10 Terrifying Video Game Horrors Nobody Saw Coming

The biggest scares are always just out of sight...

By Dan Cross /

For the playful, there are LEGO games. For the adrenaline junkies, Call of Duty. For the story-hungry, Firewatch.

Advertisement

Then there are the masochists among us. Those that need a good jump-scare to get the adrenaline pumping, or a looming, ominous atmosphere to garner their interest.

Horror games have been around almost as long as video games themselves, with 1981 Nostromo inspired by the 1979 movie Alien, taking the name from the movie's transport ship. In this early survival horror, the player was stalked by an invisible alien which only became visible when it was directly in front of you.

The Slenderman of the 1980s, if you will.

We've come along way since 1981, and while there are plenty of horror games that still terrify us, this list will focus primarily on horror characters and moments in games we didn't see coming.

That excludes common horror entries such as the infamous Lisa from P.T. and the terrifying Alien from Alien Isolation. Instead, this list will turn its attention to unexpected antagonists, disturbing events and horrific ideas that caused our hairs to stand on end and our heroes to run away with their tail between their legs.

10. Asphyxia (Silent Hill: Homecoming)

While series favourites Nemesis from Resident Evil 3 and Pyramid Head from Silent Hill 2 often take the prize for most horrific antagonists in survival horror games, both were revealed before the release of their respective games, either by appearing on the box art, or revealed in teaser playthroughs.

Advertisement

One grotesque nasty that took many players by surprise was Human Caterpillar-wannabe, Asphyxia from Silent Hill: Homecoming.

Created out of the memories of Margaret Holloway, Asphyxia represents Nora Holloway, whom Margaret suffocated as a human sacrifice. As with most Silent Hill monsters, their physical manifestation is often linked with the manner of a person's death. The many hands clawing at the monster's body and face represent this suffocation in an all-to-literal way, while the caterpillar-like body comes from Nora's obsession with Alice in Wonderland. Even the lack of eyes is symbolic of how she was murdered in darkness, whilst she slept.

The hideous nature of this monstrosity doesn't end there, with protagonist Alex killing it by wrenching the hands from it's mouth, forcing it to breathe - the absence of which killed Nora to begin with.

Lovely nightmare-fuel there, Konami.

9. High Lord Wolnir (Dark Souls 3)

There are multitude of enemies that could have made this list from Demon Souls, Dark Souls or Bloodbourne. As this list is dedicated to horrors that lurk in unexpected places, the Highlord Wolnir beat similar terrors such as the Brain of Mensis (Bloodbourne) and the nasty Mimics (Dark Souls 3) to this entry.

Advertisement

There are far scarier monsters than skeleton kings, and most action gamers are familiar with battling gigantic baddies. However, when your hero is creeping through the pitch black Catacombs of Carthus, with a flaming torch that gives only a few feet of light, stumbling across this colossal collective of giant bones is enough for your heart to jump into your mouth.

Nope! Back the way I came...

8. Sovereign (Mass Effect)

For 75% of the game, Spectre traitor Saren Arterius is the main antagonist. With his skyscraper-sized ship and army of geth in tow, Saren scours the Milky Way searching for the mysterious Conduit. Shepherd and crew pursue him, always one step behind understanding Saren's true purpose.

Advertisement

Then, after tracking Saren to Virmire, the unexpected happens. Saren's ship, known as Sovereign, opens communication with Shepherd. It soon becomes apparent that Saren is just a pawn for Sovereign, one of many Reapers. The Conduit is a hidden Mass Relay that will allow an army of similarly massive Reapers to instantly travel to the Milky Way from their slumber in deep space, with the sole intention of wiping out all sentient life.

They leave behind their technology so future lifeforms follow the same paths, eventually discovering the Mass Relays. Then, after 50,000 years, when intelligent life is in danger of wiping out all life in the galaxy through war, the Reapers appear to 'cleanse' the galaxy once more.

