10 Tiny Video Game Details That Give Away Character Secrets

Cal's lightsaber was in EVERY trailer.

By Josh Brown /

EA

No matter the medium, foreshadowing is always a satisfying storytelling device.

Advertisement

It's not easy to get right, of course, and messing it up can ruin a potential twist or reveal at the end of a narrative, but some writers are amazing at dropping subtle hints to future events or beats. This often gets to the point where you don't notice them first time round, but upon a revisit, they seem so obvious you feel a little silly.

Games offer particularly rich opportunities for foreshadowing though. In a movie or book you're presented with specific information, and sometimes you can tell when the author is drawing attention to something that will come into play later. Games are player-driven though, and because they're packed with so much to see and do, it means that sometimes audiences are so distracted with something, they miss information they could have picked up on.

Advertisement

We've covered some great examples of this before when it comes to major endgame plot twists, but sometimes games are even subtler than that, and can reveal a huge detail about a character long before it's ever actually addressed in the story.

SPOILERS ahead.

Advertisement

10. Arthur's Sickness - Red Dead Redemption 2

Rockstar

There are some impeccable little details hidden in Red Dead Redemption 2 that foreshadow character twists and entire relationships before they're explicitly brought into the narrative, from Micah worming his way into Dutch's ear or Karen's downfall following the death of lover, Shaun.

Advertisement

It's Arthur having TB that becomes obvious on a second run, through. When playing it originally, I actually thought this late-game twist kinda came out of nowhere, but when you know it's coming, it's almost too obvious what Rockstar were setting up.

There are a bunch of moments where Arthur has a coughing fit early on, for instance, which don't seem to be related, until you remember that characters only ever cough in fiction when they're unwell. At one point he even writes in his journal that he's been feeling sick, but that it's "probably nothing".

Advertisement

Most of the telltale signs come in Guarma though, just prior to Arthur actually being diagnosed.

Here, the character is coughing, fatigued, and even has the bloodshot eyes that define his appearance in Chapter 6, yet most players chalk it up to the trauma of the shipwreck, not any longterm disease.

Advertisement

9. You're Actually A Cat - Ghost Trick

Capcom

Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective (which might just be the best name a video game has ever had), is a quirky adventure title released on the Nintendo DS, which sees the player take control of a spectre named Sissel and tasked with figuring out who they're controlling, why they're a ghost, and what their purpose is.

Advertisement

It's mad, mad stuff, and that kind of mysterious set up inherently informs the player that twists are to be expected. Even with those expectations in mind though, nobody could guess that Sissel was actually a cat who was shot before becoming a ghost.

On a second playthrough though, it's so obvious that Sissel isn't human. To the point where it's a bit embarrassing. The fact that you meet other spirits who have taken different forms than their alive selves (who are also the only other spirits with amnesia, by the way), have a tendency to play fight with rats, can see in the dark, hates getting wet, and all around exhibits cat-like behaviour, clues you in without you knowing it.

Advertisement

Seriously, there are that many hints in the game that there are entire pages dedicated to the foreshadowing, and it's totally amazing.

8. The Names Of Atlas' Fake Dead Family - Bioshock

2K

When it comes to killer twists and expert foreshadowing, few games are more popular than Bioshock. Everyone knows about the "would you kindly?" reveal and the friendly Atlas turning out to be real villain Frank Fontaine, but the fact that you're being strung along and manipulated is telegraphed even further over the the early hours of the story.

Advertisement

One memorable moment sees the player attempting to help 'Atlas' rescue his family, made up of wife Moira and son Patrick, who are escaping in a submarine. The sub explodes, supposedly on account of Andrew Ryan, and the murder gives players all the reason they need to want him dead.

Of course, there never was a family and the whole event was further manipulation to not get you to question whether you were being manipulated (Bioshock is confusing). "Patrick" and "Moira" are taken from the name of a play seen on posters around Rapture, which 'Atlas' borrows for his own fake story. They're quite prominent, but the game counts on you not questioning your supposed ally and chalking the similarity up to coincidence.

Advertisement

7. Pretty Much Everyone's True Identity - God Of War

SIE Santa Monica Studio

The first couple hours of God of War are absolutely stacked with tiny details that only make complete sense later, but you don't pay them any mind because, like Kratos, you're a stranger to this world, and assume everything is as straight-forward and obvious as it seems.

Advertisement

Faye's real identity is something which is teased early on especially, when Baldur first comes knocking. He's expecting to find a giant, and instead he bumps into Kratos who he thinks is the giant he's looking for, which explains why he says things like "I thought you'd be bigger".

Baldur himself - specifically his weakness - is also teased early on, when Kratos and Atreus visit Freya holding mistletoe arrows. The witch freaks out, tells them they're dangerous and destroys them. We only find out later that because they're the only things that can break Baldur's immortality curse.

