It comes to something when the game flying the flag for next-generation necessity is the annually-released Call of Duty, but there you go. With alternate developers Infinity Ward and Treyarch trying their best to keep things fresh, it was with last year's Ghosts that the cracks players usually paper over by enjoying some serviceable multiplayer were all fracturing to obscure the entire experience. Thankfully this year it's Sledgehammer Games taking over the main instalment to produce Advanced Warfare; an entry in the series that provides the biggest shakeup to core gameplay there's been since Modern Warfare. By giving the reigns over to a team of people who have long waited in the sidelines to get stuck in, it's allowed them to fix a great number of issues the previous workers on the franchise always overlooked, along with injecting a huge amount of new content to really make it worthwhile to fans of shooting in general - rather than just COD's 'one-shot-you're-dead' signature style. It all stems from the Elysium-style EXO suits, bio-mechanical integrative exoskeletons that our future-soldiers can step into to receive massive boosts to everything from pure strength to jumping height and even temporary invisibility. This element of science-fiction drastically changes the very nature of how Call of Duty plays on a fundamental level, and it's through these sci-fi elements that it allows AW to take on Bungie's latest at their own game.
10. Rewarding Progression
As much as it has the potential to just be lights, bells and whistles, there's definitely something satisfying in seeing an in-game level-up bar shoot up post-match, showering you with positive stats and items for a job well done. Even if you lose the main match in COD, chances are you'll neck enough points through weapon use or consolation/loser's share XP to neck another upgrade for a gun or level up yourself. The word here is 'fun', and it's something that was almost completely missing from Destiny's first furtive few days. Being that post-game the rewards you received were completely randomly generated, it meant regardless of how much of your all you threw in, you could come away with a common item the guy next to you got in the previous match for a third of the effort. COD makes a point of at least trying to give you a nudge in the vein of "Attaboy champ, you'll get 'em next time" whereas Destiny walks off dismissively, knowing many will run to catch up regardless.
9. Weapon Variety
So let's start with an easy one - the weapons you'll be firing. In Destiny you're severely limited to just nine categories, the mods within altering everything from ammo-effects to blast-radius' and general proficiency when firing, among other things. It's this constant feed of 'new' weapons that provides a solid application of icing to the hardcore shooter-cake within, as Destiny's core 'feel' plays like a dream - it just doesn't have a whole lot going on in the way of variation. Each of the nine categories are differentiable enough - the handgun kicks like a mule and the shotgun feels like it could conquer a neighbouring planet before breakfast - but so far that's so Bungie. It's when it comes to delivering on some truly unique weaponry that Halo didn't already do better, that the experience falls apart. Enter COD, with enough weapons to make Michael Bay jealous as it gives you everything from twin chainguns to plantable turrets and even a laser beam (yes, really). Bungie's idea with Destiny was to give a great number of their guns 'stories' so when you saw another player with a certain gun, you'd know what they went through to obtain it mission-wise. Sadly that just isn't the case in the final game, but with COD's perk system unlocking a great many sci-fi-themed death-dealers every handful of levels, if you put the time in online you're going to look drastically different in the end.
8. Original Multiplayer Modes
Destiny's best feature is something you'll not unlock until you near the end of it's level-cap, along with having to put in close to 20+ hours into the base game before it even gets a mention. Now this is either an incredibly bold design decision or a horrifically misjudged oversight, as anyone who has played The Vault of Glass will tell you through aghast expressions - it's by far the most original and praiseworthy content in the game. Even this mode is part of a series of 'Strikes' that are incredibly hard, and that's doing away with the aforementioned amount of time you have to sink into the game to unlock it - whereas COD throws up the brilliantly-fun Uplink mode right away. It sees you grabbing a target football before sprinting towards a goal and lobbing it in. It's one point for a throw-in and two for a touchdown, except like with Halo's flags you can't shoot when holding it, leading to many a bullet-dodging sprint towards the finish as your team cover you - or open themselves up for passes so you can defend yourself. Players have even realised you can throw the ball at the enemy, forcing them to catch it and removing their ability to fire, letting you finish them off before continuing. It's modes and gameplay mechanics like this that build on an incredibly solid foundation and make newcomers to the series realise there's something genuinely fun on offer rather than the standard headshot-city approach to matches. Until Destiny unveils something truly special or unique, COD's got it beat hands down with just the one mode - and that's without mentioning the string of past match types that are available too.
