10 Times Video Games STOLE From Fans
When games "borrowed" fan art and forgot to say thanks… or ask.
For years, game developers have leaned on fan communities for support - and occasionally, a little too heavily for inspiration. Whether it's passionate modders, pixel artists, or concept illustrators, fans often create work so good it blurs the line between tribute and professional polish. And sometimes, that line gets crossed altogether.
From placeholder art that was never meant to go live, to full-blown controversies where card games, FPS shooters, or RPGs accidentally (or not) reused fan-made assets, the gaming world has had more than its fair share of plagiarism accusations.
This isn’t just about lazy dev shortcuts or shady backroom deals - it’s about the murky space where fandom and content creation collide. Some companies apologised and corrected course. Others stayed suspiciously silent. A few... just kept the artwork up.
Here are 10 cases where video games got caught using placeholder assets, fan creations, or suspiciously “inspired” artwork - and in some cases, got away with it.
10. Marvel Snap – Pixel Variants That Look a Little Too Familiar
Marvel Snap quickly became a runaway hit in the mobile CCG space, combining Marvel's enormous character roster with snappy mechanics and stylish variant artwork. But in 2023, some of those variants - specifically the pixel art cards - drew unwanted attention.
Fans were quick to notice that certain pixel variants bore an uncanny resemblance to existing fan art. One of the most cited examples involved artist Jason Kiantoro, who created a stylised Black Panther illustration back in 2018. When Snap released a pixel M’Baku card years later, sharp-eyed fans noticed striking similarities in pose, proportions, and costume details.
Similarly, a pixel variant of Sentry was flagged for resembling artwork by popular illustrator InHyuk Lee, known for his Marvel-inspired fanwork.
Second Dinner, the developers of Snap, have not issued an official response, but did acknowledge the reports on Discord, saying the team was “looking into it.” Since then, no cards appear to have been pulled or altered.
Were the similarities coincidental, or a result of over-zealous outsourcing? Nobody's confirmed anything. But the incident raised questions about how variant art is sourced - and whether fans’ creations are being referenced just a little too closely.
9. XCOM 2 – From Borrowed Influence to Official Partnership
Not every time a developer "borrows" from fans ends in controversy - sometimes, it leads to collaboration. In the case of XCOM 2, it’s hard to ignore just how much of the sequel’s DNA was shaped by the original game's most famous mod: Long War.
This fan-made overhaul for XCOM: Enemy Unknown rebalanced combat, added new classes, weapon tiers, and completely reshaped how the campaign flowed. It was such a hit with players that by the time XCOM 2 was in development, the influence was unmistakable - longer missions, more granular soldier control, deeper strategy... it all echoed Long War’s design.
Rather than deny it, Firaxis did something refreshing: they admitted it, and they officially brought the modders into the fold. Long War Studios (now Pavonis Interactive) were hired to develop day-one mods for XCOM 2, including new classes, weapons, and enemy types - essentially letting them shape the launch experience alongside the devs.
It’s a rare case where a studio borrowed from the fans... then gave them a seat at the table.
8. Ōkami (Wii) – The IGN Watermark Incident
Capcom’s Ōkami is one of the most artistically beloved games of the PS2 era - a gorgeously animated, paintbrush-driven adventure that looked like a moving piece of Japanese calligraphy. So, naturally, when the time came to port it to the Nintendo Wii, you’d think Capcom would treat it with the reverence it deserved. Instead, they slapped an IGN watermark on the front cover.
Yes. Really.
In one of the most baffling oversights in box art history, Capcom USA seemingly sourced their promotional image for Ōkami’s Wii release from an IGN review… and forgot to remove the watermark, which means that every physical copy of the game shipped in North America proudly featured the IGN logo baked right into the artwork (including the strategy guide). For a game whose entire selling point was its stunning visuals, it was the packaging equivalent of using Comic Sans on a Rembrandt.
