10 Times Video Games RECAST Major Roles

Video game changes that divided the fans.

By Rob Cain /

Voice acting; it's a commonly accepted practice in the modern gaming industry. The prevalence of actors and actresses in the digital scene is now higher today than it's ever been. So much so that it's practically a requirement to telling a top-tier story.

Advertisement

Since the onset of 3D gaming in the nineties, storytelling in games has only grown more complex and multi-layered. Once you only needed a few exclamations to fill in a portly plumber making his jump into the third dimension. As time went on, titles like Grand Theft Auto, Metal Gear Solid and Half-Life led the way for character development.

Nowadays, video game voice acting is more prevalent than ever.

As games look to get closer to movies, many more creative decisions are made when it comes to portraying the different characters. This can often involve changing actors in-between games, sometimes to the detriment of the previous performances.

From past and present, these are some of the major swaps that took place in the industry. Some took their characters to new places, while others stood out as slightly inferior. Let's dig in...

10. James Arnold Taylor - Ratchet & Clank

By far the most well known franchise from Insomniac Games, Ratchet and Clank have been tearing up the galaxy for nearly twenty years now. They've crossed three console generations and the series is set to continue with the upcoming Rift Apart for PlayStation 5.

Advertisement

The original game in 2002 gave the duo a humble beginning, pairing up the furry Lombax with a rogue robot as they took on the diabolical Chairman Drek. Being the first release, much of the game's story involved around the developing partnership between the characters with a slice of consumerist satire thrown in.

The opposite personalities were always on display; Ratchet, voiced by Mikey Kelley, was headstrong and stubborn, while David Kaye's Clank was more logical and considered.

After butting heads several times throughout the game, they learn to work together and become friends, resulting in a solid debut for the both of them.

Just one year later Ratchet's rebellious persona was changed to James Arnold Taylor, who continues to voice Insomniac's mascot to this day. Taylor's performance is much more subdued, opting for a more by-the-book personality that relied on the developer's writing. Nowadays, some fans bemoan the franchise's shift into more kid-friendly territory.

9. Roger Craig Smith - Sonic The Hedgehog

Now reaching close to thirty years in gaming, the widely recognised Sonic The Hedgehog has gone through many iterations through the years. From the classic 2D titles to modern 3D entries, there's been a constant evolutionary process. So too has the voice of Sonic changed several times across the decades.

Advertisement

Typically, voice actors for Sonic The Hedgehog carry over into other media, lending their performance to cartoon shows as well as video games. At first the character was voiced by Jaleel White for "Adventures of Sonic The Hedgehog" in the nineties.

Many gamers however are most familiar with Jason Griffith who took the reins throughout the 2000s, beginning with Sonic X. He would portray the Hedgehog sixteen times in the video game scene from Sonic Rush on the DS all the way through to Sonic and SEGA All Stars Racing. For the most part, he embodied the character's cocky attitude and always delivered a strong performance.

Jason Griffith had played the blue bur longer than any other actor, until the Hedgehog's voice was changed for Roger Craig Smith from 2010 onwards. Surprisingly, Smith wasn't brought on for the recent Sonic The Hedgehog movie as that task fell to actor Ben Schwartz.

8. Christopher Judge - God Of War

Another major PlayStation franchise to make the list, God of War's gory action and immense scale have always made a staggering impact. A lot of that comes to the sheer power of its leading man, Kratos.

Advertisement

Across three whole games and a couple of PSP spin-offs, Kratos was portrayed as one of the most bloodthirsty protagonists in the video game medium. His lust for revenge caused the deaths of countless Gods, mere mortals and eventually the entirety of Ancient Greece. Through it all, Terrence Carson delivered the character's rasping cries with immense impact.

After a full trilogy of voicing Kratos, Terrence Carson was replaced by Christopher Judge in order to provide an older, more grizzled version of Kratos. With the franchise making its debut on PS4, Santa Monica Studio shifted gears to a more thoughtful and mature adventure. Christopher Judge was a perfect fit for this new style as the bond between Kratos and his son Atreus was placed at the centre of the experience.

