10 Times Video Games Made You Feel

When video games go beyond action, into something that touches the soul.

By Ben Counter /

Can video games be art? The debate isn't going to die out any time soon, but one strong argument is that if movies, books, plays or other forms of storytelling can be art, then video games can too. While it is similarly impossible to define what 'art' is, one helpful angle is to look at a given work's ability to produce emotions in an audience. And sometimes, video games can do exactly that.

Advertisement

Whether it's grief at a tragic event, wonderment at a game's environment, fondness for its characters or just the savage joy of exterminating your enemies, plenty of computer games have succeeded in creating an emotional reaction in their players. Creating an emotional response isn't just a function of programming, but of visual design, writing, voice acting, and a dozen other disciplines working in harmony.

Plenty of games are just excuses to throw polygons around and compare DPS like it's a mating ritual, but as the medium matures, a wider audience is demanding more from their games.

That includes strong emotional engagement, as shown by the following games and the moments where they dared to make us feel.

10. The Last Of Us' Ending Confounds Us With Moral Ambiguity

The scene where hero Joel loses his daughter at the start of the game could easily take its place here as a particularly harrowing moment. But for emotional complexity and sheer developer bravery, it’s his actions at the end of the game that make our list.

Advertisement

The character development of The Last Of Us sees resentful curmudgeon Joel come to not only tolerate Ellie, the subject of his game-long escort quest, but to love her. By the game’s final sequences, he will do anything to protect his surrogate daughter from the cruelty of the game’s post-fungus zombie world.

When he learns the fungal plague can only be cured by killing and dissecting young Ellie, he flies off the handle, kills everyone and spirits his charge out of the rebel-held hospital.

Then, he lies to her about whether she could have saved the human race in death. And so Joel deceives his only friend and compels the whole world to further decades of misery, purely because he learned to love. The cocktail of emotions sparked in the player is enough to place The Last Of Us at the pinnacle of emotionally memorable games.

Even as we sympathise with Joel, we cannot forgive him, and yet how many of us would have done any different?

9. Flying In World Of Warcraft Teaches Us To Wonder

The scale of World of Warcraft at its height is difficult to overstate. It was the biggest game in the world, and a big reason was the way it ensnared its players with the sheer majesty of its world.

Advertisement

Its purest expression was perhaps the player’s first introduction to the game’s fast travel system, the flight paths between its various locations.

The wonder of flying was impressive in itself, as the expansive worlds of WoW rolled out before us in a way rare for games at the time. But the moment was truly created by choosing to make that first flight into one of the game world’s capital cities.

The spectacle of the huge, beautiful, complex cities, from the lava-lit underground halls of Ironforge to the leafy temples of Darnassus, showed off WoW’s ambition and scale in a way other MMOs could not compete with. Players felt wonder as they soared over the rooftops of Stormwind or Orgrimmar, and plenty of them stayed for a long, long time.

8. Bioshock Makes Us Feel Sympathy For The Devil

The big twist in Bioshock is that we are being manipulated by the game’s true villain into killing its apparent one.

Advertisement

Andrew Ryan, the founder of the right-wing disaster that is the city of Rapture, is set up as a dictatorial monster responsible for untold horrors in his underwater domain. When we finally encounter him he is fully aware that we are being controlled by a posthypnotic suggestion, and yet he does not run.

Ryan is a man driven by principle. Even though we cannot agree with him, we cannot deny his devotion to an ideal, a philosophy of how life should be lived. It leads to the disastrous downfall of Rapture and many lives ended or destroyed by madness, but it also leads to Ryan refusing to run when he realises he is facing his death at our hands. As we close on him with his own golf club, he tells us we are a free man, capable of making our own decisions. Though, as this leads to shattering his skull with our first blow, he sticks to his guns, telling us that "a man chooses, but a slave obeys."

He tries to stay our hand not by begging or threatening, but by appealing to our nature as a human being.

And as we proceed to beat him to death, it is impossible not to feel an uncomfortable note of admiration for this man, this monster, in a rare moment of video game regret.

7. Gabriel Knight: Sins Of The Fathers Makes Us Love Our Grandma

In the canon of 1990s of PC point-and-click adventures, Gabriel Knight stands out for the maturity and depth of its plotline, characters and dialogue. Plenty of the game sees us delve into a gooey series of voodoo-related murders in a wonderfully realised New Orleans, but perhaps the moment that stays with us the longest is when hero Gabriel has a chat with his grandma.

Advertisement

Gabriel’s shadowy past is part of the driving force behind the game’s plot, so a natter with gran is needed to solve the games central mysteries. But wonderfully, the game also gives us the chance to chat about our family, our childhood, and even to complement granny just for the sake of being kind. Gabriel clearly genuinely loves his grandmother, and we do too.

6. Dishonoured Gives Us A Father Figure

Fatherhood is a major theme of Dishonoured, as much of it is spent trying to rescue and then defend the young Imperial princess Emily who has lost her own parents. And yet main character Corvo has his own father figure in the unexpectedly paternal presence of the boatman who takes him between the game’s hub and its various mission locations.

Advertisement

Samuel the boatman is a grizzled, grumpy sea dog with the hint of a man who has seen everything, and forms a comforting bookend to the game’s mission structure from the moment he arrives at the first prison-set level to spirit Corvo to safety.

And yet Samuel is more than just a narrative device. When Corvo’s allies turn on him to facilitate their coup on the Imperial throne, it is Samuel who stays loyal to Corvo and Emily, saving his life and helping him continue on his quest to restore Emily to the throne. Samuel even provides one of the game’s few moments of levity, in his exasperation at Emily’s recounting of the naughtiness she witnessed while being held in the attic of a brothel.