What makes this encounter truly terrifying is Sovereign's total indifference to Shepherd's heroic protests. He barely takes the time to explain what Reapers are, not believing Shepherd capable or worthy of understanding, and his total confidence at the destruction of all sentient life, as evidenced by the many times they have done it before, is utterly overwhelming.

7. The Baker Family (Resident Evil 7)

For awhile now, particularly the last two main series entries, Resident Evil has been moving away from survival horror to action shooter. In place of tense atmosphere and fear were hordes of increasingly grotesque enemies.

Advertisement

The Baker Family are about to change all of that.

Borrowing inspiration from “run-and-Hide” survival horrors like Alien Isolation and Outlast, much of what we've seen so far of Resident Evil 7 sees your character as an anti-Chris Redfield, trapped inside a dilapidated mansion with a family determined to stalk you and prevent your escape.

Patriarch Jack relies on brute strength, slowly stalking you but bursting through walls when you least expect it, while matriarch Marguerite possesses some kind of kinship with killer bugs. The younger Lucas is still a mystery, but all three are infected with something that gives them remarkable healing abilities.

Of course, more terrifying than all of these is the old woman that sits silently and unmoving in her chair. She might not have said anything yet, but she keeps showing up in unusual places, often in tight corridors where you have to squeeze passed. She hasn't jumped yet, but we all know its coming.

Whatever secrets the Baker Family are protecting, they can't be worse than the Deliverance family.

6. NoonTech Diagnostic Machine (Dead Space 2)

Designed to extract information from the brain via a needle through the eye, the NoonTech Diagnostic Machine was originally used to extract information necessary to build Marker 12, wiping Isaac's memory afterwards.

Advertisement

If only it were so easy.

After Isaac's eyelids are held back and the needle begins to descend, Isaac needs to keep his heart rate down and remain calm while the foot-long needle descends directly towards his eyeball.

The happy result is Isaac keeps his eye nice and still and the needle gently glides inside, accessing the memories he needs, with the needle retracting safely.

Unfortunately, many of us felt our stomachs turn as we witnessed the unhappy result. If Isaac's heart rate rises too high, he begins moving his eye frantically. The ensuing panic causes the machine to malfunction, which, like any precision medical machine should definitely not do, proceeds to plummet the needle deep into Isaac's eye with all the force of a gut-punch.

Unable to wrench itself free, the device instead burrows deeper into Isaac's skull, before eventually reaching the brain and killing him.

Reload from most recent checkpoint.

5. The Flood (Halo: Combat Evolved)

As Master Chief battles the Covenant across the Halo's surface, he picks up hints of an underground control centre where he can find weapons that will turn the tide of the battle. However, on following Captain Keyes into the bowels of the space station, Master Chief learns they have unwittingly released a parasite known to wipe out entire civilisations, known as The Flood.

Advertisement

Suddenly a game we thought was about defending our fellow troops from an enemy alien race, becomes a battle for survival against a parasite that crawls across floors like spiders, jumps at our heads like facehuggers, and reanimates the mutilated corpses of our fallen friends into grotesque zombies with superhuman strength.

After a few hours building up our confidence and readying our Master Chief for war, Halo had us running for our lives, with The Flood living up to its name as a horrific parasite that just wouldn't stop.

Fortunately, Master Chief was able to get his revenge by taking out The Flood before it could escape. It just required the small task of blowing up the entire planet, resulting in one of the most epic game endings as we navigated our warthog across the exploding space station.

4. The Eye (Sunless Sea)

Like Mass Effect's Reapers, Sunless Sea is heavily inspired by H.P. Lovecraft's concept of The Old Ones; beings so enormous and ancient that humans are to them as ants are to us; an insignificant speck not worth a second though. One look upon these immense monstrosities is enough to drive a person mad.

Advertisement

Victorian London has transported to the edge of Unterzee, an immense ocean full of monsters, bandits and ruinous secrets. The very nature of the game is for the ship's Captain to achieve their goals of fame or fortune by exploring the mysteries of the Unterzee.

Unfortunately, everything in this murky green ocean either wants to kill you or drives you insane.

