10 Video Game Character Redesigns The Fans Actually Liked

A lot of change can come from 22 years.

By Stacey Henley /

Sometimes, video game characters get a makeover. They change their aesthetic, their outfit, or their whole attitude. Like real life, sometimes these changes are well received, and at other times they aren’t.

Advertisement

The new looks for badass/Iron Man rip off Bomberman and sexy Tiny Kong we’re both received terribly, for example, but some are quite popular.

There’s a few caveats here too. Characters like Crash Bandicoot and Spyro The Dragon have been around for so long that they’ve gone full circle. Both started with iconic designs, were given poorly received ‘edgy’ looks (Crash with tribal tattoos, Spyro with a squished face and permanent snarl), then were rebooted back to their original look.

These two don’t count, as the popular designs weren’t really changed, just reverted.

Also, several characters have been given a massive graphical upgrade since their debut, but unless the costume has been changed along with them, this kind of tweak has been discounted too.

There’s still plenty of characters who’ve gone through a traditional makeover, either through their physical appearance or just their costume. Despite redesigns often getting bad press, these ten went down a storm with their fanbase.

10. Pikachu

It was tempting to pick one of Sun & Moon’s Alola forms here, with Alolan Marowak, Raichu and Exeggutor in particular getting praise from the community.

Advertisement

However, they’re different forms as opposed to redesigns; letting them in then opens the door for whether or not Mega Charizard could qualify, and it just seems more hassle than it’s worth.

So, drawing a line under it, new Pokémon forms don’t count. While we’re at it, neither do bad sprites like Mew’s initial horrifically ugly design, as these were bad graphics, not design. Pikachu though, as his anime popularity soared, received a fully fledged makeover.

More accurately, Pikachu got personal trainer. Its sprite in Red and Blue is, to put it mildly, chunky. Not only that, it’s tail was wire thin and there was just something... off about it.

At one point, Clefable was the chief pick to be franchise mascot; with a Pikachu like this, you can see why.

Ash’s Pikachu though had a slimmer frame that curved with the shape of its limbs, rather than just being a big electric ball. This Pikachu was the one used in Pokémon Yellow and every game since, and Pokémon hasn’t really ever looked back.

9. Rad Spencer (Bionic Commando)

No, absolutely not that one.

Advertisement

The dreadlocked, newly Caribbean, stubble-sporting Rad Spencer who arrived with Bionic Commando in 2009 is a major contender for the worst redesign of all time.

However, when he returned in 2011 with Bionic Commando Rearmed 2, Rad was equipped with a third look which redeemed him.

This isn’t just the character going back to his original look like Crash Bandicoot and Spyro The Dragon. Instead, he has a few subtle changes, and though it isn’t as notorious as his bad redesign, it does at least have the (admittedly small) fanbase on board.

The new design compared to the original one (lets never speak of his Caribbean phase again) has more of a ‘cool dad’ vibe going on. He has a neatly combed, bright orange moustache, and has neatened his hair up with a bit of wax.

You can see what the god awful redesign was going for, with the original lacking in substance somewhat. Generic badass was the wrong call, but this more personable Rad has been a hit.

The game is still somewhat in no man’s land right now, but with Contra Corps and Commander Keen both getting revived recently, there’s every chance someone might dig it up.

8. Team Fortress Crew

Absolute no brainer this one.

Advertisement

The first Team Fortress crew was a fairly generic band of heroes, devoid of personality. The basic ingredients were there, but they felt just like that: ingredients. A little bit of milk here, some chocolate chips there, a raw egg over in the corner... none of it had really come together yet.

In the sequel though, this totally changed. The characters became exaggerated versions of themselves, and the change paid off massively. Team Fortress went from being just another bog standard game to one that felt like it had something to say.

These sorts of games with big casts and a limited story can be difficult to judge on appearance alone. Overwatch and Battleborn don’t look all that different on paper, yet the results couldn’t be further apart.

Fortnite has gone in a similar trajectory to Team Fortress 2, though to say so would be heresy to a certain ilk of gamers. Their character models have gotten more outlandish as the seasons have gone on, and that too has been popular with fans.

Team Fortress 2 though was the originator, and with several groundbreaking mechanics, it’s not the only way the game started a trend.

7. Yoshimitsu

Yoshimitsu is just a weird dude.

Advertisement

He comes with a different look every game, although most changes don’t really get much traction; he’s a hard character to master, is never too involved with the core story and the changes aren’t immediately noticeable. For these reasons, Tekken can pretty much get away with whatever they want and nobody will call foul.

Technically, Yoshimitsu is a title for the leader of the alien Manji Clan, so it is actually a completely different character each time. Usually though, it’s pretty consistent and he’s featured in every Tekken game to date, so a drastic new look definitely counts as a redesign.

Speaking of which, in Tekken 7, they went above and beyond. Gone were the sleek, domed curves his designs had previously shared; now, for some reason, he was a crazy squid monster.

Despite being a massive departure from previous Yoshimitsus, the look received massive praise for going all in on the weirdness. Considering another character has chainsaws for arms, outer space squid men shouldn’t be a cause for alarm.

Though this squid man is a different Yoshimitsu to the one we saw in Tekken 6, he looks so bizarre that he needs to be catalogued here.

6. Doom Guy

Doom Guy has had a big f***ing redesign in his time.

Advertisement

The modern day Doom Guy does share some surface level similarities to Master Chief, but anyone above the most casual player can easily tell them apart. The current Doom Guy looks exactly like a demon slayer should; a far cry from his over-designed and underwhelming origins.

