10 Video Game Characters EVERYONE Let Die

No shame in sending these guys to the grave.

By James Metcalfe /

In the world of video games, dying is part and parcel of the experience; a punishment to give a game a respectable challenge. As well as being a means of encouraging a learning curve for a certain section, deaths are usually followed by a quick 'Game Over' screen before players are whisked back into the action at their last checkpoint.

Advertisement

But, what happens when the deaths are chalked as permanent and are reserved for other characters?

Occasionally, games will throw up missions or sequences that will result in a character - or characters - meeting their maker. But, unlike pre-determined deaths players are helpless against, certain titles come with choices and destinies that can be intervened on.

Whether through painstaking challenges or rewards not being worth the effort, or a character straight up being too annoying to keep alive, here are some individuals every player prefers to let die.

10. Brother Verulus - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

In The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, Brother Verulus is a Priest of Arkay attending the Hall of the Dead in Markath. He's an Imperial NPC living out in one of the least important parts of the world, with most players only encountering him when they come to investigate Daedric "Taste of Death" quest.

Advertisement

Unless they are running an outlandishly saintly build or have a particular disdain for seeing where a game is willing to go, players will likely side with this clan of cannibals out in the Reach, eventually luring the priest to their hideout in Reachcliff Cave.

The final task of the quest is to kill and feast upon the Arkay priest who has been nothing but trusting of them up until that point. It is the only way of securing the Ring of Namira, and completing the Oblivion Walker trophy. What's more, taking the priest up to Reachcliff Cave, only to have a change of heart and turn on the cannibals, will force you to kill a number of Markath NPCs who were attempting said 'feast' in the first place.

There's also something in how players are forced to knowingly deceive Verulus along the way that makes the priest's death even more sinister.

9. Mordin - Mass Effect 3

Level-headed, wise-cracking and loyal 'til the end, it's no wonder Mordin Solus is one of Mass Effect's most beloved companions. And, by the time players got to the third entry in the trilogy, everything was set up for his perfect sacrificial send-off.

Advertisement

Having initially worked on the viral genophage, the scientist's demise comes as he ensures the survival of the Krogan, distributing the cure from atop a collapsing tower on planet Tuchanka. Snuffed out in an instant, it's ultimately a bittersweet moment, with Mordin not able to see the fruits of his labour pan out.

Players can save him, but it denies the scientist his redemptive finale, and one he deserves. Plus, it's a right ball-ache to accomplish. Players need to make three renegade choices over the course of all three games, ultimately concluding with them preventing Solus from going up the tower during his loyalty mission. It also requires enough reputation as a Renegade to complete.

8. The Vault Dwellers - Fallout: New Vegas

Fallout: New Vegas is a game filled with choices and decisions that can have huge impacts on a playthrough. However one that lives on in infamy involves the side mission, Hard Luck Blues. And yet, whilst it is regarded as one of the most morally-ambiguous decisions in the game, the vast majority of players will find themselves making the exact same decision.

Advertisement

This mission has you travel to Vault 34, having been told that radiation spilling out from the building is ruining the crops being grown in the surrounding area.

However, arriving at the Vault will reveal a number of trapped Dwellers inside. Players will then have to choose whether they shut down the vault's reactor, trapping the people, or set them free, but have the area contaminated for the remainder of the game.

Hard decision, right? Well... sort of.

In a trademark example of 'sacrificing the few for the many', most Fallout players tend to put the needs of the dozens of NPCs reliant on the crops ahead of the handful of Dwellers living inside Vault 34.

7. Lord Shimura - Ghost Of Tsushima

Another morally grey choice in video games that actually isn't too morally grey when it comes down to it, Lord Shirmura is the mentor and uncle of the playable hero, Jin, in Ghost of Tsushima.

Advertisement

Embodying the traditional values of the samurai, Lord Shimura is all about honour, honour and more honour. Throughout the game, Shimura and Jin come into constant conflict over their different tactics on the battlefield, with the elder mentor scolding Sakai for his 'dishonourable' acts.

At the end of the game, things come to a head and players have to duel their uncle directly. When you win, you have the option of choosing whether to spare Lord Shimura and let him live, or give him an honourable samurai death.

Off the bat, this is one of those video game choices where developers are ramming a specific option down the player's throat. Not only do both men tout this as being a fight to the death, with Jin even preparing a nice poem, but Lord Shimura begs for players to put him out of his misery once he's defeated, as there's no way for him to live after such dishonour.

With Shimura thanking his son and assuring him he will see him again in the afterlife, it's hard to imagine anyone opting to go against his wishes and keep him around after the finale.

6. Solaire Of Astora - Dark Souls

Solaire of Astora. Our little ray of sunshine in a game filled with bleak darkness and horrible monsters. The skilled warrior who purposefully made himself undead to 'find his very own sun', Solaire is a never-ending flurry of positivity and quips that has made him one of the enduring characters in Dark Souls lore.

Advertisement

However, for this bucket helmet-wearing ally, most players are perfectly content consigning him to a tragic demise. In fact, the further along in his main questline they go, players will stumble across an increasingly desperate Solaire, losing faith in his religion before going into a frenzy and attacking you in Lost Izalith.

