10 Things Fallout 5 Should Learn From 1 & 2

Never before has a return to the roots been more called for.

By Alex Bondarenko /

The Fallout franchise is up there with the best RPG titles of all time. Developed by Interplay and its division Black Isle, the first two games were an immense breakthrough in the late 90s, injecting some adult storytelling into a genre dominated by swords and sorcery. Two games in the franchise were, in fact, officially recognised as works of art: the Smithsonian American Art Museum featured it as part its Art of Video Games exhibition in 2012.

Advertisement

Sadly, Bethesda’s later instalments have abandoned much of the game’s classic legacy, and it’s about time that legacy was revived. And while the move away from third-person isometric was inevitable, such change swept away a lot of elements fans came to love about the earlier games.

A lucrative franchise like Fallout is unlikely to get abandoned – which means the devs still have plenty of opportunity to appease nostalgic fans – and show the newer ones what a true old-school RPG is like.

From writing to mechanics to locations to pacing, there are quite a few things Fallout 5 could learn from its once-acclaimed ancestors.

10. Motivation: You're Doing It Wrong

Fallout 4 saddles you with a main quest to find the protagonist's child, but forgets to do absolutely anything to build an emotional connection to him. Family is personal stuff, and if you’re going to bank on it to propel a hero to action, make sure the hero (and more importantly, the person behind the controls) has at least a modicum of feeling toward said family.

Advertisement

Fallout 4 neglects this, instead trying to shove far-fetched motivation down the player’s throat. At this point any angst the Sole Survivor might display about their lost son looks implausible at best, and downright insulting at worst.

Look at Fallout 1 for contrast. The Vault Dweller is volunteered for the main quest, whether they want it or not, just because they drew the short straw. The game openly does a dick move on you – and doesn’t force you to play along.

Instead, it gives you a couple of opportunities to say ‘screw you’, resulting in gory - but extremely satisfying - alternative endings.

9. Lay Off The Romance (Or Do It Right!)

Romance options in Fallout 4 look tacked on just to tick a box. There are many, but each is advanced by linear, boring dialogue. Granted, they don’t detract from the experience, but neither do they add much.

Advertisement

The first Fallout games had no time for such nonsense. Romance just wasn’t a thing in RPGs of the day. Sure, you could have sex here and there, and even get forced into a shotgun wedding in Fallout 2, but that’s it. And somehow that sounds about right. You’re trying to survive in a post-nuclear wasteland, and it’s okay if you’re not in the mood for sappy chats and candle-lit dinners.

If romance is to happen in Fallout 5, it has to be put in context. Generic dialogue about feelings that blissfully ignores the apocalyptic backdrop is more than simply ridiculous. It is a missed opportunity for character development.

Either do it right, or ditch it.

8. Rewind The Clock

The farther in time the Fallout franchise moves from the nuclear war that started it all, the less believable the desolate state of the world becomes. By the start of Fallout 4, 210 years have passed since the Great War. That’s easily ten generations, considering the shortened lifespan of survivors.

Advertisement

The world has already had plenty of time to rebuild. Sure, the nukes threw development back, but it’s not like everything was bombed into the Stone Age. The wasteland is littered with hi-tech stuff, and with just a little effort on part of the survivors, infrastructure could be up and running, communities could be connected and industry could be on the fast track to recovery.

A blasted, empty wasteland just won't look as real in 2300 as it did in 2161.

Instead, it could go back to the days of Fallout 1, less than a century after the Great War. Back then, groups of survivors were just banding together to eke out an existence in the harsh new environment, little was known about what’s beyond the radioactive haze that had settled upon the world, and ruins of big cities stood undisturbed – and unlooted.

7. Keep The Future Retro

One distinctive feature of the Fallout universe is its retrofuturism. It’s set in the future, but it's a future imagined by people of the past. In this case, 1950s Americans.

Advertisement

On the surface, Fallout 4 captures that pretty well. It bombards you with the relevant aesthetics and even has you play a nice intro sequence to get you in the mood. And then come human-faced cyborgs and teleportation. It’s understandable that some steps have to be taken away from the pure canon of the genre, to avoid slipping into the realm of ridiculous if nothing else. But some of those steps have been taken a bit too far.

Here's a lesson in retrofuturism from Fallout 2. That game gave the player the option to rebuild, upgrade and drive a nuclear-powered muscle car. Styled with signature 1950s tailfins and fuelled by micro fusion cells, it captured both the look and the technological vision of the setting.

Seeing something like that in Fallout 5 would be a huge boost to the game’s retro feel and have the side bonus of appeasing the fans that have been pining for a driving mechanic. Let’s just hope it comes out better than the first-person shooting did in Fallout 3.

6. Focus On What Changed, Not What Stayed

As much fun as it is to see your every favourite gin joint survive a nuclear war and become a deathclaw den (spot 10 differences), there has to be a limit for it to have an impact.

Advertisement

Fallout 4’s global map is littered with real-world landmarks. While entertaining at first, it gets bland pretty fast, and serves little purpose but to entertain the eye. We’re in the future, can we please see new things?

Fallout 2 had two notable locations that survived the war: Reno and San Francisco, each serving a narrative purpose.