The first Doom Guy wore green armour, much brighter than the more militaristic shade of his current design. It looked flimsy too, like he’d just put on a t-shirt and matching American football pads.

For some reason, said t-shirt is ripped in the middle to expose his abs. He looks as ready for a day posing at Miami Beach as he is to take on hellspawn.

Now, the bulky shoulders, chunky helmet and red finishes equipped with hellish scratches tell you all you need to know about the man instantly. Nothing about it says ‘saviour’; instead the whole look screams ‘killer’.

Doom has never been a game to pull punches, and Doom Guy now has a design to match.

His design has gotten clearer and more detailed over the years, but once they switched gears from the slightly strange original, they haven’t regretted it once.

5. Kitana

Kitana is, in a way, representing women in fighting games everywhere; especially the Mortal Kombat 9 girls.

Advertisement

Elsewhere, Tekken’s Ling Xiaoyu also got a subtle, more covered up redesign in Tekken 7, but that was decidedly smaller than Kitana’s change from Mortal Kombat 9 to Mortal Kombat X.

She had a very revealing costume in MK9, and while there’s nothing inherently wrong with that, wasn’t it a bit boring that practically all the female characters were in the same boat?

It’s like they were given their real costumes and decided to get them retailored for lapdancing at the last second.

Mortal Kombat X covered her up more, but that on its own doesn’t mean a better costume. Kasumi in Dead Or Alive worked better in the sequels which removed clothing from her initial model; although her head to toe bodysuit in the most recent offering is a great look for her too.

With Kitana though, the plunging necklines, spaghetti string clothing and lace after lace after lace just felt... beneath her. MKX she managed to still be sultry, but with a much more powerful and in control of her own destiny as a result.

Mortal Kombat redesigns aren’t always popular, but this one went down well.

4. Raiden

As you might expect from a Metal Gear game, Raiden’s redesign was cranked up to the extreme.

Advertisement

Initially, when the character debuted in Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty, he was a bit of a drip. The lithe character model, pale skin and thin white hair was a big change from the badass characters the franchise was known for, and his replacing of Snake as the protagonist was hugely controversial.

Knowing Kojima’s style, many thought it might even be a joke at the players’ collective expense.

The game itself however was massively popular, full of typically rich themes, and despite Raiden’s initial unpopularity, he became somewhat of a cult figure.

He then returned as a supporting character in Metal Gear Solid 4, but it was in spin off hack and slash game Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance where he was truly redeemed.

Any perceived physical weakness had gone the journey; this new Raiden had a psycho killer look to him.

The body suit was more defined, yes, but it also had more of a heavy metal edge, moving away from his emo look. His hair was now tough, bristly spines, and his soft, androgynous expression turned into one much harder and spikier.

3. Lara Croft

The Tomb Raider reboot was a breath of fresh air, offering a whole new aesthetic and more gritty action, with the melodramatic treasure hunt angle kept in there too.

Advertisement

Although some of the narrative arcs and villains didn’t go down an storm, Lara’s new design won almost universal acclaim.

Lara had slowly been ‘deflated’ since her triangular bra debut, but she still looked very much like a comic book character. She had a sense of being cool in the ‘90s, and the whole thing felt a little outdated. Immediately after Tomb Raider: Underworld in 2008, Crystal Dynamics got to work on a hard reboot, which released five years later.

With that came a realistic Lara Croft, one fans took to almost instantly. It helped that the death sequences were far more gruesome than they had been before, further selling the idea of a new, more mature Lara Croft.

It’s strange then that the same team who designed Lara are the ones behind the new trailer for Marvel’s Avengers, which has received heavy criticism for its blocky character designs.

Hopefully their promise to take another crack at it will result in something more in the Lara Croft frame this time around.

2. Tifa

Final Fantasy VII has obviously undergone a huge graphical upgrade with the upcoming remake, but with Tifa they’ve made some small but necessary tweaks along the way too.

Advertisement

A vocal minority are unhappy about these changes, but to be blunt: They’re unhappy that she doesn’t have as big boobs anymore.

In general though, with sleek, crisp new graphics, the majority of Final Fantasy fans are on board with a more realistic Tifa, and with little costume adjustments to fit her new form.

Her white vest remains, but is now kitted out with a black trim to tie the whole thing together. Her bare legs may have seemed out of place on a realistic looking Tifa too, so they’ve been covered up with long black socks too.

Away from the physical adjustments, her gauntlets are much more slender and well defined now; something which was technologically impossible the first go around.

These days, you can zoom in close enough to see a tiny chocobo charm on her bracelet, which is a wonderful touch.

Like all FFVII characters, graphical improvements meant she needed to be built from the ground up. From what we’ve seen, Square Enix have made some smart choices with her design.

1. Link

Link could be on this list a couple of times, having reinvented himself throughout his career. For that reason alone, he more than deserves his place at the top of the pile.

Advertisement

The first major change that wasn’t just a little tweak or graphical update was in Wind Waker, where this character design - affectionately known as Toon Link - really came into its own.

Gone were the realistic proportions and in was a funkier, friendlier, more cartoonified version of the legendary character.

After this came the more recent reinvention, with an ethereal looking Link in Breath Of The Wild. The Nintendo Switch launch title gave Link another makeover, with the title a more mature, developed and expansive Legend Of Zelda experience.

Link’s design had to match this, giving him his most fantastical look to date and bathing everything in an angelic, mystical yellow glow.

Speaking of Zelda, the titular Princess could have featured here too, especially for her Breath Of The Wild look. However, the hero of Hyrule just pipped her to the post this time around.

Advertisement