place in isn't short of horrific sights, but the absolute worst of all the various terrors in Outlast has to be Chris L Walker, one of the inmates who despite being confined to a hospital is absolutely bloody huge, is absolutely bloody terrifying, and absolutely invincible. Again, not that you have any weapons bar your camera, but most enemies you can deal with okay - all you can do with Chris is run, and hide, and pray he didn't see where you ran and hide.
6. The Xenomorph From Alien: Isolation
The newest entry on the list might also be one of the most terrifying - it's just that nobody's played enough of Alien: Isolation yet to really decided if its eponymous enemy deserves a place in the upper echelons of terrifying, unkillable video game villains. What everybody does seem to agree on is that the title manages to recreate the tone of the first Alien film in a way that none of the myriad Alien games have yet managed, as the player takes on the role of Amanda Ripley (daughter of Sigourney Weaver's Ellen from the movies), who becomes trapped on a space station with the iconic monster. The player's only defence is to hide, scare it off with fire, distract it with a noisemaker, or initiate a game-breaking glitch which shoots them and the alien out into the vacuum of space. Which, to be honest, most people would probably take over another pants-browning moment of the monster descending from the air vents above you, dragging you up and punching a whole in your chest with its mouth-within-a-mouth.
5. Everything In Alone In The Dark
It's hard to remember now that the series has been tainted by countless mediocre sequels and a couple of predictably awful Uwe Boll movie adaptations (starring Christian Bale and Tara Reid!), but the original Alone In The Dark was actually pretty darn terrifying. It might not be obvious from looking at screenshots, what with the surprisingly bright lighting letting you get a full look at the blocky graphics which are barely legible regardless, but there was a palpable sense of dread. The weird fiction of HP Lovecraft was a point of reference for the game. His stories didn't really deal with monsters in the traditional sense; the likes of Call Of Cthulhu told tales of ordinary human beings exposed to an element of the universe they were never supposed to know about, and being driven insane by their inability to comprehend it. Difficult to render in a video game, so Alone In The Dark goes for the "unkillable enemy" trope with basically every bad guy in the game, which creates an oppressive and paranoid feel as every room you enter could be your last.
4. Yourself In Shadow Of The Colossus
Shadow Of The Colossus is not a horror game. To be honest, it's difficult to know what to categorise it as. Much like Fumito Ueda's previous title, the inventive and lyrical Ico. The uncharitable would, in fact, describe Shadow Of The Colossus as nothing more than a series of boss battles, as your lone warrior wanders a desert wasteland on horseback and does battle with a series of titular giant monsters threatening the future of mankind. Just as players think they've managed to obtain the ultimate objective of Shadow Of The Colossus (ie killing all of said colossi) (yes that is the real plural of colossus, look it up), it turns out there's one unkillable enemy left to deal with: themselves. The vulnerable warrior you've been controlling for the whole game becomes host for the biggest, baddest bad guy of them all, and so the game ends with you smashing up your former friends with huge, spectral fists, until they trap you for all eternity and the credits role.
3. Pyramid Head From Silent Hill 2
Which is fine, but that actual, primal terror is a familiar feeling in Silent Hill 2, where players enter a mist-filled town that's otherwise populated by horrible, disfigured creatures whose presence is alerted by the growing static crackle of a broken radio in your inventory, which means players spend a lot of time in rooms and environments where the radio stays silent. That way you know it's safe. At least, that's how most people seem to play it. In Silent Hill 2 you play as James Sunderland, who visits the town to look for his dead wife. Turns out that (SPOILERS) James killed his wife, and the monsters are manifestations of his guilt. Hence the ultimate villain of the town is a dude with huge phallic head and sword. That chases you. And chases you. And no matter how many rounds you pop off at him, he can't be killed. He just keeps coming. Forever. Just like YOUR GUILT. And JUSTICE. And the sleepless nights which follow playing Silent Hill 2.
2. Nemesis From Resident Evil 3
Back in the day, Resident Evil wasn't an action title that saw you effortlessly cutting down hordes of the undead with machine gun fire and then suplexing a bunch of them. No, the early Resi titles almost single-handedly inventing the survival horror genre, characterised by making the player feel somewhat powerless with limited ammo, unwieldy controls, and enemies that were difficult to bump off. Or, in the case of the third in the series, impossible to bump off. The third in the series took that survival horror concept - the controls didn't let you run-and-gun - and ironically ran with it, since the titular antagonist Nemesis - that huge hulking uber zombie - would frequently show up at random, and couldn't be killed, and all you could do was try and slow him down, then leg it. Which is not the sort of frenetic action tank controls can really deal with. Double the terror!
1. The Pac-Man Ghosts
For all the amazing developments in technology, there has never been a more terrifying gaming experience than when you are cornered by the lethal foursome of Blinky, Pinky, Inky and Clyde during a game of Pac-Man. The maze the classic coin-op title is set in has the similar oppressive feel of the Resident Evil or Alone In The Dark mansions; the simple controls are classic survival horror fare; the constant respawning of your enemies has the sort of existential pointlessness Shadow Of The Colossus inspires. Not that the designs of Blinky, Pinky, Inky and Clyde are particularly frightening in and of themselves. It's the tenacity, the refusal to give up, that lands the group of sneaky spirits the top spot of the most terrifying unkillable enemies in video game history. Almost all the other enemies on this list can be permanently dealt with in one way or another. You might not be able to kill them, but you can eventually outrun and escape them, or else trap the somehow so that they won't bother you any more. At the very least, you can finish the game, and then you'll be free of them. In Pac-Man, the ghosts never go away. You eat them after grabbing a power up, they'll just reconstitute themselves. You can't kill them. They're already dead. And you remain tragically, mortally human. Albeit without arms or legs or eyes. Or hope.