7. Multiplayer Voice-Over
If you're going to be playing as much multiplayer as the big guns of the industry want you to, chances are as far as Destiny's concerned it means you'll have noticed how utterly terrible their voice over guy is. Where Halo had the brilliantly-quotable tone of Jeff Steitzer, chucking out things like "Slayerrr" or "Flag Captured" with enough weight to transcend generations, Destiny's attempt at motivation sounds more like an angry Peter Molyneux, getting more annoyed but in a really restrained way that just makes you question your very purpose in the world itself. The basic idea of the Guardians you play as in Destiny is to be humanity's main form of defence against 'The Darkness', a duty that after being berated by the voice over guy and talking to the character of The Speaker, is supposed to be something of an honour - a discipline that should come across as making you feel like you're chosen to take part in battle. However, as this sense of drive is almost completely absent in terms of scriptwriting and must instead be inferred, that lack of weight or responsibility isn't even remotely instilled in the player. Instead the many instances of a slightly perturbed Englishman saying things like "Prove yourself, Guardian!", "You're falling behind" or referring to you as a "Disappointment" are just plain annoying.
6. A Sense Of Purpose To The World
This tingle of not really knowing what you're doing or who you're fighting for or against in Destiny's campaign is something that ends up personifying the game overall. You repeatedly have to dig deep or get involved in forum discussions to really generate any sense of purpose to the proceedings, and in the end those of us that played through Destiny with the hope that everything would fall into place in the late-game were very disappointed. With Call of Duty it's long-since been a signature trait that the games' various campaigns put you in the centre of a bullet n' bombs-hurricane, the campaign itself only moving forward when you do, as the whole thing feels like you're piloting a camera through one hell of an elaborate shooting gallery, and not a huge amount more. That's not a negative, instead this is something COD has honed and refined to a state where if you've a penchant for any type of action movie, it can be a very fun ride. The problem Destiny had - and still has, being there's not enough 'expansion packs' to make the narrative even worth describing - is that total lack of purpose in the world. You're one cog in an ever-changing machine, and maybe some players are okay with contributing a little to a large war effort over time, but as mentioned in the previous entry, when you're lambasted and derided for being 'just a number' that's under-performing, it's simply off-putting.
5. A Memorable Campaign
Remember when Michael Bay was good? It's pretty hard looking back through a miasma of CG ninja turtles and girl's bottoms permeating your peripheral vision, but back in the late 90's, Bay actually had a pretty solid reputation for occasionally hitting the sweet spot between balancing awesome character moments with overblown set-pieces and a wanton need for destruction. When Call of Duty is done right, it's like those times when Bay actually works. It's dodging cars on the freeway in Bad Boys II, it's the cool camera angles and depth of field that occasionally (let's not get carried away) cements a moment in your mind forevermore, and it's that sensation that under the right guiding hand, there's a great number of us that are happy to sit back, buckle up and enjoy the ride. COD knows this in 2014, and it delivers in spades. Now naturally this isn't what Destiny was going for whatsoever, quite the opposite in fact. But even Destiny's attempt at this pseudo-philosophical bent on humanity's place in the universe suddenly being effected by a celestial entity that advances us far beyond our imaginations is a premise almost completely ignored throughout. By the end of Destiny's campaign you'll have a litany of questions and nowhere to find answers outside of visiting the game's website - something that if you have to leave the experience to do, speaks volumes as to its level of engagement.
