10 Times Video Games Lied To Your Face
No. They won't remember that.
Video games lie. Unless you're younger than five, this fact shouldn't be all too mind-blowing to you.
Since every game at its core consists of ones and zeros and if-else statements, they wouldn't be able to immerse you in their world without disguising at least some parts of their programmed nature.
However, while no reasonable person has a problem with this kind of concealment, some games take their sweet little lies even further - by fooling you into believing they possess a feature that simply isn't there.
Some games lie by giving you an illusion of choice, some lie about having multiple endings, and some lie to fool you into thinking your actions have consequences.
But no matter what the case may be, one thing is always true: the most dishonest titles do it right in your face. You just don't notice it because they know how to disguise their lies with a clever illusion of the feature they promised you.
Watch out for the deceptions in the following games. You don't want to fall for their sneaky schemes.
10. No One Actually Dies - Little Hope
Little Hope is considered to be the worst title in Supermassive Games' Dark Pictures Anthology series. The reason for this is the game's ending, which reveals, spolier alert, that none of the choices you've made throughout the story mattered.
The big "spooky" twist of Little Hope is that all but one character were just figments of the imagination of the protagonist, Andrew, and your hard fight for their survival was happening entirely in his head as a means of processing the guilt of killing the other characters in a car crash.
So what's the point of keeping them alive? You might be thinking that maybe the more of Andrew's imaginary friends you save, the better he copes with his past, but no. There are only two endings in the game, and they are determined by whether or not you were nice to the only other real character in the story, a random stranger named Vince.
How you treat Vince determines whether he calls the cops on you or not at the end of the story. All that struggle with survival and fending off demons? Completely irrelevant.
When only a few minutes of your five-hour game matter, the rug-pull probably wasn't going to be worth it.
9. But Thou Must! - Dragon Quest
Dragon Quest is a series of JRPG games that are especially popular in Japan. The franchise has a long history that precedes even some of the most popular JRPG titles out there and has established a lot of the genre’s tropes.
Including the most annoying one of them all - fake choices.
It all started with the first Dragon Quest game, in which a princess asks the player if they love her, and if they answer no, she tells them "but thou must" and asks them the question again.
This little gag became the foundation for Dragon Quest’s tradition of fake choices. Ever since, each Dragon Quest title has included at least one “yes and no” question that, no matter how you answer, the game will force you to give it the answer it wants anyway.
This charade has gone on for so long that, even though this cliché can get pretty annoying in other franchises, most Dragon Quest players have grown to enjoy its appearance in the series.
It’s a tradition. A tradition of lies and deceit, but a tradition nonetheless.
8. Siding With La Croix - Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines
Due to its rushed development, Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines is missing a lot of its planned features, one of which is the game’s endings.
Although there is technically at least one ending for each faction, in reality, only half of them can be counted as actual endings. The other half just lie to you about providing an alternative narrative, as is the case with the most infamous of Vampire’s epilogues, siding with La Croix.
La Croix, the Prince of Camarilla, who spends the entire game ordering you around, can be made into a potential ally, despite his betrayal of your character.
When you come to his tower to end his un-life, you may choose the option to join forces with him, thinking your alliance will make Camarilla stronger.
However, this simply doesn’t happen. Not because La Croix betrays you or you betray him, but because halfway through the ending cutscene, the two of you explode.
Yes, the game simply kills off your character as soon as you make the choice to spare La Croix, because you’re not actually supposed to side with him.
That, and the developers probably didn’t have enough time to give him a proper ending.
7. Leave Batman To Die - Batman Arkham City
The story of the Batman: Arkham games is pretty linear, so you don’t really expect to be able to make any plot-defining choices throughout any of your playthroughs.
However, when Batman: Arkham City throws you a bone in its Catwoman-focused DLC - which seamlessly integrates into the events of the main story - it could at least follow up on this premise instead of fooling you into thinking you might finally have some say in the outcome.
In the DLC, when Catwoman manages to empty the vault she’s been trying to raid since she wound up in Arkham City, she’s confronted with a decision. She can either leave the super prison with the loot or go back to save the captured Batman from certain death.
Except there is no real choice. The moment you leave with the money, the credits roll, and the game immediately rewinds you back to the crossroads so that you can save Batman.
It’s understandable that developer Rocksteady wanted you to save the person who makes the entire narrative of Arkham City possible, but if they’re already adding a choice, they could elaborate on the consequences of your actions a little, or at the very least add a short cutscene showing the aftermath.
Otherwise, the choice isn’t really a choice, is it?
6. Sacrifce Yourself - Saints Row IV
There are two things that can be said about Saints Row IV: one, it doesn’t take itself too seriously; two, it doesn’t take other games too seriously either.
Saints Row IV is filled with little gags and references to other gaming franchises, like romance options parodying the relationship system in Mass Effect and a mission making fun of Call of Duty.
Naturally, the list of jokes made at the expense of the gaming industry also includes a jab at the trope of fake choices. It happens during the mission where the player attempts to storm Zinyak’s mothership in order to rescue the hacker, Matt Miller.