Thankfully, there have been more and more ways found of keeping this cheery companion alive in the years since Dark Souls' initial release. Sadly, most of them require very deliberate actions not told to players in the game. The most obvious requires you discover the secret path in Lost Izalith and kill the Red-Eyed Chaos Bug before it has the chance of infecting the Knight.

For most of us, we probably should have been told before we sliced this crusader up.

5. Jayden - Heavy Rain

Heavy Rain was a trailblazer in choice-based video games, with every decision having huge ramifications on the paths characters took. Main men Ethan Mars and Scott Shelby are both required to make it to the end of the story alive, but the two other playable characters, journalist Madison Paige and FBI investigator Norman Jayden can both find themselves meeting a permanent demise in their pursuit of the Origami Killer.

Advertisement

Madison actually has the most potential deaths in the game, however, it is the FBI's finest players most likely ended up killing during their playthroughs.

Not only can players cause Jayden to die of an overdose on the Triptocaine and ARI technology he uses both in-game and in the epilogue, but the four different levels in which he can be killed are the easiest to slip up on.

'Solving the Puzzle' will give very little warning that players are on the verge of an overdose, 'Fish Tank' has some tricky quick-time events that see Jayden stabbed by a katana, and the fight with Mad Jack features a sudden action that, unless spotted quickly enough, drops Norman into a car crusher.

All in all, getting Jayden to the end of a playthrough alive is a serious achievement.

4. Asher - Telltales' Game Of Thrones

Telltale's Game of Thrones, episode 'A Nest of Vipers' will conclude with two of the main protagonists, Asher and Rodrik Forrester being ambushed by the Whitehills after the former arrives in Westeros. The pair find themselves at the city gates, knowing one must stay behind to ensure the other can escape.

Advertisement

Through Gregor and then Ethan's deaths, House Forrester are shown to be a family in dire need of a true leader; someone fierce on the battlefield, but also skilled in the arts of diplomacy. Someone, the game attempts to constantly stress, Rodrik embodies.

The idea of hauling Rodrik off the cart, all the way back to health, only to have him killed off just as he's about to get going again is just too sad. Plus, the rivalry with Ludd, Gryff and the Whitehills is shown to be more of Rodrik's thing, rather than his brother's.

Asher is always quick to say, "He's no leader". His one purpose throughout the game is to be reunited with his family, and give his brother the support of an army. With that fulfilled, his final sacrifice makes all the more sense.

3. Citra - Far Cry 3

Across Far Cry 3, players spend their time running around the Rook Islands looking for Jason Brody's friends. Along the way, they will encounter Citra, the alluring leader of the Rakyat who ends the game asking players to kill their friends and embrace life on the islands as the group's leader.

Advertisement

Not only will choosing to side with Citra lead to the deaths of all of Jason's friends, but it'll also trigger a big hint from the developers that you made the wrong call, with Jason himself being killed off by this rebel-leader-turned-wannabe-Goddess.

Overall, most players make the far more sensible decision to stick to their mission and choose their friends. However, doing so will cause Citra's death when she steps in the way of Dennis' attack on Jason.

And whilst it's a sad moment for Brody, it's one we're fairly confident in saying he'll get over once he's back to civilisation.

2. Matt - Until Dawn

Slashers are filled with characters written in to inflate the body count, and that is the role Matt has been given in Until Dawn. In all honesty, even he spends most of his time wandering around wondering what he's supposed to be doing in the game.

Advertisement

Ultimately, Matt is the easiest member of the party to have killed off due to how many seemingly unimportant decisions can have an effect on his fate.

To keep him alive, players have to disagree with Emily over going to the fire tower, not hit the Elk with the axe, keep the flare gun and then choose to save Emily twice and hit a target. Bear in mind, these are all split decisions players need to know to make in advance or stumble upon, and they don't take into account various quick time events or actions needed during each chapter.

What's more, keeping Matt alive also requires players to show patience and compassion to Emily, who is certainly less than pleasant to him. Players who decide to teach Emily a lesson by being less compliant with her are often, unwittingly, choosing to let Matt meet his maker.

A lesson in standing up for yourself here.

1. Zoe - Resident Evil VII

Resident Evil: Biohazard kicks off with players being introduced to protagonist Ethan Winters, who is shown driving to Louisana after receiving a call from his wife, Mia. Mia has been missing for three years, and her message leads Ethan to a derelict estate that has been infected by a biological weapon spilt across the area.

Advertisement

Zoe is introduced as the youngest member of the Baker family living in the estate, and she routinely gets in touch with players to offer assistance.

Near the end of the main storyline though, players will escape the house and be presented with the option of giving one remaining serum to either Mia or Zoe. Whichever one players choose will be cured and depart the house with Ethan, leaving the other to their fate.

Your loving wife that has summoned you here and been your main focus throughout the entire campaign, or the wise-cracking daughter of the cannibal family that just put you through hell?

Tough choice, that one.

What's more, Capcom even go out of their way to lament players who choose Zoe that they've made a bad error. Picking Mia will eventually see the couple escape the estate, with Zoe saved by her uncle Joe in what is the game's canonical ending.

However, picking Zoe will see the youngest Baker sibling killed a minute or so after hopping on the boat with Ethan, with Mia also dying later on in the tanker ship.

Advertisement