4. Locomotion And The Flow Of Combat
What's the identifying thing that makes you know you're watching footage of Destiny? You could make a case for the boost-jumps, but it's the character-powers that really make every deathmatch pop. Lobbing balls of dark energy across the map or setting light to your pistol for increased damage are those moments that can really turn the tide, and depending on how much you like extended firework displays, Bungie's restraint at governing their use by giving you a meter that slowly fills is a divisive one. COD has no such incredible powers, but it does take on Destiny in the movement stakes, as along with a one-two boost jump that can redirect you in mid-air (something that makes airborne firefights great fun) you can also punch the lights out of the nearest soldier with enough force to send them careening across a room, or leap up and perform a slam attack. None of these things are governed by a meter or any sort or a reward, instead matches in COD tend to take off at lightspeed and remain there. Sure that more floaty-yet-weighty feel is something Bungie cultivated perfectly with Halo, but in Destiny there's something missing from the flow of combat when it comes to really hooking you in for the long haul.
3. Fantastic Use Of Concept
The idea of bio-mechanical soldiers isn't anything particularly new, although you'll be pretty hard-pressed to find any games that really do it with the realism and weight on display here. Instead, taking such a cool sci-fi concept and delivering on it in the semi-real world is pretty refreshing. Okay sure, the campaign story gets pretty dumb at points and you could easily argue the whole thing is 'unrealistic' just on the face of it, but COD is thoroughly sure of itself throughout - something just not the case with Destiny. Dancing between faux-religious pandering and the expectance that you'll join the characters in staring listlessly at the world around you whilst remarking on how much they all don't know does little to make you understand what a giant floating orb is doing in the sky, or why you should know your Awokens from your Fallens. Destiny does nothing with the potentially brilliant world the art team have designed - because it does look absolutely gorgeous, all things considered - whereas COD knows exactly what it can be, and acts accordingly. They even give you a perk that drastically reduces the aim-flicker when being shot; one of the most annoying things about the previous 'COD experience' everyone's put up with for years.
2. A Next-Gen Feel And Experience
The rather nebulous-sounding 'next gen experience' is something players have been trying to seek out all year-long, as it certainly didn't appear in things like the slightly shinier-looking Assassin's Creed: Black Flag or the by-the-numbers Knack. Ryse definitely had some kick, but like 300 there wasn't a lot going on behind all the eyeball-tickling abs on display. COD doesn't up the ante too much in terms of innovative gameplay, it simply takes what Titanfall was trying to do and role-reverses it. Whilst the latter elected to champion slower, mech-based combat only to find out players like to sprint around unencumbered, COD's core gameplay makes your base soldier a three quarter-human, one-part hybrid, also capable of occasionally diving into a mech suit for some additional firepower. It's in the graphics where you'll really be blown away though, Battlefield 4 had a similar visionary gut-punch last year, but that game was dragged down by a series of bugs that ended up taking it off at the knees, with EA providing a couple of bandages to wounds that really needed some care and attention over time. Advanced Warfare's cutscenes are uncannily realistic - just look at Kevin Spacey above - and in-game the amount of particle effects, realistic physics, detailed environments, explosions and overall realisation that everything is revolving around you (at 60 frames per second no less) is something the previous consoles couldn't do to anywhere near this level.
1. A Full Product
Destiny is a 'full retail product' by definition and nothing else. It was sold at full price and consumed en masse, to the tune of tens of thousands of copies. But as has been long-discussed on forums, reviews and between players since that first launch day, is whether it's actually worth the money. There's no discernible story - its original intent for a campaign was gutted out for the sake of expansions (the first of which is out now) and so with millions of fans of Halo's multiplayer component seemingly outweighing those that only play for the campaign, Destiny has managed to slide through relatively unscathed due to a supremely tight online mode. Overall the game is bare-bones, you've got a string of missions with some terribly-voiced dialogue along with some semblance of a narrative in regards to mentioning characters and doing nothing with them, and you have the online deathmatch variants with a sprinkle of exploration in some side-quests - that's it. COD features a very memorable and enjoyable campaign with a variety of mission types and goals, an incredibly robust multiplayer, a dedicated cooperative mode that can be played locally and a general feeling that you've put money down on a full game - not just an empty husk waiting to be filled over a much-discussed 'ten year plan'. Which other aspects of gameplay or presentation does COD do better than Destiny? Let us know in the comments!