The former is an example of how ironically little the Great War has changed for some: they are still territorial, violent and driven by base instincts even as bright casino lights flash overhead. The latter is a late-game revelation that some communities have been industrious enough to flourish and a glimpse of what a rebuilt world could be like.

By contrast, quite a few settlements were formed after the war, like Arroyo or Modoc, and have their distinct stories and personalities. In some, traces of pre-war locations can be found underneath, but their subtlety makes them all the more worthy as a nod to reality.

5. More RPG, Less Builder Simulator

For someone supposed to be on a frantic search for their kidnapped child, the Sole Survivor surely spends a lot of time trying to build the tallest tower of aluminum cans and cereal cartons in all of Massachusetts.

Advertisement

Yes, we’ve survived the nuclear holocaust and it’s probably time to rebuild, but this is borderline stupid. Instead of advancing the plot, exploring irradiated ruins or interacting with interesting NPCs, the Sole Survivor sinks days upon days into junk runs, scouring and re-scouring every map marker for the last roll of duct tape and broken typewriter. All that, to accommodate a bunch of witless survivors who can’t find a place to sleep unless you lead them to it.

As much as a penis-shaped megastructure built of junk improves the post-nuclear Boston skyline, this is not world-building. It’s padding, designed to soak many more hours of playtime than it’s worth.

Back in the day, world-building was done through meaningful player actions. You made truces between raiders and townsfolk, busted corrupt officials and secured food shipments for struggling settlements. That, plus the latest-gen graphics technologies, would make for unprecedented immersion potential.

4. Don't Dumb It Down

Seriously, Bethesda, we can handle full sentences.

Advertisement

What irked fans the most about Fallout 4 is its oversimplified dialogue system. Every conversation has a maximum of four possible answers, one of which is taken up by ‘ok, bye’ most of the time. Each of the options is then further boiled down to a couple of keywords for easy consumption.

Compared to the verbose and clever writing and multi-branch dialogues of the first two games, this is a downright insult of the players’ intellect.

This doesn’t just go for dialogue and writing as a whole. By Fallout 4, the entire RPG model was downsized to a few dozen perks. What used to be separate skills, traits and perks, is now a colourful chart to be ticked off at every level.

Setting the bar that low looks little short of an affront to the complex and deep Fallout universe. Bringing back some of that depth would revive many fans' faith in the franchise.

3. SPECIAL Should Feel Special

In Fallout 1 and 2, every point you shifted in your character’s SPECIAL attributes had weight. Every one had a real impact on your abilities. In many cases, there were breaking points where a high – or low! – attribute opened up or cut off different paths to complete a quest.

Advertisement

SPECIAL was next to impossible to increase, especially in the first game, and that made it all the more special. Your initial decisions mattered, and every character was created unique.

In Fallout 4 your initial SPECIAL distribution means so little that you soon forget you even have those stats. On top of that, with the removal of proper perks and skills, there’s very little reason not to pump all your initial points into Agility and Perception for perfect VATS speed and accuracy.

After all, there’s no level cap, and nothing is stopping you from maxing out every attribute. Everyone ends up equally special, which means no one really is.

2. Make Power Armor Mean Something

Nothing is as iconic of the Fallout franchise as the power armor. Just look at the cover of every game in the series, except the estranged half-brother that is Brotherhood of Steel, and there it is, glaring ominously with the helmet’s eye-slits.

Advertisement

Finding power armor in Fallout 1 and 2 meant a big deal. It was a signal that you’re entering the endgame. You’re up there with the dangerous people now. You’re the powerhouse. You’re no longer afraid of deathclaws.

Fallout 4 hands you a power armor and pits you against a deathclaw not an hour into the game. You don’t even have to look for it, the game insistently leads you to it. A few hours in, you’re the Tony Stark of your own stable of a dozen power armors. You can even paint them like your favourite Iron Man suits. Sure, they also need to be powered, but cells aren't exactly hard to come by.

Throwing franchise icons at the player like that is just plain cheap. It aims for a quick nostalgia kick, which soon wears off and leaves you with a sour aftertaste, sitting on a pile of worthless power armors that you don’t feel like you’ve earned.

1. Go Hardcore

For a game about post-nuclear survivors, surviving in Fallout 3 and 4 is remarkably easy. You can sleep off or stim up broken limbs, haul around immense piles of ammo, and all of your companions are essentially immortal.

Advertisement

Sure, there is New Vegas’ hardcore mode and the survival mode added in a later update for Fallout 4. Both rectify some of the issues, adding weight to ammunition and requiring slightly more effort to cure broken limbs. They also make you require food, water and sleep to survive. This seems like a reasonable thing to do in a post-apocalyptic scenario, but instead of making things more interesting, it makes them a chore.

And then there are the immortal companions. What’s the purpose in caring for someone, protecting them and sharing your last stimpack with them, if once smoke clears, they just brush off the dust and stand back up, good as new.

Now, Fallout 1 and 2 were never up there with the most difficult of games. But they still made you think twice before abandoning a companion in the line of fire, because magical resurrection just isn’t a thing in the wasteland. If they die, they die. And unless you know how to set a broken leg straight, you have to hobble to the nearest physician, because a quick stim shot won’t knit broken bones back together.

Fallout 5 could use at least a bit of that gravity, just as a reminder that the wasteland isn’t fooling around with us.

Advertisement