Even worse? Fans had noticed it almost immediately, posting scans and asking if their boxes were bootlegs. Capcom later issued an apology and offered replacement covers (without the watermark) to those who mailed in a request. But the damage had already been done. It became a meme-worthy moment in gaming history - not just for the blunder, but for how little quality control seemed to exist at a major publisher.
7. Destiny 2 – A Little Too Inspired by the Community
Destiny 2 is built on lore, spectacle, and surprisingly thoughtful cutscenes. But in 2023, players noticed one scene hit a little too close to home - for an entirely different reason.
An official lore cinematic featured background art that was nearly identical to a fan piece titled "The Veil of Darkness" by artist Julian Faylona. Bungie admitted the mishap, explaining it had come from an external vendor and that the company was unaware of its origin. They later credited and compensated Faylona.
Unfortunately, that wasn't the only time the community saw their work staring back at them. The Ace of Spades Nerf replica gun - yes, that’s a thing - was released with a design suspiciously similar to fan artist Tofu_Rabbit’s 2015 mockup. Same colorway. Same details. Same vibe. Again, Bungie owned up, promising to make amends.
It’s clear that Bungie values its fanbase - they’ve cultivated one of the most passionate communities in gaming. But when elements from that community keep ending up in official releases without upfront credit, it’s a bad look.
At least they’ve learned their lesson... sort of.
6. Marathon – When Bungie Ran with the Wrong Art
Marathon is meant to be Bungie’s triumphant extraction shooter comeback, a moody, sci-fi reboot of their beloved 1990s FPS. Instead, the game tripped over its own concept art - before it even released.
Shortly after alpha footage was revealed in May 2025, Scottish artist Fern "Antireal" Hook noticed an alarming number of assets that seemed to be lifted directly from her 2017 cyberpunk poster work - everything from the word "ALEPH" to recurring symbols and design motifs.
Side-by-side comparisons went viral. Bungie confirmed the issue quickly, blaming an unnamed “former artist” for submitting the work without proper attribution. They paused development, promised an internal review, and reportedly reached out to Antireal directly to "make things right."
It wasn’t the studio’s first brush with this kind of controversy. For fans, it felt like a pattern - especially when paired with a previous Destiny 2 misstep (as mentioned earlier). The optics of a billion-dollar studio accidentally ripping off indie artists twice in two years? Not great.
To Bungie’s credit, they owned up and took immediate steps to rectify the situation. But when your game’s name is Marathon, you probably don’t want to start the race by faceplanting into someone else’s art portfolio.
5. Fortnite – Swipe First, Ask Questions Later
At this point, Fortnite has basically become the metaverse’s version of a pop culture vacuum cleaner - sucking up everything from Marvel skins to Billie Eilish concerts. But behind all the brand deals and flossing lies a murkier truth: Epic Games has a history of borrowing dance moves from real-life creators… without always asking first.
It started with “Swipe It,” an emote that looked suspiciously like rapper 2 Milly’s Milly Rock. He sued, Epic shrugged, and the case fizzled thanks to copyright law not really knowing what to do with choreography at the time. That should’ve been the end of it, but no - Fortnite kept stepping on toes.
In 2022, renowned choreographer Kyle Hanagami sued Epic for copying four counts of his routine for Charlie Puth’s “How Long.” Epic called it a coincidence, but the Ninth Circuit disagreed, ruling that the emote might actually infringe on protected choreography. Epic quietly settled in 2024.
Then in 2025, another lawsuit dropped - this time from Felix Burgos, who accused Fortnite of lifting his Touching the Sky routine beat for beat. And unlike earlier claims, this one came with choreography registrations and timestamped proof.
4. League of Legends – When Riot Got a Little Too Inspired By Its Fans
League of Legends isn’t just a game - it’s a global juggernaut, boasting over a hundred champions, endless lore, and one of the most creative fanbases on the internet. But for all Riot’s polish and production, a few champions have raised awkward questions about just where that inspiration really came from.
Take Kindred, for instance - the eerie dual-character champion made up of a spectral lamb and a haunting shadow wolf. Shortly after their 2015 reveal, fans noticed uncanny similarities to the artwork of Chiara Bautista, whose illustrations of a pale lamb and dark, antlered wolf had been online for years. She didn’t accuse Riot of theft, but she did acknowledge the likeness was a little too close for comfort.