Our genuine fondness for Samuel, and our gratitude at his presence even when the game is tearing everything away from us, proves that emotional gaming moments don't have to involve misery and horror.

5. Resident Evil 4 Forces Us To Empathise With Everyone We’ve Killed

Whether Resident Evil 4 marks a high point of the series or the beginning of its wayward journey into action game territory, its setting certainly sticks in the mind. Set in a decaying corner of Europe, its world is packed with bedraggled, parasite-infected locals who start out murderously unfriendly and only get worse.

Advertisement

While Resi 4 does plenty to keep us scared, its most truly emotional moment is hidden in the post-game credits. They show a series of illustrations about the history of the village our hero, series veteran Leon S. Kennedy, has just depopulated.

We see the villagers’ simple, rustic lives as they work the fields and tend their homes, lives based around community and family. We see them smiling, loving, living, as they have done for generations.

But then they are stricken by a plague which we know from the game’s events is caused by the prehistoric Las Plagas parasite. Their world falls apart as violence and horror enter their bucolic lives.

Finally, they witness the hideous deformities of the parasite’s later stages. And we are filled with horror, not because of the gruesomeness of the final scenes, but because these are the people we have just killed.

They had their story, too, and we were the final tragic act.

4. The Walking Dead Manipulates Us Into Shattering The Innocence Of A Child

Few game series rely as heavily on creating player emotion as Tellgames Games’ choice ‘em ‘up based on the comics and tv series of The Walking Dead. The first season is particularly harrowing as we didn't expect it to confront us so directly with the consequences of our actions, and at one point in the second episode it takes advantage of our gamerly aggression to make us the bad guy.

Advertisement

Lee, the game’s hero. is looking after the adorable Clementine, both keeping her alive after the zombie apocalypse and trying to prevent the horrors of this world from brutalising the young girl. Lee’s group of survivors fall prey to a group of cannibals who, after offering them much-needed shelter at their farm, plot to kill and eat them. Lee discovers this and confronts one of the evildoers in the barn.

The player is faced with a choice of whether to let the cannibal live, or impale him with a pitchfork. Of course we killed him, we’re gamers and we have the power to kill bad people. Of course we’re going to give this multiple murderer the nasty, brutal death he deserves.

So we did.

Only Clementine saw us do it. She witnessed the man she’s grown to trust inflict an act of retributive violence on another human being. Our instant regret at what we had done, the quenching of our desire for justice by the shattered innocence of a child, is the cruellest and most brilliant trick The Walking Dead has pulled off to date.

3. Call Of Duty: Black Ops Brutalises Us With Its Prison Level

Call of Duty: Black Ops brought the series a maturity and depth of storyline it has lacked before or since. Particularly memorable is its sequence set in the Soviet gulag of Vorkuta, where hero Alex Mason takes part in a mass breakout orchestrated by mad Russian inmate Victor Reznov.

Advertisement

Vorkuta is a cruel and savage place, and it only gets worse when the breakout begins. Reznov's manic exhortations drive dozens of prisoners into the guards' machine guns, and the prisoners are no less brutal with their butchering of the soldiers who try to contain the breakout. A gigantic prisoner named Sergei Kosin hurls guards around as others club them to death on the ground.

The intensity and fury of the breakout reaches it climax as Mason gatling guns his way through the prison gates. The scale of the death, and the implication of how valueless life is in the gulags, is exhausting and affecting.

By the end of the level, the player is exhausted by what they have witnessed.

2. Final Fantasy VII Taught Us Grief

This entry will come as no surprise to fans of the Final Fantasy series. The way it robbed us of a main character, not just someone we had become accustomed to but an emotional heart of the plot, was a real kick in the teeth and one of the elements that makes Final Fantasy VII so well-loved.

Advertisement

For those who haven't experienced this virtual bereavement, one of the big plot beats of Final Fantasy VII comes when hero Cloud Strife and his friends are seeking the game's vulnerable magic user (and de facto party healer) Aerith. Just when they find her, the game's villain Sephiroth appears and stabs Aerith with a sword-thrust through the heart.

And she's dead.

Not down to zero hit points, not the subject of a quest to bring her back to life. She's dead, forever. In the context of a colourful JRPG, it's a shocking turn of events that created an echo of Cloud's grief in the player.

1. Dragon Age: Inquisition Showed Us We Can't Have What We Want

Dragon Age: Inquisition still holds its own as a fantastically sprawling, open world fantasy RPG with tons to do. Its characters and their relationships are a major part of what makes it so good, among them the mysterious elven sorcerer Solas.

Advertisement

As is traditional among BioWare RPGs, the player character can romance many of the game's characters, including Solas, whose mystery and vulnerability proved irresistible to plenty of players.

Similar to other characters in the game, romancing Solas means frequent conversations, character-specific missions and carefully made choices to ascend through the levels of affection. Finally, the player triggers that magic sequence where the player and Solas declare their love for each other. Surely Solas and the player character will next be seen in a tastefully raunchy cutscene where they consummate their game-long affection?

But they do not. Solas explains their love cannot be. All the player's investment and effort in romancing this pointy-eared dreamboat is met with a final, crushing rejection.

The player character can rail against Solas, they can beg, but Solas remains adamant. It just can't happen. The emotion sparked by such rejection is genuine, and it makes the game's final revelations all the more poignant when we learn who Solas truly is.

Advertisement