In the south of the sea, random nameless tiles generate. One such tile is that of a small rock, which, when approached, an enormous eye beneath the waves opens, staring intensely at the ship. The monster is never fully revealed or explained, but is a clear sign of an ancient being or immense power, lurking beneath the ocean.

Whether you choose to sail towards The Eye, risking permanent insanity or death for the opportunity to hear the monster's message, or whether you turn and sail away as fast as you can, you're unlikely to make it home with all your marbles in tact.

3. David (The Last Of Us)

The Last of Us has its fair share of horrific moments, yet, amongst all the heartache of lost friends and tragic messages left behind for lost family members, the biggest horror of the game is arguably the very human, very charming, David; leader of a small community that survives Winters by eating ill-fated travellers that pass through their town.

Advertisement

What makes David particularly terrifying is the gradual reveal of his true nature. Initially friendly and welcoming, Ellie's abduction and Joel's meddling reveal his inner beast, culminating in a terrifying game of cat and mouse as David and Ellie compete to hunt and gut the other.

To those gamers that play this battle on Survivor difficulty without listening mode, I can only salute you.

The horror of this event reaches its crescendo with Joel unable to reach Ellie in time, forcing Ellie to kill David herself. All of her fear and anger come gushing out as she repeatedly stabs David again and again. As Joel forces her away, he and the player know that the sweet innocence we all loved about Ellie has just been murdered along with David, and she will never be the same again.

2. Family Matters (The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt)

Geralt's search of Ciri sees him encounter all manner of nasties, be it the Witches of The Wood and their penchant for human ears, caves infested with giant, jumping spiders, or paintings haunted by an imprisoned-wife-turned-wraith. Worse still are the gut-wrenching tragedies of materialistic women cursed to transform into hideous, spoon-collecting trolls or werewolves tricked into killing their own loved ones.

Advertisement

The tale that takes the prize for brutality and horror in The Witcher 3 – which is little like choosing who your least favourite child – is “Family Matters”. Having traced Ciri to the Bloody Baron of Velen, Geralt learns of the Bloody Baron's abusive, drunken history with his pregnant wife. Having beaten her so badly one night, she miscarried and the Baron quickly buried the dead foetus.

On learning the truth, Geralt warns the Baron that the baby will likely transform into a hideous botchling, a rotten, zombified monster that will seek out the family that failed it so it can use its multiple layers of sharp teeth to rip their heads off.

Whether the player chooses to kill the botchling, or help the Baron transform it into a Lubberkin so that the family might find peace, it is the brutal tragedy of the quest that horrified players, and, despite the terrible nature of the Witcher world and its inhabitants, this mission still managed to shock players around the world.

1. The Groom (Outlast: Whistleblower)

Whistleblower sandwiches the main plot of Outlast, with the player taking on the role of Waylon Park, the employee that sends the anonymous note to doomed main game journalist, Miles Upshur. After being discovered, Waylon, having been subjected to hypnotism and experimentation, escapes his cell and seeks a way out. After losing his fingers and incinerating a man, you'd think his day had been hard enough.

Advertisement

Enter Eddie Gluskin, aka The Groom.

Poor Eddie is desperately seeking his perfect bride, but faces a couple of issues. Firstly, he has the rather odd tendency to see men as women, choosing to brutally mutilate their chests and genitalia until they somewhat resemble the female of the species. Secondly, and this is partly down to his surgical prowess, but also his inner psychopath, he has a habit of killing his brides.

What makes this character so terrifying isn't only his blatant insanity, but, after finding us hidden in a locker, which the game cruelly places strategically, knowing we will think it is our only escape, The Groom drags the locker to his surgery table where we witness his 'surgery' first hand. It's only due to outside interruptions that, when it comes to our turn to be strapped to the table, that we manage to escape with the family jewels in tact, leading to the creepiest and naked-est game of cat and mouse in gaming history.

--

Which creepy characters, moments or reveals came out of nowhere? Let us know in the comments!

Advertisement