Then there’s Seraphine. In 2020, indie artist Stephanie Dorris alleged Riot used her likeness and personal details for the pop-star mage - including matching pink hair, glasses, a musical background, and even eerily similar social media posts. Riot denied the claims, but the controversy exploded across fan forums and left a sour taste in the community.
To be clear, there’s no conclusive proof of plagiarism in either case. But when similar art starts turning up in multi-billion-dollar releases, is it ever a good look?
3. Assassin’s Creed Shadows – Borrowed Symbol, Big Apology
When you’re drawing inspiration from history, it’s one thing to evoke a period - it’s another when you borrow a symbol without asking.
That’s what happened with Assassin’s Creed Shadows. Ubisoft used the Sekigahara Teppo-tai reenactment group's flag, a real, historically significant banner, in two concept art pieces, without permission. The group only found out once leaked images surfaced, and they were understandably upset at the unauthorized use of their symbol.
Ubisoft Japan responded with an apology. The flag would be removed from all promotional materials and digital formats, though it would remain in the collector’s edition art book - a lingering oversight that rubbed many the wrong way.
This wasn’t just a few quiet tweets - it sparked enough outrage that even Japanese lawmakers weighed in. Criticism mounted over cultural insensitivity and the importance of respecting historical symbols.
It’s a rare timeshift: a major studio not just accused of borrowing, but caught red-handed, forced to apologize and revise. It’s a solid reminder that when you “borrow” from history - or real communities - a proper ask is the best foot forward.
2. Abandoned – Stock Images, Placeholder Art… and Nothing Else?
For a game that never released a single second of playable content, Abandoned had an uncanny knack for making headlines. Touted as a cinematic horror exclusive for PS5, it was the debut project from Dutch outfit Blue Box Game Studios - a team that, despite lofty claims, never seemed to deliver anything concrete.
Behind the scenes, the project became a mess of borrowed assets, placeholder art, and misleading marketing. Blue Box's 2021 teaser app promised real-time rendered environments - instead, it offered a four-second clip of a man walking on floorboards, using what appeared to be Unity store-bought elements. A GamesRadar report confirmed that leaked images were from a 2019 tech demo filled with store assets and incomplete models, nothing more.
Things got murkier. According to GameSpot, Blue Box’s Hasan Kahraman allegedly solicited fan-made art and game ideas, pitching them to external investors without securing full development plans - or, seemingly, permission. Some early trailers featured concepts that closely resembled other games, sparking confusion over whether the footage was real or just mock-ups designed to attract hype.
In the end, Abandoned became the poster child for how borrowed art, vague promises, and zero follow-through can spiral into gaming’s most notorious vaporware tale.
1. Pokémon TCG Pocket – “New Art Coming Soon”
Pokémon is one of the most beloved, polished franchises in gaming - so when something this lazy shows up, it’s more than a little shocking. In early 2024, Pokémon TCG Pocket launched as a digital card game spin-off. But instead of wowing players with shiny new cards and collector-friendly artwork, some users were treated to cards that literally just said “New art coming soon.”
That’s right. In a franchise that has made billions off beautiful, nostalgic card designs, a major update for Pokémon TCG Pocket launched with blank placeholders.
Days before the release of the Wisdom Of The Sea And Sky set in July 2025, the community discovered that some of the actual art that had made it into the game had been plagiarized from fan artists online. Multiple pieces were direct traces or repaints of DeviantArt and Twitter uploads, with zero credit given. The developers eventually acknowledged the mistake and began replacing the art… but by then, the damage was done. Screenshots of the placeholder cards went viral, as did comparisons between the fan originals and the knockoffs.
Fans were left wondering: how does a company as powerful as The Pokémon Company - with access to thousands of talented artists - resort to placeholder cards and traced art in an official product? It felt like a slap in the face to both artists and fans, especially in a medium where visual design is everything.