Judge certainly got into the role both in and out of development, continuing to wow the masses with the famous line: "Read it, boy" at The Game Awards in 2018. He will reprise the role again in the upcoming God of War: Ragnarok.

7. D.C Douglas - Resident Evil

Since its debut, the Resident Evil franchise has led the way for survival horror. The main antagonist of the franchise was one who lurked behind the scenes. Albert Wesker, a former scientist of Umbrella, was one of the leading minds behind the catastrophes of the T-Virus.

Advertisement

While the series icon was originally voiced by Pablo Kuntz in the franchise's debut title and Richard Waugh in the 2000s, D.C Douglas took over and gave the character a British accent from Resident Evil 5 onwards. For anyone who played that title, the new actor stamped himself onto the series.

Clearly, Capcom wanted to craft a grand return for Wesker in the fifth entry and D.C Douglas certainly pulled it off, creating a performance that commanded every scene he appeared in. This went hand in hand with the new direction the antagonist went in. As opposed to manipulating events from behind the scenes, the more direct approach Albert shows became the driving force.

D.C Douglas has continued to voice Wesker since 2009 and while his role in the franchise has lessened over the last decade, the character still commands a weighty presence whenever he turns up. This also extends to Marvel Vs Capcom 3 and other spin-off titles.

6. Eric Johnson - Splinter Cell: Blacklist

Before it went into obscurity, the Splinter Cell franchise stood alongside the likes of Metal Gear Solid as a defining stealth experience. In-between hiding and taking out guards, players were treated to the gravelly voice of Michael Ironside, who played protagonist Sam Fisher with a sarcastic, remorseful tone. This persisted across every mainline title up to Splinter Cell: Conviction.

Advertisement

Michael Ironside's classic performance as Sam Fisher was traded out for a much younger sounding Eric Johnson in 2013's Splinter Cell: Blacklist. Ubisoft has said this was done for the purposes of motion capture; they needed an actor who would embody Sam Fisher's physical prowess as well as his voice.

While it didn't impact the gameplay experience, filling the boots of a very well-received performance was going to be a challenge for Johnson. As opposed to the gruff and introspective agent we had in the past, Eric's performance does feel more by the book.

It's now been more than seven years since the last Splinter Cell game, though Michael Ironside did return to the character for a brief yet poignant reflection on the AAA stealth genre. When Sam Fisher will come out of the shadows in anyone's guess, as is the case with the actor playing him.

5. Troy Baker - Batman: Arkham Origins

When Batman returned to the AAA gaming scene in 2009, it set the standard for every superhero title to follow. After two superb entries with Arkham Asylum and Arkham City, the franchise was given to WB Games Montreal for its third entry. The result was Batman: Arkham Origins, a prequel set in the early days of Batman's career.

Advertisement

Recasting the Joker was one of many major challenges WB Montreal tackled when attempting to live up to Rocksteady's efforts. While there was no official report on the reasoning behind the change, it was likely down to the game's setting.

The iconic performance from Mark Hamill was changed to Troy Baker to capture a younger sounding Joker for the prequel. There were certainly some massive expectations considering how brilliant Asylum and City were. Thanks to his strong experience in the voice acting scene, Baker was admirably close.

What Origins did do was create a palpable rivalry between the Caped Crusader and the Clown Prince of Crime; thanks to some strong writing and psychedelic sequences involving the villain, Troy Baker made the most of the material. While some players may have preferred a Batman game without the Joker for a change, Origins still made an impact.

4. Michael Keaton - Call Of Duty: Black Ops 2

If Modern Warfare 3 was the moment opinions started to move against the Call of Duty series, then Black Ops 2 was the moment Treyarch surpassed Infinity Ward as the most accomplished developer in the long running franchise. When the series was stagnating, Treyarch's title stood out as an outlier.

Advertisement

A lot of what made Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 work was its campaign which experimented with player choice and multiple endings for the first time. As a sequel, it featured many of the same characters, most notably Alex Mason, Frank Woods and Jason Hudson who all contend with the rise of a vicious Nicaraguan terrorist named Raul Menendez.