As you navigate through the ship, you will eventually come across a room where Zinyak gives you a choice. You can continue to fight and save Matt, or, if you trust Zinyak’s word, you can give up, and in exchange, Zinyak will spare humanity from his conquest.
Of course, Zinyak isn’t to be trusted, and the moment you step through the “give up” door, your character is disintegrated. You get a game over, and you’re immediately brought back to your last checkpoint.
Well, the choice was clearly a joke. And if you fell for it, the joke’s on you!
5. Yes And No - Pokémon
Just like the previously mentioned Dragon Quest, Pokémon is notorious for including nonsensical moments of choice throughout the games that don’t actually change anything at all. Other trainers will ask you if you want to fight or if you’re ready to start your adventure, and if you answer how the game doesn’t want you to, it will force you to make the right choice anyway.
It’s mostly done as a joke, but sometimes the fakeness of your choices can actually prove to be detrimental to your experience, like in the case of this one deceptively serious decision in Pokémon X and Y, in which you can choose between a gold nugget and a Master Ball as your reward, only to be given both of them anyway.
Come on, Pokémon! Some stakes and consequences every now and then couldn’t hurt anybody. If someone wants to miss out on their only chance at getting a Master Ball, let them do it!
Otherwise, what's the point of asking the question?
4. Siding With Gortash - Baldur's Gate 3
Baldur’s Gate 3 owes a huge part of its popularity to the amount of thought put into the player’s potential actions.
Even the most outrageous solution to a problem is likely to be acknowledged by the game in some way, which is why it’s pretty disappointing that there is one rather major decision Baldur’s Gate 3 won’t let you make in its final act, even though the game lies to you about the option being on the table.
Spoiler alert: in Act 3, one of the primary antagonists, the tyrannical Lord Gortash, offers your character to team up and rule the world together. If you play as the Dark Urge, Gortash even reveals himself to be your friend from before you lost your memory and says that you were meant to team up from the get-go.
Because Gortash seems to be genuinely interested in a partnership, you might be tempted to accept his offer and see where it may go, especially on your evil playthrough.
However, the choices make no impact on the story whatsoever, as immediately after you join forces, the Chosen of Bane is killed in a freak accident, trying to reach the Netherbrain.
Well, so much for being evil buddies.
3. Three Endings - Mass Effect 3
Mass Effect 3’s original ending is considered to be one of the worst endings in the history of video games ever. It’s easy to see why, as it essentially rendered every choice you made as Shepard completely meaningless, on top of providing you with an unimaginative illusion of choice.
The Extended Cut and Legendary Edition fixed the ending a little bit, but those who witnessed the original know exactly how disappointing it was to find out all your hard work culminated in a random ghost child handing you the solution to your problems on a silver platter, as though you never had to make all those sacrifices at all.
No matter what you did throughout the game, in the finale you always got to choose between three color-coded endings, in which you activated the Crucible and: destroyed the Reapers, controlled the Reapers, or assimilated the Reapers.
Now, the endings sound somewhat distinct, but the cutscenes that played after you made your choice were nearly identical, with the exception of only one short scene. But the worst part was still that the endings had nothing to do with how you played Mass Effect prior to that decision.
The stakes have never been lower.
2. No One Will Actually Remember That - The Walking Dead
The Walking Dead games, as well as the rest of Telltale's releases, managed to become so successful in no small part thanks to the choices you made throughout your playthrough.
The gravity of the supposed consequences of your decisions, coupled with the ominous reminders telling you that someone "will remember that," constantly puts you on edge, making you believe that you're about to make a choice that will alter the lives of your characters forever.
But nothing could be further from the truth. No one will actually remember that.
The reality of Telltale games is that they're actually incredibly linear, and the choices you make never affect any major points of the plot. Characters you might be trying to save the entire game will die anyway if the plot demands it. Your attempt to influence them to act a certain way will magically disappear the moment they need to shoot someone in the head to add some end-of-season cliffhanger to the mix.
Of course, this doesn't mean the game's story cannot be gripping and exciting at times, but once you realize how pointless your decisions are, trying to do your best in the game loses all charm.
1. Fake Stakes - Detroit: Become Human
Detroit: Become Human, like other David Cage projects, has been criticized for having a rather generic storyline, but it's still a wholly entertaining narrative experience. Your choices in the game feel impactful, and the quick-time events during action sequences create a sense of suspense.
Until you learn that they are, in fact, almost entirely pointless.
As it turns out, the apparent life-or-death stakes in even the most intense moments in Detroit: Become Human are just an illusion. The main cast of characters cannot die until the third act of the game, meaning that no matter how badly you mess up the quick-time events, there is no real consequence for it.
Connor, who can fall off a building, get shot, and run over by cars, comes back alive all the time thanks to CyberLife providing him with a new body. Markus and Kara, who don't enjoy the same privileges, simply avoid the consequences of their failure with convenient plot armor.
All in all, the only punishment you get for not trying to keep your characters alive in the first half of the game is the hilarity of watching them fail miserably at the most basic physical tasks.
Which is honestly more of a reward when you think about it.