Advertisement

There's a bunch more in God of War, which makes a second playthrough so worth it.

5. Peter Englert's True Name - Death Stranding

Sony

There are a bunch of details, like in God of War, that are thrown at the player early on in Death Stranding, only making full sense many hours down the line, though they are clearly signposted beforehand. However, the one which isn't explicitly revealed unless you seek it out, is villain Higgs' location within the open world.

Advertisement

At a couple points you'll receive an e-mail from Peter Englert, who repeatedly asks you to haul a delicate pizza over to his house in the arse-end of nowhere. These are some of the most difficult challenges in the entire game, and each time you arrive, he's never there to meet you in the flesh, always having an excuse to not answer the buzzer (or join the Chiral Network).

After completing the final challenge, an e-mail reveals this has actually been Higgs messing with you the whole time, and the place you've been delivering to was his hideout.

Advertisement

It's a surprise (especially considering most people assumed the obfuscated identity was simply hiding another celebrity cameo), but the pseudonym Higgs reveals his real identity. It's an amalgamation of Peter Higgs and Francois Englert, the two scientists responsible for the Higgs particle theory.

4. Eva's Gun Reveals Her Allegiance - Metal Gear Solid 3

Konami

After playing through Metal Gear Solid 3, you'll probably never feel comfortable trusting a person again. Everyone in this game is at least a triple agent for some organisation, and by the end pretty much everyone has betrayed Snake and proven to be not who they say they are.

Advertisement

This includes EVA, a supposed spy who's infiltrating the terrorist organisation Snake is hunting down. In the end, it turns out she was working for the Chinese government the whole time, and leaves her American lover high and dry.

The game doesn't exactly shy away from providing you with hints about her true colours though, but like Snake, you probably implicitly trusted this attractive super spy.

Advertisement

The biggest giveaway is her weapon. Her mauser is entirely unique to her, and is actually a Chinese Mauser Type 17, a clear nod to her real allegiance. Considering how much of a gun nut Snake is in this, he should have realised.

3. The Lightsaber's True Origin - Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order

EA

Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order slowly peels back the curtain on who main character Cal Kestis is and how he relates to the Jedi Order, but one of his secrets was hiding in plain sight in pretty much every trailer leading up to the game's release.

Advertisement

For the most part, the devs did a pretty good job of hiding the fact that Cal doesn't just wield a regular old lightsaber, but actually a double-edged one, despite giving players all the info they needed to realise that detail.

The reason why he's seen only using one half of the weapon in the trailers and in the early game is because the lightsaber itself is actually damaged, and the hilt has been destroyed. That's due to it being his master's weapon, passed down when he was slain during Order 66.

Advertisement

The thing is, going back, that fact was always front and centre.

I always wondered why Cal's hilt looked strangely large compared to the actual blade, and the reason is that it's not actually a hilt at all.

Advertisement

2. Saren And The Illusive Man Have The Same Eyes - Mass Effect

Bioware

The Mass Effect franchise isn't lacking in great villains, and the very best of the bunch keep you guessing as to their motivations right to the end. At the time, ME1's Saren was a revelation; an alien bad guy whose motives you could understand, but so clearly corrupted by Reaper indoctrination that the only humane thing to do was put him out his misery.

Advertisement

The second game introduced the Illusive Man, the shady leader of Cerberus who appears to be on your side. After all, he's one of the only people who believes the Reapers are a threat, and shifts heaven and Earth to literally bring the player character back from the dead.

He becomes the primary human antagonist of the third game, where it's revealed he also has been fully indoctrinated by the Reapers, and has started to fuse himself with the alien tech.

Advertisement

However, signs of indoctrination were present from his very first scene, with him having the same glowing eyes that Saren had. This is further explained in a spin-off comic, which depicted the Illusive Man's first run in with Reaper tech years prior to the games, which caused the change in his irises and started the slow indoctrination process that was accelerated in the third release.

1. Why 2B Isn't Friendly With 9S - Nier: Automata

Square-Enix

Nier: Automata has so many twists wrapped within twists that you have to play through the game literally three times to understand everything that's going on.

Advertisement

The aliens you thought you were fighting have been dead the whole time! The humans you thought you were defending have also been dead the whole time! The characters you're playing as are actually kinda evil and brainwashed!

The most surprising thing, though, is that the first android you play as, 2B, is an execution droid designed to kill partner 9S when they reach a certain point on their journey.

Advertisement

This real purpose actually explains so much in hindsight, especially how adverse 2B is to getting to know her counterpart. She always acts cold to 9S' inquisitiveness, and in general, is kind of a dick to him despite his constant good nature and offers of friendship.

At the end you realise this is all intentional, as one day she's going to have to kill him, and getting personal will only complicate matters.

Advertisement