The CIA operative Hudson was played by Ed Harris in the original Black Ops, but was swapped out for an equally well known actor for the sequel. Michael Keaton didn't have the same gruff personality as his predecessor, but he still made sure the narrative's twists and turns landed with the right impact.

As Menendez's bloody campaign of revenge gets worse, Hudson is left on the receiving end of his brutality, ending the eighties portion of the campaign on a grisly note. Keaton really gives it his all here, delivering a solid performance that goes hand in hand with the game's darker tone.

3. Terrence Stamp - Halo 3

Bungie's Halo trilogy remains a powerhouse in the FPS scene; when the story wrapped up in 2007, gamers were treated to a powerful sense of finality. Even with all its strengths, not every piece of Halo 3's story was a flawless conclusion.

Advertisement

The primary antagonist for the most part in the Prophet of Truth, who leads what remains of the Covenant with his religious fanaticism. After stabbing the Prophet of Mercy in the back and claiming absolute power in Halo 2, Truth heads to Earth to commence his final destruction of the human race and eventually plans to fire the Halo rings.

For the final entry in Bungie's trilogy, Michael Wyncott was swapped out for Terrence Stamp. A great actor, but many fans agree his performance is inferior. In Halo 2, Michael Wyncott's portrayal was sophisticated and devious, creating a clever villain who would murder his opponents in their sleep rather than attacking them outright.

Stamp's performance loses much of that scheming nature, replacing it with a fairly generic set of ramblings about becoming a God. The way he interrupts a broadcast at a human base is the most glaring mistake Bungie made with the writing. Be that as it may, it didn't take away too much from Halo 3's greater strengths.

2. Ben Jordan - Spider-Man

The most recent change to make the list, Marvel's Spider-Man PS4 was an undeniably sublime effort from Insomniac Games. For their first licensed product, they knocked it out of the park with another excellent superhero experience.

Advertisement

In addition to its stellar gameplay and superb presentation of New York City, the game's story was surprisingly deep, putting itself alongside the webslinger's finest outings. The protagonist himself was played by Yuri Lowenthal, a veteran voice actor who had previously voiced the main character in Ubisoft's Prince of Persia trilogy.

Despite the rousing success, Insomniac saw fit to change Peter Parker's likeness to a younger looking actor. To the dismay of many fans, Insomniac has recently replaced Yuri Lowenthal's face with a younger looking Ben Jordan for facial capture. While Lowenthal provided the voice and motion capture for Spidey, his work was mapped onto John Bubinak's face in the final product for PlayStation 4.

The developer has stated that Jordan's face provides a better match for Yuri's performance and will serve the franchise going forward. This includes the remastered PS5 version of Spider-Man, Miles Morales and the upcoming follow-up. Fans have disagreed with this change, violently so, but Insomniac is firm on their direction going forward.

1. Kiefer Sutherland - Metal Gear Solid

As the franchise that led the way for the stealth action genre, Metal Gear was once an acclaimed and widely beloved series. Outside of its deep stealth template, the franchise also offered deep and complex stories that drove the cinematic revolution in gaming.

Advertisement

From Metal Gear Solid in 1998 all the way through to Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker in 2010, the iconic stealth operative Solid Snake, along with his father Big Boss, was voiced by David Hayter who crafted a highly recognisable persona for the character. After a full decade of performing the hero, any new voice actor was going to have a major challenge on their hands.

So it was that when Metal Gear Solid 5: The Phantom Pain entered development, Kojima wanted a different actor to embrace the game's darker tone. For the final outing of Big Boss, the studio went with Kiefer Sutherland, an actor best known as agent Jack Bauer in the series "24".

Sutherland would end up delivering a highly gravelly performance with fewer words to go around. The idea was to make Snake a man of fewer words with the player's actions in-game defining his character. What this ended up doing was stripping the once charismatic soldier of much of his inner traits. While the game's final twist does make up for this somewhat, there's no doubt that Kiefer's portrayal is a step down.

Do you have any other major voice actor changes in video games to share? Pop them in the comments down below.

Advertisement